3 ms·
Another option no one has menitoned is AMP. Many sites that try to use "paywalls" have AMP URLs which point to pages that have all the full text of the article
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y ago
Another option no one has menitoned is AMP. Many sites that try to use "paywalls" have AMP URLs which point to pages that have all the full text of the article in <p> tags. These AMP sites generally look great in a text-only browser that does not run Javascript. Popular example is WSJ. In the URL, add /amp before /article/.
Paywalls are insidious because they target non-subscribers. Why let non-subscribers view articles. Why not password protect all subscriber content. Paywalls are a way to make money from (the attention of) non-subscribers, targeting them with ads and tracking. The strategy is apparently to annoy people to the point of subscribing. Yet even if they subscribe they will still be subjected to advertising. One potential advantage is that a paying subscriber has an enforceable contract. In theory the contract could contain enforceable privacy protections. "Tech" companies would never agree to give people enforceable privacy protections; it would destroy their "business".
The way to save journalism, especially local news, is to regulate "Big Tech" middlemen, who generally do not employ journalists and produce zero content.1 The quality of journalism in general has taken a nosedive, but placing the blame for that on web users not purchasing subscriptions is conveniently ignoring the true culprit.
1. Arguably that's a prerequisite to maintaining their Section 230 protection. In the recent Supreme Court oral arguments, Google's counsel argued Google is not a publisher. Then minutes later she argued Google has to make design decisions "like any publisher", therefore Google gets a free pass to reorganise information in annoying and perhaps harmful ways to maximise ad services revenue, like inserting "popular" videos into YouTube search results that have nothing to do with the query string.
- donohoe 4y agoBut the number of AMP versions is dwindling as Google is no longer forcing it.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y agoYep. And the browser vendor can make changes to DevTools, archive.ph is already privacy-unfriendly and blocked in some countries, it could disappear, 12ft.io could disappear, and so on. The fact that seems least likely to change is that most "paywalls" rely on Javascript, CSS or some other "feature" of so-called "modern" web browsers. I have lost count of how many times an HN comment alleges "paywalled" in a thread and I am reading the article just like any other because I am not using a graphical web browser. I would not even know there was a "paywall". Paywalls have dependencies.
- Scoundreller 4y agoMy 25 year old knowledge of lynx has come in handy too! While I’m sure some combination of plugins can do it, Tor is another go-to for me for paywall avoision. Too bad violoncello is no longer available in the iOS App Store.
- every 4y agoMy lynx is always at the ready for paywalls and other annoyances. My guess is that showing up using such an archaic tool implies you might also be using a screen reader setting like blynx [1]. The more thoughtful sites will even give you a link to jump directly to content from the top... [1] http://leb.net/blinux/blynx/ http://leb.net/blinux/blynx/
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y agoLynx was a program I used on the early www. In the early 2000s I moved on to something better. Without much effort anyone can have a static binary with better HTML table rendering that is significantly smaller than today's lynx. readelf -d links There is no dynamic section in this file. stat -c '%s' /usr/bin/lynx links 1894400 1276712
- basch 4y ago> maintaining their Section 230 protection There’s no such thing as maintaining protection. It’s not something you “lose.”
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y ago"Other proposals would have more broadly exposed providers to liability for hosting unlawful content, if the provider is aware of that content.318 For example, the Platform Accountability and Consumer Transparency Act (PACT Act) would have amended Section 230 so that certain providers lose immunity under subsection (c)(1) if the provider is notified about illegal content or activity occurring on its service and does not remove the illegal content or stop the illegal activity within 24 hours." "Proposals like the PACT Act would state that if a provider is aware of an unlawful post, it will lose immunity for a lawsuit premised on that specific post.334" "The CASE-IT Act would have taken a similar approach, providing that service providers and users lose Section 230(c)(1) immunity for a year if they engage in certain activities, including permitting harmful content to be distributed to minors, if the harmful content is made readily accessible to minors by the failure of such provider or user to implement a system designed to effectively screen users who are minors from accessing such content.337" "In the same vein, other bills would have caused providers to lose Section 230 immunity if they use algorithms to distribute content to users or display behavioral advertising.338" https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/R/R46751 https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/R/R46751