5 ms·
> It directly contradicts itself here. The summary for Dues Ex is also wrong (terrorists attacked the statue of liberty before the game, and only the very first
by Dylan16807 4y ago
> It directly contradicts itself here. The summary for Dues Ex is also wrong (terrorists attacked the statue of liberty before the game, and only the very first part of the game features the statue and it's not to "thwart a terrorist attack on the Statue of Liberty").
I wouldn't call that a contradiction. I think it's fair to only count attacks that go through.
- arp242 4y agoNo, you misunderstand; it was attacked in the setting of the game, several years prior to when it takes place. https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/deusex/images/d/dd/Statue_of_Liberty1.png/revision/latest?cb=20150115012026&path-prefix=en https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/deusex/images/d/dd/Statu...
- Dylan16807 4y agoThat's it being wrong. You said it contradicts itself and is wrong. How does it contradict itself?
- arp242 4y agoIt says it doesn't know about fictional terror attacks on the statue of liberty, and then it does point out one. Also, turns out "The Statue of Liberty has not been attacked by terrorists" isn't even correct either: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Tom_explosion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Tom_explosion – you could argue a bit about the semantics of "terror attack" and whether it was the statue of liberty that was attacked, but it turns up on all the search results (I actually wanted to find other fictional accounts).
- Dylan16807 4y ago> It says it doesn't know about fictional terror attacks on the statue of liberty, and then it does point out one. "I wouldn't call that a contradiction. I think it's fair to only count attacks that go through. " It "knows" about a thwarted plan for an attack. I don't think it's a "direct contradiction" to "know" about that but still say "I am not aware of any works of fiction in which terrorists attack the Statue of Liberty."
- arp242 4y ago> It "knows" about a thwarted plan for an attack. It's not thwarted. Look at the picture from the previous comment. Does that look "thwarted" to you? ChatGPT confuses a lot of things here, and now you're confused because ChatGPT is confused. There is a terror attack, but it's NOT the case that "the player must thwart a terrorist attack on the Statue of Liberty". It's merely something that happened in the fictional setting, before the story even takes place. In many ways this thread demonstrates my point quite well: it's kind-of roughly correct, but mixes up some crucial things which does make a meaningful different, and now someone unfamiliar with the subject matter is confused as well. In this case, it's just a game and of no real importance, but it goes to show ChatGPT should now be used for anything of any importance in its current state.
- Dylan16807 4y agoI put the word "knows" in quotes for a reason. You're the one getting confused here; you don't understand what I'm saying. The bot is wrong. I know it's wrong. I keep saying it's wrong. You keep giving evidence for why it's wrong. That's not the issue here. If we play along in the hypothetical where the bot isn't wrong, there is no contradiction. It is telling a coherent story.
- arp242 4y ago"I am not aware of any works of fiction in which terrorists attack the Statue of Liberty" followed by "I know about Deus Ex" sounds like a contradiction to me (even though the summary is wrong). Had it instead said "I've heard of it, but don't really know the details" or something to that effect instead of an authoritative statement would be different. But it doesn't really matter; it's inconsistent and unreliable. Whether you could classify this or that as a "contradiction" isn't important and mostly just pedantic argueing.
- Dylan16807 4y agoIt's not a contradiction because it doesn't know about the successful attack in the Deus Ex backstory. At least, that's the claim in the conversation you quoted. Wrong but not self-contradictory. > But it doesn't really matter; it's inconsistent and unreliable. Whether you could classify this or that as a "contradiction" isn't important and mostly just pedantic argueing. But it wasn't inconsistent in your conversation. That's my point. It was wrong in a self-consistent way.