4 ms·
I propose that we refer to this class of behavior as “grooming”.
by hinkley 4y ago
I propose that we refer to this class of behavior as “grooming”.
- nonethewiser 4y agoWhy?
- junon 4y agoBecause it's influencing the behavior of a nuanced decision making machine (kinda) in order to do your bidding. I think grooming or "grooming attack" are great names, personally.
- ant6n 4y agoWhy not something related to sleeper cell.
- schaefer 4y agoThis might be a close fit in strict terms of technical usage of the word, but it’s a non-starter from the cultural context. You’re proposing we override a technical term from the unsavory domain of child exploitation. Please, can we not?
- hinkley 4y agoThat’s a bit reductive. We also use grooming to discuss forms of recruiting done by fringe and especially antisocial groups (cults), in which case the connotation is identical. If you’re going for AGI, then this activity is a form of abuse. If you’re not going for AGI, then we have a different problem, in that if we allow computers to make decisions without any human interaction, we’ve hamstrung the Rule of Law. There’s no “one” to sue for ruining your life. If human actors are ruining your life, that’s a crime, and should be treated as such. Even if the computer is the triggerman.
- junon 4y agoOr perhaps we can all accept that language is nuanced and that we can discern context like intellectuals?
- mtkd 4y agoMost people call it data poisoning, not sure why article didn't use that
- hinkley 4y agoWe need to stop describing horrible actions with wide reaching consequences in the passive voice. And we need to start socially punishing people who insist on doing so. Otherwise the wheels are coming off. Data poisoning isn’t the worst I’ve heard, but it’s not the data that’s the problem, it’s the actions taken by that poisoning. That’s the subversion that matters, not “the data”.
- jraph 4y agoIn what way is data poisoning in the passive voice? It's a nominal group. Pretty efficient and straightforward. Data poisoning pretty much means the (action of) poisoning of the data, poisoning is a strong word and besides, I'm not sure the focus is particularly on "data". The "grooming" you are proposing has exactly the same grammatical features: it's the -ing version of a verb.
- hinkley 4y agoBecause it makes it sound like I broke one of your drinking glasses instead of killing your dog. Data is an inanimate object. Misusing data affects Organics.
- austinjp 4y agoWell by that token, grooming might as well refer to combing your hair. That's clearly daft, though. In fact, its current usage probably first emerged in the 1970s in relation to child abuse [0]. Since then it's been hijacked by various right-leaning individuals and groups as a dog-whistle for whatever they happen to be most worried about today [1]. That makes it a heavily over-loaded word that's becoming a general fnord. The problem with fnords is that they discourage thinking. So I'm not in favour of using 'grooming' to refer to data/model poisoning. [0] https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0886260517742046 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/088626051774204... [1] https://www.edweek.org/leadership/why-misusing-groomer-as-a-political-smear-is-especially-dangerous/2022/04 https://www.edweek.org/leadership/why-misusing-groomer-as-a-...
- CodexArcana 4y agoWhy not a Manchurian Attack?
- badcppdev 4y agoI was going to say that I felt your suggestion was a little too obscure. But I googled and see they remade the movie in 2017 so maybe more people would get the reference.