Have you actually read the article? The title is just a summary and the author fully acknowledges that their argument is essentially based around edge cases, n

Have you actually read the article? The title is just a summary and the author fully acknowledges that their argument is essentially based around edge cases, not that this in any way diminishes it for me. It’s just an interesting piece of theorising. I think your comment (particularly your 4th paragraph about ivory towers etc) comes across as overly harsh and a little aggressive.