8 ms·
New research finds almost 90% of women penalized due to work achievements
- lr4444lr 4y agoIs it possible that men experience this in equal numbers, but just don't interpret those interactions in the same way?
- wonderwonder 4y agoOr no one cared enough to ask them. I find this the more likely explanation.
- positron6000 4y ago[flagged]
- janktank 4y agoThey're only 50% of the population, right?
- positron6000 4y ago[flagged]
- janktank 4y agoIsn't this the same kind of dismissive, silencing behavior the submission calls out? You don't seem to practice what you preach.
- positron6001 4y agono, because you haven't advanced any argument to be dismissed or silenced. literally just support for "won't someone think of the men?" that argument hasn't been silenced - you can find it in every right-wing crevice of the internet. and i'm not preaching anything, just out here observing how every women's issue on HN gets turned into "but what about the men?" or "they must be lying." anyways, i have to get back to work oppressing men in the workplace. unfortunately we'll never know their plight - as we can tell from the comments here, men definitely suffer in silence and are completely unheard.
- yamtaddle 4y agoThe study fails at its (apparent?) purpose of highlighting sexism in the workplace without that point of comparison, though. It'd still be pretty weak even with that (it's survey-based—observational studies are expensive and hard, but way better), but it's the bare minimum we'd need to even begin to figure out what kinds of interesting things the study might point toward for further examination.
- wonderwonder 4y ago"The rate of suicide is highest in middle-aged white men. In 2020, men died by suicide 3.88x more than women." https://afsp.org/suicide-statistics/ https://afsp.org/suicide-statistics/ Yeah screw those guys right, women are obviously experiencing way more stressful lives and have to deal with more negative things.
- positron6001 4y agothis is an article about women in the workplace, not suicide stats or an attempt to measure some kind of vague notion of suffering ("negative things"?). but sure, let's turn an article about an issue that women face into one about men. again, won't someone think of the men? and only the men?
- altairprime 4y agoThere’s a labor department study that found that 25% of US unemployed men will flat out refuse paying work if it doesn’t pay them better than their peers — and then they resent their peers for having paying work. So of course men are more likely to get depressed commit suicide: “I’m worthless unless I’m worth more than he is” is a cruel and vicious ethos to believe in, and hands responsibility for mental well-being to their neighbor’s salary. (No doubt there’s other reasons too, but all the same: men self-inflict a lot of harm that’s unique to men. Men ought to do something about that.)
- wonderwonder 4y agoCurrent unemployment rate is 3.4%. assume half are men. So 1.7%. 25% of that is 0.425% of men. Maybe not the greatest statistical measure to judge men's suicide rates on. How would men even know how much their coworkers make? I would very much like to see the wording of the question that drove this survey. Did the study ask the same question of women? If not then how do we know this is just not a human thing. Why base the suicide rates on that and not on getting cut down at work or any and all the issues the article says women are suffering from at a high rate? They seem more likely to explain a nearly 4x suicide rate.
- dyno12345 4y agoyou don't know if gender is even a casually related factor if you don't collect data for both genders
- HideousKojima 4y agoYeah, this is all self-reporting based mostly on perceptions of things as opposed to things that are objective and/or quantifiable. I don't know about you, but when I tell my coworkers/managers "Hey I found like 100 SQL injection vulnerabilities in this legacy codebase can I please have permission to fix them?" and they ignore me, I don't assume they're undermining me or jealous of my success. I assume they're just idiots.
- yamtaddle 4y agoI've had an idea I proposed in a meeting ignored, only to be greeted warmly and immediately adopted when proposed later in the exact same meeting... by a woman (and not one higher than me on the "totem pole", either). I didn't interpret it as sexism, but if I'd been a woman and her a man, I guess I probably would have taken it as not just sexism, but egregious sexism, the kind of blatant crap one can hardly believe exists. I gather that's actually one of the nasty things about sexism—it's hard to really be sure when what's happening is sexism, versus when it's just ordinary shitty things that happen to everyone.
- altairprime 4y agoYour anecdote lacks any information on existing social networking that may be in effect, that could provide a gender-agnostic explanation for this outcome. This outcome occurs quite regularly with engineers who disregard social networking with their leadership, regardless of the gender of those who have invested in networking and reap the rewards of it in recognition and “being heard”. You’d need to establish a pattern of refusal to network with non-women, in order to have grounds to pursue a gendered case, given only this anecdote as evidence.
- yamtaddle 4y agoOh, of course. Again, I don't think it was sexism. But something that, under other circumstances, would look very very much like blatant sexism—might not be. Which causes problems for lots of women (I've heard) because they'll hesitate to act on actual sexism, due to all the second-guessing. This is relevant for the study, because "experienced a thing that, viewed through a certain lens, looks a ton like sexism" is something that I could answer "yes" to (more than once, actually! That was just the one that would have most-looked-like sexism if our positions had been reversed)... but I'm pretty sure it wasn't. Without some kind of baseline rate for this stuff, it's hard to tell what's actually going on. Further, as men and women might interpret the exact same events differently, you'd really need an observational study to begin to suss out the reality—a survey's not going to cut it, beyond maybe providing guidance on areas for further research.
- altairprime 4y ago[flagged]
- lr4444lr 4y agoThere are some huge confounding variables there. If they went to other jobs where their coworkers had no knowledge of their pretransition existence and noticed this shift, I think you'd have a compelling case.
- fidgewidge 4y agoTrans women also report that the hormones they take make them act and feel more feminine, so if women are more likely to feel that way given the exact same circumstance as men then you'd see the same results.
- wonderwonder 4y agoOr maybe after imbibing large amounts of hormones and the desire to be both seen as women and accepted by women their perception of previously normal behavior changed and they now view it's as assumed persecution to fit in.
- figlett3 4y ago[flagged]
- brainzap 4y agoI wonder what the biologic reason behind this is.
- ciancimino 4y agoWould be nice to see what tools can help women give insights into culture before being locked into an environment. I feel lucky I found a company that values my input and efforts.
- jdmtheNth 4y ago"insights into culture" Would be logical and reduce perceptions and assumptions of sexist behaviour. Unfortunately, it won't be done because the expectation is that it is a culture that must accommodate anyone that thinks they belong there. Unless it's men in women's prisons, then it's ok for some reason.
- fdgsdfogijq 4y agoArent women making more than men now in the younger generation? Below 30 they are blowing men out of the water in terms of income and educational achievement.
- throwawayacc5 4y agoThey are, but that is a hate fact.
- cassac 4y agoWhat is a “hate fact”?
- gruez 4y agoPresumably facts that imply politically incorrect statements. The most obvious one would be "despite being x% of the population, [group] commits y% of the crimes".
- civilized 4y agoIt's a mocking reference to how people can dislike it when facts that don't match their ideology are presented in a discussion. In this case, someone who wants the focus to be on women might be irritated when facts about men falling behind are presented.
- gruez 4y ago>Below 30 they are blowing men out of the water in terms of income and educational achievement. source?
- korroziya 4y agoClickbait news sites.
- DanTheManPR 4y agoI suspect OP is referring to articles about how young women make more money than young men in some metro areas. You can look at actual nation-wide data from the BLS: https://www.bls.gov/news.release/wkyeng.t03.htm https://www.bls.gov/news.release/wkyeng.t03.htm
- wonderwonder 4y agoI am highly skeptical of research from an organization whos existence depends on the problem they are attempting to solve remaining in existence.
- RomanPushkin 4y agoRude. I don't see any reason why such organization shouldn't exist. I see the different side though. There is a pretty big number of male-dominated industries. And I'm not surprised by the numbers the research found. My recent conversation with a friend from Google: - How many women are on your team? - Not too much - Oh, but what's the number? - Zero, there aren't any
- wonderwonder 4y agoI'm not saying they shouldn't exist. If their funding depends on a problem existing though, I'm pretty confident that their research will always find that the problem exists and is of high importance. Not many charities are going to go, our research found this isn't really an issue, we're shutting down. Are there no women on his team because of sexism? or because far fewer women choose to graduate with a CS degree? You are assuming sexism when the answer could simply be a lack of qualified candidates. What if women simply don't like CS at the same rate as men? Only ~22% of CS graduates are women. Or is that sexist to acknowledge that those numbers may drive team makeup at software companies?
- mym1990 4y agoIt isn't about the organization existing, but about the organization backing research that reinforces the organizations beliefs(which could totally be valid). It's like the sugar industry backing research that says sugar is good for you.
- korroziya 4y agoThis.
- attemptone 4y agoFor the same reason I dismiss any paper from a department that focuses on 'Unified field theory' Or Computer Scientist that do research. Those eggheads can't see the forest because of all the trees. 'Is iT cOMputaBLE?' sure, but if you don't start the computation and are just theorizing it will never be computable. 'QuaDratic TIMe ComPlexiTY oF TRansfomerS?' Just buy more RAM and CPUs. What's the problem?
- yamtaddle 4y agoSurvey-based, it appears, and I'm not seeing what the results look like for men. Which is weird considering the apparent focus of the study, since you can't even begin to draw any conclusions about the role of sex in this, without that point of comparison. Maybe it's in the full study? (Nb. this doesn't necessarily mean that the proposed reforms aren't a good idea)
- colpabar 4y agofrom tfa: > Methodology: The study was planned and carried out in 2023. An online survey was sent out to contacts in Women of Influence+’s database and was also shared on social media. Most of those who received the survey identify as women. The survey was sent out on January 9, 2023, and closed on February 10, 2023. In the end, 4,710 respondents took part in the survey across 103 countries. So scientific! This would be like if the NRA claimed that there actually isn't a gun problem in america because they surveyed their members.
- rhn_mk1 4y agoIs this a problem on the gender axis? Or is it a problem across the board? It's entirely unclear, and it'd be a mistake to conclude that women get penalized [while men do not]. > The survey was sent to contacts in Women of Influence+’s database and was also shared via social media. The majority of those who received the survey identify as women. So the study didn't actually measure women specifically? There's no breakdown by gender anywhere in the whitepaper.
- korroziya 4y agoI'm going to take commentary about women problems from a website called "women of influence" with the tiniest grain of salt.
- positron6000 4y ago[flagged]
- kneebonian 4y agoThe actual study can be found here: https://www.womenofinfluence.ca/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/tp-whitepaper.pdf https://www.womenofinfluence.ca/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/t... The methodology was thus: > The study was planned and carried out between January and February 2023. An online survey,using a mixed-methods approach, was sent out on January 9, 2023, and closed on February 10, 2023. The survey was sent to contacts in Women of Influence+’s database and was also shared via social media. The majority of those who received the survey identify as women. In the end, 4,710 respondents across 103 countries took part in the survey. This paper discusses the data revealed by the survey including the prevalence of TPS for women in the workplace an examination of who is doing the cutting, the effect it has on women both in terms of their psychological health and workplace performance, the resulting impact on company productivity and retention, and the solutions suggested by women on the front lines to manage, mitigate, and eliminate this silent systemic syndrome Couple of points to highlight from the methodology: > The survey was sent to contacts in Women of Influence+’s database and was also shared via social media. > In the end, 4,710 respondents across 103 countries took part in the survey Note the absence of what the response rate was. > The majority of those who received the survey identify as women. Note: No control or comparison group.
- RobotToaster 4y agoSo it isn't even published in a peer reviewed journal?
- bitbang 4y agoThe methodology backing this report is garbage.
- janktank 4y agoThe methodology of this study is embarrassing.
- neotrope 4y agoWhat garbage. Claiming survey results from self-selecting anonymous website visitors as "research" isn't even junk science — it's spam.
- legitster 4y ago> 77 per cent of respondents had their achievements downplayed > 72.4 per cent of respondents were left out of meetings and discussions or were ignored > 70.7 per cent said they were undermined because of their achievement(s) > 68.3 per cent had their achievement(s) dismissed > 66.1 per cent said others took credit for their work It's hard not to read this as "respondents overwhelmingly reported experiencing normal workplace things at work".
- wonderwonder 4y agoThe numbers in the article are difficult to believe. "Almost 90 per cent (85.6 per cent) indicated that their stress had increased because of Tall Poppy Syndrome" So 90% of women are very successful and "tall poppys" "Almost 70 per cent (67.8 per cent) of respondents looked for a new role/job and 50 per cent left their previous role/job" 50% of the 90% of women got new jobs because they were cut down for being too successful. That seems like a lot of people, due to the numbers this probably involves the majority of companies. Where did they go work? The article is very vague with numbers only using percentages. I would not be shocked if the total number of respondents consisted entirely of the authors friends and family. Edit: it's actually worse than I expected. While there were more participants than I thought; 4k+, they were all on the mailing list of the org. So a woman's org focused on sexism in the workplace polled it's members to ask if there was sexism in the workplace and then reported it as widespread fact. Terrible
- M95D 4y agoI can say yes to many of those situations, and I'm a man.
- kthejoker2 4y agoSince everyone is complaining about methodology, what would be a valid research experiment? What did they miss? Is it just the self-reporting aspect?