6 ms·
Homelessness is primarily a housing problem
- jdaggers 4y agoWhile I don't doubt the statistics brought up in this article, I am skeptical about how the underlying data was sampled. The majority of "homeless" people are not necessarily who everyone is talking about when they think "homeless" (e.g. people dressed in rags sleeping on the streets/doing drugs in public.) I personally suspect that there's quite a difference in that sub-population.
- bombcar 4y agoThere’s a big crosstalk that happens because almost everyone is referring to the chronically homeless (or whatever the technical term is) whereas the vast majority are homeless for 6 months or less.
- Natsu 4y agoYeah and even here we hear stats like 33% have serious mental illness, 20-40% have drug issues, etc. I'd bet those figures are even more skewed if we look at the long term homeless populations. But it's true, we really do have to get more housing and the biggest problems there are permitting, NIMBY issues and inflation driving up costs. Ideally we'd work on all significant contributors to homelessness at the same time, though.
- Aloha 4y agoI believe firmly they are two different cohorts, and if you stay homeless longer and longer, you start to homogenize into the other cohort and pick up there comorbidities of that cohort.
- rmason 4y agoI have been studying the homeless problem. In Lansing the problem has exploded 4-5X in the past twenty years. I am looking for a way locally that my tech skills can help, even in a small way. It was suggested that I learn about the efforts of Celebrity Rehab Dr. Drew who is outspoken on the homeless problem. He wants permission to treat the homeless who are mentally ill. He believes not only can they be helped but returned to productive members of society. But he is opposed by L.A. politicians who have blocked him. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2MRrlIpQ-Hk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2MRrlIpQ-Hk (9 minutes)
- forgetfreeman 4y agoWith respect consider setting aside your laptop and volunteering with Habitat For Humanity or similar. You'll learn valuable skills and have a direct measurable impact in your community.
- zzzeek 4y agoDr drew is a fraud and a grifter unfortunately
- forgotmypw17 4y agoHomelessness is primarily a problem created by the requirement to continuously upkeep your shelter financially or risk losing it. The ability to perform this upkeep can be wrecked by any number of things, which there is not enough space to list here. The overwhelming majority of people who fail at this upkeep are saved by their support network, so the actual problem is several orders of magnitude larger than any official statistics. Most people who lose their shelter fall back on family and friends and may spend years living on couches, in closets, spare garages, cars, etc., without ever being picked up by the "homeless" statistics. How or why this system came about is beyond the scope of this comment, but it is an iceberg most people only see the tip of. And it is not a necessity, nor is it a reality in many other places around the world.
- Aloha 4y agoOften times that support network, will for years sustain people in their own home too, before the couches and other forms (of defacto, but not statistical) homelessness take over.
- AtlasBarfed 4y agoEveryday life is a treadmill, a neverending ceaseless treadmill, and bad things happen if you fall off that treadmill. For some people, the treadmill is cake: so easy to keep up with it is almost bothersomely slow. But... get a bit of a leg cramp, or lose energy, age a little, or get a bit of mental trauma, and that simple treadmill gets much more terrifying and ominous each day you have to run it. As I get older, those nutso men that shutter away in some far flung cabin with no contact with the world ... gets more appealing. Or simply a van down by the river.
- Incipient 4y agoBut what would be the effect on the amount of dilapidated housing, or "slum areas" without this maintenance requirement?
- forgotmypw17 4y agoI think there would be more people living in poorly maintained buildings instead of not having any building to live in.
- 29athrowaway 4y ago"Homeless" refers to many things. It can refer to a person living in a car, a person living in a shelter, a person living a tent, a person living in a homeless camp, a person living under a piece of cardboard, etc. Some people become homeless at a point and manage their way out, others stay homeless. If you are an alcoholic, or a drug addict, and want to get drunk or high or both in a regular basis, you don't like the rules at the shelter... what place is best for you? a shelter with strict rules where you can't drink or get high, or a homeless camp? The homeless camp. The problem with people like the article author is that they try to monopolize common sense. A person working at Walmart, earning minimum wage while living in their car, has a very different reality to a drug junkie living in a homeless camp. The term "homeless" refers to both. I would not try to begin a serious analysis by mixing such different things.
- Aloha 4y agoA homeless shelter is not solving homelessness - Furthermore - lets just look at some of the common rules imposed on the homeless seeking housing - * No Pets * No Visitors * Curfew Time * Limits on the number of people per unit (meaning, families and couples cannot always be accommodated together) - and a host of others. Also in some places there is a requirement that you have a social worker, and/or receiving mental healthcare treatment - except there are long waiting periods. For most long term homeless people telling them "you have to give up your dog" will keep them on the streets - we need "housing, no questions asked" rather "housing with rules". Most short term homeless do not qualify for these programs - it turns into a kind of License Raj to try to get in, and maintain your status in these programs. If you want to impose your moral vision on people, thats fine and dandy, the jesus-people have been doing it for decades with their missions on skid row, but that wont solve homelessness. I believe there is no such thing as 'unworthy poor' all poverty is worth solving, because the broader societal costs in not solving poverty is corrosive on wider society - and the first step to solving poverty is attacking the homelessnes problem.
- sytelus 4y agoThis dude looks like another “content creator” mission on putting out click optimized links with no substance, no data and no real research. These amature opinion distributors are cancer to information society.
- zzzeek 4y agoInformation Society, great band. They still play I think. Also homelessness is a housing supply issue.
- bryanrasmussen 4y agoOk the article was a guest post on the blog by a guy named Aaron Carr which I take is this guy https://www.linkedin.com/in/aaroncarrny/ https://www.linkedin.com/in/aaroncarrny/ who seems to be some sort of reasonable expert on homelessness, the article has a lot of sections with stuff like this >Furthermore, if mental health were the main driver of homelessness, places with the most mental illness would have the most homelessness. However, the data shows the exact opposite: followed by a scatterplot graph Rate of Serious Mental Illness Versus PIT Count (per capita) with links to the source of the graph for example this https://www.sightline.org/2022/03/16/homelessness-is-a-housing-problem/ https://www.sightline.org/2022/03/16/homelessness-is-a-housi... So, what is your actual problem with 'this dude'? Or the 'content' that has been 'created'? on edit: I could totally understand (without necessarily agreeing) if your post was "this guy looks like someone trying to increase funding for their organization by cherry-picking stats to support a tenuous case"
- readthenotes1 4y agoI wonder how much mental illness and drug abuse contribute to staying in a place you can't afford a roof?
- notjulianjaynes 4y ago20 million Americans have a substance use disorder. About half a million people in the United States are currently experiencing homelessness. So the overlap in those populations is like 2%. Source: couple lazy google searches.
- freddref 4y agoWhat percentage of homeless have mental illness or drug abuse issues?
- usgroup 4y agoThe regressions presented on the graphs are misleading at best. The effect of outliers on the fitting looks fairly obvious as are the high density linear areas.
- ARandomerDude 4y ago> And, at long last, we have arrived at the actual root cause of homelessness: housing costs. To prove this point the author shows 4 graphs with R^2 values of 0.55, 0.27, 0.24, and 0.28. That's a tough sell, especially when the non-underlined portion of the abstract he showed reads: > most people with substance-abuse issues remain homeless for 12 months or longer.
- legitster 4y agoThis seems pretty cut and dry to me. Single Resident Occupancy units used to be incredibly common - from shared adult dorms to chicken-wire hotels. Now they are non-existent. In 50 years this represented a loss of over a million housing units! Today there are 500k people living on the streets. I don't think it's a coincidence.
- forgetfreeman 4y agoSee Also: the ridiculous lot size requirements for single trailers and the de facto ban on trailer parks.
- Aloha 4y agoUrban Renewal/Beautification and NIMBYism to an extent killed both trailer parks and single occupancy units. I'd also note the death of the boarding house between 1920 and 1970 as another issue contributing to things.
- Incipient 4y agoIn the 50-100 years since then, you think we don't have the tech or capacity to have been able to "upgrade" trailer parks into even studio apartments? Feels like a huge oversimplification to just say "all would be fine if we had trailer parks".
- manicdee 4y agoYou say “trailer parks” I say “affordable housing”. Affordable housing solutions like dorms and bedsit apartment blocks aren’t feasible in many places like the USA where it’s literally illegal to build anything other than high rise apartments or standalone homes.
- zumu 4y agoWhy should issues like homelessness be reducible to one 'primary' cause? Highlighting housing costs as a significant contributing factor is an important point to make, but there's no need to undermine the other contributing factors through bad faith arguments and cherry picked statistics. Yes, homelessness clusters in cities with robust social programs, esp. those with temperate weather. These same cities are also the most expensive in the US, effectively creating homelessness traps. As for following in the footsteps of Houston, it's not nearly as feasible for these places. They have up to 10x the homeless populations and 2-3x the housing costs. Compare providing 5,000 units in Houston vs providing 70,000 in Los Angeles. We should absolutely look to provide more subsidized housing to the needy, but it's clear we aren't aren't able to do it in the most in demand real estate markets in country. EDIT: numbers
- whitemary 4y ago> We should absolutely look to provide more subsidized housing to the needy, but it's clear we aren't aren't able to do it in the most in demand real estate markets in country. Who will you hold responsible when they can’t find jobs where they live?
- Aloha 4y agoWe choose not to do it - and I dont believe its calls for subsidy alone, if you build 100,000+ market rate units in SF Bay, PDX, or SEA - the price for market rate housing will drop, by some measurable amount. You keep letting developers build housing until there is no more demand to build more, even if it's the foo-foo luxury apartments - they will put downward price pressure on the 3rd floor walkups.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoYou are assuming that the economics of house building is such that developers would do as many projects as they could if only they were allowed to, but even in the current market, property developers are still very picky and have to make sure they can make a decent profit; land costs are only one part of that. If you let developers build 100,000 market rate places in one city, (a) they actually don’t have the resources (labor, capital) to do that in some reasonable time frame and (b) they would pull back if sale prices began dropping below their costs plus profit margin.
- Aloha 4y agoWe also make it very hard to climb back out of homelessness - if you've had an eviction, it's very hard to find a place to take you. I have a friend in Portland, he's a single, male, with no kids, in Portland - and there is no program to help, hopefully you make 3x the rent and can save up first/last, and a months deposit. What's worse, he has mental health issues, but he makes too much for medicaid and too little to buy insurance, so he can either work, or have healthcare, and those are the options - either way, the only place he can find to live is in a minivan.
- exabrial 4y ago> we can build an ample supply of housing and subsidized housing. Sigh. That’s the conclusion? Land is cheap. Literally most of the US is empty. Housing is stupid cheap. Housing is crowded coastal cities is not. What the article did highlight really well (maybe accidentally) that homelessness sticks around for multiple reasons: 40% substance problem, mental illness problem, etc. maybe there’s always two factors, maybe that’s why efforts aren’t ending it?
- Aloha 4y agoThere are no jobs in those places, and if there are, little housing, or little way for the people sleeping in a tent somewhere to go there. Furthermore people are afraid of moving to places they know no one, further away from their support network and familiarity - so they dont.
- buzzert 4y agoThere are varying levels of tolerance of homelessness across the country. On the other side of the equation of tolerance are several factors, including politics but most especially rent prices. People in cities with low rent prices are far less likely to tolerate homelessness than cities with high rent prices. Cities with high rents will use high rents as a scapegoat for inaction in solving the problem (i.e., “we need to build more housing!” as if that’s a perfectly tenable thing to do on a landlocked peninsula filled with extraordinary regulations on building). If someone becomes homeless (or rather, is becoming homeless) because they can’t pay their rent, wouldn’t they… move somewhere cheaper? That is in fact what usually happens. Those who become homeless instead often do for reasons other than not being able to afford rent; these people are quitting society. Japan has Hikikomori, and we have the homeless.
- gremlinsinc 4y agoIt's increasingly getting harder to find a 'somewhere else' to move. I mean in the 90s you'd move across town, now you need to move east of the Mississippi. The average home price in Utah was 350k 4-5 years ago. It is now 560k. I was close to being able to afford one, now I'm a decade out from it, and then maybe never. I'm more likely to buy some land and a tiny home, and call it a day. We need to control the greed that is homeownership/rent-seeking, and put caps on things, or at least institute a land-value tax tied to rent : wages ratios.
- buzzert 4y agoYou don't have to move across the country. Considering SF, you can just move to Modesto, which is 1.5hrs away and has a third of the cost of living.
- proc0 4y agoIf the problem is housing, and some cities don't have homelessness problems because they have cheap housing... then why don't the homeless people in places with expensive housing go to the places with cheap housing? Is it maybe because they prefer living in the more expensive area even if it means sleeping outside? is there maybe some individual-level incentive playing a factor here? Something is not adding up. Some cities have cheap housing, and others have expensive housing. In theory people could relocate and avoid sleeping outside, at least a huge portion of them, yet instead we see increasing populations in places with expensive housing. I'm just saying there is something missing from the picture because if housing was the primary cause, relocating would be the obvious solution that most people would rationally choose. Instead it seems like people insist in staying in the expensive housing areas, because I assume the cheap housing areas are boring, and they might not have as many government programs. It doesn't surprise me that government can't solve this problem, because they are unable to analyze it in the proper level of detail and instead use super high level statistical correlations which have not led to any results.
- petesergeant 4y agoIf I was down and out, I’d want to stay in the place my friends and family were, rather than pitching up in a whole new city, without a vehicle, funds, and without knowing how to get government assistance
- buzzert 4y agoYou should also try to imagine that your friends and family want absolutely nothing to do with you also, and that would be a clearer picture of the problem.
- proc0 4y agoIn that scenario, why would you not live with a relative until you can find work and pay rent? If they're not helping you at that point, they're not worth that much as family, in my opinion. I would guess most homeless people have no one to rely on, and so a fresh start somewhere else should at least be an option.
- 4y ago
- 1letterunixname 4y agoBold and presumptuous title like we're a hivemind. There are plenty of homeless people in America who are merely poor and nothing else: no drugs, not drunks, not criminally-antisocial, not crazy, and not desiring to sleep on hostile architecture bus benches. Some are too old to work and don't have a support system. There are no magic bootstraps to pull on and US social services rarely seek out to assist individuals.