4 ms·
I had a professor in grad school who had studied how admissions inputs correlated to various measures of success (which is of course a fraught subject of uts ow
by ghaff 4y ago
I had a professor in grad school who had studied how admissions inputs correlated to various measures of success (which is of course a fraught subject of uts own). This was a while back though I assume not much as changed. As I recall, standardized tests followed by some sort of adjusted class rank were the best predictors while a lot of the softer stuff like interviews and letters of recommendation were pretty close to worthless. I expect schools could drop some of the more time-consuming softer stuff with very little impact on the admissions process.
In MIT's case it probably is especially important to assess certain types of skills, because someone who doesn't have a reasonable math background for example is going to have a bad time. (Though problems doing math is a surprisingly common theme in higher ed including at the grad level--even with programs you wouldn't think were especially quantitative.)
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> while a lot of the softer stuff like interviews and letters of recommendation were pretty close to worthless It’s telling we’re seeing testing attacked while these are preserved.
- lumb63 4y agoIt’s not a mistake, that’s for sure. I’ll be more blunt since a lot of other comments in this thread beat around the bush: higher education institutes are removing objective admissions criteria so that they can admit less qualified minorities on subjective grounds.
- baremetal 4y agothe question is, why? why are they doing it? the real reason not the ostensible one.
- IshKebab 4y agoMoney presumably. There's an extremely strong incentive for educational institutions to spend their long term reputation on short term financial gain by setting high fees and giving everyone a high grade. Basically everyone loves it except people who already graduated. And maybe employers, but employers tend to do their own tests because of the difficulty of comparing external test results across time and institutions.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> question is, why? Discretionary admissions with social goals turns the university, and its administrators, into institutions with broad public remit.
- ljhlkjlkj 4y agoProbably three reasons: 1) They're trying to get ahead of a Supreme Court ruling, which will likely rule Ivies are discriminating against Asian candidates. 2) Elite cultural zeitgeist is in favor of discriminating against Asian and non-elite white candidates. 3) More subtly, the top Ivy admins are overwhelmingly Jewish, and they've likely received push back from Jewish alumni/donors, as Asians have displaced smart-but-unremarkable Jewish candidates. A recent Tablet article alluded to Asians displacing Jewish candidates, which has been an unreported theme in the Ivies over the last 20 years. Those three things are driving much of it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ghaff 4y agoWell, on the one hand, student applicants want to feel that "I am not a number, I am a human being." And admission committees put a lot of time and effort into trying to discern qualities that go beyond some numbers of the page to admit a qualified but diverse student body (for reasons both good and arguably bad or ineffective).