5 ms·
Steel was already being used in Europe 2,900 years ago, shows study
- __void 4y agowtf this fact melts my brain! Man already knew (meteoritic) steel and it is a known fact, but that we could already produce it is absolutely mind f-ck and rewriting the history books, predating by millennia some dynamics that were previously certain
- kjs3 4y agoThat seems histrionic...what rewrites or dynamics are going to be significantly changed? I mean, it's a fascinating discovery and all and thank gawd our ancestors were so clever. A timeline or two might get updated, but the headline seems to be "culture that left little evidence of their existence figured out how to make steel to make marks on hard rocks; no one else picked up on it for a millennia or two". This isn't by any means the first time we've found some ancient culture figured out something really neat earlier than we expected but it didn't go anywhere at the time.
- __void 4y agoproducing steel requires a huge, huge amount of knowledge, energy (fire) and materials (wood, coal and ores), it took us millennia to maximise the process... to know that someone, even 'accidentally', was producing it eleven centuries earlier is at least fascinating to me; Actually, I don't know how 'revolutionary' it is in total, but in the meantime my brain explodes!
- rsynnott 4y agoI think you're generally dating steel production too late (100AD?) As mentioned in another comment, earliest known was nearly 4000 years ago, and there was quite large-scale production in India by about 2500 years ago. Steel didn't really take over the world until later (arguably not _really_ until the Industrial Revolution), but that was more down to the practicalities of making it than anything else.
- kwere 4y agolinearity in history will be seen in our future like newtonian phisics, good enough to describe what we see but "incomplete", the "relativity equivalent" would be outburst of (relatively isolated) civilizations that collapsed without leaving substantial legacy. For example known unknown great ancient civilizations as Bactria–Margiana Archaeological Complex (Oxus) or guatemala cities under rainforest
- kjs3 4y agoNewtonian physics is still good enough and used every single day. "Civilizations that collapsed without leaving substantial legacy" are footnotes in academic papers: fascinating and useful if you're in the tiny number of people in the field of research, not so much otherwise. Not the same thing at all.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rsynnott 4y agoI mean, while this is certainly interesting, it's worth noting that this is just pushing back the date for steel production _in Europe_. The earliest known steel production is quite a lot earlier (1800BC), but it was in what's now Turkey.
- OscarCunningham 4y ago"The future is already here — it's just not very evenly distributed."
- mabbo 4y agoI suspect steel making was one of those pieces of knowledge that got lost frequently. The reason: it's incredibly expensive, in terms of energy requirements. I have read that Roman legionaries, covered in armor, took acres of wood per soldier to make the charcoal needed to make the steel using traditional methods. Entire regions could be deforestated to outfit an army. Technology is the story of better access to energy and information over time. Steelmaking requires both, and 2900 years ago we had very poor access. Edit: as Luc pointed out below me, that figure is just for iron armor. Proper steel requires higher heat and even more energy.
- Luc 4y ago"To put that in some perspective, a Roman legion (roughly 5,000 men) in the Late Republic might have carried into battle around 44,000kg (c. 48.5 tons) of iron – not counting pots, fittings, picks, shovels and other tools we know they used. That iron equipment in turn might represent the mining of around 541,200kg (c. 600 tons) of ore, smelted with 642,400kg (c. 710 tons) of charcoal, made from 4,620,000kg (c. 5,100 tons) of wood. Cutting the wood and making the charcoal alone, from our figures above, might represent something like (I am assuming our charcoal-burners are working in teams) 80,000 man-days of labor. For one legion." Of course it's from https://acoup.blog/2020/09/25/collections-iron-how-did-they-make-it-part-ii-trees-for-blooms/ https://acoup.blog/2020/09/25/collections-iron-how-did-they-...
- mabbo 4y agoThat's where I read that! I had forgotten, but of course it was the delightful Bret Devereux. Still, that was just for iron. Steel requires even more energy- higher heat I believe?
- hef19898 4y agoAnd better ore. And more of it. It was until the early 20th century, way into the industrial revolution, that iron production outpaced steel production by 9 to 1. Today it is the opposite, with simple iron basically impossible to get.
- Synaesthesia 4y agoI guess any steel from that long ago is bound to have vanished by now, they surmised that only a steel chisel could have made the carvings. Is there anything else which could also be hard enough to carve the rock? A chisel made of rock?
- OJFord 4y agoTheir geochemicalanalysis, metallographic analses, and experiments showed it wasn't possible with iron, required a carbon content high enough to call 'proper steel', and your suggestion is hey maybe they used a rock?
- pcrh 4y agoBoth steel and quartz have a mohs hardness of about 7.... just sayin'
- londons_explore 4y agoSteel in the right conditions can last almost forever. Lacking water or lacking oxygen are the main preservers, and there are plenty of pockets underground with those conditions. If there were any substantial number of steel tools 2,900 years ago, we would have found one by now. However, if there were just a few very rare examples, it's unlikley we'd find evidence of them.
- bluGill 4y agoSteel is a byproduct of iron production in very small quantities. If you separate that steel out you can make a knife, but it is a once in a lifetime for iron production regions. So it could be that rare examples is all we get. Though who knows if a better process was found and then lost.
- roywiggins 4y agoThey found a steel chisel and also tried to work the rock with softer chisels, and couldn't. "Analysis of an iron chisel found in Rocha do Vigio showed that Iberian stonemasons from the Final Bronze Age had the necessary tools. The researchers discovered that it consisted of heterogeneous yet astonishingly carbon-rich steel. To confirm their findings, the researchers also carried out an experiment involving a professional stonemason, a blacksmith and a bronze caster, and attempted to work the rock that the pillars were made of using chisels of different materials. The stonemason could not work the stone with either the stone or the bronze chisels, or even using an iron chisel with an untempered point."
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoGives a new meaning to "Toledo Steel."
- londons_explore 4y agoWhen archaeologists say it "isn't possible to do X with Y", having attempted to do it in an afternoon of trying, I don't really believe them... 2,900 years ago there were lots of people, each with lots of time. It seems very possible that there was some way to carve this stone, and we just haven't discovered it... For example, maybe the stone is weakened if you try to carve it after a frosty night... Or is weakened by being soaked in lemon juice... Or is just worn away by being rubbed against another piece of the same stone... There are all kinds of methods of achieving the apparently impossible which are non-obvious.
- andrewflnr 4y agoThey did also find the actual chisel, though. And it's very possible that, say, rubbing acid or scraping with a stone does make a mark, but I bet it's sufficiently distinct in shape, side effects, etc to be ruled out here.
- jjoonathan 4y ago> archaeologists say it "isn't possible to do X with Y" Do they? Many people use "everyone said X was impossible, but I found out how to do X!" as a framing device to tell their story, but whenever I investigate one of these I generally find that it isn't strictly, err, true. People weren't saying "X is impossible" so much as "we think tribe T didn't know how to do X so this artifact was probably imported" or something similarly hedged. The new information is genuine, but the narrative is just storytelling.
- barbazoo 4y ago> there were lots of people, each with lots of time I bet tons of Human innovation came from people just having time and nothing to do. I wonder, throughout history, if this was a privilege or if even ordinary people had time like this (obviously not the resources necessarily).
- londons_explore 4y agoI suspect that throughout history there has generally been quite a lot of 'free time'. Music and art and drinking alcohol all appear to be mostly free time/entertainment things, and I suspect a group of people who had to work for all of their waking hours wouldn't partake in those things much. Even in nature, it seems most creatures have a lot of free time. For example, most birds seem to spend much of their time sitting in trees chirping, rather than hunting for worms/seeds. I could imagine that "I have free time to sing" is a big sexual selector - an individual who doesn't need to spend 24/7 hunting for food is a 'stronger' mate. I wonder if the same applies to humans?
- vishnugupta 4y ago"Forging a Katana"[1] is a fantastic documentary! I learned to appreciate steel as a material and what it takes to create a steel blade. There is so much craft and experience required to make one. Here's[2] another documentary about making of Santoku knife. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VE_4zHNcieM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VE_4zHNcieM [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tbbky_RwFyc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tbbky_RwFyc
- hotpotamus 4y agoI saw that as a NOVA documentary[0]. They also had a sequel of sorts, "Secrets of the Viking Sword" that showed a modern blacksmith trying to re-create crucible steel from that era[1]. [0]https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/ancient/secrets-samurai-sword.html https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/ancient/secrets-samurai-sword.... [1]https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2204408/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2204408/
- hef19898 4y agoThat is such a rabbit hole! A book I can recommend is "The Art of the Japanese Sword" by Leon and Hiroku Kapp. Also a great resource if you want to go into knife / blade making yourself. What is really interesting so, is the metallurgy behind that. Basically, Japanese blacksmith had to work around the fact that all they had was basically crappy ore deposits with loads of unwanted impurities. And they did so masterfully. Modern day mono-steel is ahead of whatever historical swordsmiths had, it is almost ridiculous. One of the greatest benefits, besides having clearly defined and refined properties regardless of batch, is how easy heat treatment is. Those standardized properties mean what ever part one makes behaves the same way when heat treated at a certain temperature. And that temperature is surprisingly easy to control, guessing the right temperature was what kind of made sword making a black art so to say. EDIT: Also look up Peter Johnsson, he has great content on the geometry and dimensions of European swords. His swords, from Viking style all the way to renaissance ear ones, are pieces of art. He is also really accessible, I just shot him a mail with questions regarding heat treatment of blades for a yet to start project, and the back and forth was really, really helpful.
- mhb 4y agoPrimitive Technology: Decarburization of iron and forging experiments: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pOj4L9yp7Mc&t=7s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pOj4L9yp7Mc&t=7s
- joshmarinacci 4y agoThere’s a big difference between possible and practical. There’s a reason steel production didn’t take off until the Industrial Revolution.