7 ms·
As Kenya’s crops fail, a fight over GMO
- Kukumber 4y ago> Farmers who buy seed protected by some types of patent must sign an agreement not to sell or save seed from these crops – so they are obliged to buy fresh seeds every year. The dark side of the GMO propaganda, then you have the royalties ;) https://royalsociety.org/topics-policy/projects/gm-plants/who-is-paying-for-gm-crop-development-and-who-owns-technology/ https://royalsociety.org/topics-policy/projects/gm-plants/wh...
- frostburg 4y agoThis is an often repeated anti-GMO talking point, but in reality typical farmers don't want to spend time and effort in making their own, inferior, seed.
- giantg2 4y agoI agree, in first world countries. I'm not sure this is as true in the developing world.
- xyzzyz 4y agoYeah, in the developing world they follow a lot of traditional practices, like seed saving or underuse of artificial fertilizers or pesticides, which results in bad yields and leaves them poorer.
- hgsgm 4y agoSome might call that "more sustainable" and "less subject to foreign imperialist control"
- xyzzyz 4y agoYes, the people who don’t care much about well being and flourishing of people in poor areas of the world might say that. Sure, they work their asses of hoeing the rows, and get quarter of the yields people in the west get with ten times more labor input, but at least it’s sustainable. No, sorry, I reject this sort of anti-human approach — people in poor countries deserve to flourish too, and using best farming and industrial practices is crucial to achieve that. I find this sort of keeping impoverished people in a cycle of poverty in the name of “sustainability” (whatever that means) to be rather despicable.
- unmole 4y agoIt most definitely is true in India.
- themitigating 4y agoHow is it a dark side? It's part of the agreement and known before signing
- kiba 4y agoMore to do with the patent than the actual technology.
- bluGill 4y agoSince the 1940s farmers have preferred hybrid seeds that don't breed true. Saving seeds is an extremely stupid thing to do, so no farmer hesitates to sign the agreement.
- modo_mario 4y ago>Saving seeds is an extremely stupid thing to do, so no farmer hesitates to sign the agreement. Hard disagree. I know of a good few farmers seedsaving. They mostly do relatively small scale and/or organic and one I'm particularly close to's business is mostly centered around selling seeds so that's definitely not representative....but I dare say it's still a dumb statement. Especially in the context of Kenyan farmers where the majority of farms are comparatively small as per quick google.
- mistrial9 4y ago> Since the 1940s sales totals as evidence? > farmers have preferred Which farmers, in what markets? > hybrid seeds that don't breed true does this apply to the Organic markets as defined by the legal definition of Organic ? > Saving seeds is an extremely stupid thing extremely stupid statements quickly accuse others of being extremely stupid, in my experience > so no farmer hesitates hesitation.. you mean understanding the agreement? then deciding on your own, with your own counsel ? > sign the agreement which legal jurisdiction ? what language is the agreement in ? where is the venue for resolution of conflict?
- qz_kb 4y agohybrid seeds don't breed true. You need to research what hybrid means, I have no idea why you bring up "organic markets" as if the market/growing conditions affect the genetics of a plant??
- jcampbell1 4y agoHeterosis.
- AlbertCory 4y agoIt's a dick move to demand a citation for everything. Do you do that for all the posts you AGREE with?
- hajile 4y agoWhat does GMO do to solve “we didn’t get any rain”? They’ll get sold into patent slavery they can’t afford to solve the wrong problem.
- do_poopoo 4y agothere are gmo crops that rely on less water to grow - they'll use those. agree with your second point, possibly already there.
- infecto 4y agoThe article states they are wanting to use drought resistant strains. I am assuming the drought resistant could be translated as “plants that don’t need a lot of rain”.
- derekp7 4y agoWell, there is drought resistant crops. Yes, it is true the crops can't grow without any water at all, but often times drought means less water, and that causes the crops to become more susceptible to disease. So that is one way of making a crop drought resistant, is to make it disease resistant.
- hajile 4y agoDrought resistant not a silver bullet. It can help, but only up to a point (and that point seems lower than the sales guys and sponsored studies under optimal conditions might indicate). Edited because part of this wasn’t factually correct.
- Godel_unicode 4y ago> These are plants that have had genes from another organism inserted into their DNA to give them a new trait, such as disease or drought resistance
- mistrial9 4y agothere are already crops that grow under less-rain conditions, but sales teams are checking your subscription status right now
- 32kfjh23 4y agoArticle talks about corn, but GMO is something with tradeoffs as GMO dwarf wheat may not grow better than regular wheat under drought conditions. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/pce.13819 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/pce.13819
- A_D_E_P_T 4y agoWRT patent slavery: My understanding is that patents are not globally enforceable. A US patent is enforceable in the USA. If you want to protect that same invention in Mongolia, you'd need to file for a separate patent in Mongolia and have it approved. There are certain timing and procedural limitations, as well. (e.g.: If you're an American citizen, you're obligated to file in the USA first. If your patent has been published, it may be no longer capable of attaining a foreign patent.) The "patent slavery" claim is therefore only credible if: (1) - The GMO seeds in question have a local Kenyan patent. (2) - Local Kenyan courts decide to enforce the rights of the patent holder, and toss arguments that "an act of God," or something similar, compelled farmers to use the GMO seeds. I think that both steps are a priori unlikely. Virtually no patents -- even very important ones -- are filed in every possible jurisdiction. And I don't think that the courts would side with the patent holders in any case, for, e.g, force-majeure/act-of-god/unequal-agreement reasons.
- mordae 4y agoI don't believe US or EU will sell them the crops without patent enforcement.
- hinata08 4y agoIt terrifies me to have a patent on the only crop that can grow in a country. Food is a necessity What happens if the seller decides to quadruple the price overnight ? (à la OPEC but for crops) If some country does 'sanctions' ? (like Russia or the USA when they can't just declare a war to a place) or if the economy collapses and imports are expensive ? (imagine Venezuela, but the country is also not able to buy crops that work) these crops sellers will own the Kenyans. I wouldn't buy the crops if patents were enforced. it feels like some SF novel (or the Washington Consensus, yet again) Back in the days, China forced foreign companies to work with domestic companies to sell in China. And at least, they are independent on some technologies now.
- unmole 4y ago> It terrifies me to have a patent on the only crop that can grow in a country. If dreaming up an implausible scenario scares you, maybe that's on you?
- photochemsyn 4y agoThis has to be one of the most poorly researched articles on the subject I've seen. First, they want to introduce BT-maize, which has nothing to do with drought resistance - it's been engineered to produce a biotoxin that some pests have already developed resistance to: (2021) Resistance to Bt Maize by Western Corn Rootworm: > "Since the 1990s, an important innovation in the management of agricultural pest insects has been the commercial cultivation of genetically engineered crops that produce insecticidal toxins, which in turn act to protect plants from feeding injury by insects. To date, these transgenic crops, which include cotton, maize and soybean, have produced insecticidal proteins derived from the bacterium Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt). Benefits associated with planting of Bt crops include reduced feeding injury from pest insects, decreased yield losses from pests and less harm to the environment. However, the evolution of Bt resistance by insect pests can diminish these benefits. One serious insect pest currently managed with Bt maize is the western corn rootworm. The larval stage of this insect feeds on maize roots and can substantially reduce yield. In some parts of the US Corn Belt, western corn rootworm rapidly adapted to Bt maize, and currently, some populations show resistance to all commercially available Bt traits." https://www.mdpi.com/2075-4450/12/2/136 https://www.mdpi.com/2075-4450/12/2/136 The next question is, what's the cost of introducing this in terms of patent restrictions on seed production, seed costs to farmers, etc.? Reuters at least addresses the issue: https://www.reuters.com/world/africa/kenyas-gmo-maize-push-sowing-trouble-food-sector-farmers-warn-2022-12-15/ https://www.reuters.com/world/africa/kenyas-gmo-maize-push-s... Given the inexorable climate trends, maybe Kenya's farmers really need better irrigation systems or help with transition to more drought-resistant crops like cassava? https://www.devex.com/news/kenyan-farmers-look-to-drought-resistant-cassava-as-grain-substitute-103834 https://www.devex.com/news/kenyan-farmers-look-to-drought-re... > "Cassava production in Kenya dropped in the nineties and early 2000s due to diseases, unavailability of clean seeds, poor varieties, and agronomical practices."
- evandijk70 4y agoWith regards to 'seed slavery's, how can farmers be worse of than they are now? They can always go back to the normal seeds if that is cheaper. Regarding resistance, you could make the same arguments for any pesticide. Moreover, this is about outlawing a technology. That should only be done if that technology forbid is harmful to the environment or public health. The farmers can then decide whether they should transition to other crops. That should not be imposed from above.
- inpdx 4y ago"Although GM crops are completely safe to eat" While I think that's far from settled, it's certainly true that Bt corn encouraged the liberal use of Roundup, which is not completely safe.
- elcritch 4y agoIt’s not the “GMO” part that’s problematic — it’s what is done with GMO. Humans have been “genetically modifying” crops for millennia. The case for the rise of modern “gluten sensitivity” actually being “roundup sensitivity” seems pretty strong. Likely wheat just absorbs it more.
- hgsgm 4y agoHuman selection isn't quite the same as human modification.
- bequanna 4y agoWouldn’t that pretty easy to test by giving those who claim gluten sensitivity some organic wheat?
- modo_mario 4y agoI think that would have to be a longterm study where the test subjects don't just avoid wheat with it sprayed nearby but also other products affected by it. Correct me if I'm wrong but I think the claim is that the residual glyphosate or the like can affect certain gut bacteria (and overgrowth of certain others) which leads to the symptoms as those bacteria might be helpfull in breaking down gluten. So a person affected this who suddenly eats organic wheat would still exhibit the same symptoms. I don't think there's been proper proof or studies for this but the idea doesn't seem to be too far fetched since it comes from studies on fish and the like where similar things were seen.
- dekhn 4y agoComparing classical plant breeding with GMO (or with the techniques used in the green revolution) isn't really that useful. There are too many technical differences between a process that uses selection which operates over hundreds to thousands of years, and a process which instantly changes the phenotype of a plant. And those differences matter a lot! The only truly risky GMO I've seen was a case where the allergen from brazil nuts was accidentally introduced to experimental soybeans, which seemed to cause the soybeans to trigger brazil nut allergies in people. That was discontinued pretty quickly.
- guilhas 4y agoWouldn't this be a modern form of colonization, since these countries cannot produce these seeds? Extinguishing local crops for patented seeds produced by a company abroad