6 ms·
> IPv6 for local networks, makes no sense is completely unnecessary, and is a hill I will die on. IPv4 is here to stay. Why would you make everything gratuitou
by lmm 4y ago
> IPv6 for local networks, makes no sense is completely unnecessary, and is a hill I will die on. IPv4 is here to stay.
Why would you make everything gratuitously complicated by having two separate forms of addressing? All that IPv4 gains you is new and exciting ways to mess up your networking. Just give every device a normal public address (of course you probably want to firewall off inbound traffic from the WAN to the LAN, but that's got nothing to do with addresses) and have a normal network rather than some bizzare frankenstein mashup.
- acedTrex 4y agoA pipe dream, but the best case seems to be a total standardization on v6
- znpy 4y ago> you probably want to firewall off inbound traffic from the WAN to the LAN But all modem/routers are doing it anyway, they might as well do that on ipv6. Effectively all router appliances (at home and soho level) are linux appliances, and the firewall is built into the kernel (and in use anyway).
- phpisthebest 4y agoSorry I do not trust the likes of home router vendors to implement a linux firewall correctly While people may say "NAT is Not security", it is in fact a layer (ahd huge one) in the security onion, that ipV6 is likely going to increase drastically the amount of ransomware and other malware on the public internet simply because that NAT layer is gone
- yamtaddle 4y agoI remember what it was like when lots more home computers were routable from the public Internet, because having a NAT router between them and there wasn't a nearly-100%-adoption thing yet. In fact, I worked at an ISP (dial-up and DSL) in that era. It was indeed a shit-show. Adding a NATting router to those set-ups instantly increased their security tremendously. Sure you could use a proper firewall, but the router w/NAT Just Works.
- phpisthebest 4y agoI cant wait until all the printers, and webcams all showup on the public internet again....
- yamtaddle 4y agoPortscanning for smb shares and webcams, LOL. Good times. Found entire offices routing their whole network publicly, back then, shared network drives and printers right there for use by anyone who stumbled on them. It was nuts. Worms spread like crazy. It was a real mess, and that's with the Internet being way the fuck friendlier than it is now.
- garbagecoder 4y agoWhat's ironic is that the IPv6 people will tell you you can do all of that with IPv6. Which is true, but if we NEED TO CHANGE because we're out of addresses then why go to something that doesn't use the address space? The problem IPv6 seeks to address has mostly been engineered around for now.
- JohnFen 4y ago> The problem IPv6 seeks to address has mostly been engineered around for now. For now is the operative phrase. These are band-aids to keep IPv4 running, but they won't be effective forever.
- JohnFen 4y ago> Sorry I do not trust the likes of home router vendors to implement a linux firewall correctly Neither do I, but that's a fixable situation. Get an appliance router that lets you put DD-WRT (or similar) on it. Or use a computer instead of an appliance and set it up any way you like.
- phpisthebest 4y agoI am by trade a network administrator, and I run enterprise gear in my home. I am not running a home router or dd-wrt. But I am not a typlical user going down to best buy to pick up the latest Belkin or Asus wireless AP / router combo they have on sale for $99 and hooking it up to my internet using default "wizard" settings from the mobile app... Nor I am I trusting Comcast, or ATT to configure their residental rented equipment properly with proper firewall rules My comment is not about me, I have enterprise grade nextgen firewalls that are $$ My comment is about Grandma that calls up comcast to have them set it all up, or Sally that is going into best buy for the "Geek Squad" so hook her up...
- Symbiote 4y agoLarge ISPs like Comcast already have enormous IPv6 networks, and have appropriate, default-deny firewall configurations for them. I'm only familiar with the largest ISPs in Britain, but they also have default-deny configurations on the IPv6 routers they supply. Obviously. > Grandma / Sally Try avoiding the casual ageism and sexism.
- phpisthebest 4y ago>Try avoiding the casual ageism and sexism. Try not to find offense in all things, feel free to refer to my comment thread from the other day about offense being a you problem not a me problem ;)
- KerrAvon 4y agoIf I’m following your logic, you’re saying you trust tplink etc to keep Grandma safe, but only for IPv4, and not IPv6? Why?
- blibble 4y ago> that ipV6 is likely going to increase drastically the amount of ransomware and other malware on the public internet simply because that NAT layer is gone malware has connected outwards to c&c servers for more than 20 years
- pixl97 4y agoThis is one of the worst takes I've seen in this thread. NAT is only kind of a firewall and there have been plenty of terrible router firmwares out there that have lead people to subvert it (UPNP being one of the most problematic). If you in your other thread don't trust the ISP device, then don't trust NAT on your ISP device either. Quite often the ISP can have their modem route traffic from their internal 10 net to your internal network if they so choose to. Instead IPv4, or IPv6 setup to drop NEW/SYN connections to your devices via a router that you provide.
- phpisthebest 4y ago>If you in your other thread don't trust the ISP device, then don't trust NAT on your ISP device either There is no logic there. firewall configuration is much harder to secure than NAT configuration.
- lmm 4y ago> There is no logic there. firewall configuration is much harder to secure than NAT configuration. Disagree. Just the XML parsing logic required for uPnP alone is more complex than a basic firewall implementation.
- JohnFen 4y agouPnP seems a distraction from the topic. It's not necessary for networking to network -- my LAN intentionally does not support it at all. It is necessary for certain use cases, of course, but it's not mandatory in a network in the general case.
- lmm 4y agoIt's necessary for feature parity with IPv6 (or, equivalently, with the 2000s-era Internet). Even if you don't use uPnP, the amount of complex protocol parsing necessary to support/work around NAT (e.g. SIP is particularly tricky) is a larger attack surface than a full IPv6 stack.
- hitpointdrew 4y agoWhy would I want any of my devices on my network to have a publicly route-able address? > Why would you make everything gratuitously complicated by having two separate forms of addressing? How is IPv6 itself not "gratuitously complicated". You think I am going to remember the IP of my firewall, my network switch, if it is that mess of characters that is an IPv6 address? I can easily recall 10.10.10.1 is my gateway, or that 192.168.1.1 is my gateway. You think instead setting up local DNS server and domain so I can do myrouter.lan is somehow "less complicated"? Hard pass.
- xxpor 4y agoWhy would you need a DNS server? That's what mDNS is for.
- vetinari 4y agoSome people might have more than one subnet. Or road-warrior VPN and VPN-ing in. It is nice when your networks name resolution works, even if you are outside your network.
- JohnFen 4y agomDNS has some downsides that can be important for some. For instance, the fact that you can more easily set the same host name on multiple machines, or the fact that it uses a lot of bandwidth.
- 4y ago
- JohnFen 4y ago> Why would you make everything gratuitously complicated by having two separate forms of addressing? If it ain't broke, don't fix it? If IPv6 brings no benefit to my LAN, why should I spend all the effort needed to shift it to IPv6? I can just make the connection to the internet IPv6 and leave everything else alone. Although I have additional friction in my case, in that I have numerous devices that are IPv4-only. So no matter what, I'd have to at least have one LAN segment that is IPv4.
- pixl97 4y agoBecause that's not the way TCP was designed in the first place. Instead you're used to hack on top of hack to make IPv4 not explode in a ball of flame there are far more billions of end points than IP addresses. The thing is you really don't realize how shit your network experiences are because of this. Everyone is just attempting to tunnel more services via HTTP/HTTPS and the particular fun problems that entails rather than having byzantine hacks built in to their NAT routers. IPv4 is no longer fit for purpose.
- garbagecoder 4y agoIf I don't realize how shit it is, I don't think it's a shit experience. I don't care how it was designed and what you call a "byzantine hack" I call a feature that saved the Internet about 20-25 years ago. Having everyone on a public addressable host is not good. (Yes, I know you can do this on IPv6, but then it's like you're just applying Byzantine hacks to get the security feature you already had on IPv4.)
- lamontcg 4y ago> Having everyone on a public addressable host is not good. We had every host on an IPv4 address at the University of Washington back before 1998 and NAT was actually banned by the CAC Department since they billed by number of nodes on the network, so NAT was a way to cheat their billing system. I learned quite a lot of internet security from having 1998-era Unix servers hanging directly off onto the internet with no firewall or NAT.
- tristanbvk 4y agoFinally some sense. There are so many senseless IPv4 shills here. IPv6 always works, never had a problem with it. Just switch to it alrready.
- slackdog 4y agoI'll switch when IPv4 stops working. Until then, I have no reason to switch. > It's costing ISPs I hate my ISP so this is actually a feature. If they add an IPv4 surcharge to my bill then I'll reconsider.
- throw0101c 4y ago> I'll switch when IPv4 stops working. Until then, I have no reason to switch. IPv4 has stopped working for a lot of people already, especially if they're not with a fancy-pants ISP with lots of legacy IPv4 addresses already 'in the bank'. From another discussion: > I've actually run into this [CG NAT] helping a friend host a game server on their residential internet in a more rural part of Texas. They had to call their ISP and request a static IP address at an extra cost of something like $5/mo. * https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35046929 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35046929 IPv4 is also not working for the Indian reservation mentioned in the article: they had to spend >$200K to support these Roku devices.
- slackdog 4y agoSure, I get that. But it's their problem, not my problem. I'll only switch when it becomes my problem.
- garbagecoder 4y agoSo, because I don't want to change something that works and whose predictions of demise have been grossly overstated by decades I'm a shill? "Just switch to it." Sure, pal, You pay all of the transition costs for everyone and you got a deal. Not everything needs or should have a public IP address much less a bunch of IOT garbage. I suspect you, like everyone else who just says, whY aReNt We On IpV6 yEt??!11 imagine that most people's security practices are like yours and most people's ability to maintain software and security practices are like yours. They are not. I'm holding out for a modern address space extension conceived this century that doesn't suck, or at least a naming convention that doesn't suck. But no one will change until it's really needed and "hack" that improve the Internet, even if by accident, like NAT, can't fix it.