2 ms·
> They're not helped, but they're not hurt. Sorry, despite your nice exposition I still don't believe it. If you really think a blue screen doesn't negatively
by amelius 4y ago
> They're not helped, but they're not hurt.
Sorry, despite your nice exposition I still don't believe it. If you really think a blue screen doesn't negatively impact acting performance then it would require some kind of scientific experiment to convince me.
- jfengel 4y agoI'm not sure it's the kind of thing that really admits scientific evidence. By the metric of "dollars earned" or "jobs hired" actors of every different school of acting get jobs, and I doubt it makes a measurable difference at the box office. It's an art so the techniques that work are the ones the artist chooses. I'm sure there are some who are happier with an animatronic and others who would just as soon scream at a production assistant on a ladder.
- dagmx 4y agoBy the same token, do you have scientific evidence that they’re helped by not having a blue screen? One person is clearly talking from experience of working with actors here (if you’re unaware of the person you’re replying to)
- amelius 4y ago> By the same token, do you have scientific evidence that they’re helped by not having a blue screen? Yes, it is clear that the person I'm replying to has more experience in this field; I'm just a "simple consumer" of movies. However, having experience can sometimes blind you from inconvenient facts. I think the burden is on the industry to prove that new technologies have no negative effect on the end product.
- jfengel 4y agoThe effect on the viewer is more important than the actor. It's our job to make it interesting no matter what the circumstances. You are just supposed to enjoy it (enough to spend your money on it). Audiences definitely like practicals, even when they aren't as realistic. People adore Baby Yoda even though it's obviously a puppet ... in fact because it's obviously a puppet. They also react very positively to the Volume, which is so much better than blue screen even though it's just as fake to the actor. (They're usually not even looking that direction.)