8 ms·
High-skilled visa holders at risk of deportation amid tech layoffs
- joshka 4y agoIt's not clear from the article why the USCIS suggestion[2] to apply for a change of status is not a reasonable one. You can't work, but if you're in the highly skilled visa category, you reasonably should have a buffer of funds to handle this risk (and if not, that's generally your mistake rather than your employer's or the US government). Last I looked[1], the estimated processing time for my i539 change to a B1/B2 was 23 months (currently 13mo in CA, 19-29mo elsewhere), during which time I'm able to look for work, just not actually perform work as an employee. I didn't accrue unlawful status either. That's a lot longer than 60 days that is being complained about. If you can afford it, take a break, take some time to recover post-layoff, travel, live cheaply, focus on building things other than your career. The 2020s have been tough. It's worth it to remember that and come back to work refreshed rather than burnt out. 1: https://egov.uscis.gov/processing-times/ https://egov.uscis.gov/processing-times/ 2: https://www.uscis.gov/working-in-the-united-states/information-for-employers-and-employees/options-for-nonimmigrant-workers-following-termination-of-employment https://www.uscis.gov/working-in-the-united-states/informati...
- 908B64B197 4y agoThese layoffs are actually great for clearing some of pool of H1B recipient who, white frankly, shouldn't have been granted visas in the first place. Keep in mind that If I want to hire: A smart graduate from EPFL, Polytechnique or ETH Zurich who interned at CERN and has contributed to the Linux kernel for a software engineering job at a unicorn startup or A grad from a second tier "technical college" in India with a visa refusal rate of ~90% for a job doing manual UI testing and QA for a body shop [0]. my only path forward is H1! They'll both be listed as "computer related occupations" and apply for the same visa in the same quota. Does that make any sense to anyone? Of course, my odds of getting a lottery spot for the former are dramatically lower, since we all know body shops and consulting firms won't hesitate to file 4-5 applications per seat they plan to fill out (so one can hopefully get a spot in the lottery and not get any RFE). [0] https://www.nbcbayarea.com/news/local/silicon-valleys-body-shop-secret/78781/ https://www.nbcbayarea.com/news/local/silicon-valleys-body-s...
- dfgasdgsd 4y agoYes, but a lot of these layoffs are happening at the unicorn startups / Googles of the world, and these people generally map more closely to your former case. So this is just lowering the scale of the pool, but the ratio is probably unchanged - completely agreed on the need for reform.
- kjellsbells 4y agoI wonder if it could be used in the other direction: use a layoff to clear out old, expensive local citizen talent and fill the gaps with cheaper h1b or offshored labor?
- WirelessGigabit 4y agoH1Bs are time limited (6 years). And converting them to Green Card is VERY expensive.
- jltsiren 4y agoIt's more time-consuming than expensive. If you need labor certification because you don't qualify for EB-1, the entire process currently takes something like 3 years. And that's the ideal case, where nothing goes wrong and your priority date is current.
- WirelessGigabit 4y agoWell you can get advanced parole and a work permit while waiting your priority date.
- ashish10 4y agoyou make a point about offshored labor. But idea that H1-B talent comes cheaper is completely wrong.
- ldjkfkdsjnv 4y agoH1Bs work much longer hours and are willing to do alot of grunt work. They also have a harder time switching jobs. They absolutely drive wages down
- hardwaresofton 4y agoWhile I think it’s wholly in America’s best interest to keep most if not all of these people in our economy… This might be amazing for the countries they came from. Getting an unexpected repatriation of a bunch of previously drained brains and some capital is a nice prospect for countries that have (hopefully) matured and improved in the interim
- georgeburdell 4y agoThe social media app Blind, which is probably 50% Indian users now, is touting the “join a consulting company” route to staying in the U.S. i don’t know how viable it is.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- georgehill 4y ago> 50% Indian user Are you sure? According to Similarweb, most traffic comes from Korea. https://www.similarweb.com/website/teamblind.com/#traffic https://www.similarweb.com/website/teamblind.com/#traffic
- ashish10 4y agoMight be 50% of users in America is of Indian origin (H1-B Visa).
- user_named 4y agoKorean version is a different app
- aioprisan 4y agoThere's no demographic data to back up that claim.
- orange_joe 4y agoI've seen a few posts on blind that ask people their background that seem to follow that general percent. Obviously incredibly non-scientific.
- ageek123 4y agoAnecdotally, that stat seems about right.
- ravagat 4y agoThere's a huge gamification of these consulting companies
- xiaodai 4y agoCome to Australia please!
- litiholofan 4y ago[flagged]
- bhouston 4y agoI know it is a bit heartless, but this has a positive side to it. The current wave of layoffs are coincident with the rise of significantly novel AI algorithms that will create a ton of new opportunities. There are going to be 1000s of AI startups, more than there would have been without these layoffs. If immigration laws force highly skilled developers to return home, then many of those startups will be located outside of the US. This would be good for their home countries, and less so for the US. A personal tragedy for those who have build up lives here and will see that destroyed in a matter of months, but a net benefit for the rest of the world in the long run. It is things like this that reduce discrepancies between developed and developing nations - whether intentional or not.
- kerpotgh 4y agoEasy to say when it doesn’t effect you. Lots of things would be good for the world that would foist suffering on a small group of people but that’s not how we try to do things.
- bhouston 4y agoWell, I guess as a non-US citizen I have no control or influence on US immigration policy. I think it hurts both the US as a whole as well as the individuals involved. Cross pollination is incredibly important though. I've seen it in my personal experiences. Taking back Silicon Valley and other big company experience and operational knowledge back to their home countries and then applying it there is a massive benefit to their home countries's competitiveness.
- kerpotgh 4y ago[dead]
- inerte 4y agoAnd if their planes crash on their way home even better: - less jet fuel consumed, preventing climate change - the insurance money goes to underdeveloped countries, lowering income inequality - the VCs get a chance to reallocate their capital, thus leading a more market dynamics
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoCompanies that laid off employees in the United States should lose their H1B quotas for 5 years. If you got rid of workers, you shouldn’t be able to say you have a shortage and need to bring in more workers.
- bonniemuffin 4y agoThat seems clever at first glance, but I'm not sure it actually makes sense. If they laid off sales and recruiters, but need to hire software engineers, it's not like the sales people were fungible resources who could've just switched into software roles. It's very possible to BOTH have an excess of employees in one type of role, and still be struggling to hire a different (more difficult-to-fill) type of role. Maybe if they only lose their H1B quota for the specific types of roles they laid off, but that seems like it would be very complicated to enforce.
- post-it 4y agoI'm a Canadian software developer looking to work in the US in the next few years. If I work on a TN visa and get laid off, do I also have 60 days to find a new job or leave? Is it less of a hassle for a company to sponsor a TN visa compared to an H-1B, improving my chances of finding a new job compared to an H-1B holder? Also, when applying to US jobs that ask if I need visa assistance, should I say yes or no? Since my understanding is that I apply for the visa at the border, I just need proof of employment.
- hervature 4y agoYes, TN visa is extremely easy to acquire and one can have multiple TN visas at the same time to work for multiple employers. This is especially relevant to nurses who technically need a visa for each hospital they work at. I am currently on a TN and have had 5 in as many years as I jumped around employers. Each new one requires re-entering the US. One time I flew in from Brazil and got it at Houston when I landed. I have never been denied and happy to answer any questions. When applying, I would say it depends. For startups, it was mostly a casual conversation where I walked them through the process. For smaller places, I wouldn't say you need sponsorship until you talk with a human because no lawyers need to be involved. For large multinational companies, they probably deal with TN all the time so no problem there. EDIT: "Extremely easy to acquire" is doing a lot of heavy lifting. One has to have the professional credentials as required by NAFTA and a job offer in hand. I assume you have both of those things before looking to apply for a TN.
- 29athrowaway 4y agoIt's a temporary worker visa, not an immigrant visa. Same as H-1B and others. If anyone offered you any guarantee that you will be able to permanently stay in the US with a temporary worker visa, you are being scammed.
- hervature 4y agoFor Canadians, the TN is up to 3 years and can be renewed an indefinite amount of times. It's basically as close to permanent without actually being permanent. Plus, it gives you an indefinite amount of time to make connections and even realize if you want to stay before going for a path to permanent residency.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- blindriver 4y agoI sympathize as so much to say that I understand and I've been there as an H1B immigrant myself. One of my friends got personally deported for overstaying her H1B, and got a 10 year ban from entering the US. However, there was never, ever a period of time where any of these H1B holders were ever guaranteed permanent residency in the US. Not a single time in the last 20 years. Every single one of them KNEW what they were getting themselves into, and that not only could they get laid off at any time, but the road to a Green Card was extremely, extremely long (10+ years) and hard. I personally helped one of my best friends get his Green Card after 10+ years of waiting (he's Indian). But at no point was he under any belief he was owed anything. He hated the situation, but he knew exactly what he was up against, and the same goes for every other H1B holder. So, it sucks, but it's part and parcel with the privilege of working in one of the best countries, in one of the best paying jobs in the world. None of these H1B holders are owed anything, and if their 60 day timer runs out, yes, they will need to leave. And I fundamentally disagree with increasing the number of GCs for Indians. The Indian body shops have completely exploited the H1B system by inundating H1B applications, which is why it is so heavily overrun with applicants. We should not reward this bad behavior, so just let everything work itself out over time, without rewarding the bad players.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> None of these H1B holders are owed anything They are owed common decency. They are owed a responsive government that gives them the ability to plan their lives. The whole idea of giving employers control over their employees’ ability to stay in a country is perverse. > We should not reward this bad behavior, so just let everything work itself out over time, without rewarding the bad players. We should fix the system so “bad players” cannot exploit it.
- blindriver 4y agoThey are given a tremendous amount of generosity. Once they are in the GC process, they can extend their H1B indefinitely, something that wasn't available when I got my GC. The spouses are eligible for an EAD, meaning they can work whatever job they want. They have 60 days to find a new job. They can buy houses, they can job hop, they have a lot of flexibility considering that they aren't citizens. There isn't a single Indian H1B holder that doesn't know they need to be here 15+ years to get their GC and if they get laid off, they need to find a job quickly. And yet, they still gamble on it. Very often they win and get their GC. Sometimes they lose and they have to go back to India. It sucks, but they signed up for it. The US doesn't owe them any sort of guarantee besides the flexibility and generosity that they already give them.
- graymatters 4y agoWhy the tech visa holders are any better than any others, with the same or similar visa? Time to return some sanity to the hiring processes of the US tech world.
- Tomis02 4y agoIt's rough, but it's a personal choice for a TECH WORKER to move to a country with draconic immigration conditions. If you brought your family over then you should be ready to leave the country at a month's notice. Understand that you're not really wanted in that society, even for a tourist visa you may have to jump through a lot of bureaucratic hoops depending on your country of origin. There are other countries with friendlier visa conditions. You may have to learn a new language but you'll probably have a more stable and predictable experience. But if you chose to go to the USA and subject yourself to the H-1B uncertainty, then live with that choice.
- Beaver117 4y agoFWIW it's even harder to immigrate to Europe than the US
- Tomis02 4y agoCould you elaborate, please?
- Beaver117 4y agoMost European countries just have very strict immigration rules. The US is actually on the easier side. That's what I've heard.
- Tomis02 4y agoI find it hard to believe that the US would be on the easier side. There's no direct path from H-1B to Green card, for example. But if you pick Belgium or France, you can get citizenship after 5 years of legal residence. Germany has a requirement of 7 years. Sounds like a lot, and it's a real hassle, but at least there's light at the end of the tunnel.