4 ms·
It's not entirely distinct. One could just as well describe the "spirit in the turnip" as the sum of the potential forces it can exert on the world, the effect
by krapp 4y ago
It's not entirely distinct. One could just as well describe the "spirit in the turnip" as the sum of the potential forces it can exert on the world, the effect of the cultural image of turnips, even its "essential turnipness" in a Platonic sense. We have no problem referring to the "personality" of an old house, the "menace" of a gun or gendering cars and ships as female because they "embody" certain gender archetypes. The philosophy and metaphysics are both approaching the same essential concept from different directions, with different assumptions.
- beepbooptheory 4y agoPerhaps, but that feels like a distinct claim, rather than a reason to just lump these things together, or a reason to assert one is the rehash of another. And either way, the philosophy in question here is not about embodiment of platonic forms, but rather simply the agency/character of plain objects on their own terms. If you are interested at all, the book they reference is quite good, and almost certainly not what you'd expect. Ill just say it's more Deleuze than Plato :)