5 ms·
I find it hilarious that EA had the concept down and just blew their opportunity with Simcity 2013 (always online (which by the way was actually not true, peopl
by satvikpendem 4y ago
I find it hilarious that EA had the concept down and just blew their opportunity with Simcity 2013 (always online (which by the way was actually not true, people cracked the online requirement within the first day or so), had to contract with other users for basic services like sewage and electricity), paving the way for competitors like Cities: Skylines to take the lead instead.
This reminds me of the same thing that happened with Stardew Valley, the creator missed the old Harvest Moon games, didn't find a suitable substitute, and just build the entirety of the game from scratch, teaching himself art and music composition too. He's made over $300 million in revenue so far and might be the first solo game dev (or even regular software dev) to hit $1 billion in the course of the game's existence.
It just goes to show that the dominant players are not always dominant forever, and that common YC startup advice of understanding what exactly users want (hint: they don't want always-online DRM-filled games that nickle and dime you with microtransactions (well, most people anyway, there are always gacha/gambling-type whale gamers)) and serving them well is still correct.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Laaas 4y agoTurns out, building good _anything_ is profitable.
- nikanj 4y agoBut building user-hostile crap _anything_ is way more profitable
- PeterisP 4y agoWell, no, not really - the example of Simcity 2013 vs Cities: Skylines given above is a great example where the user-hostile crap was much less profitable than what EA could have gotten based on their brand if they would have just made a straightforward remake similar to Cities: Skylines.
- kiba 4y agoThere's brand destroying short term strategies, and strategies that optimize for longevity.
- jahewson 4y agoIt's definitely not! Many good things cost more to build than people are willing to pay for them.
- satvikpendem 4y agoYeah, lots of good things aren't profitable (at least to the ones making them). Xerox PARC comes to mind, Xerox didn't want to capitalize on those good things that were made there and thus Gates and Jobs did instead.
- fulltimeloser 4y agoXerox wanted to capitalize, but their business model, target customer and price point was not as innovative as the technology they had to offer.
- GuB-42 4y agoThe Dreamcast was considered by many gamers the best console of its time, great hardware, affordable price, great games, developer friendly. And yet, it was a commercial failure and it ended the Sega consoles. Generally, for big profit, you need to build something good, but the reverse is not true. And you can still make small profit with crap.
- swarnie 4y agoSimcity 2013 was the first time i asked for a game to be refunded. After that was rejected it became the first time and maybe only time i've used a credit card charge back. I know "boycotts" don't work in the gaming industry but i can honestly say i haven't bought an EA product since. That has been slightly easier by them only churning out yearly sporting games filled with micro transactions mind.
- db48x 4y agoIt’s amazing just how few EA games I have purchased in the last 10 years!
- colechristensen 4y ago"EA" didn't have the concept down, Maxis did. They bought out something and ruined it, par for the course for acquisitions. Isn't it great when founders get a pay day but does that kind of thing really benefit everybody else? Just in general it doesn't seem that allowing most mergers is a particularly good thing for the American public, benefiting mostly just very large corporations who get to offload risk on to startups and their investors and reward only a lucky few (though skill is important, who succeeds and gets a good exit has a lot to do with luck)
- kevinventullo 4y agoPerhaps a more optimistic view is that the acquisition represented a one-way transfer of wealth from EA to the founders and shareholders of Maxis, who to their credit did bring good things into this world. It’s not clear to me that we would be better off if Maxis had never been acquired.
- jstummbillig 4y ago> It just goes to show that unlikely stuff does happen but not as much as likely stuff. Generalising from anecdotes and cherry picking data remains ill advised.
- MikusR 4y agoThe only thing that was bypassed was forced disconnect after losing internet. You still could not save or trade between regions while offline. Server emulator appeared 4 months after release. Official offline mode was released a year after release.
- EamonnMR 4y agoEven if you got past the always online aspects, it just felt like a huge step down from Sim City 4. Too many opaque things going on, too much thrown at you, too high concept, didn't feel like building a model train set anymore.
- pavlov 4y agoI posted this earlier [1] but it’s an interesting little twist to this story… While EA was busy destroying the SimCity brand with unadulterated capitalist greed, Cities: Skylines was created with public funding from the Finnish government. No VCs wanted to invest in such a niche company. They were only able to get off the ground thanks to money from Finland’s public startup funding and arts grants. Capitalism on its own isn’t always enough to ensure that successful products get built. Sometimes it takes public funding to salvage a good idea that capitalism managed to burn down. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35047255 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35047255
- chris_va 4y agoHow are we defining capitalism here? Because, you know, people are still getting paid for the work they are doing.
- rasjani 4y agoFinn here and i know the game and company and by no means Im not downplaying what you said but; In general - there are quite a few possibilities to apply for grants and similar monetary benefits from the goverment, municipalities and few ngo's here. And as a finn - I would find it actually miraculous that company such as Colossal Order would have never ever benefited from public funding.
- dysoco 4y agoWonder why a "The Sims" competitor hasn't appeared yet, would the lack of branding and general "charm" of The Sims(like Simlish) be a dealbreaker?
- _mitterpach 4y agoThat was actually one of the announcements made! Seems to be a Sims clone, in the early stages of development. I'm honestly looking forwards to it, rather than spending 1,000$ on Sims 4 on Steam.
- 0x457 4y agoTheir sims-like game is actually developed by Paradox, so it's guaranteed there will be endless paid DLCs.
- omnibrain 4y agoOn one hand, that’s absolutely true. On the other hand Paradox does a good job in maintaining the base game and constantly supplying it with free new features with every expansion.
- munk-a 4y agoI am extremely optimistic looking at the CK3 DLCs though - they're closer to the early CK2 expansions that massively rehaul large portions of the game mechanics. I'm not certain if they're fully committed to that direction but it certainly feels better to look at those sorts of expansions than, say, HoI4 or some of the EU4 expansions which are generally just regional flavor packs. I think they're not enamored of their reputation for crap shoveling and are making a concerted effort to deliver more value with their overhauls and that's why I've never really viewed them the same as skin-pushers like Roblox, CS:GO, The Sims or Fortnite.
- labster 4y agoPDX has been burned before by releasing DLC features that implicitly depend on other DLC features, and having to release patches that either unblock or kludge around it. The policy of “new mechanics are free, special abilities are paid” seems to me like a hard-learned lesson on maintaining configurations.
- sfcarrot 4y agoEA is supposed to be pretty happy with its SimCity BuildIt as it is a new way of generating lots of revenue through micro-transactions and makes the balance sheets look better. Meanwhile, players are pretty happy with Paradox's real passion about how to build a better city simulation game. For what it is worth, it is a win-win-win for EA, players, and Paradox Interactive.
- kridsdale1 4y agoThe original Maxis team are the losers here. They worked 4 years to make something they thought would drive the genre forward but were sabotaged by executives who forced them to add DRM which destroyed the franchise when the servers exploded on release day. Then all their assets were transferred to another team who made the mobile version.
- standardUser 4y agoThe gameplay imitations were far more severe than the DRM and online stuff. A clean release may not have generated such a brutal backlash, but it wouldn't have resulted in a genuine SimCity successor either.
- bakuninsbart 4y agoEspecially recently, Paradox has a streak of publishing overpriced, unfinished, even broken games. I'd wager that the success of Cities Skylines lies more with the developer than the publisher, and hope hope hope that PDX stayed away as much as possible from CS2s development.
- rishav_sharan 4y ago> He's made over $300 million in revenue so far and might be the first solo game dev (or even regular software dev) to hit $1 billion in the course of the game's existence. That would be Notch, who made Minecraft
- satvikpendem 4y agoWas Notch a solo dev when he sold to Microsoft? I think he had a team already. The Stardew Valley creator still doesn't have a full time team, I believe.
- eps 4y agoAs of May last year Stardew Valley sold over 20 mil copies, so 300 mil sounds about right. As staggerring as it is. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stardew_Valley#Sales https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stardew_Valley#Sales
- raincole 4y ago> He's made over $300 million in revenue so far and might be the first solo game dev (or even regular software dev) to hit $1 billion in the course of the game's existence. So you use revenue as a measuremeant of success, which is very reasonable. > (hint: they don't want always-online DRM-filled games that nickle and dime you with microtransactions (well, most people anyway, there are always gacha/gambling-type whale gamers)) Then you said this. You know in terms of revenue, microtransaction is the most successful model, right? Mobile gaming is now bigger than PC gaming + console gaming. And they're basically all microtransactions. $300 million sounds a lot but it's just 2~3 months of Genshin. If revenue is a sign of what players "want", then the only logical conclusion is a lot people "want" microtransactions, they just don't admit it like people want BigMac but say they want to eat healthy. I think it's a strong no-true-scotsman fallacy right here. You believe players don't want microtransactions, because you don't think those casual players who play Candy Crush, Clash of Clans or Genshin are "true players".
- Quarrelsome 4y agoSo apparently people _want_ to smoke tobacco. My issue with your comment that I have attempted to frame in that pithy one-liner is that microtransactions are often sold through a manipulative sales window, in some cases games are designed around them to make the micro-transactions more appealing (e.g. games that throttle your progress unless you spend). In addition, using revenue as a measure of popularity with micro-transactions is problematic because they are designed to effectively segment the market. This means they're not necessarily a solid indicator of what an average/median user might want because sometimes much of that revenue is a product of relatively few users (aka "whales").
- Raz2 4y agoI disagree. Target audience is not the same. Stardew Valley and Cities Skyline do not compete with Clash of Clans. Making something unique can make more revenue than replicating other successful model with hight competition.