6 ms·
I think we'll soon discover that the sugar industry is paying a lot of money for all this 'research' and 'news coverage' on sugar alternatives. The phrase 'non
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
I think we'll soon discover that the sugar industry is paying a lot of money for all this 'research' and 'news coverage' on sugar alternatives.
The phrase 'non-nutritive sweeteners' is just too loaded a term for me to accept.
Any article that doesn't heavily emphasise that excess sugar is right now killing people is suspect.
> Studies show that when other countries, including Chile and Australia, instituted policies to reduce sugar consumption, the result was an increase in artificially sweetened foods and beverages.
Oh no, artificial sweeteners replacing the "natural" corn syrup in my caffeinated beverage. How frightening, I want good old fashioned corn syrup killing me while providing empty calories.
- meroes 4y agoI'm the opposite - I want my food to match my biological expectations, one of the largest being sweet = I just took in quick calories. Not for any grand reason other than I let my hunger and energy levels guide my food choices. I find that the best way long term. I don't have a strong biological instinct of discerning corn syrup from "natural sugar". That is something reading labels helps me with. But I can't fight the biological urges the same way. Empty calories are still somewhat beneficial. I eat a lot of fruit for energy, but sometimes I just want something even quicker and easier to digest and process for my calories, like jelly beans or something. And fruit is more expensive.
- eldaisfish 4y agoThe important piece here is context, as it always it. One example - i grew up eating bread that used no sugar or very little sugar. North American bread tastes too close to cake. Many North Americans don’t share my opinion because their baseline is different. Almost all food is a combination of flavours and it is not easy to spot added sugar. The idea of « sweet » is a lot more difficult to use in the real world.
- tracker1 4y agoGo carnivore for a week, and you'd be surprised how overly sweet everything tastes after... until you get used to it again that is.
- CyberDildonics 4y agoYou don't need a "carnivore" diet for that, you just need to avoid sugar and adjust to it.
- tracker1 4y agoAvoiding sugar may still include very sweet fruit varieties, or juice that can still prevent such adaptation... otherwise, sure, you can do similar without full on carnivore. All said, it was an example.
- throwway120385 4y agoA lot of the problem I have with fruit now is that it's picked so early that it's virtually flavorless. Fuji apples for instance have this beautiful floral/tangy/fruity flavor when they're allowed to ripen on the tree. But go into a supermarket anywhere in my neck of the woods and they're these green things that are just beginning to turn red, and they just taste like fresh leaves with sugar in them. And the supermarket is charging like 4 dollars a pound for the lowest quality crap fruit they can get.
- raegis 4y agoThe trick for me is to get them from a grocery store with a huge selection. Among a hundred or so apples, there's usually 2 or 3 red ones. The flavor is amazing.
- throwway120385 4y agoIn my early 20's I made it a point to stop drinking and eating garbage like Starbucks frappucinos. After a period of 3 years I found myself in a place that only sold the pre-made frappuchinos and some other drinks, but no water or water-like drinks. So I bought one. And in the intervening years it had become disgustingly sweet. Like so sweet that I almost threw up and had to throw away half the bottle. So yes, avoiding sugar will change your tastebuds.
- jrockway 4y agoWhat is "North American" bread exactly? I bake my own bread and use a tablespoon of sugar; the bread does not taste sweet. But if you buy like Wonder bread in the stores, that's intentionally sweetened to taste like cake. I have never seen anyone buy that stuff, though.
- tstrimple 4y agoYou've never seen anyone purchase the best selling brand of white bread in the US?
- QuarterReptile 4y agoSurely we're not surprised how detached, on this site, we mostly are from common consumption behaviors?
- ryeights 4y agoStroll through the prepackaged bread aisle of any U.S. grocery store and look at the sugar content on the nutrition labels. At my local Safeway, the generic brand 100% whole wheat bread contains 4g of sugar per slice. With 16 slices in a pack, that’s a third cup of sugar per loaf. The ingredients? Whole wheat flour, water, sugar, wheat gluten, honey, brown sugar, yeast, oil, salt, …
- paiute 4y agoI enjoy converting g to number of sugar packets which is about 3g. So that's 1 packet per slice (which the yeast might eat). When you say that a coke has 10 packets of sugar it makes you gag a little.
- drekk 4y agoWhen I bake bread I use a pinch of sugar for an entire loaf. The yeast are just fine eating the flour. Thinking of a packet of sugar PER SLICE is insane to me. Especially for whole grain
- deleted 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- autoexec 4y ago> American bread tastes too close to cake. I've heard multiple people from other countries say the same thing. It seems crazy to think about people using cake for bread in sandwiches, but I can see why they'd think that. Even the packaged lunch meats sold in stores have sugar added to them for some reason, I wouldn't be surprised if the deli meat did too. The only thing without added sugar in a sandwich might be the lettuce!
- tracker1 4y agoI'm mostly inclined to agree... I try to keep my total carbs below 50g/day and net carbs under 20g/day, I'm diabetic and prefer to minimize my use of exogenous insulin. The cap on the total, is because there are definitely affects from fiber, sugar alcohols, etc that aren't accounted for otherwise. Too many people will turn to the alternatives as an all you can consume buffet and not realize that what is being consumed still has 40-60% of the effects that sugar does on glucose control alone. And that doesn't cover the effects on gut flora. I'm not fond of the vegetarian push in TFA though. I think animal products are perfectly natural and generally good nutrition sources and that the refined fats and sugars are far more dangerous generally speaking. Fruit juice in quantity being as or more dangerous as soda. Fructose does everything bad to the liver that alcohol does without the negative reinforcement of a headache after.
- deafpolygon 4y ago> Fructose does everything bad to the liver that alcohol does Does the alcohol itself not add to the damage?
- tracker1 4y agoSure... but you don't need alcohol... just fructose will do it. The point is that most people don't know that fructose alone will cause liver damage in anything resembling significant quantities... eg: more than 100g HFCS or table sugar a day, which many western people regularly consume... especially if they think that fruit juice smoothies are healthy.
- ed123 4y ago[dead]
- tracker1 4y agoI'm mostly referring to juice (called out smoothies)... also, specifically referred to HFCS and Table Sugar (about half Fructose). Worth noting a serving of juice is about 4oz (125ml) and should only have 3-4 servings of juice a week... not a massive fruit juice smoothie. With fruit, will depend on the fruit and fiber content... most berries are much better (lower GL, higher fiber) than an orange, pineapple or grapes. But higher sugar content fruits with lower fiber content or very high quantities can still be problematic. https://www.dietdoctor.com/fructose-fatty-liver-sugar-toxin https://www.dietdoctor.com/fructose-fatty-liver-sugar-toxin https://www.nih.gov/news-events/nih-research-matters/how-high-fructose-intake-may-trigger-fatty-liver-disease https://www.nih.gov/news-events/nih-research-matters/how-hig... https://openheart.bmj.com/content/4/2/e000631 https://openheart.bmj.com/content/4/2/e000631
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lo_zamoyski 4y ago> I let my hunger and energy levels guide my food choices. Perhaps "inform" (as in a signal that does not determine decision) might be a better approach. Hunger is not strictly correlated with need. That is, hunger and appetite are also subject to habituation. If someone is accustomed to eating three large meals a day with snacks in between, they will likely feel hungry when one of those meals is eliminated, or even when snacks are reduced. We hardly need as much as we generally consume, and the last thing we need is to be led around by our appetites. Like children, they can tell us what they want, but it is we who must assess what is actually needed or within healthy limits. Lack of hunger should also not form the basis for not eating. I suspect that's why you included "energy levels" as another signal. If you're not merely hungry, but feeling weak, and you know you haven't eaten in a while, then you could probably use some food. I would argue that adopting a schedule and using fasting to reduce intake and "noshing" and conform hunger reoccurrence to this schedule are a good approach. Fasting also has the benefit of helping us discipline our appetites, something people are generally miserable at unless they practice self-denial or have them disciplined by outside causes. Disciplined appetites sharpen the mind and strengthen the will and contribute to virtue and therefore true freedom (in the classical sense, not the liberal sense which is a recipe for enslavement). This latter benefit is more important than the first. Furthermore, human beings are animals, but we are not beasts. We do not merely guzzle slop from a trough. We eat meals. Meals are not merely about obtaining nutrition.
- autoexec 4y ago> Disciplined appetites sharpen the mind Do you have a source for that? To what extent is the mind "sharpened" by putting off snacks?
- meroes 4y agoYou’re right on many points. And yes I did say energy levels to account for not relying solely on hunger. You’re using the “through disciple -> freedom” idea from Aristotle I think. And you’re using what is needed. I agree for your conception of humans we need the regimen you lay out. I don’t argue with that. But how do you fill your plates? With discipline you count each asparagus frond, weigh each food group, count every calorie? No, at some point we are listening to ourselves. Since we are already doing that, why not skip many of these middle-practices? I am very present taking in food and assembling my meal. Why do I need Greek philosophers to tell me what I already know? Eating is for ourselves. Not everything is so selfish and personal, but it is one case where listening inward is the primary focus. Contrast to listening to the needs of others in order to be happy. Maybe that’s another discipline, to be present and listen inward. And not appeal to principles of others. I also arrived at this stage by failing with other diets over 7 years or so. It’s not like I had some grand principle at the beginning. I could not do certain things I like to do with fasting. I hike and stretch every single day as physical therapy for an injury. Fasting would wreck me.
- Alex3917 4y ago> I want my food to match my biological expectations, one of the largest being sweet = I just took in quick calories Except for that your biological expectations should be that sweet foods are relatively slow calories. We've co-evolved over millions of years to get sugar from fruit and other complex carbs. Refined sugar has only existed for a couple thousand years, and has only been ubiquitous for a few hundred years. To the extent that your body is expecting a quick rush of calories after eating something sweet, that's only because your body is very reactive based on your prior eating habits, not because that makes any sense from an evolutionary perspective.
- meroes 4y agoI’m talking in terms of carbs as fast vs fat and protein as slow. Not the different type of carbs. I should have been more precise.
- LewisVerstappen 4y agoIt's best to just read what actual researchers/doctors think rather than rely on bullshit corporate media like WaPo/CNN/etc. You can read - Peter Attia (Stanford MD) -> https://peterattiamd.com/more-hype-than-substance-erythritol-and-cardiovascular-risk/ https://peterattiamd.com/more-hype-than-substance-erythritol... - Layne Norton (Nutritional Sciences PhD) -> https://youtu.be/Ad8_scQtHFM https://youtu.be/Ad8_scQtHFM They both think the study is being sensationalized by the media for clicks (as usual)
- hbcondo714 4y ago> the sugar industry is paying a lot of money for all this 'research' and 'news coverage' on sugar alternatives This has happened before. In the 1960's, the sugar industry funded research that downplayed the risks of sugar and highlighted the hazards of fat: https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/09/13/493739074/50-years-ago-sugar-industry-quietly-paid-scientists-to-point-blame-at-fat https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/09/13/493739074...
- waboremo 4y agoSugar isn't the only industry either, Dairy operated the same ways. Funding nonsensical research about how healthy and great it is, meanwhile the study is just on added vitamin D, something milk doesn't have naturally. It's how they get away with it, and all you would see in news and ads is "drink milk it's healthy!" Dairy even worse in many ways, because there was no requirement in the food pyramid (and it's related forms) to have a bunch of sugar. However, it's been standard for decades to push multiple full cups of milk per day.
- pkaye 4y agoDon't also forget when margarine was considered healthier than butter. Or that activists were pushing McDonalds for switch from tallow to vegetable oils. Now we consider trans fats and many vegetable oils bad. Or that one time eggs were considered to raise your cholesterol.
- _aavaa_ 4y agothat one time? I feel like you could set your watch to how often eggs being bad flip flops
- drekk 4y agoTallow is absolutely not better for you than frying in oils. Tallow also has trans fats. Margarine is lower in saturated fats than butter with none of the cholesterol. None are good for you versus a liquid oil like canola. Eating more fruits and vegetables is always going to be better for you all other things being equal. I still eat fried foods as a vegetarian but my cholesterol is way down. When I donate plasma there isn't gunk in the filter like everyone else. Dunno why people think eating meat and butter every day is possibly sustainable at a health or ecological level. Our ancestors were lucky to get bone marrow. That's the baseline. We still have those same bodies and brains. We've just changed the environment completely and are seeing the consequence (less acute mortality, higher chronic mortality)
- Fauntleroy 4y agoDeal with a bout of fake-sugar-induced gut fauna chaos and you'll be singing a different tune. It sure woke me up on the subject.
- seizethecheese 4y agoI really doubt that sugar is more profitable than fake sugar for industry.
- Teknoman117 4y agoRegardless, I do wish products containing them were labeled better. My dad is allergic to most of them. We nearly had to make an ER visit after he ate some pickles because Kosher decided that they suddenly needed to put artificial sweetener in their pickles.
- dayvid 4y agoAgree. Sugar also blasts your immune system: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32395846/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32395846/ Better to reduce sugar and artificial sweeteners, but sugar alone, especially in a concentrated food/drink additive form is far worst for you than artificial sweeteners.
- brainzap 4y agoInternational Life Sciences Institute
- hedora 4y agoFrom what I can tell, sugar is much better than corn syrup, and corn syrup is much better than 100% of well-studied non-nutritive sweeteners. Most of the issues with all those things boil down to “they blow up your metabolism and gut microbes”. The whole organic artificial sweetener thing is clearly just cynical labeling. Worse, the soda industry found that young people almost unanimously avoid diet soda, so they renamed it “light” and added some sugar back in (to screw over the diabetics and cement their status as products that should not exist.)
- FollowingTheDao 4y agoNo. Absolutely not. These are drugs that we do not see in high quantities in nature, JUST LIKE SUCROSE. This is a whole 'nother industry with the same bad interest; their profit. They aim to serve people pleasures over their health. Just eat natural foods, it's not hard.
- sitzkrieg 4y agoits not hard if you can afford it
- FollowingTheDao 4y agoI am homeless and live in a minivan on disability and I can afford it.
- autoexec 4y agoIf you've got a healthy diet plan that homeless people can follow I'd like to know. What is your typical diet in a day? How much are you spending on food? How are you cooking it and how much of your time is spent preparing for/cooking/cleaning up after meals?
- FollowingTheDao 4y agoCanned seafood in olive oil, rice rice pasta, gluten free bread, potatoes, some veggies but not much, and I do not eat a lot, maybe 1800 calories a day. This is healthy for me though, genetics....
- Tarq0n 4y agoThat's just the appeal to nature fallacy. When people talk about natural food the main benefit is the lack of processing for palatability and heterogeneity (varied eating). There's no reason why molecules occurring in nature would automatically be healthier.
- zzzeek 4y agothese articles are useful because the change that has to occur is that people's dietary habits simply have to change. trying to "substitute" sugar in an attempt to keep someone's experience of food exactly unchanged is futile. the answer is not that people should go back to using sugar, it's that food should be *much less sweet*. Sweetness itself is an addictive thing that one can and should lose their dependence on.
- datavirtue 4y ago"Any article that doesn't heavily emphasise that excess sugar is right now killing people is suspect." It is emphasized multiple times in the article.
- datagram 4y agoInstead of using artificial sweeteners, another option is to just make things less sweet. In most cases I feel like I would prefer that.
- pixelpanic360 4y ago[dead]