6 ms·
‘Compostable’ plastics no longer able to be composted in Boulder
- ccamrobertson 4y agoThe paper leaf bag ban is the worst part. Not looking forward to fall 2023.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rqtwteye 4y agoThe plastics industry is always coming up with bullshit initiatives to make people feel good about using plastics. First recycling, then composting. In the end, these initiatives are known to be failing. The only way is to reuse and stop using single use items.
- ccooffee 4y ago"Stop using single use items" is a REALLY hard goal. Outside of extreme homesteading/off-grid situations, I don't think it's actually possible. At the grocery, I can purchase some produce and dried goods (from bulk food bins) without needing single-use items. But most of my produce has stickers or rubber bands, even at the farmers market, so I still cannot avoid them. "Grow everything yourself and never interact with society" doesn't seem like a very fulfilling life to me.
- Nextgrid 4y agoThere's a difference between "stop using single-use items completely" and merely reduce their usage. There's a lot of excessive packaging in supermarkets that can be addressed without compromising usability/user-experience and ultimately reducing the plastic footprint significantly. Most produce doesn't need stickers or rubber-bands for example, nor does it need individual packaging - the packaging can be provided at the supermarket in the form of a single plastic bag.
- yjftsjthsd-h 4y agoSure, reduction is a reasonable goal, but this thread started with > The only way is to reuse and stop using single use items.
- 9dev 4y agoLiving in Germany, I don't even need plastic bags - I take produce from large bins, and carry it home in my bag pack (or shopping bags if I'm out doing a week's groceries). Why do we even need single-use plastic bags at all? Supermarkets over here sell more robust, reusable shopping bags at the checkout. These are a good alternative if you forget your own.
- Nextgrid 4y agoProblem with reusable bags is that you have to have it on-hand. Fine if you plan your visit to the supermarket or have a car where you can always have a few stashed. If you don’t have a car and only go to the supermarket occasionally on the way back from somewhere else you’re very unlikely to have a bag with you, so you end up buying the “reusable” bag every time and at this point I’ve thrown away several hundred of those over the last couple years as they accumulate at home and I have no use for them.
- manicdee 4y agoWe might have to train people to think about things before they do them. Or heck, even plan things ahead of time, like adding things to a shopping list instead of buying one item at a time on impulse. Though I admit this might be too radical an idea for the majority of today’s youth.
- Hardwired8976 4y agoI also go occasionally to the supermarket and I just put a tote bag or any kind of other bag into my big bag in case the stuff doesn‘t fit. That can‘t be too hard and you should be able to figure that out without wasting several hundred reusable bags
- 9dev 4y ago
- cratermoon 4y ago> rubber bands Natural rubber or synthetic? The former is biodegradable and compostable at industrial facilities. Don't put rubber in your backyard compost bin, though, even if you're 100% sure it's natural. I agree about the little plastic stickers, though. Those are an abomination.
- hinkley 4y agoIf anything should get compostable plastic it’s food stickers. I used to volunteer with a group that got compost from the yard waste composting facilities in Seattle, and that stuff was full of banana and apple stickers. And that’s presumably after it had been through a screen. Microplastics or soon to be. I don’t know what the alternative is. If you want to write your congress critter it helps if you have an alternative suggestion.
- maxerickson 4y agoThere's been experiments with marking the skin with a laser. And I guess there are edible inks (which at least offers the opportunity to remove the plastic, even if it still off putting).
- hinkley 4y agoPaper stickers with a corn based glue and a bit of clay to make them shiny seems like a reasonable solution that still works with sticker guns. Those second stickers you see the stores put on, I haven’t seen those in the compost, so I’m suspecting they either break down or compost, but the distinction is important. Invisible plastic is still plastic.
- jlarocco 4y ago> "Grow everything yourself and never interact with society" doesn't seem like a very fulfilling life to me. It sounds like a great life to me... but not very realistic in this day and age.
- dheera 4y agoAt the very least I think it's a reasonable goal to require that plastics not be used for single-use items. Plastic is a fantastic material for reusable items of sorts, but it doesn't belong in a single-use drink cup, food container, or bag, until we have the technology to truly recycle it and the law enforcement to require that said recycling happen. Execution is important. I've been seeing so much fuss about banning plastic straws but no fuss about the cup. I frequently see drinks in plastic cups with paper straws. Completely backwards.
- danbolt 4y agoCollecting rubber bands from grocery store purchases is kind of like long-term saving. You should start early and not fret about downturns (eg: the occasional one breaking from wear). If you keep a steady supply, you’ll have a healthy nest egg that you can call on when you need it.
- amalcon 4y agoI never understood why the stickers are usually plastic rather than paper. I'm sure there's a reason that I just don't know. It just always seemed to me that if paper is good enough for a price gun, it should be good enough for a barcode.
- rqtwteye 4y agoPlastic has a lot of advantages over paper and unfortunately it’s too cheap.
- rocket_surgeron 4y agoI have almost completely eliminated single-use plastics from my life to the point that my only non-recyclable waste output is a single half-full 20-gallon bag set out for collection approximately every three weeks. The very few remaining items are typically cleaning supplies such as bleach and hazardous cleaning agents but for safety and hygiene purposes I do not consider those a high priority for finding non-plastic alternatives. Please note that I do not include the several-microns-thick coating of plastic that coats the insides of some cardboard boxes and aluminum cans as "plastic output" due to its total annual weight (in my case) being less than that of a single bottle of shampoo. For shaving I use a safety razor, whose blades come in cardboard. For shaving cream I use a puck that comes in cardboard packaging. My toothpaste comes in compressed pellets and all of my soap, even shampoo, comes in bar form. There are currently no plastic single-use items in my bathroom. Even my toilet paper is purchased in bulk, 80 rolls at a time, and comes in a large cardboard box with each roll packaged in paper. It is a recognizable brand's "Industrial" product line. Rather than paying for water most of my cleaning products are purchased in powder form, usually under a recognizable brand's "Industrial" product line, in bulk. This means that yes, I do buy a 5-gallon bucket of laundry detergent but in over a year after I have finally used it all I have a reusable 5-gallon bucket that does not go into the waste stream. You can also buy items like that in cardboard boxes lined with a plastic liner but even then the volume of plastic is, after many years, less than that of a single plastic laundry detergent container which only lasts months. Even cleaning products that, again for health and safety reasons, come in plastic containers I buy them in bulk, dispensing them into reusable (and much higher quality) applicators. This means that the (realistically) unavoidable use of plastics is minimized. The amount of plastic used in a single 128-ounce bulk "industrial" cleaning bottle is less than that used in 4 32-ounce (typical sized) bottles and the reusable (again, "industrial") spray bottles I use to apply the product last for years if not decades. For food items I typically do not buy anything that comes in plastic with the main exception being sliced bread, but again that volume of plastic is so low it is almost irrelevant. When I realized that I was throwing away ~30 plastic yogurt containers per month I started making yogurt myself in an instant pot and storing the yogurt in glass jars. Doing so requires almost no effort-- the instant pot does it for you. I've been doing this since 2011 with the same jars, which will probably last another 100 years, so I have not thrown away over 4,000 yogurt containers. In your example, the rubber bands and stickers are irrelevant. Years, if not decades, of rubber (assuming you mean synthetic rubber, natural rubber is fine and will biodegrade) bands and stickers add up to a single bottle of dish soap's worth of plastic. Plastic is a wonderful material but it is immoral, to me, to use it without foresight of its impact and costs. It requires effort, but is not "hard". Effort does not equal "hard". My anti-plastic crusade started because I live on the Chesapeake Bay and became involved in Bay cleanup initiatives about a decade ago. I'd say 9 out of every 10 items I recovered were plastic items, some from as far away as New York State, having floated for hundreds of miles down the Susquehanna and Delaware Rivers.
- rqtwteye 4y ago“ But most of my produce has stickers or rubber bands, even at the farmers market, so I still cannot avoid them.” As consumer there are only limited ways you can reduce single use. We need to change the economics so excessive packaging is too expensive.
- eloff 4y agoSince the move from single use plastic bags to reusable ones, my environmental impact has increased. Firstly I now have to buy garbage bags, where I previously reused shopping bags. That completely negates the benefit. But let’s ignore that and say most people just trash them. Even in that case you’d have to reuse a reusable bag 20 times to break even. I don’t know about you, but on average maybe I get 0-5 reuses out of these bags. That’s just squarely worse off than we were before.
- taude 4y agoI just reuse my "disposable" bags anyway, like ziplocks and stuff. I agree the fancy "reusable" plastic bags are pretty much junk (when storing food, like lunch items). It does make sense using the reusable grocery bags, though. Those things last a long time and don't get gross inside. I'm waiting for someone to invent the re-usable dog-poop bag. ;)
- srcreigh 4y agoThe reusable dog poop bag is probably a bucket. Maybe smaller one with a lid.
- djleni 4y agoUm what kind of reusable bag are you using? I’ve had the same reusable bags for probably 5 years now and not a single one has failed.
- taude 4y agoI think it depends that you're reusing them for. I bought some of those "Stasher" branded reusable plastic bags for lunch things, they got gross pretty quickly, hard to wash, and then they started coming apart at the seems. Pretty dumb optimization, considering they cost $15 for three bags. My grocery bags, though, for loading up at the store are good, and last a long time. As in all things, moderation, do the 80% etc...
- SapporoChris 4y agoThere are reusable bags that are fairly durable. I bought one in Mexico, I think its woven plastic. Not cheap thin plastic by any means. I bought it from Bodega Aurrerá which is owned by Walmart de México y Centroamérica. The bag is labeled 100% recyclable. I've been using it for eleven months, so far it has a one 2 cm cut in the bottom of it. It is still very useable.
- taude 4y agoYuep, everyone forgets it's the THREE R's: Reduce, Reuse, Recycle....
- hinkley 4y agoBecause consumer marketing now thinks only recycling makes them money. In the Great Depression and then during several nostalgia cycles after, companies sold products in or with reusable containers. Everything from tins to depression glass was a value add for the products. Your grandma may still be keeping sewing supplies in old cookie tins, reusing Ball jars that food came in, etc.
- xnx 4y agoTrue. Almost all talk of plastic packaging waste is a (deliberate?) distraction from larger issues. e.g. buying a new car will generate more plastic and other waste than a lifetime of plastic bags and utensils.
- colechristensen 4y ago"Compostable" plastics are a polymer made of lactic acid units chained together called PLA. It is absolutely compostable, but needs specific conditions. In nature it breaks down very much faster than other plastics and in pure form at least, though it still lasts a while. Because it's lactic acid and animals are already full of lactic acid, the concerns about polluting the environment with it are much lower. It sounds like the recycler they're using only has the correct facilities to process some but not all of these PLA plastics and are having contamination problems with people putting non-compostable things in along with the compostable ones. They're also refusing used coffee filters so it seems the problem isn't plastic industry scams but poor compliance with people putting the wrong things in the compost bin. I've known several well intentioned but slightly clueless people who put just about anything in the recycling or compost not realizing that they were just contaminating the stream and making things much worse. It's almost the opposite where recycling/composting proponents are giving and getting wrong impressions about how much really needs to be put in the landfill.
- hinkley 4y agoShouldn’t used coffee filters go in yard waste though? What’s the vector for rejection you’re thinking of? I live with people who keep putting soiled cardboard in recycling. Only last year did I win the war on pizza boxes.
- colechristensen 4y agoThe Boulder composter is rejecting coffee grounds for compost for whatever reason. That seems pretty strange to me I have no idea why they would. In general coffee grounds should be compost. Maybe people were trying to compost whole coffee kureg pods or something?
- hinkley 4y agoI use paper filters, and unbleached if I can get them. I’m not convinced that all of the tea bags we get are plastic free. In fact some fancy tea we tried definitely was in a plastic bag. I got us interested in other teas ASAP. I wonder if there are coffee filters loaded with plastic out there. Coffee is wonderful on its own for composting. It’s very nearly the correct C:N ratio just by itself.
- realworldperson 4y ago[dead]
- burtonator 4y agoI wish we would just refuse to recycle to push for reuse. Reuse could actually work. If we were to standardize on thicker plastics, that could last longer, we could just have like 10-20 standard container sizes and constantly reuse them.
- triyambakam 4y agoThe bolded words in the article is a stylistic choice that makes me uncomfortable.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- RegularOpossum 4y agoI expect this to be the start of a trend based on my own personal experience. I bought some "compostable" bags for my kitchen scrap bin that I would then dump in my outdoor composter. Six months later when I went to get my compost, large pieces of bag not only remained but had harded into solid chunks. Took an hour to sift out the chunks from the compost. Edit: turns out I was ignorant of how they actually work.
- akiselev 4y agoA good rule of thumb is that truly compostable bags are almost completely useless as bags in the real world. They're just barely good enough to carry the scraps from the kitchen to the compost bin but they won't work as a liner for more than a few hours in the presence of moisture.
- jefftk 4y agoThe normal way people solve this is with materials that require a small amount of heat to break down in addition to moisture. Industrial composting facilities run at 120-140F. But yes, these don't break down with home composting which is almost always much lower temperature.
- ccooffee 4y agoHow large is your composter? Many of the "bio-plastics" require high heat composting to decompose, and even then may require a large amount of time. Unless you've got a massive compost pile with adequate aeration and turning, almost no bio-plastics will truly decompose at home. From the EPA[0]: > If a plastic product is labeled “compostable,” can I add it to my home compost pile? > No. Unless the label indicates that the product is okay for home composting, you should not try to compost it at home. Plastic that is labeled as compostable is generally intended to be sent to an industrial or commercial composting facility which has higher temperatures and different breakdown conditions than those found in a typical homeowner’s compost bin. If your community has a residential compost collection program, check with your local government or recycling company to find out if they will accept compostable plastic under this program. [0] https://www.epa.gov/trash-free-waters/frequently-asked-questions-about-plastic-recycling-and-composting#home https://www.epa.gov/trash-free-waters/frequently-asked-quest...
- toomuchtodo 4y agoEnable and enforce waste collection/disposal systems and plasma gasify all of it. Problem solved. The Rube Goldbergesq current state is annoying.
- nerdponx 4y agoWhat happened to plasma gasifiers? I kept reading about them years ago and I thought New York City had ordered some, but haven't seen them in the news since.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoMore expensive than landfills or shipping plastic to the developing world. Usual externalities.
- carapace 4y agoMolten Salt Oxidation. "Burn" plastic (and everything else) in a bath of red-hot liquid salt. Exothermic reaction. Produces "synthesis gas". It's used to dispose of munitions and DDT and shi-- stuff like that.
- lokar 4y agoEven if these compostable service items can’t be composted at least they would degrade in the environment, right? There is no real issue with landfill space. True problem is lots stuff never makes it to the landfill.
- amluto 4y agoThis is not obviously a good thing. Landfill space is plentiful, and many plastics are quite stable in landfills and lock up their carbon content. But things that decay are likely to emit methane and CO2. IMO the biggest benefit of compostable materials in food service is that they have a decent chance of eventually degrading to safe materials if they end up outside a landfill.
- lokar 4y agoI’m thinking of the potato utensils, do they emit methane?
- amluto 4y agoI imagine it depends on what happens to them. They’re largely made out of carbon, oxygen, and hydrogen, in a fairly high energy state. If they turn into microbe food in an aerobic environment, they probably turn into CO2 and H2O. In an anaerobic environment, they could turn into all manner of chemicals. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Methanogenesis https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Methanogenesis
- cmckn 4y agoWhen organic mass is sent to the landfill instead of being composted, it decomposes without oxygen, buried in the fill. Anaerobic digestion produces methane, while aerobic digestion only produces carbon dioxide. Methane is a much more potent greenhouse gas than carbon dioxide.
- jefftk 4y agoYes, if your landfill doesn't make any attempt to capture methane. Modern landfills, however, generally do, and this can be much cheaper than running a separate collection and handling system for compost. The captured methane can either be flared off, or used as a fuel.
- ilyt 4y ago> including paper materials, tea bags, coffee filters What's reason for that ?
- number6 4y ago"paper" materials are often enriched with plastics, so that your teabag does not rip if you pull it to hard or softens up in hot water.