6 ms·
They removed reserve requirements (ie. cash you need to keep on hand) but there's still capital requirements (ie. assets you need to keep on hand).
by gruez 4y ago
They removed reserve requirements (ie. cash you need to keep on hand) but there's still capital requirements (ie. assets you need to keep on hand).
- eru 4y agoYes. Though as a small nitpick, I wouldn't describe capital requirements as 'assets you need to keep on hand'. No matter your capital structure, all your liabilities will be matched by assets. What matters is that after your accounting for your fixed liabilities, like deposits, you still have plenty of total assets left over to have a thick equity cushion to absorb losses. In accounting terms, equity is also a liability. But it's a very benign one, as your shareholders can't demand their money back. There are other forms of liabilities that act like equity in their ability to absorb losses. But equity is the simplest and generally the most import one.
- helsontaveras18 4y agoWow, I never thought of / heard anyone explain equity as a liability to pay to shareholders. It’s brilliant!
- eru 4y agoYou might like to read up on the very basics of accounting. There's lots of other interesting concepts there. See https://martin.kleppmann.com/2011/03/07/accounting-for-computer-scientists.html https://martin.kleppmann.com/2011/03/07/accounting-for-compu... for an intro. Accounting might sound rather boring, but at its core its about understanding businesses (and economies) with numbers. It can be as varied and interesting as companies are. Of course, in practice there's lots of cruft build on top of relatively simple concepts. But the simple underlying concepts are still fascinating. The link above explains double entry book keeping in terms of graph theory and network flows. The basics of deprecation are also quite interesting (to me, at least).
- orwin 4y agoJust a small comment on this: To me, accountants have a better grip on reality than economists. It's an accountant who taught me real economics (I was originally pursuing a math degree with economy as a 'minor' (not really how it's working in my country but close enough)). I had to unlearn some of what I learned in my first year, but I had a way better grip on how money work after that (and decided to create value and changed course).
- eru 4y agoYes. Well, carpenters have an even better grip on reality. Accountants and economists are doing different things. Both fields are useful, and there's some small overlap between the two. Many people could benefit from learning some 'rationalised' accounting, ie accounting without the accumulated historical accidents and tax dodges. (Those are also interesting. But less as a description of a reality, and more in the same vein that the Talmud is interesting.)
- orwin 4y agoBut orthodox economic theory goes against most thing i learned. To be honest, i really thought it didn't matter, that macroeconomics was on its own, and that economists are valid expert to listen to. We were still in eurozone crisis, and while i thought "This plan doesn't make much sense" when the Troika laid out what Greece should do, GDP and socioeconomic markers were not stuff i learned or cared about. And then like 5 years ago, i learn about MMT, read about it, disagree on some points, but it overall make much, much more sense and si way closer to reality than Friedman theories to me. It seems like macroeconomics do follow the stuff i learned when i wanted to become a quantitative analyst or whatever (i only wanted to do math tbh, and didn't follow finance classes that much). And then during Covid we have all those "expert" economists who start to talk everywhere. But now, i am sure they are talking out of their own asses. They had now idea of what production is. The simple idea that production is linked with energy is novel for them. They probably are useful, like sociologists are useful, but i'd like to hear them on medias as much as i hear sociologists. Or even less, since i do think sociologists have real-world application to their thesis, for harm reduction during stampede. Let's say as much as medievalists historians.
- derf_ 4y agoThey relaxed the need for a capital conservation buffer, too. These actions were part of the Fed's response to the market panic at the onset of the pandemic, and you can read a bit about their reasoning in their own press release: https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/pressreleases/monetary20200315b.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/pressreleases/mone... Capital requirements are complicated. There are different types of equity and assets are risk-weighted, but treasuries and the types of bonds SVB bought are generally given the lowest risk-weightings.
- Jensson 4y agoFunny that they didn't deem T-Bonds to be high risk given that it was they who crashed the value of those T-Bond by increasing interest rates.
- panarky 4y agoYou identified the root cause of this whole thing. Long-term bonds get preferential treatment in the risk-based capital calculation because they have low default risk, which allows banks to run with thinner equity capital, even though they're exposed to high interest rate risk and have a portfolio highly concentrated in one high-risk industry. Capital ratios don't adequately account for actual risk.
- eru 4y agoYes. That's (part of) why FDIC is a bad idea: it partially insulates depositors from the need to monitor what their bank is doing. In banking, we want a flight to quality.
- CHY872 4y agoAnd the FAA is a bad idea because it insulates travelers from the need to monitor what their plane is doing?
- 4y ago
- sScTE9qEMCxEk34 4y agoIsn't cash kept on hand the relevant attribute here? Whether they're solvent or not, they ran out of cash to meet withdrawals.
- mullingitover 4y agoWhat I don’t understand is why they weren’t restored as part of the effort to tamp down inflation, and instead the fed just raised rates. Seems like that should’ve been the first move.
- sgt101 4y agoMy little brain sees this as a reason for failure here. SVB had liquid assets (bonds) that it could sell to meet the demands of the depositors, but those assets fell in value creating losses. The bank was forced to crystalise those losses because it had no cash buffer to fall back on. If some substantial part of the liquidity had been held as cash this wouldn't have happened.
- BrandonS113 4y agoNo. This week, the treasuries and other assets in capital are effectively cash equivalents.
- rvnx 4y agoThe worst part of it, is that once interest rates started raising and they started seeing the obvious (but not critical!) impact on their long-maturity bonds, they simply could have switched to shorter-maturity bonds and be totally fine. But they preferred to gamble.