3 ms·
> I've also started therapy 2 months ago, but it's going slow and it hasn't been very useful yet. My #1 piece of advice is, find a new therapist. Therapy isn'
by crazygringo 4y ago
> I've also started therapy 2 months ago, but it's going slow and it hasn't been very useful yet.
My #1 piece of advice is, find a new therapist.
Therapy isn't one size fits all. You need to not only find the right type of "modality" for you (e.g. CBT and IFS* are worlds apart, generally you want somebody "integrative/eclectic" who will combine the right modalities for you), but you also simply need to find somebody to click with. It really does depend on trust and chemistry to a shockingly large degree.
I know multiple people who did years of therapy that was next to useless, then found a new therapist that just 2-4 sessions made a huge difference.
It's entirely normal and expected to "shop around" with therapists. Try an initial 1-2 sessions with 3-4 different therapists, and be upfront with them about what you're doing as well. They won't take it personally -- they're therapists -- and they're even more aware than you that therapeutic outcomes are super dependent on just finding the right personal match.
When you find the right therapist who is really in tune with you, you can go from having a "breakthrough" every couple of years, to every couple of sessions. It's crazy how different the outcomes can be, and how few people are even aware that the outcomes can be so different.
(Note that this is less applicable to CBT which is very recipe-oriented, paint-by-numbers, surface-level treatment. CBT can be great as a short-term fix for distorted thinking patterns, but it's not designed to address anything deeper, so a good match with a therapist matters less.)
* CBT = cognitive behavioral therapy, IFS = internal family systems
- sdoering 4y agoThis advice is golden. Please OP, listen. I can only second this. There is so much truth in it, that even the German medical insurance system understood this and made it so that the first five sessions with a therapist are only for getting the feel of each other. Only after that you settle for the therapist or for "real" therapy (paid by the insurance). The first sessions are also paid, but you can switch until you find the right fit (if one can find an appointment in Germany, but that is another story). So please, OP, look for someone more fitting.
- verteu 4y ago+1, I've been to 5 or 6 therapists and 80% of the progress came from the first or second session. The remaining sessions were almost always repetitive and useless to me.
- ncr100 4y agoI think this advice is too-disruptive for this person: It's too quick to just throw away another relationship. The poster talks about being Distant from Friends, and recently Separated. Also they talk about growing up in a Toxic Family - another "bell ring" for the "feeling unsupported" song. Advising them to swap out a ANOTHER emotionally supportive person in their life, their therapist, is going to cause them further abandonment - it's going to cause them to suffer. So, come at that specific advice from a different direction. Advise them instead to open up to the therapist more. The problem doesn't yet seem to be an incompetent therapist. It's more that their relationship is still shallow.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mettamage 4y agoDamn! Favoriting this comment, thanks for the lesson. Might become handy later in life :)
- viburnum 4y agoThis is good advice. Many therapists are one-trick ponies. For example, talking about trauma for three years won’t help you if your real problem is undiagnosed ADHD. Some challenges require ongoing help from a therapist (borderline personality etc) but otherwise if you’re not seeing rapid improvement they’re not helping, and might be making things worse.
- TrevorFSmith 4y agoI second this advice. If you don't feel like a therapist is almost immediately helping you identify, process, and communicate your emotions and history then it's not a good match. I know first-hand that it's a PITA to switch to a new therapist but the return on effort can be massive.
- Schroedingers2c 4y agoI have been with her now 4x. I have talked about my upbringing and that that is the motivation why I came to see her. Then the breakup happened, so the last two times we talked about that. Apparently she is specialised for adult children of complicated parents. And apparently next time we will do some questionnaire or something. So far we have only talked and she suggested one book ("iRest - Healing PTSD") which I started reading. She is supportive, but so far she mostly said I should find things I like doing, join sports clubs, try mindfulness and basic stuff like that. I know that my issues run deeper.
- dimal 4y agoIf you do have PTSD, I’ve found that somatic experiencing therapy has been amazingly effective for me. Talking about trauma only gets you so far. It sounds crazy and very “woo”, but I’ve found that trauma really is stored in the body in the form of held muscle tension. I found that I was literally physically bracing myself against the things I feared, 24 hours a day, every day. The constant physical tension was telling my brain “something is wrong” and no amount of talking about it would help dispel that feeling. Learning to identify where this is happening and how to release it has been invaluable for me. I second the previous commenter’s opinion. Therapists all have their individual ways of seeing and working. What works wonders for one person will be a waste of time for another. If you’re not getting much out of it, keep looking for someone that can help YOU.
- ThinkBeat 4y agoThis can also be a pattern of avoidance. If you are challenged and you dont want to face the hard issues you quit and find another one.
- crazygringo 4y agoI'm talking about finding your first long-term therapist, to try out several. Not about jumping therapists every three or six months. Also, people who can't face the hard issues generally just quit therapy altogether. They don't usually jump therapists. Switching therapists really is usually because it's not working, and more of the same therapist isn't going to help.