6 ms·
Sabine Hossenfelder basically posted a rant about particle physicists on Youtube last week, about how they are doing science wrong. Basically she said you are
by hinkley 4y ago
Sabine Hossenfelder basically posted a rant about particle physicists on Youtube last week, about how they are doing science wrong.
Basically she said you are supposed to change your theory based upon results that don't match the theory, and what they have been doing for decades is looking at gaps in the results, and imagining particle theories that don't alter the expected results in the currently explored energy levels, just in the unexplored ones. Then when people get funding to look into these frontiers/gaps, and find that everything looks the same, they adjust their theories to push them out into the gaps.
That's not Science, she emphatically states.
For myself it sounds like saying, "well you don't know Unicorns don't exist because we haven't looked everywhere, what if they're in <unexplored forests in the Congo>?" Then the Congo gets explored and they say, "well maybe they're in Antarctica".
- HPsquared 4y agoIf thousands of people have careers in unicorn-hunting, that's what will happen.
- hinkley 4y agoWhile watching her complain I kept thinking, "publish or die".
- js8 4y agoPublish (in a scientific journal) or publish (on Youtube). No hiding from the invisible freedom of the market.
- LudwigNagasena 4y agoI don’t get that complaint. It’s like hearing a software engineer complaining “write code or get fired”, yeah, well, that’s your literal job?
- hinkley 4y agoHave you been reading the threads about the reproducibility crisis that pop up here regularly? Essentially some people worry we have more people who need to write papers than we can sustain with our current research horizon, and people are making shit up or at least being overly optimistic. As Feynman used to say, "The most important thing is not to fool yourself, and you're the easiest person to fool."
- LudwigNagasena 4y agoTo all reproducibility problems I say “publish more”. Do you plan to do a study? Register it and publish your methodology before data collection. Have you collected data? Publish it. Have you finished the study? Believe it or not, publish it. Do you want to do a 20 year long study on a particle collider built specifically for you right after finishing your PhD? Well, sorry, you have to build your reputation so that society sees that you are not one of those people who “are making shit up or at least being overly optimistic”.
- pixl97 4y agoYea, but it's like all the software doesn't work or has huge security holes....
- theurerjohn3 4y agoThings like this make me want to read Against Method [1]. Like, yeah that seems 'not science' in one serious sense, but also not really? It falls into what I understand of Kuhn's 'normal science'. Slightly adjusting their theories to explain existing data is exactly what you should expect scientists to do, until the gaps get so big no adjustments are sufficiently concise. For a defense of the 'unicorns in unexplored forests', that was pretty much the approach that led to the discovery of most of the standard model. Plus, given dark matter and dark energy, we know something must be out there, even if its not unicorns, there's something. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Against_Method https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Against_Method
- Maursault 4y ago> Plus, given dark matter and dark energy, we know something must be out there, even if its not unicorns, there's something. Because science is paradigmatic, this is the problem. We do not know something else must be out there because we have no direct evidence of either Dark Matter nor Dark Energy, which, btw, have absolutely nothing to do with one another. We might just not yet have the intuition to understand what is causing our perception of the need for these labels. I, for one, am absolutely convinced Dark Matter is absolute bunk and will be widely accepted to not exist eventually within the next 50 years. The initial reason for Dark Matter's existence, to explain rotational velocities of spiral galaxies we assume spiral galaxies appear to have more invisible matter, has been explained by the fact that the initial observation was of a galaxy in isolation, and the assumption that it was an isolated inertial frame without considering the cluster of galaxies around it, which perfectly explain spiral galaxy rotational velocities without any need for Dark Matter. But because science is paradigmatic and even in the Space Age the correct information is taking decades to disseminate, many if not most are still are convinced Dark Matter is needed even though no one knows what it is. It's nothing, really, it's a phantom, imagination gone haywire. Also, as other unexplained developments occurred, these too got lumped into Dark Matter, which galaxy clusters can not explain. So the problem becomes the shame of not just saying, "we don't know... we don't understand this," and labelling it something to fake it like we do understand it. This is a flaw of modern science, or at least of cosmology,i.e. the unwillingness to accept that we don't (yet) know the precise reasons for what is observed.
- sorokod 4y agoThis one? If so I would not call it a rant, she pulls no punches which is a positive thing. "What's Going Wrong in Particle Physics?" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lu4mH3Hmw2o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lu4mH3Hmw2o
- college_physics 4y agothe thing is that this pattern of pushing to unexplored energy levels did work before. Unicorns were found in the unexplored forests of Congo. In fact an entire zoo of unicorns of all shapes and forms was found, an incredible achievement that stands among the most important stuff our gray-tinted gel has managed to internalize about the universe. You can't blame modern day particle physicists for being born late for the Unicorn chasing party... so the argurment now is, for how much longer is it reasonable to be roaming difficult terrains in the hope that we might have a repeat miracle? Its practically impossible to answer. "All Unicorns have been discovered" has been a scientist's cry as far back as Laplace.
- hinkley 4y agoThe last time we found something that was predicted by the Standard Model was 1983, wasn't it? That's 40 years. edit: her complaint is that once funding sources realize that 'particle physicists shill ridiculous ideas for research grants', all of the money dries up and won't return for at least a generation or two. That's an existential threat to the field. That sounds like a legitimate complaint to me. Unfortunately she's also shining a spotlight on the thing she's worried about other people noticing.
- college_physics 4y ago> That's 40 years. Is that a lot? On what basis could we decide?(1) I am not saying it isn't, I am just saying it is a rather subjective call which sort of looks at the prior pace of discoveries and extrapolates a judgement. (1) it took more than that from the first gravitational wave detector to an actual discovery
- hinkley 4y agoI'm going to start repeating myself in separate replies here. Einstein didn't predict gravitational waves as a standalone theory. Gravitational waves are a prediction of General Relativity. General Relativity was shown to be plausible based on data already at hand and data they could collect. Gravity waves and lensing and frame dragging all confirm what we already suspected to be true. Which is good and bad news because they increase the corroborating evidence for an existing theory, and they take out huge chunks of opportunity for some other theory to explain the same phenomenon but introduce new loopholes or consequences that let us do new things like build Foundation power supplies (nuclear reactors the size of gumballs) or FTL travel or explain why galaxies move 'wrong'.
- lynx23 4y agoJust unsub her. She picked up a lot of people by her bold way of presenting. Most discover after a while that she isnt worth watching.
- hinkley 4y agoI'm not even subbed. The things I am subbed to just don't generate new content at the rate that I hit youtube so I end up with suggestions.
- Loquebantur 4y agoYou seem to imply, most people were smart. But statistically, most people are not. Hossenfelder critzises physics. That is a good thing to do, regardless of whether she is always right about it. Being smart, you can learn from her even if she is not. At the very least about how to present better.
- willis936 4y agoSerial contrarian jumps on table and shouts. More at 11. A telltale sign of a crank is attacking career scientists, which is her brand. What insight is she offering? Destroying is easy, creating is hard. Lies spread faster than truth. In general she is a force of confusion rather than enlightenment. It's too bad because she seems capable, if only she'd follow through rather than chase headlines.
- phkahler 4y ago>> What insight is she offering? For a while she was offering an honest look at a field going nowhere, and suggestions as to how they might better spend time and money. Now I think she's just profiting from her new popularity by doing a not so good science/tech show.
- precompute 4y agoA "Career Scientist" is very, very bad news!
- vkou 4y agoA career contrarian can be even worse. A career scientist actually needs to justify their output, to their peers and the people signing the cheques. And if not career scientists, who exactly do you think should be making a living... Doing research? Undergrads? The admins? The timecube guy? Nobody? There's a lot of problems with science as it's done today, but that snipe is a banal, tribalistic take that is all-too-common.
- precompute 4y agoThat would've been a great reply had the title of the main post not been "Cargo Cult Science". For me, a "career scientist" is someone that publishes papers solely to hold a position at an org / institute / uni / etc (yes, yes, everyone needs food on the table... not the point here. One can still have integrity). The career scientist couldn't care less about being right, only about how many citations he's gonna get and whether anyone's going to discover any flaws in his paper.
- imranq 4y agoI don't see what the problem with Sabine's analysis is? I thought it was great. Shouldn't particle physicists have more expectations of what they expect to find rather than we want to find X and we are going to search the entire energy frontier to find it. The problem is that the energy frontier is limitless so the ROI could be extremely poor unless we had a good idea of what we expect
- bjornsing 4y ago> The problem is that the energy frontier is limitless so the ROI could be extremely poor unless we had a good idea of what we expect AKA the full employment theorem of particle physics…
- parton 4y agoIf we knew what to expect, it would be engineering not science. The fact is, we have tried having expectations, most notably supersymmetry, and those haven't turned out very well because we are literally venturing into the unknown. Part of the fun is that sometimes a wild theory works out (GR, Higgs) and sometimes it doesn't. I think if we push the energy frontier one more time, there's no real reason to expect us to find anything -- but there's also no reason for us not to find anything.
- marcosdumay 4y agoThings are more complicated than that. Something is there causing those phenomena. People have a theory that it may be unicorns, so they are out looking for unicorns. Those are supposed to be hard to find, and people are still searching on the hardest possible places that can hold them. It may also not be unicorns, on what case nobody has any idea what it may be. Some people are trying to make such theories, but none got a good one yet. On this level of detail, there is nothing wrong at all with any party of the above. All of the problems are with finer details.
- Tostino 4y agoIt matters when the limited resources are spent chasing unicorns that are vanishing unlikely to actually be there. That is part of the argument. Those dollars could go other places than these giant particle accelerators that haven't shown anything much since the Higgs Boson, and no theories are more than guessing that we will.
- lanza 4y agoEh, your analogy isn't apt. The problem in physics is that the space of possible theories has been searched so exhaustively that what these physicists are doing is just about the only choice. To make your analogy close to physics -- imagine you found a unicorn horn and can tell from the biological makeup that it is indeed a horn grown from some sort of horse-like mammal. If you searched 99.9999% of the earth for animals that might have grown that horn and found nothing then the best thing to do would be to continue looking within that 0.00001%. We can't figure out what comes after the standard model of particle physics. But we know it's wrong. e.g. we know black holes exist and something has to happen within them. But we don't have a theory that can predict what that is. e.g. we found a unicorn horn. So we have to desperately search for it. Hossenfelder is right that it's shitty to have to keep pushing the energy boundaries in which we hope we'll see some interesting behavior. But there's literally nothing else to do. We've searched 99.99999% of earth and there's no unicorn. Do we start denying the existence of the unicorn horn that we're holding?
- ikrenji 4y agoidk the amount of experiments / work vying for funding is far bigger than what can be funded. and if a big chunk of the funds is allocated to building bigger accelerators then a lot of experiments or other work might not get funded. im not saying its better to fund other projects over the next big accelerator or dark matter detector, but i dont think its right to say there is nothing else to do besides that...
- parton 4y agoThere's other physics to do, but it's not fundamental physics. The science questions for which we need accelerators can't be answered any other way.
- BizarroLand 4y ago> The problem in physics is that the space of possible theories has been searched so exhaustively that what these physicists are doing is just about the only choice. Can't say I agree with that one. I think we're capping out on the physics that Einstein and ilk laid out for us to explore. This is an ideal time in the next 20-40 years for a new revolutionary genius to figure out the next big thing. I'm not going to make any sci-fi prognostications but I have a feeling like there's a new threshold to cross coming up, one of those unknown unknowns that we'll suddenly figure out thanks to a flash of insight by the right person being in the right place at the right time kind of things.
- User23 4y agoFeynman mentions a similar point in QED when he talks about the "science" of proton decay. The proton hasn't had the courtesy to actually decay in an experiment, so all they do is keep publishing increasingly high lower bounds on the proton's half-life. It's fascinating that someone can make a career out of a phenomenon not being observed.
- analog31 4y agoFolks talk about the lack of support for things like replication studies and the publication of negative results in the life sciences, as contributing to the widely proclaimed replication crisis. Establishing a solid negative result that rules out hypotheses is worthwhile if unglamorous. Citing an upper bound on the half-life is all that can be credibly reported. It's how you put an error bar on something that's non-negative but consistent with zero.
- User23 4y agoSure, but when an event supposedly happens on average less frequently than once every 10^32 years maybe it’s time to consider the possibility that the sought phenomenon never occurs. At least that appeared to me to be what Feynman was getting at. The life sciences equivalent would be a study of unicorn sightings. None so far, but they could be out there so please fund my research!
- analog31 4y agoPlacing an upper limit on the half life means that zero is within the reported bounds, so they are considering the possibility. Whether to fund difficult research, when it's reasonable to give up, and when it escapes beyond reasonable definitions of science, are separate questions. Physics is wrestling with these questions in a number of areas, such as the search for an empirically testable theory that reconciles quantum mechanics and gravity. The life sciences have no equivalent. Precision measurement is not their bag, which is OK. Physics is the first to arrive at such a roadblock. Maybe the search for proofs of some famous math conjectures is an analogy to draw guidance from.
- learnedSloth 4y ago> For myself it sounds like saying, "well you don't know Unicorns don't exist because we haven't looked everywhere, what if they're in <unexplored forests in the Congo>?" Then the Congo gets explored and they say, "well maybe they're in Antarctica". In India: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Indian_One_Horned_Rhino.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Indian_One_Horned_Rhino.j...
- dougSF70 4y agoAs a counter point to this, by all accounts Millikan had worked out the charge on an electron but had not validated it by experiemnt. Knowing what thw result should be, he then designed an experiment to arri ve at this result. Not very scientific at all.
- sidlls 4y agoHypothesis: the charge on an electron is X, as predicted by Y. Experiment: observe the charge on an electron. The experiment could have shown the charge to be other than X: in which case (assuming repeated experiments confirmed it) the hypothesis was wrong and a new one would have been needed. "Y" wasn't invented out of nothing: it was built on other observations, hypotheses, and theories. Seems pretty scientific to me, but I'm biased (since I'm a physicist). I think at some point we (physicists) are just going to have to realize we're at the point where the models we have maybe should be taken for what they are (incomplete), and re-examine the data and construct new hypotheses to design experiments for. I'm certainly not the physicist to do that (I haven't been practicing for almost 15 years now, and even when I was I was not the Einstein caliber physicist to do it), but there will be someone or a group who do that. I hope soon, as I'd like to see it!
- worrycue 4y agoSounds a bit like epicycles. When they found data that doesn’t match, they just added more epicycles until it did. Took until Kepler and the idea that orbits were mostly elliptical for people to throw out epicycles altogether.