4 ms·
nowadays even the lower 10% have their basic needs covered and some left for leisure Only really because of what's left of the welfare system, mainly Medicaid,
by _delirium 15y ago
nowadays even the lower 10% have their basic needs covered and some left for leisure
Only really because of what's left of the welfare system, mainly Medicaid, Section 8 housing, food stamps, and the EITC; which I agree does help on the low end, but is increasingly being time-limited and rationed (e.g. Section 8 is hard to get into). The 10th-percentile household income in the U.S. is around $12,000. If that's all you had to live on, even in cheapish parts of the US it'd be quite a stretch to pay rent+food+transportation+healthcare out of that, especially for more than one person.
The problem is that a society where everybody have similar incomes is somehow fairer, when there is no logical chain leading there and to top it off it causes ruination.
Well, I've lived in both the U.S. and Denmark, which have very different levels of income inequality, and I wouldn't say Denmark has suffered ruination. There are pros and cons, of course. The logical chain isn't that complex if a society actually wants to implement it; it doesn't require some kind of communist revolution, just high and highly progressive taxes (including on capital gains), a national healthcare system, and a strong safety net.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoThe 10th-percentile household income in the U.S. is around $12,000. If that's all you had to live on... It's not all you have to live on. People in these income ranges tend to have consumption of $18-22k. ftp://ftp.bls.gov/pub/special.requests/ce/standard/2009/income.txt The missing piece of the puzzle is that a lot of people in these income ranges receive many benefits which do not qualify as income.
- _delirium 15y agoThat's what the first part of my reply is, isn't it? EITC, Section 8 housing, food stamps, Medicaid, etc., are where the extra money comes from. Which I agree is a good thing, and what makes it at all possible to claim that the 10th-percentile income is one that's possible to live on. But I don't think those programs are very secure (they've been significantly cut, many are hard to get into now if you weren't already in, and I think more cuts are likely), so the prospects aren't great.
- jpadkins 15y agoUmm all of those programs budgets grow year over year every year.. Some of them spiking in recent years. Cuts from future growth rates are not cuts, they just slowed growth of a program.. You might be able to paint a picture of cuts per capita, but that is due to immigration driven population growth, not cuts to the program.
- muyuu 15y agoDenmark's safety net is one thing, some whacko communist universal subsidy is another. Said safety net doesn't decrease disparity significantly, while giving some universal coverage for basic needs. As long as it's not a bigger burden to the economy than the alternative, I'd have nothing against something like this. I also believe the safety nets here in the UK are about right, in general terms. The government is still too big though. Denmark's income inequality has increased during the last decades together with their living standard. http://www.oecd.org/document/22/0,3746,en_21571361_44315115_49185046_1_1_1_1,00.html http://www.oecd.org/document/22/0,3746,en_21571361_44315115_... Notice the language there. "The situation has worsened" because the rich are now richer, even though the living standards have improved dramatically in all income ranges, somehow "the situation has worsened" because now the gap is 6 to 1, instead of 5 to 1 as it was in the 80s. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_disparity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_disparity
- jnorthrop 15y agoDid you really think a national healthcare system is a "whacko communist" idea? If you want to debate it's merits please do, but don't resort to petty name calling.
- muyuu 15y agoNope. I actually take a National healthcare system for granted, ideally working under proper scrutiny. I'd rather have what we have here in the UK than what's in place in the US (as far as I know about it). I was talking about this other idea: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income_guarantee http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income_guarantee
- gyardley 15y agoIt's not a completely wingnut idea. I first bumped into it in Hayek, who was in favor of it and not much of a socialist. The rationale works like this - given that some less-fortunate members of society will need assistance at some point in their life, and given that 'conservative' != 'asshole' and we don't want to just let them die in the street, we have to provide some form of limited welfare state. Since we have to provide some form of limited welfare state, what's the best way to do it while preserving as much freedom as possible? We could set up a large government bureaucracy to do this, with rules and regulations and intrusive measurement for determining who can get what, or we could simply periodically cut everyone a small check. Hayek thought the small check was a lot less harmful than the large bureaucracy. I'm inclined to agree. It'd be better still if the government could get out of the welfare business altogether and leave it to our individual communities - I certainly don't mind that my synagogue dues are used to help our poorer members, and if my tax bill was lower, I'd have still more to donate. But that would require a cultural shift to make practical - it's a shame, but most people in America no longer belong to small, supportive communities.