4 ms·
If you want to fix the shortage of electricians (and trades in general), remove the gatekeepers and open up the profession. People aren't entering the field not
by paxys 4y ago
If you want to fix the shortage of electricians (and trades in general), remove the gatekeepers and open up the profession. People aren't entering the field not because it is undesirable but because the process is too damn onerous for newcomers (by design).
You first have to do 6-12 months in a state-approved trade school (costs $15-20K on average in CA).
Then comes 4 years of apprenticeship. But good luck finding a licensed journeyman who is hiring or actually gives a shit. And if you're lucky, you will spend the entire time doing bitch work and get paid a whopping $12/hr. It also comes with requirements like bringing your own truck to the job. Want to join a union? Rejection rates for early career apprentices is >95%.
If you somehow make it through this you finally get a license and the honor of fixing people's light bulbs. Do this for a decade or two and gain experience and you'll be making like $80K/yr (https://faradaycareers.com/careers/electrician-salary https://faradaycareers.com/careers/electrician-salary).
No shit smart people are studying coding instead.
- marcosdumay 4y ago> Do this for a decade or two and gain experience and you'll be making like $80K/yr Hey, that's good evidence that the supply isn't actually very constrained. (But yeah, apprenticeship terms are bullshit.)
- mostlysimilar 4y agoPerhaps those barriers are higher than they should be but for something this critical it's a good thing there's process, training, and regulation. Safety and reliability are more important than speed. Software engineering could probably use a few barriers. There's some exceedingly shitty software out there getting pumped out by people who hop in to make quick money and get hired by companies who don't care and just want to pay people less. The world needs to catch up to how critical software is and course correct away from it becoming a race to the bottom.
- jacobsenscott 4y agoThe barriers have nothing to do with safety - they are a moat designed to keep competition out and wages high. The moat worked a generation or two ago - you could make a good middle class living as a tradesperson. It doesn't work anymore, now we just have a shortage of tradespeople and nobody wants to jump through the hoops when there are easier ways to make higher wages.
- briHass 4y agoAs always, the truth is somewhere in the middle. The NEC is fairly complex, and there are lots of gotchas and techniques that you really only learn by doing it for some time alongside someone experienced that can guide you. If it was your house, would you want the equivalent of a bootcamp electrician mucking around with minimal oversight? Sure, there are inspectors, but they can't be expected to catch 100% of the issues, and most people wouldn't want the job to take 3 times as long as the junior electrician is forced to redo huge amounts of work. That said, there should be stricter requirements for offering apprenticeships. If the law requires it to work, anyone that has achieved that status should be mandated to take on X apprentices over their career.
- gjsman-1000 4y ago> No shit smart people are studying coding instead. Unless you are playing the long game. With the advance of AI… 20 years from now he’ll have a stable job in a severe Electrician shortage, while the Silicon Valley teams will have replaced themselves and be out jobs. I think that is closer than SV wants to admit. Outsourcing is getting higher quality, economic downturns are already hitting SV with layoffs, low-code is getting better… and ChatGPT, doing programming in 20 years? Seems pretty dang certain to me.
- dragonwriter 4y agoAll of the history of programming has been magnifying the value of programmers by automating more of programming. Automation doesn't replace automators (it makes their work more abstract and productibe, but that just increases the application space and quantity of output consumed.)
- paxys 4y agoSoftware engineers in this country are perpetually on the brink of extinction. 20 years ago people would discourage you from the career because all the jobs were going to India. 10 years ago there were supposedly too many CS graduates and there could never be enough demand to sustain them. Today everyone is convinced that the AI takeover is just around the corner. I'm not panicking just yet.
- gjsman-1000 4y agoRemember, all it takes is a blockade, not even an invasion, of Taiwan and new computing projects are on indefinite hold. And we will start de-computerizing industries out of necessity. It could be that quick.
- zamnos 4y agoThat's a fascinating perspective. Okay, so Taiwan is blockaded and we can't get any more computer chips for the near future. Then somehow we decomputerize industry? Why wouldn't we just start using older computers, of which there is a glut of them? (Just check ebay.) Also many industries, after seeing efficiency gains, are unable to decomputerize. What happens to them?
- vidanay 4y agoAnd by the time you reach that point, you have a broken back and a shitty attitude.
- mfer 4y agoThis misses out on the culture problem. A lot of high schools teach kids they must go to college. Kids feel like failures to consider the route of skilled trades. Many schools have removed the hands on classes that prep people to be comfortable working with tools and their hands. So, kids have less prep to go out there. There is a culture element to this. > You first have to do 6-12 months in a state-approved trade school (costs $15-20K on average in CA). This isn't everywhere. Many other states have a much simpler setup to get into trades. Sometimes there is a trade school (and sometimes the industry covers the cost). Sometimes you start a job and learn on the job. You take certification tests along the way. What you describe for CA isn't everywhere.
- taylodl 4y ago> What you describe for CA isn't everywhere. It is for electricians. I come from a family of electricians working in many states, including the so-called "red" states. This is the process. It was designed to impede entry into the skilled trades. That may have been a good strategy in another era, but it's not a good strategy now.
- paxys 4y agoEveryone keeps saying this but it doesn't really make sense. People chase money, not social expectations. Heck open up OnlyFans for the perfect example of this. More and more schoolteachers (a historically respectable career) are becoming sex workers (a historically disreputable career) simply because it makes more economic sense. Let's say we do somehow make trades popular and everyone goes to trade school instead of college. What then? Is there magically going to be more state funding for apprenticeship programs? Will there be better union representation? Will states make better laws around workplace injuries? Will wages somehow get higher? (Quite the opposite in fact if more people are entering the profession). You have to fix all this first, and that in turn will lead to better public perception of the profession. It can't be the other way around.
- callmetom 4y ago[dead]
- 4y ago
- letitbeirie 4y ago> No shit smart people are studying coding instead It's hard to come anywhere close to software money as a licensed EE designing the electrical things, let alone as the one building them.
- rcarr 4y ago> and get paid a whopping $12/hour. It’s even worse than this in the UK. For the first year of your apprenticeship you get paid £4.81 per hour which works out at $5.78 an hour. Unless you’re living with parents who won’t charge you rent, the apprenticeship route is off limits unless you find a company that pay a proper wage. They do exist but competition for the places is extremely fierce. The wage does go up in your second year to your age band’s minimum wage, so if you’re 23 you’ll get a whopping (/s) £9.50 an hour, but if you’re 18-20 you’re on £6.83 and if you’re still under 18 you’re stuck on the £4.81. Absolutely disgraceful.