3 ms·
"I am not aware of any works of fiction in which terrorists attack the Statue of Liberty" followed by "I know about Deus Ex" sounds like a contradiction to me (
by arp242 4y ago
"I am not aware of any works of fiction in which terrorists attack the Statue of Liberty" followed by "I know about Deus Ex" sounds like a contradiction to me (even though the summary is wrong). Had it instead said "I've heard of it, but don't really know the details" or something to that effect instead of an authoritative statement would be different.
But it doesn't really matter; it's inconsistent and unreliable. Whether you could classify this or that as a "contradiction" isn't important and mostly just pedantic argueing.
- Dylan16807 4y agoIt's not a contradiction because it doesn't know about the successful attack in the Deus Ex backstory. At least, that's the claim in the conversation you quoted. Wrong but not self-contradictory. > But it doesn't really matter; it's inconsistent and unreliable. Whether you could classify this or that as a "contradiction" isn't important and mostly just pedantic argueing. But it wasn't inconsistent in your conversation. That's my point. It was wrong in a self-consistent way.
- arp242 4y ago> it doesn't know about the successful attack in the Deus Ex backstory There ya go: What's the backstory of the statue of liberty in Deus Ex? In the game Deus Ex, the Statue of Liberty serves as a central location and plot point. The statue has been converted into a highly secured base for the United Nations Anti-Terrorist Coalition (UNATCO), which is the organization that the player character, JC Denton, works for. The backstory of the statue in the game is that it was damaged by terrorists in an attack prior to the events of the game. The terrorist group responsible for the attack is a shadowy organization known as "Majestic 12," which serves as the game's primary antagonist. In response to the attack, the statue was converted into a heavily fortified UNATCO headquarters, which serves as the player's base of operations for much of the game. The statue is also home to various high-tech facilities and laboratories, where UNATCO develops advanced weaponry and nanotechnology. Throughout the game, the player learns more about the backstory of the statue and the role it plays in the game's overarching conspiracy plot.
- Dylan16807 4y agoWas I not clear enough that I was talking about the single transcript? I really don't know how to be clearer. You're now demonstrating inconsistency between conversations. Great. But your earlier claim was that it directly contradicted itself inside that specific conversation. I don't think it did. (And no, a new conversation where it directly contradicts itself inside the same conversation won't change my mind, because I already know it can do that. I was just saying it didn't in your original example.)
- arp242 4y agoI continued the previous conversation, but okay. You're being exceedingly "but akshually" pedantic about the entire thing. This entire conversation has zero value and nothing of any significant meaning was discussed at all. Congratulations; I hope you feel very smart about yourself. I was a fool to even reply to your initial comment to start with.
- Dylan16807 4y agoWhen I repeatedly explain "No, that's not what I said, not even close.", that is not being pedantic. My original post was less than 20 words with no intent to add any more.