5 ms·
The key point here is that its not a permanent construct, its using natural mechanisms to slow down wave energy and encourage regrowth of the dunes and littoral
by ggm 4y ago
The key point here is that its not a permanent construct, its using natural mechanisms to slow down wave energy and encourage regrowth of the dunes and littoral zone.
In Australia we've had a lot of permanent fix approaches which were massively counter-productive. If you want to stop sand being mobile then be prepared to lose it entirely. Really? about 200m-500m back from the waters edge is probably the limit of where routine construction should take place. it doesn't make for million dollar views but its safer for that property owner, the commons (assuming you live in an economy where the intertidal zone is public access) and the dunes.
The Gold Coast is a huge sweep of beach which depends on sand from the river Tweed, which was walled off to make a clear run for boats, and now they have to pump sand to replenish. Noosa depends on sand pumping. Rocks might help, they might even make some fantastic surf breaks but they wind up altering the nature of the beach. If you want a beach like surfers paradise or main beach or noosa, you really don't want rocks.
The berm he's made suits his local hydrology. It won't be exactly the same everywhere.
I kind-of hate being the typical HN naysayer. I'm not a tidal engineer or an ecologist or civil engineer. This is stuff which is discussed quite a lot in Australia, since we cling to the coast and an image of ourselves as "in love with the sea" it becomes increasingly necessary to look at how to hold on to what we've got. The run of sand up the eastern seaboard of Australia is amazing. (its like barchan dunes, permanently on the move, in our case south-to-north)
I've visited some of the beachfronts of Washington state and Oregon and they're glorious. Huge trees litter the tide line, amazing to see. We've nothing like that in Australia really, our rivers aren't full of giant redwood logs like that. We have different problems with disappearing Kelp forests, as does the Californian coastline, Oregon might have some of the problems Washington State does.
- floeng 4y agoYou’re absolutely correct that in this area, his dynamic berm fits the hydrology, and that these are not good solutions in other places. Examples: - If the coast is too steep, the rocks won’t reach an equilibrium, and you now just have erosion of rock before your erosion of sand. - If egg-laying sea/coastal life needs sand like sea turtles or some birds - Surfers and tourism (as you mentioned) - If the sand erosion is acting as a source for something downstream; stopping the sand movement will cause erosion in that area (nourishing the beach with sand would probably be a better fit) (Edited formatting)
- pfdietz 4y agoAlso: it's going to depend on the quality of the available local rocks. This thing was using basalt, which is pretty hard.
- FiatLuxDave 4y agoThere is actually a wikipedia article about the technique in the article, which mentions the locations: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dynamic_revetment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dynamic_revetment Note that all the projects mentioned are along the US Pacific coast. So I don't think you are being a naysayer, as much as pointing out that it is not useful everywhere. I live on the east coast of Florida, and we have similar problems to Gold Coast with infrastructure blocking the longshore drift of sand. Sand is constantly in need of replenishment in locations say, south of Port Canaveral. I wonder if we will ever have a property right to the river of sand in the same way that water rights are enforced upon rivers. I seem to remember a method proposed of placing wave attenuators just past the break as a way of depositing sand, but unfortunately I cannot remember the name of it and could not find it through a quick search. I was hoping that we might try this method where I live.
- ianburrell 4y agoI think that can happen naturally, unless they are dumping rocks on my hometown California beach. There is a layer of rocks below the summer sand level that are exposed in winter. I guess they could have dumped rocks years ago when erosion was problem. My hometown beach was fixed by restoring connection to lagoon behind it and allowing the sand to be dumped in the ocean not the lagoon. Restoring the lagoon and digging a channel helped but what really helped was building new bridge that didn’t block the flow. They used to dredge sand to have enough in summer. Now there is plenty in summer but can get rocky in winter after storm.
- DoreenMichele 4y agoThis is stuff which is discussed quite a lot in Australia, since we cling to the coast and an image of ourselves as "in love with the sea" FWIW: Half the human race lives less than 200km from the sea. https://www.reddit.com/r/MapPorn/comments/uxrinu/half_of_the_world_population_lives_at_less_than/?utm_term=1870696506&utm_medium=post_embed&utm_source=embed&utm_name=&utm_content=header https://www.reddit.com/r/MapPorn/comments/uxrinu/half_of_the...
- Jedd 4y agoIt's an odd thing to quibble about, but 200km is quite a distance, and not what I'd say 'coastal'. I'm 135km from the coast (I'm north west of Sydney, AU) but that's a 2h5m drive away. I'd not claim to be coastal. 200km means no one in the UK could be considered not coastal -- IIRC it's impossible to be more than ~115km from the coast. I think a more telling statistic is that in Australia, more than 85 per cent of people live within 50 kilometres of the coast - mind, even 50km inland wouldn't fit what I would think of as coastal dwelling.
- DoreenMichele 4y agoNah, it's not an odd thing to quibble about. I did try to word it such that it wouldn't be misinterpreted as me saying "200km is the same as coastal."' I appreciated the info in the GP comment and I realize Australia is likely more extreme than average, but one of the reasons humans are so concerned about rising seas and eroding beaches is because it impacts so many lives. If 90 percent of people lived more than 200km from the coast and it was sort of "a handful of weirdos" that lived near the beach, I think humans wouldn't be so distressed by these things. It would be "Meh, nature out there can do what it wants. My house is safe and life goes on."
- Jedd 4y agoI still fondly recall my English teacher at high school (several decades ago) describing our population here as 'like the scum around the edge of an empty bathtub'. Despite that I do remember him as a cheery chap. Anyway, I'm sure most of the population lives near water, mostly oceans, but sometimes (inland) along rivers. Proximity to the coast is very misleading, as obviously the risk is predominantly down to elevation. As I noted, 100% of the UK live within 120km of the coast, and my weirdo assessment of their populationi aside, with an average elevation of 160 metres, most of the land will be fine. London's screwed, of course, with even only minor sea level rises. They're an exceptional case in all kinds of ways. Let's move on. Best info I can find is an NPR article that suggests some research 15 years ago estimated about 600M people lived within 10 metres of sea level. So, if Greenland goes, they're all displaced. Anyway, this doesn't really contest TFA's point, which seems to be 'large aggregate will slow down erosion'. Obviously holding your soil in place doesn't help much if it's held in place under 10 metres of saltwater.
- prawn 4y agoFor those interested: "almost 90 per cent of today's Australians live within 50 kilometres of the coast" I live 11km by car (9km on a map) from the excellent beaches here and almost never go because it's "too far".
- ace2358 4y agoI used to love in inter city north Melbourne for the cool life style. I moved to northern rivers area after 30 years of living in the city. I moved to a house about 1.5km for the beach. Over three years that went from “the closest I’ll ever live to the beach!” To “I can’t be bothered going to the beach, it’s a bit cloudy, not worth it!”. I now live 400m to the beach and go everyday. I’ve grown up a bit an realised that I may never live like this again! We definitely are a costal nation. I love hearing the ocean roar as I go to sleep.
- Andaith 4y agoDon't worry, I can walk to 2 different beaches in 10 mins, but they're both "crap" and "doggie beaches", so we instead drive 40 minutes to go to a "good beach"...
- Someone 4y ago> The key point here is that its not a permanent construct, its using natural mechanisms to slow down wave energy and encourage regrowth of the dunes and littoral zone. A nice example of that is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sand_engine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sand_engine: “A volume of 21.5 million m3 of sand, dredged from 5-10 km offshore, covered an area of 128 ha, spanning 2.4 km along the coastline and extending up to 1 km offshore. The sand was deposited in the form of a hook-shaped peninsula. Wind, wave and tide action were allowed to distribute the sand further.” Since it was successful, the same approach was used in the UK, too (https://coastalsolutions.ireport.royalhaskoningdhv.com/13001009A1 https://coastalsolutions.ireport.royalhaskoningdhv.com/13001...)
- kitd 4y agoAnother technique is used at Elmer Beach in the UK. Rock breakwaters are built with gaps between them. This means that the natural movements of sediment with the tides fills up the space behind them, ie between them and the shoreline. They also make for nice sheltered little bays. https://www.chelifer.com/?page_id=4645 https://www.chelifer.com/?page_id=4645
- bsenftner 4y agoSlight aside with this question: how much awareness is there in Australia with the collapse of the Thwaites Ice Shelf? Considering Australia's national identify of beach culture, that collapse is going to change everything. I'm curious if there is discussion, and if so of what nature. In the 'States the situation is virtually unknown. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/antarcticas-collapse-could-begin-even-sooner-than-anticipated/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/antarcticas-colla...
- ggm 4y agoIt's understood that we're going to be affected and that its a when not if in some peoples minds. The thing is that we have more direct and present climate change issues so sea level rise which is slow (to date) is not figured in planning compared to existing sources of higher mean tide such as land sinking, combined with big rain events. Brisbane where I live already has king tide events swamping some streets. 10cm is enough to be potentially problematic, never mind 1.5m. "The river with a city problem" is a good read about the insanity of building greater Brisbane on a giant floodplain. Kiribati is already under. We get quite a lot about Oceania problems, displacement. I think thwaites is still treated as the next generations problem.