7 ms·
Emacs is software from the 80s that failed to adapt to the current times. It failed to innovate and address UX issues so its market share devoured.
by charcircuit 4y ago
Emacs is software from the 80s that failed to adapt to the current times.
It failed to innovate and address UX issues so its market share devoured.
- mlatu 4y agoit still has its place and it is the best customizable software tool i have encountered so far
- medo-bear 4y agomarket share seems like a wrong term for a product that doesnt seem to give an f about it. nor does it seem to care about some mean reversing ui. what it does seem to care about is the users that keep using and loving it ;)
- charcircuit 4y ago>product that doesnt seem to give an f about it. They should care about it. Losing market share means people are finding more value in other editors. Do the developers not want Emacs to give the most value as possible to users?
- medo-bear 4y ago> Losing market share means people are finding more value in other editors. some people just dont get it. emacs is not an editor :)
- bigbillheck 4y ago> Do the developers not want Emacs to give the most value as possible to users? They clearly do not.
- tmtvl 4y agoI disagree that Emacs losing market share necessarily means that people find more value in various editors. While that could be the cause, there are various other possibilities: more people are being mandated the use of various of those editors, those editors may have better marketing, the systems people are using may come standard with editors that are "good enough",...
- asoneth 4y agoI agree that Emacs commits a number of unforced errors with regard to its user experience, especially for novice users. My guess is that with some usability studies they could flatten the learning curve substantially and significantly increase their market share with only minimal burden on existing users. Having said that, "market share" doesn't seem like a relevant metric since the community seems perfectly content being niche.
- charcircuit 4y ago>since the community seems perfectly content being niche. This is just admitting defeat. There is no reason Emacs couldn't be the number one editor right now. GNU projects in general all tend to fail to innovate and seem to ignore the last couple of decades of learnings.
- medo-bear 4y agoseems like you have a bit of an agenda. are you sour about something ? for me emacs is probably the best piece of software i ever used and i use my hardware for everything :|
- charcircuit 4y agoI'm sour that emacs sucks. I would like to be able to use it for everything, but if I'm being honest with myself other editors simply work better for me.
- BeetleB 4y ago> There is no reason Emacs couldn't be the number one editor right now. There is a simple reason for it not to be number one: The developers and users do not care for it to be. I certainly don't. As long as Emacs has hit critical mass (which it trivially has), it is good enough for me. The number one selling car is Toyota. You wouldn't go and say Porsche is an inferior product because they are not the number one selling car.
- asoneth 4y ago
- gpderetta 4y agoMarket share is not a feature that helps me. A thriving ecosystem and active development is. Emacs doesn't lack either. Failing to implement UX fad of the moment means that you can rely on the GUI being consistent across years instead of having to relearn it every few months.
- charcircuit 4y ago>Market share is not a feature that helps me. But it does show what software is generally better. >A thriving ecosystem and active development is. Despite being thriving it still is very lacking in code navigation abilities and has poor performance in general. Not to mention the editor grinds to a halt when working on big files due to extensions being poorly optimized. >Failing to implement UX fad of the moment means that you can rely on the GUI being consistent across years instead of having to relearn it every few months. The user experience of a product is much more than just the user interface. Emacs requires you to learn elisp and write a whole configuration file by hand or use really clunky menus.
- medo-bear 4y ago> But it does show what software is generally better. Have you not been giving the pep talk, "if everyone jumped off a building...", as kid ?
- marcosdumay 4y agoWhat is most annoying in development is how often people just decide to all jump off a building for no good reason. Usually that talk is nonsense, but not here.