7 ms·
OpenAI CEO Sam Altman sent startup six-figure loan after SVB collapse
- sql-spy 4y agoStartups that are worth saving will be saved. Cashflow won't be what kills some of these startups.
- warent 4y agoI don't really know much about venture capital but this sounds like a gross oversimplification. More like, the startups that are saved will be a mixed bag of worthwhile startups and dead-end startups. Meanwhile some worthwhile ones will sadly be left behind with the dead-end ones.
- sql-spy 4y agoOfcourse it is an oversimplification but it really is that simple. If the business is profitable, it will survive. If its still relying on free money to pay the bills, its time to make it profitable.
- PeterisP 4y agoThe fact whether a startup has positive cashflow or not isn't really reflective of whether that is a worthwhile startup or a bad one, but rather whether it's at an early stage or a relatively mature one. The most bestest startup in the world would still be relying on investor's money to pay the bills if it's just starting to build its product and the time to make it profitable will come in a year or two or more (e.g. a biotech startup can take many, many years until the product gets approved for patients and earns its first cent). Yes, if a business has "grown up" from being a startup and is fully self-funding not only its operations but also its growth, then it will survive, but the definition of a startup is something that's still trying to reach that stage and isn't there yet.
- illiarian 4y ago> The fact whether a startup has positive cashflow or not isn't really reflective of whether that is a worthwhile startup or a bad one, but rather whether it's at an early stage or a relatively mature one. For the past 10 years or so none of the "successful wrothwhile startups" have positive cash flows, and those that seemingly do still manage to post hundreds of millions of dollars in losses yera after year after year. The whole modern startup business is either "work at a loss until a successful exit for the founders" or "work at a loss forever with no expectation of profitability for some reason". None of them are worthy.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> whether a startup has positive cashflow or not isn't really reflective of whether that is a worthwhile startup or a bad one A start-up that fails because of this mismanaged their treasury, didn’t pull money in time, couldn’t borrow against their claims and couldn’t convince anyone to advance payroll. That’s reflective on leadership. It’s a teachable moment. But it points to deeper naivety.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wpietri 4y agoDepends on your perspective. One of the articles of faith in this industry is that good startups get investment and succeed, while bad ones fail. To whatever extent that's true, it won't be particularly worse here. Startups who made treasury management errors and are experiencing cash crunches can make very good cases for bridge loans and extra investment from their existing investors. If their investors are like, "nah, pass" then that's a pretty good reason to question their potential generally.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoI'm normally very against the HN norm of just naming a fallacy and considering an entire argument dismissed but in this case I think it does apply. This is not a Just World, some unworkable companies will get bridge funding because of their connections and no other reason. Aside from that timing is always a thing. There's certainly a company out there that is 8 months away from proving the soundness of their idea that now only has six months of funding, or whatever. The idea that in every case, "the market" or whatever will arrive at the most perfectly correct conclusion is silly at any time, but particularly in one of uncertainty and upheaval.
- wpietri 4y agoYeah, I'm not arguing that "whatever will arrive at the most perfectly correct conclusion". (And I don't think that sql-spy was arguing that either.) What I'm saying is that I don't think this particular circumstance is going to be any less just than usual. Indeed, I think there's good reason to expect it to be more just given that what we're talking about is mostly a short-term cash crunch that's easily explained. E.g., one company is raising $1 bn for bridge loans: https://techcrunch.com/2023/03/11/brex-ceo-is-trying-to-raise-over-1-billion-in-a-weekend-for-svb-related-bridge-loans/ https://techcrunch.com/2023/03/11/brex-ceo-is-trying-to-rais... That kind of support is not something marginal startups have access to in normal times.
- sql-spy 4y agoCircumstances changed. Running a startup means time is never on your side. If you are still 8 months away from proving "soundness" of your idea then you are already too late.
- swatcoder 4y agoBy design, venture-backed startups are about sticking a plate of spaghetti to a wall to look for the sticky bits. There are few sure tells of what startups are “worth saving” until they’re already quite successful. Assuming that the SVB unwinding is more than a hiccup in cash availability, what will determine who gets saved will mostly come down to affinity and luck. Promise and value are a sort of first pass filter, but startups are just plain noisy and chaotic field.
- rat9988 4y agoDoes someone have a name for this fallacy?
- mhb 4y agoTautology
- wongarsu 4y ago"Startups that are worth saving will be saved" feels like the same category of statement as "It's always in the last place I look". They both describe common sense behavior (save things worth saving, or stop searching once you found what you're looking for). But they are not tautologies in the strict sense, you can make them false; and quite frequently they are false in practice, mostly due to imperfect information.
- the-dude 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-world_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-world_hypothesis
- youngtaff 4y agoStartups that can be sold will be saved… From a pure financial point of view Uber would never be viewed as a startup that was worth saving… for it’s investors the whole point of the IPO was to cash out and leave someone else holding the loss making baby
- brunooo 4y agoOne of those rare opportunities to clearly assess VCs from the outside, and surprisingly good steady reaction by him and Khosla. Who else?
- ralph84 4y agoKhosla’s legacy is trying to privatize public beaches. Nothing he does will make people forget that.
- brunooo 4y agoNot necessarily disagreeing but still worth pointing out that he did the right thing here.
- benatkin 4y agoAlso don't forget about openwashing and potentially helping Microsoft dominate again* on sama's side. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Openwashing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Openwashing * one of the last things I want
- phphphphp 4y agoMaybe it’s not fair to compare Garry Tan to sama in this situation because Garry is the current president and sama is the former, but, it’s nice to see sama’s measured response compared to Garry’s. Garry is shouting from the rooftops that more than a million jobs are going to be lost if the fed doesn’t immediately do something (that we all know it isn’t going to do). I wouldn’t want to be a YC startup right now, listening to Garry stoke panic. Kudos to sama for being pragmatic and calm.
- brunooo 4y agoBeing in an active leadership position makes his decision to spend time on live-streaming panicky half-baked takes … worse?
- grey-area 4y agoThe fdic and fed probably will do exactly what Gary Tan and many others recommended - no bailout of the company or shareholders but organise a facility so that the depositors get 100%. They’re trying to sell it first but if that doesn’t work they don’t really have other options if they don’t want to be dealing with massive job losses and multiple bank runs next week.
- vagabund 4y agoCommendable of course but also feels like a no brainer. Depositors will almost certainly be made whole. Word will spread of the deed and the goodwill generated will more than repay the low-risk short term loan.
- resource0x 4y agoWhat is six-figure loan? Is it like $100,000? Is it really a heroic act worthy of posting on the front page?
- kfrzcode 4y agoAnywhere between $100,000 and $999,999, ostensibly.
- ignoramous 4y ago> Altman did not confirm the amount he gave to Rad AI, or any other startups, but Gurson told Reuters he would guess Altman has given at least $1 million to his startup and others. > Sam has been sending stuck startups money today with no docs, just saying 'send me back whatever you can whenever you can' May or may not be front-page worthy (and regardless of the PR potential / optics), this is Sam walking the talk, as it were.
- exhaze 4y agoBased on my interactions with Sam, he doesn't seem like the kind of guy who would ever do this for PR. I think he just somehow became aware of this company and, in classic sama fashion, decided it should not fail due to SVB, reached out to the founders, promptly wired them money.
- gfsdgsfgfds 4y agoJust one anecdote of many. I'm a founder of a bootstrapped startup. We are/were with SVB. On Thursday I tried to get a Brex cash account setup to move some operational cash there but it didn't happen in time. I thought of wiring money out of SVB to my personal account but decided it felt too dodgy. Payroll for 2 weeks ending March 15th had to be funded through Gusto by tomorrow (March 13th). So I did all I could do without delaying payroll, dropped my salary to near zero and wired the payroll money to Gusto from my personal checking account. Being bootstrapped and low headcount this was possible. I'll have to retrospectively do some loan paperwork I guess. It would have been a tougher comms to staff if I didn't happen to have enough liquidity personally.
- rdl 4y agoNot a lawyer, but I would be pretty comfortable with SVB -> personal account if you documented why and communicated about it in advance with board/counsel. (Obviously the next step would be opening a Chase/etc. account and sending the funds on to that, not using your personal account for company business on an ongoing basis, but a limited number of emergency transactions should be fine.)
- Waterluvian 4y agoIsn’t it generally a cardinal sin of business finance though?
- dboreham 4y agoAlso nal and naa but no: it's "comingling" that's bad. If you explicitly document the transactions, don't do it all the time, and ideally use matching amounts in and out, it's not comingling.
- rdl 4y agoComingling is. In this case there is a clearly articulable reason why ("our bank is going out of business"), and it's temporary, documented, etc. The twin risks to avoid are appearance of embezzlement, and appearance that you're treating the business account and personal account as one (which potentially allows piercing corporate veil/attaching personal assets), but if your building is on fire, you're allowed to break the window to rescue the kitten.
- roboy 4y agoQ from outside the US: why is capital needed for payroll mid month? Are there some automatic insolvency processes if it is missed by a day? Why do the companies fall apart if there is just a few days of payment delay? (I mean it is obviously a shit situation, and having to tell the team payment might take a few days more than usual is bad, I am just surprised how 2 days of no-cash seem to wreak havoc…)
- icelancer 4y agoWage payment delays in the state of California are severely punishable under law: https://www.ottingerlaw.com/blog/wages-hours/employer-not-paying-wages-on-time/ https://www.ottingerlaw.com/blog/wages-hours/employer-not-pa...
- phphphphp 4y ago“If you receive a late paycheck, California Labor Code 210 requires employers to pay a penalty of $100 for an initial violation.” Severely is overselling it.
- dragonwriter 4y agoIts $100 if it is both a first offense and not willful. For any willful or intentional delay, or a second or subsequent late paycheck regardless of willfulness, the penalty is $200 plus 25% of the payment that was due. (And if any terminal paychecks are late, there are greater penalties – waiting time penalties equal to an average days pay for each day of delay up to 30 days – though I don’t recall if there is a wilfullness condition or modification to that.)
- icelancer 4y agoThe link I found undersells it, too. In some cases, the corporate veil can be pierced and executives can be made personally liable.
- icelancer 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tiffanyh 4y agoIt seems weird to hear about this generosity from Altman’s family, as opposed to - from one of those companies who was helped. Humble brag?
- sethbannon 4y agoAll VCs should be doing this. Sadly, many aren't. https://twitter.com/sethbannon/status/1634934773377294336 https://twitter.com/sethbannon/status/1634934773377294336
- phatang 4y agoI need 6 thousands
- ShamelessC 4y agoQuick someone get this person 6 thousands!!!
- temp2022account 4y ago2,000; 4,000; 16,000; 32,000; 64,000; and 128,000 are my favorite thousands! We don't talk about 8 anymore, black sheep of the thousands family.
- alexashka 4y agoJust so we're clear - this is the equivalent of me giving a co-worker I like who lost his wallet and his phone 100$ so that he can have lunch, dinner, get home safely, etc.
- Balgair 4y agoRelated: Unfortunately, this tends to be a common fallback in many business when times are tough. My folks had to do this with their employees a few times when I was a kid. Other people in that industry had to too, from time to time. As other commenters state, if you know that a boss does this for you, then you now know a good boss to have. Though, most bosses won't tell you they did it, obviously.
- milofeynman 4y agoShopify is doing something similar for their merchants https://twitter.com/tobi/status/1635038686466441216 https://twitter.com/tobi/status/1635038686466441216
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]