5 ms·
> A model of power consumption by autonomous vehicles predicts that once widely adopted, they will consume as much power worldwide as data centers do. It's ref
by crazygringo 4y ago
> A model of power consumption by autonomous vehicles predicts that once widely adopted, they will consume as much power worldwide as data centers do.
It's referring to the energy to power the brains of self-driving, not to move the vehicle.
But that seems... fine? I can't tell if the article wants us to think that's a lot.
Data centers and networks account for something like 1% of global electricity use.
If autonomous driving saves a ton of lives then an extra 1% is well worth it. Just from productivity increases alone it may also be well worth it. But also, the "brains" will presumably become more energy-efficient over time (as electronics have generally), and the share of renewables is increasing.
I don't really see a problem here.
- grey-area 4y agoThey can also be programmed to drive in a more efficient way that humans so there is a net saving of power.
- m463 4y agoI think that pretty much sums it up on many levels. I think of not just better route planning, but that one delivery driver can service 100's of customers who would otherwise make a trip themselves.
- trompetenaccoun 4y agoFor delivery you're right but we could have this today already. There's no reason not to put minimum wage drivers in a car and have them do this today. We have computers and mapping already, self-driving isn't needed for this at all and paying someone 100 dollars a day or whatever is guaranteed to be much cheaper than the self delivering truck - at least for now and in the foreseeable future. So why isn't it a thing? Clearly not for the lack of self-driving tech.
- mechagodzilla 4y agoDo you actually have any data to back up the 'net saving of power' part?
- mindslight 4y agoIt's more palatable to be moving at only 65mph or even 55mph if you're a passenger and don't have to pay attention, as opposed to being an active driver going 75-80mph to finish the task as soon as possible. And I doubt self driving cars will be programmed to speed and then slow down when they spot a cop, where human drivers are generally overspec'd enough to do that.
- defrost 4y agoIf this is a serious question then you can look to eight years of autonomus vehicle records held by Rio Tinto in the mega scale mining sector (800 million tonne / annum moved) running dump trucks, trains, etc. Continous 24/7/365 operations show operational energy amd maintenance efficiences from supervised autonomous trucks over human operated trucks.
- grey-area 4y agoNo, but I think it’s quite obvious humans do not drive with efficiency in mind the vast majority of the time.
- marcosdumay 4y agoBesides being fine, I also doubt it will stay true. Datacenters have been consuming more and more energy because the work they are expected to do is always increasing. Self-driving cars have some phenomenally large problem to solve... and that's it. Any efficiency gain on those computers will realize as reduced consumption.
- pubby 4y agoYou need to take Wirth's law into consideration.
- wing-_-nuts 4y agoPlease define the uncommon words you use...
- teach 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wirth%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wirth%27s_law
- piyh 4y agoThe only thing that's going to constrain how much compute that cars will consume is cost and impact on range.
- midoridensha 4y agoExcept that's not it. The problem will get bigger and bigger, requiring more and more compute power. You see, whatever system you design to autonomously control a car will never be "enough", or perfectly safe. There are simply too many variables in the environment, too many possibilities. So a certain design, taking a certain amount of compute power, will give you a certain level of safety. But it won't be perfect. People will want more safety and better systems. That'll take more power (probably exponentially more, as we've already seen with other simulations). The cycle will never end.
- 4y ago
- akira2501 4y ago> If autonomous driving saves a ton of lives then an extra 1% is well worth it Your total scope is about 40,000 road deaths. Off the top 1/6 of those are pedestrians most often hit at night. Another 1/6 is motorcycles. A little more than 1/2 are those who are drunk or otherwise impaired. Around a 1/3 involve someone under the age of 24 and male. People presume that driving is exceptionally dangerous. If you actually examine the data you realize it's one of the safest things we do, given the _trillions_ of miles that are driven every year in the US alone. From this perspective, it's not at all clear that greater levels of automation are going to improve anything. From the history of introduction into airlines, it will initially make travel _less safe_ until drivers are retrained to use the new systems in a way that doesn't enhance risk. These will often be non-intuitive lessons. If you put a human in a machine also designed by a human and use it around other humans, you will never eliminate human factors.
- crazygringo 4y agoI don't know where you're getting 40,000 road deaths from, because: > According to the World Health Organization (WHO), road traffic injuries caused an estimated 1.35 million deaths worldwide in 2016. That is, one person is killed every 26 seconds on average. [1] I also don't know what the breakdown you give has to do with. If we can save the lives of pedestrians, drunk people, and males under 24, then amazing. Also, a quick Google search reveals that in the US: > Deaths and injuries resulting from motor vehicle crashes are the leading cause of death for persons of every age from 3 through 33 (based on 2003 data). That sounds pretty dangerous to me if it's the leading cause of death. Maybe not that dangerous per-mile, but clearly those miles add up. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-related_death_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-r...
- akira2501 4y ago> I don't know where you're getting 40,000 road deaths from, because: US road fatalities. This is because NHTSA catalogs every one of them and the circumstances leading up to them. This product is called the FARS. > If we can save the lives of pedestrians, drunk people, and males under 24, then amazing. You're assuming they'll use the automation. Or you're presuming it will be forced on people. Which ignored motorcycles. Or bicycles. People use those. > Deaths and injuries resulting from motor vehicle crashes are the leading cause of death for persons of every age from 3 through 33 (based on 2003 data). I'd like to know where you got that statistic from. In the US, it is not likely to be true. Accidental self inflicted injury, a separate category, is often the most common until Heart Disease and Cancer become factors. The reason to use the US is because it is a developed country, a wide variety of different states and road conditions, and it has a single reporting agency covering it. Presuming that automated vehicles are going to lead to major improvements outside of developed nations is a bit unfounded.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Gordonjcp 4y ago> If autonomous driving saves a ton of lives then an extra 1% is well worth it. Just from productivity increases alone it may also be well worth it I think that's a pretty optimistic assessment of it. So far they've only been capable of driving in conditions where humans don't have accidents anyway, and driving in more difficult conditions is a bit of a "ladder to the Moon" scenario. I don't buy into the whole "think of all the time you'll save" thing either.