4 ms·
No, he doesn't: the Asimov robot series uses these rules as a story telling device and show that, while these rules look good at first glance, are simply imposs
by ragebol 4y ago
No, he doesn't: the Asimov robot series uses these rules as a story telling device and show that, while these rules look good at first glance, are simply impossible to to follow. This leads to interesting stories, that's what they're for.
And I don't think anyone is seriously working to make LLMs to adhere to these three Laws of Robotics.
- a_bonobo 4y agoAsimov is also quite handwavy in how these laws are implemented within the robots, making them out to be written in stone. I haven't encountered an LLM with a premise that cannot be broken out of.
- euroderf 4y agoDon't forget the 4th Law ("A robot shall not have or use access to means of unlimited self-reproduction") and the 5th Law ("A robot shall be able to explain its decisions").
- dekhn 4y agoI don't think it would be difficult to make a chatgpt derived LLM that was able to explain its "reasoning" on how to apply the laws of robotics to any situation. Sort of like "Daneel meets the trolley problem", I guess. I never really thought much about the laws of robotics- they seem more or less impossible to achieve in a wholly consistent by any reasonable objective-seeking robot.