7 ms·
Britain’s biggest skills problem is that many firms don’t value them
- moremetadata 4y agoIts who you know, not what you know that count's in the UK. Introverts who prefer to stay anonymous and private because they value privacy, having contact with as a few people as possible, will always come off worse.
- LatteLazy 4y agoIt's vitally important that people get skills and get educated. Just not vitally important enough for any employer, government or other beneficiary to spend even £1 on it...
- some_furry 4y agohttps://archive.is/b2ZVW https://archive.is/b2ZVW
- KRAKRISMOTT 4y agoThe invisible hand will take care of them. Make sure not to hand out bailouts like candy again.
- daniel-s 4y agoBasically this. Companies go bankrupt or shrink in size if they do things like undervalue staff skills. Stop rewarding bad behaviour with bailouts.
- skippyboxedhero 4y agoNo-one got bailed out, that is actually part of the problem in the UK. The US cleverly bailed out key firms, let the really troubled ones fail, and had no disruption to growth from financial disorder after 2010. The UK acquired the same firms, went full ham on regulation, and there has been massive corporate deleveraging because most banks don't really do corporate lending anymore. However, any firm that did have existing finance relationships was grandfathered in. Rates fell, and so these old inefficient firms have largely survived hoarding both labour and finance (the UK also has a disproportionate number of very unproductive family-owned firms). The UK is the textbook case of finding the absolute worst thing to do at the worst time. I wouldn't say the issue is necessarily bailouts but regulators (and particularly the BoE) not understanding that the financial cycle plays a role, that bureaucrats shouldn't be intervening into management decisions by banks, that fiddling the price of money has trade-offs...I agree, but the decision to bailout is a product of beliefs that continued to damage after 2010 (and this was far less the case in the US, the bubble in tech stocks/SPACs/etc. demonstrates that the system is still alive...this didn't happen in the UK).
- AtlasBarfed 4y agoBecause the invisible hand squeezes out the indolent rich?
- precompute 4y agoThe invisible hand supports, and does not strangle! We are far past "Capitalism".
- docandrew 4y agoThere’s the story of a manager who starts booking expensive training courses for his team, and another manager says, “but what if you spend all this money on training and they take their new qualifications and leave the company?” to which the first manager replies, “and what if we don’t give them any training, they stay low-skilled, and they stay?”
- jamisteven 4y agotbh I hate this approach of up-skilling / free trainings, all they are really after with this is squeezing every last bit of juice out of you so they can continue to consolidate job roles and make you do more with less, instead of hiring SME's for specific things, they have a jack of all trades working on an endless amount of items that use to require a team of 10+ people to do. Especially in tech roles.
- alexpetralia 4y agoDoing more with less is the point of productivity growth (which is a function of upskilling).
- yawnxyz 4y agoIf a company could already hire / poach an upskilled worker, wouldn’t they already have done so? (From other countries)
- ben_w 4y agoThey might try, but people with useful rare skills can get away with asking for more money during job hunts, and that's not always the case (or at least not so soon) for existing employees. (I'm hypothesising wildly, this isn't necessarily accurate).
- mytailorisrich 4y agoIf it's really expensive training then it's not uncommon to mandate that the employee must stay, say, 2 years afterwards or repay the training's cost pro-rata. In any case, people leave because they are unsatisfied and/or underpaid so if the company has that covered attrition will be low.
- halabarouma 4y agoAlmost two thirds of London businesses are struggling to fill vacancies, while UK firms prepare the biggest pay rise in more than a decade to deal with the continuing skills shortage.
- cactus2093 4y agoI just can't take any discussion of "skills" seriously that equates skill to some formal certification or degree. As a software engineer, basically all the skills I use to do my job on a day to day basis are things I've learned from experience, or informal mentorship from other engineers, or reading blog posts on programming practices and then applying those things and seeing what works and what doesn't. But to an economist none of this counts. A 24 year old that just started their first job after getting a masters degree in CS is considered objectively more skilled than someone with an undergrad degree and 10 years of experience.
- rippercushions 4y agoThe article is talking more about blue collar work like warehouse workers and lorry (truck) drivers.
- acatnamedjoe 4y agoThis isn't really true. The article talks about apprenticeships. While traditionally apprenticeships in the UK were mostly for blue collar work, these days you can do apprenticeships in almost anything: software engineering, law, medicine, management, etc. The full list is here: https://www.instituteforapprenticeships.org/apprenticeship-standards/ https://www.instituteforapprenticeships.org/apprenticeship-s...? Top 3 on the list: Space systems engineer, accounting finance manager, robotic systems engineer
- sosull 4y agoI would think that software engineering is the exception that proves the rule: people with domain knowledge are highly motivated to share what they know, ask questions, consolidate knowledge, and refine processes using the Internet. Working in another field (public services might be a good example) it’s often not possible to test out hypothetical solutions, or find relevant expertise, or to even discover that whole areas of knowledge actually exist. In that context, relevant qualifications have a little more weight.
- MonaroVXR 4y ago
- iamflimflam1 4y agoThe problem seems to be that there are a large number of jobs that just don’t need skilled staff. How much training do you really need for a lot of jobs? The answer is that these low skilled jobs should be eliminated by more automation - which is great - but then you need to find a lot more higher skilled jobs for everyone to do.
- Spooky23 4y agoWhen it’s time for employee development, you hear that argument. When it’s time to hire, you want someone with 40 years of rust experience, who is under 30, and is a 20x rockstar.
- chank 4y agoYes, but they're also trying to eliminate the need for high skilled jobs as well or at least send them to countries where they can pay less.
- dan-robertson 4y agoI think it basically has to go the other way around: somehow demand for the labour of the people currently doing this low-skill has to go up, pushing the cost up, incentivising automation. This argument somewhat assumes that automation isn’t currently incentivised much, but I think that’s false; I guess there must be other reasons for more automation not happening… The price of low skill labour in the US has been increasing, I think. I don’t know if that’s because of increased demand or reduced supply or something else though.
- Nextgrid 4y agoOne problem with automation is that the people in upper management themselves rely on having lots of people to manage. Getting rid of those people puts their own position and standing at risk. Also, we don't yet have humanoid robots with full feature-parity to actual humans, so automating some jobs might require a change of process to convert it to one that is amenable to automation - in doing so, it may arise that the entire process is pointless and this would obsolete the jobs of a lot of paper-pushers, raise an uncomfortable question and ultimately be a politically unpopular move. A second problem is that non-tech companies lacking competent in-house technical expertise will always choose to outsource it to a shitty consultancy which will take advantage of them, waste years and not deliver anything viable or cost-effective in the end.
- skippyboxedhero 4y agoProductive work and non-productive work largely pay the same. Almost all middle-earning but high-productivity jobs will have a legion of support staff earning almost exactly the same wage but doing nothing that is productive in itself. The only place I have found this not to be true is in finance, where there is a clear incentive to reduce operational costs in order to increase the bonus pool. In engineering, tech, healthcare (almost everywhere in local govt), actually acquiring skills is pointless (if you are able to nepo your way into a management role). That is how you end up with large numbers of over-qualified people simultaneous with low productivity. All the subsidies and incentives for firms to train staff make no difference, we have all the skills we need but the price of those skills is very low. The problem is management competence. Most managers are also unskilled, even managers with technical skill usually come into management after graduating not after working at a lower level. This kind of mismanagement happens everywhere but is the rule in the UK. The US is quite far from perfect, but the UK is not even close to this level yet. We are still at the level where the system is not working.
- AtlasBarfed 4y agoHot gptchat take of the minute: programmers are less threatened than middle management Imagine replacing middle managers with basically dictation and tracking personnel and delegatingdecisions and report to chatgpt.
- skippyboxedhero 4y agoA colleague who is non-tech but does light ETL work (this relates to the subject: only in the UK could they fail to hire someone to actually do this work properly) was propounding to me about the benefits of ChatGPT. He could ask it for Python or SQL, and he could just paste it in and it would do all his tasks. His conclusion was: programmers are getting replaced, and he will replace them. In reality, he will get replaced because all he is doing copy-pasting snippets. To actually build a full system that will slough away staff requires domain knowledge that a chatbot doesn't have. ChatGPT will come first for the people using it most now. I often think about starting a business-process outsourcing company in the UK. I know there are companies in Japan (also a country known for overhiring). But then you talk to managers about their processes, and you realise they genuinely do not understand anything about technology...it is just pointless, like trying to teach German to a chimp. The stuff you see in local govt/healthcare would bring people on here to tears. The local govt was trying to hire people to improve processes...their listed tech contained no programming languages and just included managed services. You see tech roles, and it is all the same: just managed services, no actual coding...it is incredible.
- renewiltord 4y agoThat's because these "skills" are useless and usually an indicator of someone who cannot deliver visible results. It's like how if you read that someone is an MSCE, it actually increases the probability they're a bad engineer.
- fadyfady 4y agoI don't think the problem is not requiring skills, it's instead the failure to pay for them. It's fine to hire people 'without skills' provided that you give people an incentive to get them-- i.e. you pay them more if they have skills, and a lot more. If it's well-known that workers with skills command high salaries, then workers will train themselves or acquire the certificates that bring those higher salaries. Britain's failure is in having bad compensation for workers, and being unwilling to give them incentives to acquire skills.
- onion2k 4y agoSoftware companies in the UK, and companies that employ devs as part of another business, are terrible at recognising the value that their staff represent. It's pretty much universally true across the industry here that you can't really work your way up in a company - progression comes from job hopping and pretty much nothing else. You can do all the training, certifications, and learning you like but it won't substantially change your employers view of you. It's a bit of a daft situation really. Companies spend far too much on hiring that could be going on wages. My wages specifically. :)
- itronitron 4y agoThat used to be the standard view of devs in the US as well, but has likely improved somewhat (hopefully) with the rise of Google, Apple, Amazon, Netflix, etc. This was brought home (pun intended?) to me back in 2015 when my wife and I were vetting realtors for the sale of our house. One of the realtors, actually an 'elderly' husband and wife, after being told (by me) that I was a software developer proceeded to share that they had retired from working in HR at a software company and went on with 'oh my, don't you know how crazy and entitled those ridiculous software developers are!' That wasn't their first misstep, and we went with a different realtor.
- mkl95 4y agoIsn't this a worldwide issue?
- cosmodisk 4y agoI think the problem is multifaceted: 1) Managers often don't know what skills people lack or how to take them a few steps up using new skills. Usually these are not the core skills people need to do the job. For instance, an accountant could do a decent job, yet only have basic knowledge of excel. The accountant's manager, depending on the complexity and the psce of the company,may or may not be aware of it. Everyone's happy the way it is. However, if the accountant knew Excel better, some tasks would take only half the time, whilst others could be automated and so. This is extremely common in a lot of companies 2) People don't want to upskill. Yes, I'm aware it's a blanket statement, however both as a manager and simply as a colleague, I found this to be the case. Very few,even if they are aware of the problem( e..g. skill shortage) try to address them. I can't count the number of times I told people to at least try to learn x, because their job would become much easier and they'd get more money. Nope, not interested.. Also, actively offering people time and access to learning resources don't seem to help much either.
- Nextgrid 4y ago> I told people to at least try to learn x, because their job would become much easier and they'd get more money. Nope, not interested How much more money? I'm frankly not sure there is any skill you can learn on your own (without full-time commitment and/or paid formal education) in a reasonable time that would make financial sense for a typical 50k/year office clerk to learn, at least not in the UK. The closest to this would be software engineering, but even then, it would take you ~10 years of experience to reach the level of a proper senior software engineer, and even that only gets you 80k on average in the UK - a sizeable chunk of which will get stolen by the taxman. 10 years of effort starting from scratch to not even be able to double your salary (and again, the net salary is even smaller, as taxes increase) is not a winning strategy. You're better off bullshitting and playing office politics to move up in the pecking order at your current company and increase your salary that way.
- cosmodisk 4y agoI offered people working in a call centre environment to learn crm administration: gradually, with all the support they may need, etc. We would have transitioned them into new roles once they gained some knowledge. The pay in new roles would have been higher than they'd ever get in the call centre environment. There are lots of things people can learn in a relatively short period of time that would benefit them. It may not be financial reward at first, but being able to draw the necessary insights, do things faster and more efficient are beneficial the many.
- Animats 4y agoNo, it's that they don't need them. From the article: "Some 23% of jobs in Britain require no more than a primary education...". About half of people in the US with college educations do jobs that don't require them. For most of the US population, college is not cost-effective. This is going to be a problem as the US is forced to get back into manufacturing in a big way by world events.
- aaomidi 4y agoIt’s almost as if we don’t need this many workers but capitalism provides no other way for people to feed themselves, so we end up making bullshit jobs to keep people alive. If jobs were a thing that not everyone had to do, and it drew in passionate people who really just want to do that work, not only would we have more efficiency and creativity. We’d also have more job satisfaction and probably even faster absolute progress. This situation is only going to get worse. Our economic system is very sticky and the expectation of everyone has to work makes people “feel good”.
- dan-robertson 4y agoWhy does the U.K. not need so many workers but the US does (as implied by low unemployment despite interest rate hikes and increasing pay for lower-paid workers who, presumably, do ‘bullshit jobs’)?
- aaomidi 4y agoThe problem exists in the US too. We just have so much more money so the problem is masked imo.