5 ms·
Relevant opinion by jwz [1] ... Google's statement is obvious bullshit, and here's why. The way you "support" pseudonyms is as follows:
by bad_user 15y ago
Relevant opinion by jwz [1] ...
Google's statement is obvious bullshit, and
here's why. The way you "support" pseudonyms is as
follows:
1. Stop deleting peoples' accounts when you suspect
that the name they are using is not their legal
name.
2. There is no step 2.
UPDATE: Also, Google hasn't "relaxed" their policy. The name(s) you choose are still passing a review process and once a name is "flagged" you'll have to provide evidence that the name(s) in question represents you and is an "established identity".
And for example, in case the name represents an online identity, you have to have a "meaningful following" -- basically, there can be only one +Madonna, except these aren't random/made-up user handles, such as on Twitter.
Also, most importantly, Google+ still bans anonymity.
UPDATE 2: I was partly mistaken in my conclusions. See comments by @ElbertF below.
[1] http://www.jwz.org/blog/2011/10/eff-declares-premature-victory-in-nymwars/ http://www.jwz.org/blog/2011/10/eff-declares-premature-victo...
- rryan 15y agoCheapViagra DotCom has added you to her circles.
- nknight 15y agoSo Google suddenly can't handle some spam filtering? If I go log into my gmail account right now, am I going to find all the spam dumped in my inbox? And has the webspam team resigned en masse? Where did this sudden bout of incompetence come from, exactly?
- jrockway 15y agoPeople tend to think Google is just its frontend. They see pictures of people and some blog-like comments and say, "I could have written that over the weekend!" Then, since they don't know how to solve the spam problem, they think that Google doesn't know how to solve the spam problem either. As it turns out, Google does have some spam-fighting ideas. Some things slip through the cracks, of course, but the algorithms are always getting better.
- AndrewDucker 15y agoIf Cheap Viagra wants to follow me then that's up to them. I don't have to follow them back, after all.
- eru 15y agoIt's more about those messages being used as the spam in themselves.
- squiggly101 15y ago"CheapViagra DotCom has added you to her circles" ...if you suspect this is a spam account, click here to ban them from following you and report them to Google. Well that's how it works on Twitter anyway, and seems fairly effective.
- kevinh 15y agoA pseudonym system is ripe for abuse. I can certainly understand why Google would be adverse to implementing it. If not being able to use a pseudonym is a gamebreaker for someone, they should not be using Google+. Side note: I respect jwz, but I can't take anyone who says "Fuck those guys, seriously" seriously.
- bad_user 15y agoYeah, but this is Google. They should know better, especially considering how they are integrating Google+ in search results. Twitter does this much better. They allow people to be whatever/whomever they want. But in case YOUR identity is important to you and your following, then you can get your account verified: https://support.twitter.com/groups/31-twitter-basics/topics/111-features/articles/119135-about-verified-accounts https://support.twitter.com/groups/31-twitter-basics/topics/... Well, Twitter isn't providing this to the public anymore. Mostly because they are saying that the surest way to prove legitimacy is to link to your Twitter account from your website, or other properties. Isn't this so much better? It is better and I'll tell you why. This G+ policy won't stop bogus accounts because Google can't verify all the accounts created. But guess who'll get hurt - it won't be the spammers that sell viagra.
- kevinh 15y agoI disagree. Here's the scenario I envision with spammers on G+. Tell me if you see it differently because I could certainly be missing an angle. 1. Spammer signs up with fake name (something like John Smith) and either has no profile picture or some picture pulled off Google. 2. Spammer adds users to their circles. 3. Users see the circle request, but, since this is just some random person adding them, they don't reciprocate. In this interaction, spammers don't have an avenue of communication except via their username. If they could use a pseudonym, their username could be www.getcheapp1llz-ezi.ly, which would be as effective a way as ever to get people to go to their site. On a site like twitter, where usernames are not limited by any criteria that I'm aware of, the spammer would have the medium of username as a communication method. Now how much of this is relevant to modern times, where spammers are mainly working on SEO for spam websites? I don't know. For what it's worth, I know a few people on G+ who clearly have a pseudonym as their name and they haven't been banned yet.
- AJ007 15y agoThis policy is even worse than deleting users accounts for obvious non-real names: "we’ll be adding support for alternate names – be they nicknames, maiden names, or names in another script – alongside your common name." The whole point of a nickname/handle/etc is to disconnect it from your real identity. Google wants Google+ to be a phonebook connecting people to their semi-anonymous nicks? Google can go fuck themselves. Thankfully all of the hot girls are still using Twitter and FB; I'll stick with those and leave the geeky stuff to semi-anonymous participation on the internet's various sub-communities.
- thristian 15y agoMy biggest practical issue¹ with G+ has always been that I could never recognise any of the people in my circles because they used their real names instead of the names I knew them by. As long as I can see people's nicknames and figure out who I'm talking with, I can grudgingly put up with the rest. ¹: As opposed to philosophical issues like centralisation or privacy.
- yuhong 15y agoIdeally I'd prefer that people be authentic if possible, but I know in the real world there are various problems that makes this not always possible. I'd push for these problems to be fixed too.
- ElbertF 15y agoYonatan Zunger (who works on Google+) posted this in a comment: "Our name check is therefore looking, not for things that don’t look like “your” name, but for things which don’t look like names, period. In fact, we do not give a damn whether the name posted is “your” name or not: we will not challenge you on this basis, nor is there any mechanism for other users to cause you to be challenged for this."
- bad_user 15y agoThat's refreshing to know, however I feel that it should be clearly mentioned in their names policy. Also, I take away from this quote that an account such as Fake Steve Jobs would not be allowed, right? Daniel Lyons, the editor behind the Fake Steve identity, revealed himself after 14 months and his anonymity was pretty cool. http://www.fakesteve.net/ http://www.fakesteve.net/ https://twitter.com/#!/FSJ https://twitter.com/#!/FSJ
- ElbertF 15y agoFrom the same comment (no way to link to it directly): "The other case is people such as +trench coat, who are so well-known under this handle that it would be bizarre not to let them onto the system under this name. For this case, we allow appeals based on being well-known under the name: thus the ability to prove the 'established pseudonym.'"
- grandfathered 15y agoThis is not really sufficient. Anyone who does not have an established handle needs to spend a year or so acquiring a following under some other services in order to be good enough for Google Plus. Consider, for example, kids who want to create their first pseudonym. This kind of policy very much pushes them toward using their real names, arguably at the time in their life when it is worst to do so.
- marshray 15y agoThis is incorrect. If they find out you're a kid trying to be safe online, they'll help you out by summarily deleting your account. Problem solved!
- yuhong 15y agoNot that Google can do anything here, but personally while I am not for real name policies, I do want the problems with using real names be fixed if possible.
- prodigal_erik 15y agoI must negotiate with nosy, judgmental primates to obtain food and shelter. I'm all for fixing that, but in the meantime, I don't put anything substantive and controversial on the permanent record for my True Name.
- yuhong 15y ago>I must negotiate with nosy, judgmental primates to obtain food and shelter. Funny way to word it. Anyway, I did say I am not for real name policies.
- jrockway 15y agoMy reading of Google's new policy is that you can't be cuddlybunny1984, but you can be "Cuddly Bunny" or +cuddlybunny1984. Furthermore, if you have a government ID that says your name is cuddlybunny1984, then you can be that too. The goal, I'm assuming, is to prevent the site from looking like Xanga. (To be honest, I do find it really weird to be using my real name online. "Jonathan has shared XXX" sounds stupid to me, because nobody in real life calls me Jonathan. But that's how I write my first name. I would prefer "jrockway has shared XXX", since that is more "me" than a first name that 239483 other people have.)
- obtu 15y ago> If we challenge the name you intend to use, you will be asked to submit proof that this is an established identity with a meaningful following. You can do so by providing links to other social networking sites, news articles, or official documents in which you are referred to by this name. Note that this name and your profile must represent you, and not an avatar or other secondary online identity. Profane or offensive names are not allowed. seems to be the one concession from their policy so far (I consider linking pseudonyms to the real name a screw-you more than a concession). I'm not sure how established Cuddly Bunny would have to be, but that person would have to work at their identity on a more tolerant site for some time, at which point Google+ needs them more than they do. Hopefully these friendlier sites won't follow Google and Facebook's lead.
- jrockway 15y agoHopefully these friendlier sites won't follow Google and Facebook's lead. This is weird, isn't it. It makes me wonder what problem Google and Facebook are trying to solve with "social networking". They're basically sites that you go to because you're you, rather than other sites on the Internet that you go to because the content interests you. The rest of the Internet doesn't care what your name is. If you abuse your posting privileges (or whatever), you just get banned, end of story.