9 ms·
Germany refuses to agree to EU ban on new fossil fuel cars from 2035
- infamouscow 4y agoIronic considering we have a German MP saying the following only a few months ago. > This is in no way about sanctioning the Orbán government, but about sustainably strengthening the rule of law — which Hungary voluntarily committed to when it joined the EU - Michael Link, https://www.politico.eu/article/germany-lawmakers-push-hard-line-hungary-rule-of-law/ https://www.politico.eu/article/germany-lawmakers-push-hard-...
- ginko 4y agoI don't see the irony here. Those two cases are barely related other than that both involve Germany.
- infamouscow 4y agoThe quote from November 2022 of a German MP saying that Hungary must go along with the laws enacted by the EU commission. It only took a few months for the shoe to be on the other foot. Now it's Germany, rather than Hungary that does not want to comply with EU law.
- znkynz 4y agoIts not EU law as yet. EU Members can weild the veto if they choose.
- arlort 4y agoNo, they can't on this. This procedure requires "only" QMV. That's not to say it'll definitely pass, but there's no veto https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/council-eu/voting-system/voting-calculator/ https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/council-eu/voting-system/... You can play with possible coalitions on this link, to be fair due to its population and the nature of this law germany is de facto a swing vote
- peterfirefly 4y agoThere is a difference between not complying with something that already is EU law and not agreeing with the other member states during negotiations BEFORE something becomes EU law.
- ginko 4y agoThe proposed 2035 fossil fuel car ban isn't an existing law. It's in the negotiation stage and Germany is negotiating. This is completely different from Hungary not following laws existing when they joined the EU.
- arlort 4y agoThe "shoe on the other foot" expression implies that the two situations are the same, or at the very least comparable The situation in hungary is the government violating core principles that stand at the heart of the EU with behaviours that, were Hungary applying for membership right now would see them rejected outright Right now germany is signalling they might vote against a proposed change in ordinary law. That's how laws are made, some actors vote for, some vote against and if there's enough actors in favour the law becomes such and binds all It'd be remotely comparable if Germany were refusing to comply with an adopted law, and even then comparing rule of law principles with commercial regulations would be distasteful at best
- lock-the-spock 4y agoApart from the replies below that these are different issues, the real argument concerning rule of law is that Hungary is receiving EU funds which then flow in shady coffers as the Orban government chooses to not enforce the law of simply sets up intransparent 'legal' but unsound systems. Orban is undermining the basics of democracy and a functioning state to keep in power and get a profit - this is far far away from a discussion about engine types.
- epicureanideal 4y agoI’ll be honest, it seems like every even semi-conservative government gets talked about this way, such that even American presidents are compared to Hitler, and at this point I just assume without mountains of evidence that it’s just propaganda and whatever Orban is doing is just unpopular with the left. The left does plenty that I’d call unconstitutional (although the right is catching up), but they’re not talked about as much in the popular media. Just saying, there are probably tens of millions having the same reaction as me. When everyone is called a dictator, don’t be surprised when we yawn when the next person is called a dictator. And some day it might be important to have a useful label like that.
- toyg 4y agoOrbàn is not just "unpopular with the left", but also with moderate centrists like French president Emmanuel Macron. He's been effectively thrown out of the European People's Party, the traditional European right linked to Christian establishment. When you're too crooked even for the ruling elites, you're probably crooked beyond salvation. Sometimes people cry wolf because there is an actual wolf, and refusing to accept it will result in getting eaten.
- epicureanideal 4y ago> moderate centrists like French president Emmanuel Macron. But who is also a globalist whereas Orban is not. > even for the ruling elites The ruling globalist elites. The “citizen of anywhere” elites, who are not allies of the “citizens of somewhere” elites, to use Victor Davis Hansen inspired terminology.
- LatteLazy 4y agoThese measures are all so far in the future they are irrelevant. It's like giving people a loan their kids will pay.
- Bostonian 4y agoCar companies decide how to much to invest now in new lines of gas-powered cars based on views of future government policies, so the measures are not "irrelevant". At a micro level, someone considering buying a gas station or building a new one will consider the lifetime revenues of the business.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoCar companies have plenty of know-how to predict the future of their field of technology on a 10-15yr timeline. They're perfectly capable of calling obvious bluffs. While everyone was busy back patting and circle jerking over the 2035 mandates they were investing in new gas engine architectures for commercial vehicles (so like minivans on up to medium duty trucks) because they looked at the state of diesel tech and emissions rules, looked at the state of gas engine tech and emissions rules and looked at the state of battery tech and decided that the box van of the future was gonna have a gas engine option. At the end of the day you can't legislate a technology jump into existence.
- mabbo 4y ago2035 is 12 years away. That's not immediately, but a significant number of politicians will still be around in 12 years.
- mrtksn 4y agoThis probably needs someone well versed on domestic German politics so to be interpreted correctly.
- cinntaile 4y agoIsn't it usually just a money thing? They have a huge car industry and a huge chemical industry, both require quite a bit of fossil fuels.
- Tarsul 4y agoThis is the FDP (neoliberals) trying to collect points for itself, as the only thing they did since coming into office is being an annoyance. Which is why they really suffered in regional voting contests lately and why they are a little in panic mode and trying it with their usual clientel policies (which means: let businesses do whatever they want). It really has nothing to do with facts or anything, for the FDP it's all about talking points. The main problem is that the FDP are basically on the other side of the SPD and Greens, with which they share the office and why this will drag on until the next government will be voted upon (in 2025).
- credit_guy 4y agoMakes sense. The perfect is the enemy of the good. Plug-in hybrid cars with a decent electric range (let's say 80 km) can achieve 99% emissions reduction compared to current cars. The vast majority of trips people make are short.
- mouse_ 4y agoIs that accounting for manufacture emissions as well? I agree with you though, but what if we could sell fully electric vehicles with only ~100km range? I would buy it if I was really saving the cost and weight of a whole engine block. Useless for road trips, but most people don't need to be taking road trips every day.
- wyager 4y ago> Useless for road trips, but most people don't need to be taking road trips every day. One of the primary benefits of owning things, as opposed to being a rentoid, is over-allocation to seamlessly handle peak/long-tail demand scenarios. Yes, a lot of people could save money by only riding bikes or taking taxis or whatever, but the extreme inconvenience associated with getting caught in a demand surge makes ownership worth it a lot more than first-order average-oriented thinking would suggest. Having to get a rental car every time you want to drive more than 100km sucks.
- bluGill 4y agoAn engine block (including transmission) is light compared to batteries. Maybe a small car with a very limited range is lighter, but not for something useful. Electric cars are typically significantly heavier than their ICE counterparts. 100km is not a useful range. Remember that for best battery life you really need to only charge to 80%, and and never let the battery get below 20%. Now cut that entire range in half for cold weather. You are now down to 30km range that you really can use. That is round trip range unless you really have chargers everywhere you might go. The average US commute is 40 miles or 65km. Though given you are using km you probably have a shorter distance, but even still your 100km car is cutting range too close for comfort for most people. (and you probably have better access to transit, why not get rid of that 100km car completely) I don't know how to compare manufacture emissions. I do know that metal shaping has been optimized a lot, while I would assume as new technology modern batteries still have a lot of room for improvement (the older batteries probably not), so I wouldn't trust a comparison if you had data.
- sandworm101 4y agoArticle title is wrong, which is made clear in first para. >> Germany's government is refusing to agree to European Union plans to effectively ban the sale of new cars with combustion engines from 2035, according to Finance Minister Christian Lindner. (Fossil fuels = bad) does not mean the same as (combustion engine = bad). There are lots of green combustion options, first on the list being hydrogen gas as fuel for a combustion engine. Then there are fuel-from-air approaches whereby a normal combustion engine would burn hydrocarbon fuel made without "fossil" carbon sources. German auto makers are rightfully upset at being told to abandon such lines.
- frankreyes 4y agoInteresting, another example could be "Green methane", when produced with solar power and recycled from CO2 from the atmosphere. Either a Sabatier process or a methane producing bacteria
- froh 4y agomethane or methanol? this guy makes a methanol fuel cell and battery hybrid car: https://www.rolandgumpert.com/en/ https://www.rolandgumpert.com/en/
- VBprogrammer 4y agoGreen hydrogen as a road transport fuel probably doesn't make sense at all, nevermind burning it at ~25% efficiency. Fuel cells are a possibility at ~90% efficiency but there are so many industrial used of hydrogen that we'd be better displacing methane derived hydrogen in those places before considering it for transport.
- sandworm101 4y agoI'm not so sure. Some of the diesel-from-air tech looks promising. It is expensive, more expensive than reasonable battery tech at the moment, but I wouldn't abandon the concept. If BMW wants to research and potentially sell a zero-carbon combustion fuel cycle, more power to them.
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoSo how long before 2035 will be 20XX ban on ICE and then slowly fizzles out? Exactly as happened with biofuels?
- Ekaros 4y agoI would guess 2030 or so. With industry pressure and everything. Actually 2035 is worrying short timeframe. That is less than 12 years now. Which is like two model generations of vehicles...
- linuxftw 4y agoThere's lots of biofuel produced, it's called 'trees' and the UK burns them for power. North American logging operations pelletize the scraps and the UK burns it. None of this is sustainable whatsoever, but it's being done.
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoWell I was hinting on rapeseed oil added into gas, which used to be mandatory
- mhandley 4y agoDifferent countries in Europe can set different road rules, though they cannot discriminate by country. If other EU countries wished to play hardball, they could always do something like setting a 5 km/h speed limit for any (fossil) internal combustion car registered in the EU after 2035. Not many people in Germany would buy a car that is effectively restricted to Germany, and none would be sold anywhere else in the EU, so no mainstream manufacturer would bother with type approval.
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoWell, except whole Eastern and Southern Europe, where BEV are unaffordable So from whole EU you are left with France, Austria and Benelux.
- dmitriid 4y agoBEVs are unaffordable pretty much everywhere (if there are no government subsidies). Every single BEV model seems to be 20-50% more expensive than its ICE counterpart. And the "cheap" ones are something like Renault Tweezy, useless to most people.
- onethought 4y agoTotal cost of ownership is reduced significantly with BEVs Government subsidies exist for oil and ice vehicles as well. I think if you subtracted all subsidies ICE must be far more expensive because oil infrastructure is obviously way less efficient.
- TheLoafOfBread 4y ago> Government subsidies exist for oil and ice vehicles as well. Maybe in USA there are subsidies on gas. Come to EU, 50% tax on gas, no subsidies.
- onethought 4y ago
- throwayyy479087 4y agoGermany is dragged kicking and screaming into the future, which has become very common lately. Tanks to Ukraine, Nord Stream 2, turning off all their nukes, now this? Maybe if Greta scolds them they'll do it, they certainly seemed to take all of their nuclear advice from her.
- nostromo123 4y agoSure hope Germany is not planning to build any windfarms on reindeer grazing grounds or whatever the current indignation of the week is for her! ;) https://www.cnn.com/2023/03/01/europe/greta-thunberg-wind-farm-norway-sami-climate-intl/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2023/03/01/europe/greta-thunberg-wind-fa...
- mytailorisrich 4y agoThe German car industry, Europe's really, is not ready. That's the issue. They know this will hurt them and advantage those that are ready like Tesla and some Chinese automakers starting to move into Europe.
- kwhitefoot 4y agoThe best selling EV brand in Norway last year (2022) was Volkswagen, just a few cars ahead of Tesla and growing The Chinese sell fewer EVs than Skoda, BMW, etc., in Norway.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoTesla now uses BYD batteries (at least partly) at its Berlin factory (the yanks have a gigafactory in Berlin, Germany and they use batteries from China...) Meanwhile in Norway: "It is followed by the MG ZS (+15.5%) up 35 ranks on June just a the BYD Tang climbs 6 spots to a new record 6th place overall," [July 2022] [1] That's an unknown brand from China that's only just moving into the European market! And MG is now Chinese. In any case, Norway is a small market. Here 'ready' means being able to produce as many EVs as they do ICE now throughout Europe. Yeah, German carmakers are on top of things... not. [1] https://bestsellingcarsblog.com/2022/08/norway-july-2022-mg-5-byd-tang-6-break-records-in-market-off-31/ https://bestsellingcarsblog.com/2022/08/norway-july-2022-mg-...
- toyg 4y agoIMHO it's not a matter of readiness - most German automakers now have EV models that are very good, VW's ID.4 for example is excellent in my experience. It's the fear that they won't make as much money as they are now, losing lines that probably will still be profitable in 2035. It's likely that 20-30% of the market will simply refuse to transition to EV, either for ideological or practical reasons; nobody wants to lose those customers.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoIt's not just a question of having models. Readiness means reaching production levels comparable to ICE models now. If they are against a ban in 2035 it obviously means that it's not good for them, which can only mean that they think they cannot make it, either in volume or price point, or both.
- somethoughts 4y agoAn interesting alternative initiative that I hope goes viral (often times things on HN do go viral). Mandate that all gas/petrol stations have at least two working fast chargers (i.e. Level 3 800V) by 2030 in exchange for a gas station operating license/permit and check them monthly. Time limit caps can be imposed at 8 minutes which is equivalent to the fill up time for a gasoline based car/truck. At 5 minutes, a Hyundai Ioniq 5 can be charged up to 68 miles of range which should get you out of most situations.[1] [1] https://www.hyundai.com/worldwide/en/eco/ioniq5/charging https://www.hyundai.com/worldwide/en/eco/ioniq5/charging
- onethought 4y agoThat only works if all the cars have decent charging circuitry on them. There are a lot of slowish charging EVs
- sokoloff 4y agoThat at least makes it possible for a car owner to choose a car that does have a fast charging capability. If you don’t choose such a car, you don’t get fast charging which seems both fair and obvious.
- somethoughts 4y agoYes this is also not a now proposal. The thought is by 2030-35, the technology will exist to get to 80%/100 miles in 5-8 minutes. I think the automatic cut-off at 5-10 minutes similar to the time of an ICE fuel pit stop is key. Also having a human attendant who is around to ensure people aren't leaving their car unattended while hogging the fast charging EV chargers while they go off to have a 5 course dinner is also critical for both gas station owners and other users.
- wintogreen74 4y agoLots of hubris to title your idiosyncratic proposal as an alternative to the wholesale ban on the sale of ICE cars...
- random314 4y agoMercedes and VW in-action
- kwhitefoot 4y agoThere are plenty of VW EVs in Norway. I see loads of them all the time.
- genericacct 4y agoI believe the current italian govt is on the same wavelength and has announced more or less the same
- WirelessGigabit 4y agoI'm thinking of getting a Hybrid. I can't get an electric car because I cannot charge it reliably. My concerns are flooring it from cold. So far I have not read / found literature on what the computer then does, and how this increases engine wear. I read 'reinforced components' but that's just longer until they wear out. For as long as I've been driving I have been taking it slow with the engine until it got up to oil temperature. And that actually got longer these days with having a huge amount of oil in the car. But then looking at a BMW X50e, you run the risk of flooring it on electric, and then that B58 3L needs to kick in and instantly delivery 300+HP. That just ... doesn't compute. HOW is that NOT bad but when I do that on my current, same, but non-reinforced B58 3L... I'd understand if there are reports out there that say things like 'given current oil quality we don't need to worry about cold oil performance anymore'. But we still have the time that the engine kicks in, while the oil isn't circulated. I'd be more comfortable if the oil pump was disconnected from the engine and ran when high performance is needed, bridging the gap of oil starvation when the ICE kicks in.
- rightbyte 4y agoYour concern is valid. I worked with programming hybrids and I did it like this: Engage ICE until operating temperature. Allow auto-turning it off for EM only. Hysteresis to like 2/3 operating temperature. There is a "force electric" button for like a short ride on all EM. The reason was to keep engine wear down as well as emission demands.
- WirelessGigabit 4y agoOkay so you started to drive, on ICE + EM. When ICE is on temp you allow auto-turning off. When engine fell back to 2/3 of operating temp you went back to mandating the ICE to remain on. Did I get that correct?
- rightbyte 4y agoYes. 2/3 is not exact but kinda from distant memory. Was plenty of factors. Of which emission control was the most "annoying" when optimizing for fuel consumption with the hybrid strategy. It was heavy vehicles, so dunno if car engines need different long term temperature operating ranges.
- makomk 4y agoOf course they are. If I remember rightly, the EU's NO2 emission standards for vehicles were substantially laxer than the US in order to protect the German car industry and its investment in diesel engines. This resulted in most major cities having NO2 levels in excess of that allowed by EU law, with those countries not really having any good way to come into compliance since they couldn't set their own vehicle emission standards. In the end I think a bunch of cities ended up having to ban older vehicles, screwing over anyone who couldn't afford to buy a new car and generating even more sales for the German car industry.
- numbers_guy 4y agoBan cars in cities instead. That makes much more sense and would be fairer too. This EV bullshit is yet another regressive tax on poor people. I am no longer poor, but I have sympathy for all the people who have to live paycheck to paycheck, getting hit with this nonsense.
- hexo 4y agoThat is extremely shortsighted as there are many people with various needs and disabilities who cannot get along normally without car.
- numbers_guy 4y agoI mean, here in Germany, public transport in cities is good enough that even as a wheel chair user, it's easier to use the tram than to have your own car outfitted. But no worries, if you have a P plate, then fine get an exception. Not a big issue.
- hexo 4y agoThanks, your comment proves this shortsightedness.
- jcadam 4y agoThey don't want peasants to have mobility. Hell, we couldn't possibly produce enough EVs (nor provide the power to charge so many) for most middle-class folks to own a car if ICEs are banned.
- nektro 4y agothis is good, the solution to cars is not EVs. it's investment in public transit and making people buy less cars overall.