10 ms·
Fake sugars sneak into foods and disrupt metabolic health
- eggy 4y agoOn my second round of children, and I track these things. The article is distracting if you are used to reading well-written text. You need to watch a bunch of one-liners with swiping graphics to get to the 'meat' of the argument. Too much sugar in the presentation of the material ;)
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 4y ago> Too much sugar in the presentation of the material ;) Yes exactly, even if it isn't propaganda it's too sweet for any purpose. Someone should study this.
- hbcondo714 4y agoAnother study published in Nature Medicine linked the sugar substitute erythritol to higher rates of heart attacks and strokes This study was discussed here last week: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34965453 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34965453 Two sweeteners in particular, saccharin and stevia, worsened the participants’ blood sugar control These are commonly-used; I wonder if my PCP will ever discuss / contact me in regards to this.
- orangepurple 4y agoMost doctors know and follow the "standard of care" which is excellent for treating acute symptoms and diseases. Doctors are generally terrible about dietary recommendations and knowing how to treat diseases of civilization.
- treeman79 4y agoI was having constant stroke symptoms. dozens of doctors in all specialities. One mentioned that I shouldn’t take triptans for migraines as it could trigger a stroke. Not a one mentioned anything else. Including 4 neurologists. Symptoms stopped the moment I went on blood thinners.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoWhat symptoms? I didn’t think they were quickly reversible.
- treeman79 4y agoThink 10% of usual functional to 50% in a few days of blood thinners. 4 years on and I’m probably at 80% now. Right side body weakness, numbness Severe Brain fog, visual issues, inability to write, etc. basically TIA symptoms, was having several a week. Damage was building up. Had a huge clot show up in lungs. A few days after starting blood thinners the worst of my symptoms stopped. Going off of them and they come back quickly. I have 2 known risk factors. So anything extra that contributes is a big issue.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoIC thanks.
- vanilla-almond 4y agoThe Washington Post article say: "Two sweeteners in particular, saccharin and stevia, worsened the participants’ blood sugar control" But the research paper from Cell says "Sucralose and saccharin supplementation impairs glycemic response in healthy adults." Stevia in the research paper is not stated as "impairs glycemic response". [1] Is the Washington Post article correct about the research paper findings? [1] https://www.cell.com/cell/fulltext/S0092-8674(22)00919-9 https://www.cell.com/cell/fulltext/S0092-8674(22)00919-9
- loeg 4y agoIt isn't clear to me if that study makes any attempt to control for confounding variables. Like, maybe people that are already obese or suffering from heart disease are more likely to consume sugar substitutes? I haven't had time to read the original study and ctrl+F did not locate the phrase "3rd variable" or "confound[ing|er]:" https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-023-02223-9.epdf https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-023-02223-9.epdf
- kubectl_h 4y agoWet streets cause rain.
- blue039 4y ago[dead]
- rudolph9 4y ago> But studies suggest that fake sugars can also have unexpected effects on your gut and metabolic health and even promote food cravings and insulin resistance, a precursor to Type 2 diabetes. I can’t help but think (other than being annoyed the studies aren’t linked right there) that it’s more of a correlation than causation that the artificial sweeteners are changing gut bacteria . Presumably you gut is adapt to high sugar intake, then all the sudden you’re not getting high sugar intake? Wouldn’t you expect these changes regardless of the artificial sweetener and wouldn’t the short term changes be basically a withdrawal from high amounts of table sugar which would be hard on the body in the short term but better off in the long term?
- Floegipoky 4y agoYou're making some pretty big assumptions about the design of these unnamed studies. I don't think it's safe to assume the test population started with high sugar intakes, that the studies only tracked short-term effects, nor that they didn't use a control group.
- kragen 4y agothis is wrong; the experiments in question did hold sugar intake constant
- NickM 4y agoI don't know if this is true of all types of fake sugar, but I've found that I can easily taste the difference in many cases, even when I'm not expecting it or looking for it. Like the article says, it's often with food where I wouldn't expect to find artificial sweeteners, but there's a very distinctly odd, kind of sickly sweet taste that I'll notice sometimes; whenever I do, I check the ingredients label and always find fake sugar on the list.
- nerdponx 4y agoNot only can I taste it, but I dislike the taste strongly, and my stomach definitely does not appreciate it. I actively look for and avoid fake sugars of all kinds, both traditionally artificial (aspartame, sucralose) and "natural" (stevia, monkfruit). Real sugar makes me feel worse, but differently worse, if I consume more than a small amount at a time. However, small amounts of real sugar seem subjectively less poisonous than small amounts of fake sugar, especially if the real sugar is buffered by other non-sugary food (e.g. a drop of maple syrup in oatmeal vs. a gummy bear on an empty stomach). The only exception to my fake sugar rule is that every once in a while I go for a pack of Orbit/Trident/Extra chewing gum, or a Diet Coke / Dr Pepper / Red Bull (yes I like the taste) when I'm on a long car ride and I want a little caffeine and something that tastes entertaining to fight the boredom. My stomach always hates me for it, but it's a once in a while thing, and I appreciate my body's reminders that I shouldn't consume that stuff on a regular basis.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoI prefer the taste of low calorie sweeteners to HCFS and regular table sugar from corn or sugarcane or beets.
- benatkin 4y agoHow about palm sugar? Or dates? I hear you that artificial sweeteners taste surprisingly good but I love natural sweetners and if I want to taste sweetness I love whole dates.
- orangepurple 4y agoAh yes, those pesky fake sugars sneak into foods all on their own! Title should be: "Food producers seek new addictive adulterants as an alternative to sugar"
- nerdponx 4y agoIt's the standard language of victim-blaming and deflection by moneyed interests, like single-use plastic recycling and household carbon footprint. Yes, to some extent, individual choices matter, but there are people will strong financial investment in making those individual choices harder and skewing them towards certain outcomes.
- CyberDildonics 4y agoExactly, systemic problems require systemic solutions.
- thiht 4y agoThe title made me cringe.
- voisin 4y ago“Sneak into foods” like the culprit is the fake sugar itself and not companies making decisions.
- zwieback 4y agoReminder to read the ingredient list on everything. Something I do anyway but I realize I'm a nerd and many consumers don't want to do this.
- ambicapter 4y agoThere are ways to get around the ingredient list requirements. Tic tacs famously don't list any sugar because the quantity in a single tic tac is below the threshold for reporting. I've seen "dehydrated cane juice" listed as an ingredient...that's just another name for sugar.
- conradkay 4y agoSome others to look out for: agave nectar, Cane juice crystals, Diastatic malt, Barley malt, Brown rice syrup.
- kragen 4y agoi was astounded a few weeks ago to discover that sprite and 7up now have acesulfame k in them, at least here in argentina not the diet versions, to be clear, the sugary versions
- nerdponx 4y agoI've noticed this too in the USA: artificial sweeteners being added to "non-low-sugar" junk foods. Dietary labeling laws and greater public awareness of the dangers of sugar have led people to start checking the sugar content. So they add artificial sweeteners to bring down the labeled sugar content without reducing perceived sweetness.
- autoexec 4y agoWe just need artificial sweeteners added to the labels right under added sugars. Giving consumers more information and letting them make choices for themselves is something everyone should be able to get behind.
- masfuerte 4y agoSame with tonic water in the UK. You have to buy the much more expensive premium products if you don't want artificial sweeteners.
- tracker1 4y agoGenerally, it's to better comply with limits on HFCS/Sugar. Not sure it's better or not... I generally consume zero calorie drinks, and try to limit them to with meals (caloric intake).
- kleer001 4y agoWhole foods and foods you cook yourself don't have any added fake sugar.
- treeman79 4y agohttps://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/popular-artificial-sweetener-erythritol-linked-to-higher-risk-for-blood-clots https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/popular-artificial-sweeten... They also found that some fake sugars increases clotting. Particular interest in that I used to clot like crazy when having drinks that contained that same sugar.
- notfed 4y agoI propose that in discussions like this we don't group all alternate sweeteners together as if they're one thing. For example, saying "some fake sugars increase blood clotting" subliminally throws shade on all alternative sweeteners even if only one has been studied in a study. Also, the term "fake sugars" implies that somehow sugar is real while all other sweeteners are "fake", which is again just a way to throw shade. (For example, erythritol and stevia are natural.)
- ccooffee 4y agoAside: I am not a fan of scroll-interactive stories with rare exceptions. Even though it is "just" an intro for this article, it sets up a very childish (?) framing for the article, which makes the rest of the content suspicious. If the data were good and the reasoning sound, would they still need a scroll-by cartoon of ingredients sneaking into a grocery?
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoI think we'll soon discover that the sugar industry is paying a lot of money for all this 'research' and 'news coverage' on sugar alternatives. The phrase 'non-nutritive sweeteners' is just too loaded a term for me to accept. Any article that doesn't heavily emphasise that excess sugar is right now killing people is suspect. > Studies show that when other countries, including Chile and Australia, instituted policies to reduce sugar consumption, the result was an increase in artificially sweetened foods and beverages. Oh no, artificial sweeteners replacing the "natural" corn syrup in my caffeinated beverage. How frightening, I want good old fashioned corn syrup killing me while providing empty calories.
- meroes 4y agoI'm the opposite - I want my food to match my biological expectations, one of the largest being sweet = I just took in quick calories. Not for any grand reason other than I let my hunger and energy levels guide my food choices. I find that the best way long term. I don't have a strong biological instinct of discerning corn syrup from "natural sugar". That is something reading labels helps me with. But I can't fight the biological urges the same way. Empty calories are still somewhat beneficial. I eat a lot of fruit for energy, but sometimes I just want something even quicker and easier to digest and process for my calories, like jelly beans or something. And fruit is more expensive.
- eldaisfish 4y agoThe important piece here is context, as it always it. One example - i grew up eating bread that used no sugar or very little sugar. North American bread tastes too close to cake. Many North Americans don’t share my opinion because their baseline is different. Almost all food is a combination of flavours and it is not easy to spot added sugar. The idea of « sweet » is a lot more difficult to use in the real world.
- tracker1 4y agoGo carnivore for a week, and you'd be surprised how overly sweet everything tastes after... until you get used to it again that is.
- hawk_ 4y agoThere's misguided government policies leading to weird consequences where I am. Other than Coca Cola original, it's impossible to find any carbonated drink that doesn't have artificial sweeteners mixed in. Apparently sugar above some threshold triggers tax but there are no restrictions on artificial sweeteners. This is probably not going to end well.
- Ambitious1325 4y agoIn the area I am in (Philadelphia), drinks with artificial/zero-calorie sweeteners are actually taxed the same way as sugar/corn syrup.
- tracker1 4y agoWill vary from region to region... I think GB and EU are stronger on this than in the US as an example.
- conradkay 4y agoMost of them have diet or zero in the name which makes it pretty easy to tell. The tricky ones contain some sugar (likely from fruit) and some artificial sweeteners,the only one I know of being the v8 sparkling energy drinks. I don't know of any soda that has partial HFCS and artificial sweetener.
- hawk_ 4y agoNot where I live (some EU member), not so obvious. For example all Fanta has some artificial sweetener. Diet fanta has no sugar at all.
- SaintSeiya84 4y agoAh yes, everything good in life is bad and cause cancer and diabetes and heart attacks....the blaming game has come for artificial sweeteners that were created because we were blaming sugar of everything wrong with the world. Who's next?
- jmugan 4y agoFor me it is a labeling issue. I really don't like the fake sweet flavor. It used to be you could look at the ingredients for a small set of known fake sweeteners, but they seem to invent a new kind every month so I can't keep track.
- zuminator 4y agoWhat these articles never seem to discuss is whether artificial sweeteners are anywhere as bad for you as HFCS.
- zwieback 4y ago... or whether HFCS is really that much worse than sugar water.
- tracker1 4y agoI don't really hold that HFCS is really much worse than regular table sugar... the ratios are similar. Not to mention your pancreas and liver don't really care about the source and it's broken down almost exactly the same. Fruit juice (much higher fructose) content is imo much worse than HFCS even, in that only the liver can metabolize it and the negative effects are roughly the same as consuming alcohol in similar quantities.
- SaintSeiya84 4y agoStudies also reveals that companies has been sneaking Dihydrogen oxide even in store salads!!! the same substance that's been shown to cause hyponatremia. This world is becoming unlivable!
- frumper 4y agoNot just companies add this. Farmers spread it on their crops.
- Covzire 4y agoSucralose gives me hives within about 30 mins of ingestion that lasts for days and diarrhea that lasts for at least a week.
- tpush 4y agoTo dampen the media and consequent HN frenzy, here's [0] a substantive analysis on the recent Erythritol paper and why people should be cautious of some of the headlines run by the media. [0] https://kcklatt.substack.com/p/the-alchemy-of-metabolomics-erythritol https://kcklatt.substack.com/p/the-alchemy-of-metabolomics-e...
- mixmastamyk 4y agoGuy needs an editor.
- xnx 4y agoHard to imagine that the negative effects of sugar alcohols could be anywhere near as bad as added refined added sugar.
- londons_explore 4y agoIf I were a regulator, I would try to directly link foods to health outcomes. Ie. If someone eats lots of bigmacs and then dies young, mcdonalds should have to pay a 'killer food' penalty. If someone eats lots of apples and lives to 100, then the apple farmer should receive some kind of reward. I would implement this by having some subset of the population volunteer their purchase data and health data, and have the regulator issue rewards and fines each year based on which food producers managed to make/keep their customers healthiest. The end result should be that healthy foods are both profitable and cheap, and there is an incentive to reformulate foods to keep the eaters healthier. That entirely bypasses the current problem of having food manufacturers trying to make their food look healthy while it actually isn't.
- notfed 4y agoIt's completely impossible to prove that eating some food X caused someone's death. Also, anything can kill you if you have otherwise poor health and eat enough of it, including apples.
- londons_explore 4y agoNo, but you can take data on 1 million customers of food X, and see how many died, vs the non-customers. Sure, there will be ways to game the system, like "Buy 6 of this soda and get free gym membership!". But is that a bad thing?
- notfed 4y agoI disagree, because... correlation does not imply causation. Does ice cream cause skin cancer?
- londons_explore 4y agoThe great thing about this is it doesn't matter if the cause is correlation or causation. Either way, companies will be incentivized to make their food and customer base healthier.
- smm11 4y agoI noticed a commercial last week, "65 percent of all soft drinks sold last year had little to zero sugar." Then the next morning "artificial sweeteners cause heart attacks."
- danoni 4y ago>Sucralose and acesulfame-k, are regularly used in Greek yogurts, "Greek-style" yogurt? Yes. The original Greek strained yogurt has no sugar. It is inedible. Choke-hazard.
- zagrebian 4y agoprocessed foods ⇒ cancer
- notfed 4y agoArtificial sweeteners are not processed foods, so what's your point?
- mewse-hn 4y agoLove how this article has diagrams of how insulin resistance works to scare people against using artificial sweeteners that might, "according to some studies", cause insulin resistance. SUGAR causes insulin resistance.
- BizarroLand 4y agoMy takeaway was that you should try your best to consume neither of the two products, and that you shouldn't assume that a non-nutritive sweetener was perfectly healthy and that you can consume it in unlimited quantities.
- ec109685 4y agoAnd it took many paragraphs to reach this conclusion: “The most rigorous clinical trials show that when people replace sugary drinks with artificially sweetened beverages like Diet Coke and Diet Pepsi it helps them avoid gaining excess weight.”
- oldstrangers 4y agoI still wonder why Athletic Greens uses stevia. It just tastes terrible. Even if it's natural.
- unglaublich 4y agoFake sugar? Is that like "fake leaded petrol"?
- jakedata 4y ago"When given a choice between cocaine or water sweetened with saccharin, rats will almost always choose the artificially sweetened beverage." This is how I know I am not a rat. Not that I am in the habit of drinking cocaine water but I am absolutely one of the people who are revolted by the taste of artificial sweeteners. Black coffee all day long for me, though usually decaf nowadays.
- toast0 4y agoI mean, I'd definitely pick the water sweetened with saccharin given those options; maybe these rats grew up in arcades and know that Winners Don't Use Drugs[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winners_Don%27t_Use_Drugs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winners_Don%27t_Use_Drugs
- jakedata 4y agoDiet Coke vs really really OG classic Coke.
- WalterBright 4y agoI finally gave up on protein powder. It's impossible to buy just protein powder. They always sneak in one sweetener or another. The latest is erythritol, another one suspected of causing metabolic problems. If I wanted sugar in it, I'd add it. I switched to eating a hard boiled egg instead. I'm glad I can still buy coffee that is just coffee.
- anonuser123456 4y agoNaked Nutrition sells 5lbs containers of just whey, no other ingredients.
- dragonwriter 4y agoNaked Nutrition Naked Whey is Whey Protein Concentrate, which has no added sugar but does have some sugars. (Of course, so do hardboiled eggs.) There are manufacturers that sell Whey Protein Isolate without any sugars (added or otherwise).
- dragonwriter 4y ago> I finally gave up on protein powder. It's impossible to buy just protein powder. They always sneak in one sweetener or another. There are, in fact, protein powders with no added sweeteners, though most of them still have some sugars (and usually also fat and/or nonsugar carbs) from whatever the source of the protein is (but these can be very low; e.g., Naked Nutrition Naked Pea protein powder has 27g of protein, 2g sugars (0 added sugar), and 0.5g fat per 30g serving.) But, if you really want protein powder without sugar, you can, in fact, find protein powders without it (e.g., Whey Protein Isolate.) > I switched to eating a hard boiled egg instead. At 0.5g sugars for 5.7g protein? Why, exactly, are you avoiding protein powders, again?
- WalterBright 4y agoSugar in its natural state (not refined, not artificial) is fine.
- miles 4y ago> ...allulose, stevia and monk fruit extract, are referred to as “natural” because they’re derived from plants. You are unlikely to find plant-derived allulose in many products[0]: "Because it occurs naturally in very small amounts, the allulose you find packaged for sale isn’t its natural form. It has been created artificially by food scientists from fructose (fruit sugar)." Physician and nutrition expert Michael Greger recently did a survey of the medical literature around allulose, which appears to be cautiously optimistic.[1] [0] https://health.clevelandclinic.org/what-is-allulose/ https://health.clevelandclinic.org/what-is-allulose/ [1] https://nutritionfacts.org/video/does-the-sweetener-allulose-have-side-effects/ https://nutritionfacts.org/video/does-the-sweetener-allulose...
- DebtDeflation 4y agoI would wager that most people are consuming way more sugar and artificial sweeteners in the form of beverages than food. Once you get used to drinking water as your primary beverage (unsweetened tea or coffee in the morning and beer in moderation on the weekend is fine) you will soon find yourself repulsed by soda, sports drinks, sweet tea, juice, etc. The amount of sugar (and/or artificial sweeteners) in this stuff is astounding.
- amval 4y agoNo, beer on the weekends is not fine, at least if you are somehow rating it as worse than soft drinks. There is no "moderate" amount of alcohol that you can drink that does not have negative health outcomes.
- orangepurple 4y agoFructose and ethanol follow the same biochemical metabolic pathways and are equally harmful. You just don't get buzzed from fructose. https://youtu.be/dBnniua6-oM?t=3424 https://youtu.be/dBnniua6-oM?t=3424
- zerocrates 4y agoI think people are pretty aware that something like soda is just sugar water, but sugar added to just sort of generally improve flavor in food items isn't as obvious, yet it adds up. Sugarier "low fat" options would be one of those areas where it's easy not to notice.
- jay_kyburz 4y agoWhen I'm packing my kids school lunches I try to avoid "sweet" food and prefer "savory" snacks. I play a game with myself where I try and guess the amount sugar in something. Some savory crackers are good at only 10% sugar. Some have as much as 40% sugar.
- julianeon 4y agoThis is one thing I've never been able to relate to. I'm thin - at the bottom of my weight range for my height. I eat healthy. I have very little tea & coffee (maybe once a week, tops) and zero alcohol. But I've always liked sweet things. "Does a cake taste good to you?" Yes, as good as it ever has. It tastes as good as it did when my diet was unhealthy trash. I was able to change my eating habits, and have stuck to the change for well over a year, but my "taste buds" haven't changed at all.
- TjZkxkxeky 4y agoI really want augmented reality in a google glasses like format for in-person shopping. Lookup the nutrition facts and put X's over the items my configuration says I don't want.
- jakzurr 4y agoOMG Yes, please.
- mrfinn 4y agoStevia is not a quoted "natural" thing, stevia is a plant. And a medicinal one by the way. Been drinking stevia infusions for a long time and tastes great. Nice try sugar lobby.
- bmacho 4y agoAm I the only one who likes sugar? You know that is substracted from fruits and vegetables. The one that all my 2^n ancestors consumed for billions of years. It gives me calories, so I can do stuff. (So do carbs, fats and protein.) I don't like artificial sweeteners ( I don't really like sweet stuff ), as they are not proven to be safe. (Even when natural, they are substracted from weird stuff, not from carrots or grapes or whatever.)
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> The one that all my 2^n ancestors consumed for billions of years. Your ancestors don't increase exponentially as you go back in time. Consider that the number of humans in existence gets smaller, not larger, as you move into the past.
- jay_kyburz 4y agoEverybody likes sugar the way our ancestors consumed it, in naturally occurring fruits and veggies. We object to it being added to every single food you can buy in the supermarket.
- meroes 4y agoFake sugar is not the solution to that.
- meroes 4y agoIncreasing my sugar intake helps me exercise more and be healthier overall. Fake sugars are worse than sugar being added to food. They are not the solution to that. Anyone bringing that up is strawmanning. (I bring it up only because many posters are seemingly saying, hey at least fake sugar combats extra added sugar in bread and stuff). Food with added sugar - at least it will give you energy to go do something with. Whether or not you do is up to you. Fake sugars mislead your body into thinking it just acquired energy to go do things. It has no good longterm purpose. Being low energy and hungry and ingesting fake sugar to stave off that feeling is misunderstanding the problem. That's my experience over 7 years of trying to lose weight and be healthy long term. I had a diet soda/fake sugar phase in there and it worked for a few years maybe, but I am better off overall abandoning that whole idea.
- photochemsyn 4y agoThe solution to this entire class of problems is not a question of which type of sugar or sugar substitute should be in your processed foodstuffs, it's whether you should be consuming any processed food items whatsoever. Even if you still want some prepared foods, be sure to read the ingredients label, and stick to the more traditional processed foods (bread, soy sauce, etc.) as long as they're free of the dough conditioners, high-fructose corn syrup, sodium benzoate and similar preservatives, etc. Far and away the best dietary option is to go back to basics and learn to cook at least a little using only fresh ingredients, it's one of the simplest ways to improve nutrition and general health.
- throwaway158971 4y agoI've seen an influx of articles providing "look over here" reasons for potential cause of metabolic issues. A quick search shows, in the last week: Fake sugar, marijuana, the flu, keto diet, and lack of sleep. Maybe it's just the media returning to its usual hysterics ... or maybe they're trying to distract from something else.
- autoexec 4y ago> Maybe it's just the media returning to its usual hysterics ... or maybe they're trying to distract from something else. Two things can be true! Maybe there is evidence suggesting problems with all of those things and maybe it's just being heavily pushed in media to distract from something else. Personally, I think most of the food we eat and the environments we live in are poisoned and that's how companies like it because it means you can't blame any one of them for health problems they know they are causing since it's impossible for anyone to say which of the countless poisoned things we're regularly exposed to was the cause of those issues.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]