3 ms·
"Copyright does not protect an idea, but the expression of an idea. The original photo is an original work and the second was clearly produced with the intent t
by bane 15y ago
"Copyright does not protect an idea, but the expression of an idea. The original photo is an original work and the second was clearly produced with the intent to evoke the same expression."
But isn't that essentially the problem? How many portraits are done in the style of the Mona Lisa, or landscapes in the style of a well known impressionist, or photographs of Yosemite in the style of Ansel Adams? Hell, an arts education, purely by teaching form, style and composition based on prior works is essentially a study in how to violate copyright if this ruling stands.
To me the more important question with artwork has not been copying the style of a work, that is basically how most art in the world is created. It's counterfit works that are the problem. The two images in this case cannot possibly be considered in this manner.
This is an absurd ruling that essentially means that all works must be unique in form, composition and style, and must not be inspired or based on any prievious works of any sort. That's an absurdly high bar that essentially stops the creation of most art.
- pbhjpbhj 15y agoStill on this: "Copyright does not protect an idea, but the expression of an idea." Copyright actually protects from copying. Even if the expression is identical if no copying took place then there is no infringement. That said. Copyright also expires which is what you, bane, have failed to mention. Also, copying the style - in this particular case - would have been something along the lines of a yellow cab on the brooklyn bridge with the background in monochrome. Even it seems if they'd had a red bus on Tower Bridge or elsewhere. But here they've used the same style and very nearly the same content. So I don't think you're being quite fair. An analogue might be recreating Warhol's Campbell's Soup Cans with the cans marginally rotated, basing the piece on the original work (trademark issues aside). Now I'd like to say that I think that piece actually would be a valid new work - and have quite a lot of substance - but nonetheless it would be derivative of the original beyond mere inspiration IMO. Before I get any further I'd better read the ruling ...
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Natsu 15y ago> Copyright actually protects from copying. Even if the expression is identical if no copying took place then there is no infringement. Maybe in the UK, given that the judge did say something close to that, but here in the USA that's not really true, unless perhaps you could show that there was so little creativity that it came about by accident. But you might have a hard time getting them to believe you.
- pbhjpbhj 15y agoI'm on thin ice but I think it's true in the USA too - only source I can find (for USA) with a quick search is a Caltech IP law lecture PPT (https://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:35Cr_88udtsJ:https://courses.hss.caltech.edu/Fall2006/Law33%3Faction%3DAttachFile%26do%3Dget%26target%3DLecture10Copyright.ppt+%22Independently+created+similar+works%22+us+caselaw&hl=en&gl=uk&pid=bl&srcid=ADGEESgmYzVgAy1ZBIozYCraE5tD83BQpMZ5GmniSGFhyTiJXyeiX7BLcDFFjlY-LPodpM8i1cNWhsnNghqu4czgk7Sa94LtLVJmSjT7EPKk2JL-FEWslboDokPcwmrLU3KyPYlo5UUM&sig=AHIEtbQqAe9Clp_qgbOrIk4v1IdEI1aChQ https://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:35Cr_88udtsJ:...; this is good for the general case, http://www.iusmentis.com/copyright/crashcourse/requirements/ http://www.iusmentis.com/copyright/crashcourse/requirements/). The issue is the burden of proof. In the tort of copyright in the UK I gather the burden is the balance of probabilities. Maybe in the USA courts the burden lies on the defendant proving they weren't able to copy (rather than on the plaintiff showing they [most likely] did). It's not only a defence where a work is uncreative (that might stop it being an "original work" in Berne Convention terms after all) - if it's impossible for one to have copied the other then there is no infringement (eg the alleged copied work was privately held in a different country to the defendant). --- Edit: http://forum.citizendium.org/index.php?topic=1377.225;wap2 http://forum.citizendium.org/index.php?topic=1377.225;wap2 link surprisingly has a couple of good quotations in the response from '"The essence of copyright is originality [...]"'. In particular - and I'm quoting quotes here - are these two points: "Since his work need not be novel, all that is needed to obtain copyright is originality - that the work have originated with him; the author cannot have copied it from another." (17 U.S.C.A., Section 102(a) as referred to in 'Intellectual Property: Patents, Copyright, and Trademark' by Arthur R. Miller and Michael H. Davis, page 289) and "A copyrightable work must be original and fixed. Originality does not require that the work be exceptionally creative or unique, only that it possess a mere modicum of creativity and is the product of independent creation." ('Oxford Guide to American Law', page 661) Lastly I'm going to grab my own quote from Feist V Rural Telecom (eg http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/scripts/getcase.pl?court=us&vol=499&invol=340 http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/scripts/getcase.pl?court=us... [why didn't I hit up FindLaw first, they're always good for this sort of thing]) - a US Court of Appeal judgement: "Originality does not signify novelty; a work may be original even though it closely resembles other works so long as the similarity is fortuitous, not the result of copying."
- jonhendry 15y agoYou have a point, however the problem is that something like a book or magazine could see a photograph (something professionally shot in a studio, staged, composed, cast with paid models, costumes and makeup, etc) that they like and want to use, decide they don't want to pay the photographer's price, and hire a cheap photographer to reproduce the original photograph's composition. (A friend of mine used to work at a small artist rep company in Chicago (http://www.friendandjohnson.com/ http://www.friendandjohnson.com/), that handled photographers and illustrators. This sort of thing actually happened once in a while.) I think if a photographer can prove something like this happened - if they have documentation of the magazine inquiring about a photograph, then publishing a knockoff without paying, then they have a case, because it's clear that the magazine wanted the original photographer's creative output, they just didn't want to pay for it.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- clarkevans 15y agoI think paragraph 37, where the judge quotes case law, is essential to understanding this case. The judge chooses to quote from a prior ruling and places emphasis this phrase: "defendants deny infringement but they do not advance a case of independent design" The judge then goes on later to note the defendant "could have simply instructed an independent photographer to go to Westminster and take a picture which includes at least a London bus, Big Ben and the Houses of Parliament" In other words, this wasn't a clean room development, actual copying of design took place even though the no direct reproduction occurred. This seems to also mirror the AFC test for copyright infringement. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abstraction-Filtration-Comparison_test http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abstraction-Filtration-Comparis... One you abstract out the stock materials, filter them for originality in design, and compare them, you conclude that the defendants work was indeed a copy of the essential creative elements and arrangement.