7 ms·
Identifying as an Artist
- eyelidlessness 4y agoI felt it more a transgression to tell people I was a programmer (and I still feel uncomfortable with the label “engineer” despite having the title long enough to be uncomfortable saying how long). Then again art is what led me to code, I learned how to program first and foremost because the “telling people” was either too limited (no established platforms to publish music) or too tedious (tons of redundant work adding metadata to self hosted published material, then adding it to HTML as well, then updating everything to reflect any new navigation). More than all of that though, I’ve long felt that programming computers is art. You don’t have to identify with that, but it’s a fundamentally creative pursuit. It’s full of choices and expression and compromise and imperfection. At least from my perspective, anyone who has made something that makes machines do things is qualified to claim the title “artist” if they would like to.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoI have avoided saying I am a Software Engineer (except on government forms). Computer Scientist is an outright lie (no degree in CS). Maybe my working class upbringing? I generally tell people I am just a programmer. I think it sounds kind of like plumber which I like.
- eyelidlessness 4y agoYeah I definitely come at this from a working class background. And I don’t even have any pretense of CS, I learned every bit of programming I know from either personal interest or some combination of that and inspiration/pressure among peers.
- Gigachad 4y agoThis is just you. Just about every web shitter calls themselves a senior software engineer.
- eyelidlessness 4y agoThis seems needlessly meanspirited.
- sublinear 4y agoI've met plenty of "webshits" that have a degree in computer science and have been working in it for over a decade along with almost all other layers of software dev short of, say, the linux kernel. At what point are programmers allowed to just be programmers regardless of specialization, lack of it, or education?
- ggm 4y agoIf it's any consolation I am and describe myself as a computer scientist because it's what my 1982 degree was in but I am a notoriously bad programmer and for historical reasons of timing (the year after I graduated my degree qualified for B.Eng status) I am not and cannot call myself an engineer software or otherwise.
- guntherhermann 4y agoSame, from a working class background, can't really call myself "working class" anymore, but the upbringing remains. I refer to myself as a "programmer", and when speaking to people who revere what we do I explain that the majority of programmers are effectively "digital plumbers". I have a CS degree (first class, from a very respected uni) and still wouldn't class myself as a "computer scientist", I reserve that term for those who are doing research in the field
- eternalban 4y ago> the majority of programmers are effectively "digital plumbers". I don't think this is entirely true or accurate. Unless plumbing profession also has the phenomena of plumbers removing hair balls, and other junk, from pipes put in there by other plumbers .. that said, in Brazil, we did get a glimpse of working on a typical large codebase.
- Pentamerous 4y agoI like to say I'm a "Developer", or "Software Developer", and then I can describe further what I do as "creating things" for people to use. I agree 100% with you that programming is art and a vehicle for so much creativity and liberty (think net.art, code poetry, the hundred different ways to make the same function), but even then I feel that programming is just a part of the creation process. So I tend to prefer Developer
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- JKCalhoun 4y agoStumbled on the documentary "David Lynch: The Art Life" before YouTube took it down. That and "Crumb" are a couple of films that convinced me that some people just are artists. It's not ego, or some desire to be eccentric ... they can't help it. They live "the art life", damn the consequences. You could handily list any number of other people (John Waters just came to mind). Similar to the author of the blog post, I have sort of demurred when asked if I was an artist. Partly it sounds arrogant to say, "Why, yes I am." Partly it seemed to be a thing in the eye of the beholder. "I don't know, do you think I am an artist?" Plenty of people don't think Andy Warhol was an artist, Jackson Pollock.... Sometimes I have treated "artist" as a profession. Do I get paid for my art? Why no, I do not. I get paid for programming. Although when I write a game I am both programmer and "game artist". (Or is perhaps designing an elegant API for a framework a kind of art form? Okay, maybe not.) If an artist can be a hobbyist the way many of us are amateur musicians, woodworkers, cooks, mechanics, (construction contractors), in our spare time then, yes, many of us are artists. I think the older I get though (and maybe the more films I see about artists) I am slowly coming to accept that, sure, I'm an artist too. Just maybe not a very good one.
- pasquinelli 4y agothat's a shame "the art life" was taken down, it was a really interesting film.
- jolmg 4y agoWhen I searched for it just now, it appeared on Amazon Prime Video.
- bookofjoe 4y agohttps://www.amazon.com/David-Lynch-Art-Life/dp/B071P6ZYVB/ref=sr_1_1?crid=2RRXVE31ZFJ4D&keywords=The+Art+Life&qid=1677935453&s=instant-video&sprefix=the+art+life%2Cinstant-video%2C79&sr=1-1 https://www.amazon.com/David-Lynch-Art-Life/dp/B071P6ZYVB/re...
- colinflane 4y ago
- mock-possum 4y ago> Because people don’t get to do that; to be artists. It’s a thing for children, or the pathologically detached and eccentric. Regular people, by definition, aren’t artists — or so we tell ourselves Rather, I think, most adults don't get to be successful artists - and in turn, most artists don't do it seeking success, they do it because it feels good to create. Creating art for its own sake, or for your own sake, is notoriously difficult to monetize though - creating art for an audience requires that you consider the desires of your patron(s), and that's a different skill than pure creative expression.
- slmjkdbtl 4y agoPractically, the word "art" tend to create misunderstanding because literally everyone have a different idea of what the word represents. If someone tells me they're an artist that means absolutely nothing to me. "writer" is much better in terms of communication because it tells me what you actually do. I stopped using the word years ago and it only brought me happiness in life, saved me from a lot of unproductive language games of matching one label to another.
- antegamisou 4y ago> "writer" is much better in terms of communication because it tells me what you actually do. Could also range from novelist to Substacker...
- slmjkdbtl 4y agoTrue but at least "writer" is easier to further conversation. This is a real conversation I once had: "What do you do?" "I'm an artist" "So what do you do?" "..I do art"
- krisoft 4y agoThat person didn’t want to indulge you in trying to simplify them and put them in a box they don’t agree with. There is nothing wrong with that. If they wanted to “further the conversation” they could have shown you examples of what they do, or told about their art more. If they choose not to that is on them. Perhaps they were tired, perhaps they found your question boring, perhaps they had some insecurities around their art or you, perhaps you rubbed them the wrong way.
- onos 4y agoInterestingly, Neil Stephenson’s — in the top comment on thread that was also on the front page earlier - gave this advice for improving ones writing: “Stop thinking of it as art, or as something you're born with, and start thinking of it as an acquired skill like cabinet making”
- stemlord 4y ago>Because people don’t get to do that; to be artists. It’s a thing for children, or the pathologically detached and eccentric. Yikes. Tell us how you really feel
- blueflow 4y agoWhy not say "I write essays in my free time"? It accurately describes what the author is doing without making a commitment.
- graderjs 4y agoThat's me. I identify as someone with an artist personality who works in software (right now). Just my mind is wired differently to all those engineers. Always has been. I'm like: more intuitive, more feeling, more flexible...less in need of concrete distinctions, less prone to be literal, less inclined to believe that I have all the answers and believe anything beyond what I know cannot exist. And many more...it's tough hanging out with all you engineers sometimes. I don't like stereotypes, but this one I have of the typical eng is born of much experience. I don't want it to be this way! Maybe it's not as tough for me as it is for you to hang out with artist types like me...
- boffinism 4y agoBeing blunt, it sounds to me like you're using wildly inaccurate personality stereotypes to generalise horribly about both software engineers and artists. A software dev who is inclined to believe they have all the answers is a bad software dev. And the idea that artists all need to be intuitive, and flexible is, based on my experience of many artists, laughable. Try finding a broader range of developers and artists to spend time around. Your world view may expand.
- graderjs 4y agoWhy be mean for? I open myself up and share something vulnerably here, and how do you respond? You try to invalidate it. That's not very nice. I have my experience of it. That yours differs, why do you need to invalidate mine? Why can't we both exist? No I think it is maybe your world view that needs to expand, son, and by not being inclusive of mine, but instead trying to shoot it down you are displaying the very same inflexibility that I identified which you simultaneously pretend does not exist! Ha!! :) ;p xx ;p Think about that next time before you're "blunt". A blunt instrument has limited use....even for artists! ;p :)
- eropple 4y agoYour attempt to dichotomize the world is insulting to people who have been, and are, both--sometimes at the same time. That's why you got the reaction you did, and your doubling down is, to someone on the receiving end, no less unkind than the post you characterize as "mean".
- nbzso 4y agoIn the early 2000s, I chose to leave behind my successful career as an artist and transitioned into the field of graphic design. Eventually, I ventured into UX design and founded my own company that specializes in software development and design. Initially, my success as an artist had made it easier for people to accept me into the community. However, when I decided to stop commercially painting, people labeled me as a crazy man who had no sense of direction. Only when money returned to my pocket did they embrace me once again as a success. If your concern as an artist is solely based on gaining people's approval, then you are approaching it wrong. Creativity is an inherent quality that yearns to be liberated from within every individual. Society needs the unconventional and daring ideas of artists, which they are not capable of producing due to the perceived risk involved in this lifestyle. As an artist, your guiding principle should be a self-honesty that is driven by a clear egoistic purpose (in a good way). The most crucial aspect of being an artist is the production of artwork. If you let your art speak to the world, then the rest is merely a matter of marketing.
- noduerme 4y agoI relate to this. I still tell people I'm an artist, at first brush - as opposed to a UI designer or a coder. And it's okay, and true, because I still paint all night sometimes, still write music and record, even if it isn't for work. I don't think you have to identify yourself as your job...
- nbzso 4y agoI halted my artistic career due to the concept of identity. It dawned on me that I was tailoring my artwork to suit the preferences and expectations of others, which led to a profound realization. I made a conscious decision to disentangle my creative output from commercial validation and societal pressures.
- noduerme 4y agoI think one way or the other, avoiding narcissism is the ideal thing. I do commercial art a lot. I take pride in my work. I don't consider it "art", just creative communication. And at the same time I'm not sure I consider my fine art to be anything other than creative dreaming / practice. Contrary to what you're saying, I actually think it's good to take pride and get a little emotional lift in both cases when people praise your work... but I think a sense of self is knowing not to define your own worth by what other people think of your output, and by the same token if you do define your worth that way, it makes it impossible to be humble about your own shortcomings. But it's okay to write or paint for an audience. Making art in a void is a lonely place to be.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- petesergeant 4y agoDo any artists who do it as a paid profession struggle with this? The ones I know are pretty straight forward about it. The writers and photographers and actors I know who identify as such are either doing it as their profession, or attempting to do so, for money. I would have thought you only really get into trouble here when you’re using it to try and describe a facet of your identity, and people assume you’re describing your work.
- ZoomZoomZoom 4y agoIt's hard. Doubly so if you really tick some of the boxes of people's preconceptions, like not being able to sustain yourself doing the thing you identify yourself with. In my case, I'm a musician, but I have a day job plus I do sound engineering which in terms of the income is in between. What do you tell other people in this situation? It depends on the person, but telling others you're a musician either means you trust them enough not to roll their eyes (lots of people don't, merely being polite), or you just don't care, in which case it can be a kind of a challenge (k, let's see how you react). Also, personally I suspect this can be a huge barrier to ever getting a job in tech.
- lowdownbutter 4y agoI think Larry David on Kevin Pollack's Chat Show mentions something along these lines about telling his friends/parents he's becoming a comedian.
- Cypher 4y agoTry telling people you're gay, that's 100 times harder.
- forgotmypw17 4y agoI once met someone who self-identified as an artist. I asked them, what is your medium? And they replied: LIFE.
- appstorelottery 4y agoInteresting to hear other peoples opinions... I actually find it easier to say I'm working on an "art-project" these days with zero shame. One of the advantages for me: most people assume that "art projects" generally don't start with the expectation that one is going to profit insanely (contrasted with the perception when one says "I'm doing a startup"). The measure of success is simply getting the work out there into the public, that is all an artist can do. The rest is up to the consumer. This is the perspective that works for me and keeps me happy and humble. For me, when I gave up trying to control other peoples perceptions of myself, my life became much easier. (edit: I'm doing something in the NFT space, so it's also technically true as well as metaphorically) YMMV.