7 ms·
The Offshore Networks of Oligarchs
- rektide 4y agoYounger me was so excited by bootstrapping new connectivities & systems, resented government survelliance of personal lives. The Manifesto of Cyberspace was scrawled across my brain. But wow, my dislike for how many vast powers in the world are so very un-observable was also high then, & the implications of bitcoin & cryptocurrency to let these systems grow & be harder to deal with has only gone up & up & up ever-more. Ultimately we're far more tracked by corporations anyhow now, and that only barely has to do with the currency we use.
- photon12 4y agoI recently had to leave working for a cryptocurrency adjacent startup because my stomach kept getting into knots about how oligarchs are doing a lot of VC funding in the space, and the reason they are funding it is to cement their authority.
- wonderwonder 4y agoInteresting, can you provide more details without doxxing yourself?
- photon12 4y agoThis person isn't necessarily an oligarch, but they are a major vendor of market research and VC dollars in the space. This is how important they think the stakes are around fake internet money [1]: > The Biden Administration is trying to strangle crypto. > A lot of folks have been trying to stifle that criticism, but the effort to destroy the industry is quiet but pervasive across the exec branch. > The time to make crypto an issue that wins or loses the Presidency is now. Investors in my company support that view. It's an example of doing things indistinguishable from what oligarchs want: no questions on their authority, even in the wake of massive consumer harms relating to token speculation and fundamentally unsolvable UX issues for retail consumers. I had to leave mostly because I couldn't deal with the constant cognitive dissonance. The only reliable source of income in crypto is arbing yields on customer deposits to US treasuries, and the whole space is reliant on the government for macroeconomic stability already and they are creating big deposit flow risks and banks are rightfully worried about it. [2] [1] https://twitter.com/twobitidiot/status/1624563275760279554 https://twitter.com/twobitidiot/status/1624563275760279554 [2] https://twitter.com/ecommerceshares/status/1630287169330749443 https://twitter.com/ecommerceshares/status/16302871693307494...
- rt4mn 4y ago> the implications of bitcoin & cryptocurrency to let these systems grow & be harder to deal with has only gone up & up & up ever-more. While I agree the implications are concerning, I think its difficult to overstate just how much of a stranglehold the US regulatory and surveillance machine has over the global financial system. Trying to buy and sell things online without sharing your real name or address is functionally impossible for 99% of people (unless you are willing to break the law or learn how to use cryptocurrency). This is because the gatekeepers to the Internets finances (banks, credit cards, etc) are required by law to identify who they are working with. This makes a sort of sense until you zoom out and see the scope of the problem. Because it is impossible in 99% of cases to move money around online without using those gatekeepers, there functionally is no financial privacy online. I should not have to share my bloody name or address with anyone to order a god damn box of chocolate. > Ultimately we're far more tracked by corporations anyhow now, True, and thats very concerning and should be pushed back against. But when corporations collect data on you, the worst thing they do with that data (generally speaking) is not treat it with care and the data gets stollen / made public. When the government collects data on you, the worst thing they do with it (generally speaking) is throw you in jail or kill you. The scope of the concern is astronomically higher.
- Invictus0 4y agoCorporations can deny you credit, change your interest rate, increase your bail, close your account, refuse to do business with you, and generally make your life harder.
- forgetfreeman 4y ago"I should not have to share my bloody name or address with anyone to order a god damn box of chocolate." You don't. Get off your ass and go buy a box with cash. On the drive over meditate on who generally benefits when given the ability to move large sums of cash anonymously (hint: terrorist organizations, drug cartels, and tax dodging oligarchs).
- csydas 4y agoI think you're missing the point here. I'm not a crypto advocate, but Visa and Mastercard definitely have too much power as do most online transaction processors, and the amount of information that online processors collect (at the request and joy of governments) is quite scary. A select few organizations can control whether you can buy necessities or not and cut you off even from legally earned money on a whim. Banks have finite cash on hand which limits your mobility and liquidity at any given moment in the event of an emergency. Online commerce at this stage may as well be a secondary benefit given how your information is scooped up and resold to advertisers. Financial systems are quite convenient, there's no denying that, but they're extremely fragile and the system exists at the whim of a few select people. Visa and Mastercard have demonstrated they can effectively remove persons from modern civilization at their discretion, not even with official government requirements, and that this has not been challenges is really unsettling. To reiterate, cryptocurrencies are not the answer here in their current state, as they're too unstable and basically inherit not only all the issues that normal banks bring, but also introduce a ton of new issues. I don't know how to ensure sovereignty for individuals who are legally earning compensation when a support representative for banks can click on a checkbox and make them penniless. Nevermind if the company the representative works for is influenced by an unhappy government. Finance is terrifying, and we're really in a strange place where we don't have a good answer for ensuring individual sovereignty with any currency, crypto included. I stress over this because I'm less and less confident every year that there is a good solution for this besides eschewing Finance entirely (and that's quite the magic trick...)
- diordiderot 4y agoCrypto has been pretty unsuccessful at moving large volumes anonymously over a multi year timespan https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/60462182 https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/60462182
- yieldcrv 4y agoI think there are a lot of things that aren't tracked very well. Randomly pumped tokens/NFTs - even newly issued and pumped ones - are moving large volumes anonymously. You act like a random trader that caught the wave, but really you are also the addresses pumping the asset with the dark money that isn’t intended to be cashed out. The pumped addresses just wind up with the asset and will never cash out. Your KYC'd address just looks like a good crypto trader. A clean 8,000% gain doesn't look different than a dirty 8,000% gain.
- photon12 4y agoGot this message in my Discord message requests, from 13 hours ago: Yo!*Welcome to [redacted]!* What can we offer you We providing quality crypto pumps. *We share the name of target coin in advance.* *We are professional cryptotraders* And finally, we show you how to beat the market and be ahead of everyone. **This is your chance to multiply your investment together with the cryptocurrency market whales**! ** The amount of invites is limited! Hurry up to take your place there:** : [redacted]
- yieldcrv 4y agomaybe, but that's most likely a scam where you will be exit liquidity for the leader too. but people with the "dark money" can also pay similar kinds of groups. this happens in the stock market all the time too. if you have the dark money that you won't cash out, you can do it yourself pretty easily as well, you don't actually need to notify a crowd because there are so many bots that will join a pump of any token, and that will cause it to trend too.
- DennisP 4y agoA potential solution is to make small transactions anonymous, but break the anonymity for large transactions. Of course a large transaction could be broken into many small transactions, but it'd be much more cumbersome and expensive. For specific sanctioned entities, a possibility would be to let users specify a list of addresses they're not willing to share an anonymity pool with. Here's Vitalik talking about these ideas in a recent interview: https://podclips.com/c/K3RLE1?ss=r&ss2=ethereum&d=2023-02-28 https://podclips.com/c/K3RLE1?ss=r&ss2=ethereum&d=2023-02-28
- passwordoops 4y agoHere's a link explaining the original Panama papers, on which this work and detailed analysis is based: https://www.icij.org/investigations/panama-papers/ https://www.icij.org/investigations/panama-papers/
- iszomer 4y ago403'd.
- ypeterholmes 4y agoThe premise here is very solid- shut down the small number of people that the Oligarchs depend on, and their ability to operate is curtailed much more effectively than trying to attack the oligarchs directly.
- motohagiography 4y agoThe challenge with it is that this doesn't generalize to any shared principle and it's cynical realpolitik dressed up as network science. I'd argue this paper is less a work of scholarship than an example of collusive, astroturfed, agitprop, where even though russia's oligarchs are an easy target because they are still new money and retain the taint of trade from the corruption that produced their fortunes, the authors are casting aspersions on highly regulated businesses that provide the financial rails for investing and preserving pensions and sovereign wealth. The only reason you can insure anything or have long term financial instruments at all is because of special purpose vehicles that persist longer than the whims of a given regional governing party. These vehicles are infrastructure that provides financial stability for capital flows that facilitate social stability and growth. I remember the eurozone sovereign debt crisis', and to me the paper just looks like another (tawdry) setup for blaming "speculators and international financiers" for the failed technocratic policies of their peers own makings. The approach of "going upstream," is guilt by association, and it's unprincipled overreach. The paper is entertaining, and I'm glad that the networkX python library has become so accessible that social activists can use it, but I think we should hold the authors to a higher standard.
- CyanBird 4y agoFrom my naive perspective it almost reads that you won't be able to receive your money on the proper hongkong HSBC select account and are upset about it Reality is that tax dodging is a wildly out of control problem, and worse it is considered to be de defacto standard to even run a business at all. From south Dakota to the city of London and beyond. It is really a problem
- from 4y ago
- leashless 4y agoWe're looking for the "Goldilocks Zone" of privacy. We want: * Enough privacy that activists don't wind up facing death squads * Not so much privacy that drug cartels wind up running the country. The problem is that cryptography is all or nothing: for a given observer, the transaction is either private or it isn't. I'm fascinated by models like differential privacy. Maybe there are ways of making systems which snare large scale abuses but provably leave the minnows free.
- paxys 4y agoThere is nothing about the nature of privacy itself that leads to drug cartels running the country. There could be a world with perfect privacy and a perfect justice system where this wouldn't be a problem at all. Of course that isn't realistic, but the tendency should be to always trend towards more privacy and less corruption. Thinking that a private yet safe world isn't possible is a fallacy, because privacy itself isn't the source of these issues.
- gabcoh 4y agoSmall nitpick: it isn’t entirely true that cryptography is “all or nothing”. With things like time lock crypto and proof of work you can effectively have a scheme where large scale snooping is impossible (would take too much compute), but any individual transaction can be decrypted with a bit of work.
- nine_k 4y agoAh, I remember the times when the US only allowed to export 40-bit RSA in order to be able to do just this. As a result, non-US versions of e.g. SSL were not as secure, and quickly became laughably inadequate. Frankly, I think that was mostly silly: you can either keep some math completely secret, or deal with the situation when the adversary knows the math a perfectly as you do, and can implement relevant computation. Unlike building actual rockets, implementing relatively simple math is not rocket science.
- whatshisface 4y agoThe problem is the institutions writing the laws see it as, "enough privacy to allow us to deal with the Contras, but enough surveillance to stop activists from running the country." ;)
- mihaic 4y agoAfter being in the crypto space for a while, and thinking a lot about the problem of tracing money, I've come to the conclusion that the system I'd prefer would be a hybrid. Everyone needs a quota of anonymous spending, say $50/day, $1000/ month and anything after that is public on government ledger. I've mentioned this to a few friends, who've always called it dystopian, yet all alternate systems seems to be worse in terms of illegal abuse.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> a quota of anonymous spending, say $50/day, $1000/ month and anything after that is public on government ledger You're describing cash + digital money.
- hesdeadjim 4y agoYea, but cash isn’t very web3 now is it.
- Scoundreller 4y agoShhhh, no talk about our web4 plans
- paxys 4y ago1. This system is too complicated and messy, we need to throw it away and rebuild it from scratch. 2. This new system is so simple and works perfectly. 3. Hmm, it doesn't account for this one problem. Doesn't matter, we can just iterate and add in a special case. Repeat 3 a few hundred/thousand times. 4. This system is too complicated and messy, we need to throw it away and rebuild it from scratch.
- mihaic 4y agoYeah, I think the crypto keyword threw you off, I actually dislike the entire web3 space. I also do see change as inevitable, as that's what humans usually do. That's why I think we'd need to have actively describe some desired properties of whatever money will be in the future. Partial anonymity is one of them, but it's actually being eroded now: you can't order an Uber with cash or book an airbnb for a night with cash.
- berjin 4y agoEvery time I have to fill in some AML (anti-money laundering) form I think how much of a waste of time and money it is for every party involved since the real big fish are getting around it with professional help. It's all very kafkaesque and invasive so I come to the conclusion it's more about powerful governments existing to gain more power than it is about solving any injustice.
- majormajor 4y agoNothing will be 100% proof around evasion or exploitation. The answer isn't to do nothing and let it be a free-for-all.
- ted_bunny 4y agoIt's darkly funny how nearly every control mechanism in capitalist society equates to merely making a particular action more or less expensive.
- nine_k 4y agoVery unlike in historically known communist societies, where a mere bribe was not enough, you had to have access to a right person to bribe.
- tobyjsullivan 4y agoI think both sentiments have merit and are not necessarily mutually exclusive. Money stuff tends to follow power laws. The basic, beaurocratic checks probably dissuade 80% of offenders while only stopping maybe 20% of the volume. Doing nothing would leave those 80% of offenders free to launder which seems bad. Meanwhile, it seems fair to call the measures mostly ineffective. There’s also a cost to these measures. They frequently block or add friction for people just trying to do legitimate business. Is it worth it?
- notch898a 4y agoJust as likely IMO is that the 20% are using regulatory capture to stomp out the 80% and consolidate their business and create even more effective crime.
- spiritplumber 4y agoJust make it legal to eat oligarchs.
- doodlebugging 4y agoExcept you're focusing on the wrong part of the problem here. Most oligarchs are building huge wealth not only so that they can control their own existence without any interference but also so that their children will be able to enjoy that multi-generational wealth. They want to be seen as dynasty builders. The solution should be to eat their children instead so that, for them, we have removed the incentive to hold such massive wealth as there will be no one to inherit. We'd still need to make that legal though and figure out a good spice mix and vegetable accompaniment. These are not insurmountable problems though. The first thing can be handled by initially making it legal among societies with a known history of cannibalism since it would not be a stretch for them. It can be portrayed as them making an effort to rediscover their lost traditions. Documentary filmmakers can follow their journey of discovery and someone with an accent can do a dry narration punctuated with bits of inside jokes. Then, using the power of social media to brainwash on a huge scale we could normalize this deviance by portraying these cannibal societies in a flattering way, mentioning their cannibalism in an offhand way but emphasizing more their strong connections to nature, their local environments and their reverence for tropical sunsets, bright colors smeared on their body parts, and non-obvious astronomical alignments. We already see, every day, the power of advertisers and marketers to convince ordinary people to buy, use, or believe things that most of us understand are probably bullshit. Therefore we should begin by marketing these products to Americans. Employ those marketers to shift focus from pot legalization, where they have scored some wins after only a generation or two of effort, to reduction of financial crime and destruction of oligarchies by adding children of the oligarchs to the food supply. Congress and the FCC likely will, after appropriate levels of lobbying and graft, support legislation allowing televised commercials for products made from oligarch children to be shown during major sporting events and prime time TV shows. It will take a little money to make this happen but there's plenty out there for everyone and we can always just print more. Of course, products like this will see minimal market penetration in the EU without some serious corruption and catchy advertising slogans. Their regulators are tough and they actually test food products before allowing them to market. They have to make sure that a Russian oligarch kid product was actually produced by a Russian in Russia as per tradition. We know that Americans can be convinced that all those unpronounceable food ingredients in their food must be there because it's all either good for them or it's somehow organic. They've been conditioned by marketing to believe it's better than all the stuff they routinely ate before producers jacked up prices and added organic labels to their product lines. The EU is a bit more strict, disallowing all kinds of things Americans routinely consume. Therefore there must be considerable effort expended to shift perceptions of American food products and that is where the Linux fanboys come into the game. Their enthusiasm for Linux, in all thousand-and-one variants and obscure distros, has built a self-sustaining amalgam of business, government, and home users whose energies can be refocused to engender support among the general EU population for these children of the oligarchs products that their more discerning taste buds would typically ignore or reject. With appropriate marketing, some street demonstrations in selected cities, and careful product placement at events like info-sec hackathons and Oktoberfest, EU citizenry can become heavy consumers too of products like tubular meat sticks (with spices!). For any countries that reject these consumer products we can always send in the British. They've likely invaded the same countries in the past anyway and stirring up shit to rebuild empires makes as much sense as stirring up shit to build empires did. After all, they hauled William Wallace's preserved leg around as a show-and-tell example of what happens to someone who refuses to bow to their monarchy and ended up with an empire that stretched across every time zone. Biggest bullshitters anywhere. Bigger even than Texans and I'm a Texan so I know a bit about bullshit. This whole post is bullshit. There's no reason why they can't be the biggest salesmen for oligarch kid parts. We just have to make sure, as a global community, that we don't come close to running out of oligarchs or their children as the market could be huge with the right players pushing the products. Supply must always be balanced with demand or non-oligarch children like our own could become commoditized. Perhaps the industry would need to function in the homeopathic product space where infinite dilutions can be cleverly advertised to the clueless consumers as the perfect way to enjoy and benefit from the product. Maybe in the end we only need one oligarch kid, or just a toenail clipping, or like many over-the-counter supplements peddled to American consumers, we can simply list it as an ingredient but omit it entirely. We might not need any at all! Perception is key here and that is where the real power of advertising and marketing comes into play. No one ever checks anyway. Capitalism rocks and we all just roll (over). That's enough sarcasm for one post.
- anonymousDan 4y agoJust need to do the same to expose all the trust funds owned by our own oligarchs next...
- RobotToaster 4y agoIt's interesting how they're called "oligarchs" if they're Russian, but "job creating entrepreneurs" if they're American.
- FrontierPsych 4y agoHow do I meet these oligarchs and help them hide a tiny bit of their cash and I take a 1% fee per year on a piddling amount like $100 million? I love helping people, would love to help any oligarch out there reading this comment.
- FrontierPsych 4y agoAnyone can setup their organizations to use a LOT of ways to legally minimize their tax bill. For example, you can create a separate corporation in a non-tax state like Nevada and put most of your cash in it and if you are in California, you will completely not have to pay it if you do it right. See Apple Corporation's Braeburn Capital. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braeburn_Capital https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braeburn_Capital Apple uses this to avoid all California tax on that cash that they deposit in that company. California tax is 8.84%, and that is a LOT of money that they would have to otherwise pay. There are other things that one can do, but there's a lot of record keeping and expense so you have to make enough money to make it worth it. But just owning a company is a fantastic tax break by itself. You get to write off all kinds of things as an expense as long as it is for business purposes.