14 ms·
Germany opposes EU plans for client-side scanning
- MajesticSwirl 4y ago[dead]
- mschuster91 4y agoFor once, we're blocking the right thing. Good that the CDU/CSU is no longer in charge of the Interior Ministry, but still Nancy Faeser (SPD) is barely better than the Conservatives.
- trizuz 4y ago[dead]
- _23sd 4y agoI’m a bit confused, is the German government formally opposing client-side scanning requirements or not? The article is about civil society groups voicing their concerns at a parliamentary hearing and notes that the parliament doesn’t have a say in EU legislation. But it specifically says the government wants client-side scanning removed without any specifics on that part.
- luckylion 4y agoYeah, reads like clickbait that is intentionally confusing "Germany, the country" with "Germany, as represented by these six people who were heard by a parliamentary committee yesterday".
- rat9988 4y agoThat's the same no? They are their representatives. They act with the german power. It's like saying this is trump and not usa, while his ratification is equal to the us power. It doesn't matter for the other side. (I took trump as an example as I often see him used as an example in such cases)
- slackdog 4y agoThey're not the same. There is a big difference between heads of state and and elected representatives, and an even bigger difference between heads of state and the rando activists/etc that elected representatives might invite to share their point of view. Heads of state, like the POTUS, are meant to officially embody the state itself. So if Trump while President says a thing, it is reasonably conventional to describe that as "America said..." But that isn't what happened here. In this case you don't have a head of state saying anything about the subject. The article is about various people (including "IT experts, civil libertarians, law enforcement officials and even child protectors" who aren't even elected representatives at all) giving their opinions to German Parliament. This is not a "Germany says.." situation.
- shjake 4y agoThe government of Germany does officially support it. So I guess if they are serious about it we’re sort of safe for the next few years.
- luckylion 4y agoNo, these are just experts explaining their opinions to a small group of MPs, but they're (a small) part of the legislative, not the executive (which does the negotiations on the EU level), and parliament usually votes along the government. So whatever 10/736 members think isn't "what Germany will do". It might be, but it probably won't.
- timgo 4y agoYes, the German government is strictly against chat client side scanning. This is part of the coalition agreement. https://www.tagesschau.de/inland/innenpolitik/chatkontrolle-innenministerium-101.html https://www.tagesschau.de/inland/innenpolitik/chatkontrolle-...
- EntrePrescott 4y agoThough it's not the whole government who's against but really the two smaller parties in the coalition: the FDP (liberal party, 11.5%) foremost, and to some extent currently also the green party (14.8%)… … whereas the largest party in the government coalition, the SPD (25.7%) of chancelor Scholz is not only largely in favor of such client-side scanning (of course there are also exceptions within the party), but also the party that holds the relevant ministry (interior) and thus the participation in the EU-side negociations. The current coalition contract kinda forces the SPD to oppose such client side scanning at the EU level - and we'll see to what extent they keep their word or try to play foul against the contract, but there is no doubt imho that if the next government was again a "grand coalition" of SPD and CDU without the liberals to block such stuff, then such client side scanning would be waved through by the same SPD that currently is contractually bound to oppose it. The danger of such attacks against our liberties is still very much there, and it takes a constant watchful fight for our liberties to prevent the authoriarian statists from getting through with such stuff. They never stop trying to push through ever more of their liberticide ideas.
- unity1001 4y ago> The current coalition contract kinda forces the SPD to oppose such client side scanning at the EU level - and we'll see to what extent they keep their word or try to play foul against the contract You cant 'play foul' against coalition protocols. The moment you do, the government falls.
- EntrePrescott 4y agoYou can (if you're the bigger coalition partner with a big power imbalance), and in fact it's not that rare at all and it's exactly what the CDU did quite blatantly last time they were in coalition with the FDP at the federal level under Merkel. Of course, the smaller coalition party could theoretically react to such an infringement against the coalition contract by ending the coalition… … but that would usually hurt them enormously more than their infringing bigger coalition partner, especially if the infringement of their partner against the coalition contract is about something that the majority of voters doesn't care enough about, if it's something that the bigger coalition partner can publicly spin as TINA(*)-necessary due to changed conditions or anything they can sell as a "crisis" or if the polls are currently less favorable for the smaller party than at the last elections. Ending a coalition is something that would typically come at an extremely high price for the smaller party who'd do it. Which is why it happens much more rarely than unilateral infringements against coalition contracts by the bigger coalition partner. (*): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/There_is_no_alternative https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/There_is_no_alternative
- auggierose 4y agoI am wondering, who in the EU commission is exactly pushing for this, and why?
- belter 4y agoAshton Kutcher, Demi Moore... "European Security Officials Double Down on Automated Moderation and Client-Side Scanning" - https://www.lawfareblog.com/european-security-officials-double-down-automated-moderation-and-client-side-scanning https://www.lawfareblog.com/european-security-officials-doub...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dvngnt_ 4y agofollow the money
- Kognito 4y agoWasn’t sure if you were being serious but sure enough: “Thorn, a U.S. 501(c) (3) organization founded by Hollywood star-turned venture capitalist Ashton Kutcher and his former partner Demi Moore, has been a central force lobbying for the legislation.”
- ClumsyPilot 4y agowhat the fuck? are they front men? For whom?
- jai_ 4y agoAshton Kutcher and Demi Moore have been campaigning to address child sexual exploitation for a while. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thorn_(organization) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thorn_(organization) I would guess they are simplying sponsoring this legislation sincerly without understanding the privacy ramifications if it passed.
- blue039 4y agoYou might be able to handwave some things in politics. They're either too old, too lazy, etc. They're just politicians trying to find a nice box to put everything into because otherwise you can't make laws. It's the fundamental problem with legislators that take a salary and are not volunteers for a short period. When you need people to justify their pay they start finding heuristics, no matter how awful, to create more laws. The problem is the precedent, globally, of killing encryption is well documented. There is no good solution that doesn't harm everyone. Here in the states, the Clipper Chip [0] was the textbook example of politicians trying to legislate mathematics. You wouldn't even be able to do something like "give us a copy of your private keys" because then you'd go down the path of playing wackamole with every distribution, every slightly recompiled GnuPG, etc. It's an intractable problem. We, in the US, would've gone a long way by stripping Dorothy Denning's CS PhD from her [1] after her outspoken support of such measures. Instead she has received many awards for her "work" in the field of rights erosion. The US seems to have settled on making attempts at Clipper 2.0 every decade or so. In the meantime encryption is considered a weapon legally which is how the DAs get their fill. Germany appears to have flat out opposed it...but it's only a matter of time. The EU will force them to bend the knee because historically they always have. It's a fantastic effort. Unfortunately, done by one of the biggest pushovers in Europe. There's no hope for the technical among us. The people with power who do understand, the technocrats, are behind these efforts. The people that don't understand are behind these efforts. It's only the intractability of the problem that makes legislating it dangerous. Once someone clever enough makes it tractable there won't be encryption anymore. Pre-crime is the way the world has worked since 9/11 and encryption is #0 on the list of things to legislate to death. In the US, there are likely hundreds of billions of taxpayer dollars being spent to store every last bit of communication in Utah for this eventuality.The EU has a similar program. Those tax dollars have to be justified somehow. So when you ask "who would support this"... just follow the money. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clipper_chip https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clipper_chip [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dorothy_E._Denning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dorothy_E._Denning
- chihuahua 4y agoI find it unlikely that taking away someone's Ph.D. would accomplish anything positive. How do you envision this would work in general - an angry Twitter mob demands that academic degrees are revoked, and when the mob gets sufficiently large and angry, the university who awarded the degree buckles under the pressure? If not a Twitter mob, then who makes these decisions? The Central Committee of the Party? The Committee for the Promotion of Virtue and the Prevention of Vice?
- Jyaif 4y ago[flagged]
- gchq-7703 4y agoFalse positives / false negatives are important to note. It is likely that they're saying that out of 100,000 scanned files, 10,000 to 20,000 will not include child sexual abuse.
- devmor 4y agoIf every agency and government with access to this technology could be trusted to only use it for CSAM it would be the easiest no-brainer to approve and turn on immediately. But they can't. It can easily be used to target people for political and social reasons just as easily, and once that Pandora's Box is opened it can never be closed. For the most topical example, imagine it being used in a conservative US State to target images of people not conforming to the gender they are expected to.
- slackdog 4y agoEven if the government exercised restraint and only used this technology in the manner they presently advocate for, a 10% false positive rate, presumably each resulting in an invasive investigation, is way too high.
- hexo 4y agoid say 10-20% of all content is expected to be misclassified
- hnhg 4y agoYou would have to look at it from the perspective of the base rate (for low incidence) to properly understand what that means for the wider population: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Base_rate_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Base_rate_fallacy
- wkat4242 4y agoThe problem is that for it to actually work you will need to take control away from the users over all their computing devices. Otherwise they can simply circumvent it. It would mean a model as closed as iOS, but for all mobiles and desktop platforms. I will personally never let that happen. This is way too draconian a measure to solve a problem that will not go away anyway. The predators will just go offline again or find workarounds, while it will be severely restricting all citizens in their computing freedom.
- say_it_as_it_is 4y agoWe simply can't have encryption in a world of online child predators. Think of the children.
- themitigating 4y agoI can't tell if you are being sarcastic because there is currently a massive paranoia over child predators.
- msm_ 4y agoSince they wrote literally "think of the children" I think it's pretty safe to assume they're sarcastic.
- moremetadata 4y agoWhat online child predators? I was a child before the internet and was used for pedo hunts before the internet, usually having to try on underwear in the UK store Littlewoods, the number of adults that attracted, who struck up conversations with my state employed masonic parents was quite astounding! Ergo, I think parents should be put under the spotlight!
- snapcaster 4y agoWhat? I'm having trouble what you're saying but sounds pretty disturbing
- moremetadata 4y agoWhen you consider innuendo and not just the initial message, you'll find a lot of communication takes place this way, but innuendo isn't taught to most people so they are oblivious to what's really going on around them and its really quite disturbing. Throw in a variety of drugs which can make people forget stuff or put them into a chemical trance if its not hypnosis, and people of all ages can be manipulated into actions they wouldn't have otherwise. What age can you start hypnotising kids? Some of these drugs are found in pharmacy and supermarket shelves with no checks if paying cash. This is why I say people need to have 24/7 unhackable surveillance on them at all times, in order to prove whats been done, as victims, especially those drugged wont know or realise whats been done to them, sometimes for decades if at all. Drugs/chemicals have been used to hack people for Millenia. And some parents just see their kids as cash cows, after all the mindset used to be to have a big family so they could look after you when you got too old, and this was before the socialist elements of the state in todays sense introduced things like state pensions and benefits payments. Thats why I say the state is virtue signalling when they claim to be protecting kids, but dont teach kids how to protect themselves or teach them the law to know what activity's are criminal. This isnt anything new either, its been going on for thousands of years, but history gets sanitised under the pretence of not giving anyone any ideas.
- sjaak 4y ago<dusts off OpenBSD and GrapheneOS>
- lifeinthevoid 4y agoHow will it work on computers? Will browsers do the client-side scanning? Will Apple and Microsoft implement it in their OS'es? What about Linux, will Linux be forbidden? (let's not get in the discussion that Linux is the kernel, you know what I mean).
- squarefoot 4y agoGovernments have access to what is precluded to normal citizens and hackers. All they need to do is telling the phone/router/CPU/chipsets/NIC manufacturers: "if you want to have business here, from now on you put into your firmware this small blob that will help us to catch pedophiles and terrorists", and see how quick they will comply. Open Source in software would be tolerated because hardware runs at high privileges, and if you tamper with that at production level to insert backdoors, no Open Source operating system and software can prevent them from working.
- ethbr0 4y agoThe "invisible supply chain attack by intelligence agencies" angle is a plausible vector, but doing so pervasively and repeatedly in a democracy with open records is unlikely. Room 641A was leaked in 3 years. And that was one room with one domestic telecom provider. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A To keep a secret that spans supply chains, across multiple companies, many with substantial international ownership and/or interests? Not gonna happen.
- salawat 4y agoHow many common people really understand room 641A though? There's the case to be made that the level of signal propagation and uptake is still "low enough" where even though it is public, it is still effectively secret. From a CAP theoretic point of view, the info is Available, but there is still a hefty Partition in that there is a significant degree of the population that isn't Consistent on this fact.
- 4y ago
- amadeuspagel 4y agoI hope that one day germany will gain some influence in the european union, to counter the influence of great britain and protect end-to-end encryption.
- ttctciyf 4y agoGuess you haven't been following the Brexit news?
- justinclift 4y agoWas probably meant sarcastically. ;)
- jll29 4y ago> to counter the influence of great britain and protect end-to-end encryption. In 2016, a voting majority of the UK population decided to give up their valued influence in the EU, and we miss them dearly (not sarcasm - they were a much-needed voice for common sense). This event is commonly referred to as "Brexit" or Britain's exit from the European Union, and eventually from the European Council, which it once was a founding member of.
- InCityDreams 4y ago> and we miss them dearly (not sarcasm - they were a much-needed voice for common sense). Ha! That voice for 'common-sense' you dearly miss voted itself out.
- beebeepka 4y agoAnd is a champion of the surveillance state
- wkat4242 4y agoUhhh yeah, obviously I don't want my devices spying on me. If Apple had gone ahead with their ridiculous plan I would have dropped them if I hadn't done so already the year before (I went from macOS to FreeBSD for more control and I dropped iOS years before)
- xt00 4y agoAnything that includes client side scanning is a slippery slope to fully controlling your device. Will it be illegal to somehow disable the client side scanning? If so then how long until you are breaking the law when you turn off the government scanner — or are caught “installing a new hard drive” in your computer.. etc.. Is the problem that people can send encrypted things back and forth to each other? Requiring that companies put snooping software on their device is basically the thought police. Not hyperbole but the actual thought police. Today it’s saving the children, tomorrow it’s basically any problem the governments of many nations want to try to solve.
- slackdog 4y ago> Will it be illegal to somehow disable the client side scanning? If so then how long until you are breaking the law when you turn off the government scanner And once they've normalized "your computer will spy and inform on you", is there any reason to think that won't expand to things which aren't colloquially "computers" but in fact are now computers? What about "smart houses"? All your IoT toys are computers. Once phones, laptops and PCs as mandatory reporters has been normalized, is there any reason to think all the other microphones and cameras already in people's houses won't become mandatory reporters too? If they make it illegal to disable client-side scanning on computers, might they also make it illegal to remove the crime-detecting cameras in your own home? Modern cars already narc on people, logging and uploading GPS traces that can be fed into police dragnets, just like phones. Cops can ask for a log of who's been inside a 'geofence' and where does that data come from? Phones and cars reporting on their owners, generally without their owners knowing anything about it. The 'slippery slope' isn't actually a fallacy if you have enough datapoints to legitimately draw a trend line. And I think we certainly do.
- trompetenaccoun 4y agoMy friend, these are dangerous thoughts! Once we have our wifi-enabled brain interfaces you will get punished for thinking this. Please train yourself to forget about it now before you get in trouble.
- t344344 4y ago[flagged]
- Kognito 4y agoQuite a strong statement to make, not one that I know enough about to argue either way. Do you have any references you could link to to back up your statement? I’m genuinely curious what you’re referencing.
- t344344 4y agoLets just say EU is not very family friendly compared to individual states. I do not think this discussion belongs on HN. Just pointing BS in this law.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- flangola7 4y agoIsn't the EU just a sum of the states' desires?
- shjake 4y agoNot really. They are usually a sum of some clique of useful idiot/lobbyists and somewhat competent busybody career bureaucrat desires.
- germandiago 4y agoNo. It is an agenda imposed on all EU citizens without direct representation. It goes top-down instead of bottom-up unfortunately and that is why there are so many fights. It is also increasingly invasive even of the sovereignity of constitutions of individual countries.
- irusensei 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vienna_swimming_pool_rape https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vienna_swimming_pool_rape > On 2 December 2015, at the Theresienbad swimming pool in the Austrian capital Vienna, a 10-year-old boy was raped. > The perpetrator, ..., claimed that he was motivated by not having sex for four months > In October 2016, the Austrian Supreme Court overturned the man's conviction of rape, ordering a retrial, while upholding his second charge of aggravated sexual assault of a minor. The rationale was that the prosecution had not provided evidence that the man did not know that his victim did not consent > In May 2017, judge Thomas Philipp reduced the sentence to four years in a final decision by the Supreme Court, saying that the rape was a "one-off incident" and "you cannot lose your sense of proportion here" Serious clown world material here.
- marcodiego 4y agoMy half freetard stallmanian brain says: "I wouldn't mind a law forcing client-side scanning if it affected only proprietary software." The other half of my brain says: "Indeed... I really need to be able to control which software runs on MY devices."
- slackdog 4y agoAs demonstrated by iOS, the technical means to effectively frustrate the installation and use of Free Software already exists. We (the tech industry) have already built the walls of our own prison. All that remains now is for politicians to herd us in and slam the gates shut.
- zirgs 4y agoANd yet - Google is making one of the best phones that can work perfectly fine without any Google software installed. (Pixel series). Nobody forces you to use Apple softeware. I have never owned a single Apple device and never will.
- slackdog 4y agoNor have I. But I'm afraid you're not getting it. The point is that the technical means for control have already been demonstrated by iOS, not that anybody is forced to use iOS specifically. Governments could require that Google and other manufacturers implement similar controls. The walls of this sort of prison have already been designed and shown to work, all that remains is the political will to herd people in and lock the gates.
- zirgs 4y agoLocked down computing devices existed well before before the iPhone was a thing. Pretty much all gaming consoles are locked down. I'm fine with them existing as long as a non-locked down option is available. And controls like that would mean death to open source OSes like Linux, because you can't develop and test an operating system on a locked down device.
- orcajerk 4y agoThese are the same rulers that wanted to ban memes. We all know what this is really about - banning wrong think and criticism of them.
- JW_00000 4y agoThey never wanted to ban memes. In fact, the so-called "meme ban" and accompanying "link tax" has already been approved in 2019, and implemented in several countries, including Germany. By now it must be clear that this directive does not in fact ban memes or tax links, and that that was always an exaggerated reading by internet zealots. More information at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directive_on_Copyright_in_the_Digital_Single_Market#Articles_11_and_13_(15_and_17_as_passed) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directive_on_Copyright_in_the_...
- solarkraft 4y agoI don't use Tutanota anymore (main reason: no bridge to other clients), but I'm not mad about having paid up-front for another year. Thanks for keeping this topic visible.
- gavinhoward 4y agoHere's a link arguing for encryption, in case people need it. https://everyoneneedsencryption.gavinhoward.com/ https://everyoneneedsencryption.gavinhoward.com/ Comments and feedback welcome. I'd like to make these arguments irrefutable.
- sn_master 4y agoI've seen at least half a dozen cases in the US for people arrested for child abuse material where all of them came up to be because of Google scanning their messages (not just emails). There was even a case where it was a photo sent to the child's Dr because the child had a rash, and Google's algorithms identified it and that was enough for the police to get a warrant for ALL of the user's Google account.
- trizuz 4y ago[dead]
- germandiago 4y agoIam spanish. I fully support Germany. No more and more surveillance.
- LinuxBender 4y agoRather than client side scanning, I'm surprised they have not implemented Meta's solution [1] ´ₛ [1] - https://www.diyphotography.net/meta-wants-teens-nudes-to-stop-them-from-spreading-online-again/ https://www.diyphotography.net/meta-wants-teens-nudes-to-sto...
- hermanb 4y agoIf the image doesn’t leave the device and only the hash does… What is stopping one from uploading existing public images, banning a whole lot of innocent people?
- LinuxBender 4y agoYou have a very good point. It's not clear to me how Facebook/Meta planned to verify images. Maybe they have a team of people swiping left/right.
- teekert 4y agoI don’t understand these laws. What if I don’t want client side scanning? I’ll just get a Librem or PinePhone or a pixel 6 with GrapheneOS. How are they going to stop me? Think about it really, how are they going to stop me? The implications are pretty insane if you ask me.
- brokenmachine 4y agoThey would stop you by making it illegal to use any chat app that doesn't conform to those plans.
- fleddr 4y agoWhatever happened to concepts like "probable cause" and "innocent until proven guilty"?
- brokenmachine 4y agoSounds like you have something to hide, citizen.
- sebzim4500 4y agoWill CSAM be killed by AI art? Hard to believe that producing it the conventional way can be economical when you can make an almost identical product without risking serious prison time (or any at all in some jurisdictions).
- avidiax 4y agoAI art has a problem that it can reproduce the training data, or at best, still requires the training data.
- sebzim4500 4y agoYeah, but the models exist now, and I have it on good authority that SD 1.x can be used to produce child pornography.
- mouse_ 4y agoThat, or AI art will be killed/somehow heavily regulated due to CSAM.
- dane-pgp 4y ago"Controlling the output of generative AI technology is simple. We will create context for its use. First we will censor any use related to social taboos. Then we will censor anything else that we desire. If anyone complains, we will accuse them of wanting to engage in or promote social taboos." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-gGLvg0n-uY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-gGLvg0n-uY
- wazoox 4y agoFrench Senate also announced it will reject this directive. https://www.nextinpact.com/article/71087/le-senat-propose-rejeter-projet-europeen-surveillance-masse-communications https://www.nextinpact.com/article/71087/le-senat-propose-re...
- rendx 4y agoCDC: * About 1 in 4 girls and 1 in 13 boys in the United States experience child sexual abuse. * Someone known and trusted by the child or child’s family members, perpetrates 91% of child sexual abuse. https://www.cdc.gov/violenceprevention/childsexualabuse/fastfact.html https://www.cdc.gov/violenceprevention/childsexualabuse/fast... WHO: "1 in 2 children aged 2-17 years suffered violence in the past year" https://www.who.int/health-topics/violence-against-children https://www.who.int/health-topics/violence-against-children It's a sad joke that child protection is the driving argument for surveillance. The actual numbers are _horrifying_, but almost nothing is done about it even in "developed countries". None of the organizations looking into actual violence against children is advocating for such measures. It is a completely fake and bullshit argument.
- miohtama 4y agoHow about false positives > Indiscriminate messaging and chat control wrongfully incriminates hundreds of users every day. According the Swiss Federal Police, 80% of machine-reported content is not illegal, for example harmless holiday photos showing nude children playing at a beach. Similarly in Ireland only 20% of NCMEC reports received in 2020 were confirmed as actual “child abuse material”. All machine flagged reports must be checked by a human. Somebody will check your photos. https://www.patrick-breyer.de/en/posts/chat-control/ https://www.patrick-breyer.de/en/posts/chat-control/
- rendx 4y agoThe point is that overwhelming majority of sexual abuse happens in families, and that online sharing of material is only a very small fraction of an overall "epidemic". If politicians were serious about addressing child abuse problems, they would follow the advice of child protection organizations including the CDC and WHO (and all the others). The only area where this comes up again and again is online surveillance.
- varispeed 4y agoIt's funny that I was saying the EU is going to implement this like 10 years ago and people were calling me crazy conspiracy theorist, that the EU would never have done anything like that and that EU is totally not evil. Look how Overton windows is moving. Today it's a thing and nobody calls it conspiracy theory anymore and suddenly people no longer talk about good EU. Tomorrow you'll have these scanners on you device. From then your life will be micromanaged by bureaucrats and you'll become a slave. As ideology EU is built upon is slavery.
- anenefan 4y agoIt's bad enough with the amount of private data already scraped legally by websites, without sanctioning the removal of privacy. Honestly the "for the kids" we know is BS, they say it's for the kids, even if they parade a group of well meaning people around bringing an awareness there's a problem (IMO, honestly double or treble the amount of police or IT entity around the world to penetrate the vile pedo groups) - but instead such actions proposed are almost always for other more powerful interests who see a fraction of the web as a major problem for some perceived idea they lose money to this fraction's activities. The reality is any group up to no good will simply migrate to a protocol that permits sending a file from a usb or other external source, but such file will be encrypted unlike any previous known encryption. Then the same process as the good work done presently will save the kids, agencies will slowly penetrate such groups, discover the encryption and member contacts ... At the end of day like many here have already said, it's a slippery slope. Some people are happy to use devices they really don't own the content to do as they please, they put up with google running their phone apps ... when I couldn't clear my cheap android phone's disk space of the junk which left no room for anything else, without having to reset, that was the point I gave up on smart phones - it now exists only to take texts and calls and create a wifi hotspot.
- AbusiveHNAdmin 4y ago[dead]
- julienreszka 4y agoThere is no "EU constitution". The article is not accurate about this.
- greatgib 4y agoIt is really fascinating -horrifying to see that most western governments and a big part of the population does not value or respect privacy anymore. This is crazy when you think that it used to be a core value and people fought for this.
- xchip 4y agoThe EU did nothing to prosecute pedophile priests, so not sure their real concern is to protect kids.