9 ms·
Business Insider says 97% of the Russian army is now committed to Ukraine.[1] That leaves the central Russian government very vulnerable to its own internal sep
by Animats 4y ago
Business Insider says 97% of the Russian army is now committed to Ukraine.[1]
That leaves the central Russian government very vulnerable to its own internal separatist movements, of which there are rather a lot.[2]. Some of those movements are in areas landlocked or not economically viable, but the Free Ingria movement (Leningrad oblast, including St. Petersburg) has potential. That area is bordered by Finland, Estonia, and the Gulf of Finland. An independence movement there could be well supported from Europe. Something to think about.
There's no part of Russia bordering Ukraine that Ukraine could take as a bargaining chip to trade for Ukraine's own territory. There's nothing but farmland and mountains. Which is why this war is so stuck.
[1] https://www.businessinsider.com/97-of-russia-army-in-ukraine-uk-intel-defense-putin-war-2023-2 https://www.businessinsider.com/97-of-russia-army-in-ukraine...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Separatism_in_Russia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Separatism_in_Russia
- hammock 4y ago> Business Insider says 97% of the Russian army is now committed to Ukraine.[1] The UK defense minister said this. https://www.bbc.com/news/live/world-europe-64634760 https://www.bbc.com/news/live/world-europe-64634760
- bigdict 4y ago> Free Ingria […] has potential No, it's a toy movement. > There's no part of Russia bordering Ukraine that Ukraine could take as a bargaining chip Transnistria could play precisely that role.
- notahacker 4y agoDon't really see Transnistria as remotely useful as a bargaining chip. Sure it's propped up by Russia and would eventually be integrated into Russia under Putin's wildest imperial fantasies, but it's not Russia, its people mostly aren't Russian and I'm not sure it's all that valuable either. All a Ukrainian invasion of Transnistria would do is give Putin's claims about Ukrainian aggression some veneer of legitimacy and annoy Moldova, which doesn't want to see something which is constitutionally part of their territory fought over and then bargained back to Russian control...
- pydry 4y ago>its people mostly aren't Russian They basically are. They speak Russian and act like Russians. I doubt they'd mind being annexed.
- RivieraKid 4y agoI've recently read that only about 30% identify as Russians.
- bigdict 4y agoYeah, the largest ethnic group. The largest ethnic group in California is Latinos. What's the issue?
- RivieraKid 4y agoI think your assumption that people who say they're ethnically non-Russian are basically Russian and would be ok with annexation by Russia is wrong.
- bigdict 4y agoWhat is that thought based on?
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>They basically are. They don't have russian passorts. How can they be russians?
- bigdict 4y ago> They don't have russian passorts. You clearly are not familiar with how things work in Transnistria.
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago
- anextio 4y agoThe Russians have shown that they don't care about holding territory in the short term, see Kherson withdrawal, etc. They are only focused on attrition and minimizing their own casualties. If Ukraine goes into Transnistria it will not force Russia to capitulate.
- meheleventyone 4y ago> “They are only focused on attrition and minimizing their own casualties.” ??? That’s errr... going poorly.
- anextio 4y agohttps://meduza.io/amp/en/news/2023/02/17/close-to-15k-russians-killed-in-ukraine-since-start-of-invasion-identified-through-open-sources https://meduza.io/amp/en/news/2023/02/17/close-to-15k-russia... An investigation via open sources by the BBC and Meduza (an anti-Putin media outlet based in Latvia) has confirmed the deaths of about 15k Russian soldiers since the start of the war, and estimates the true number to be up to 60% higher. What sources do you have that the widely reported media number of 200k+ is actually true that doesn’t ultimately come from the government of Ukraine (who would have an interest in over-inflating their victories) or by a western government that is militarily supporting Ukraine?
- andrewflnr 4y agoThe sources I'm seeing that say 200k include injuries. Combined with your source on actual deaths, that puts injuries:deaths at around 10:1, which sounds right.
- meheleventyone 4y agoYes like I said... err... that’s going poorly.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> An investigation via open sources by the BBC and Meduza (an anti-Putin media outlet based in Latvia) has confirmed the deaths of about 15k Russian soldiers since the start of the war, and estimates the true number to be up to 60% higher. Where do you get the estimate of the true number? Your cited source only has the count of the named individuals identified, not anything corresponding to your claimed total KIA estimate. (Also, the investigation was published, as you linked, by Meduza, but conducted by the BBC and Mediazona, not the BBC and Meduza.) > What sources do you have that the widely reported media number of 200k+ is actually true that doesn’t ultimately come from the government of Ukraine (who would have an interest in over-inflating their victories) or by a western government that is militarily supporting Ukraine? Who else (besides sources with opposite biases, like official Russian sources – who haven’t provided casualty estimates since September) would have the kind of information necessary to make a meaningful estimate? (Also, the most commonly cited figure, which is sourced to the UK Ministry of Defense, is “up to” 200,000 casualties, with 40,000-60,000 KIA, not 200K+ KIA.) But even if we go by that confirmed-by-name count as the full count of KIA, it roughly matches the Soviet KIA in Afghanistan, which was instrumental in the collapse of the USSR, so, going quite badly.
- gerikson 4y agoIsn't Transnistria legally part of Moldova? Russia can't trade that away against Moldova's wishes, and even if it was to try , it would be against the international law that made the invasion of Ukraine and annexing its territory illegal in the first place.
- bigdict 4y agoInternational law is for client states.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Transnistria could play precisely that role. Transnistria isn’t part of Russia and Ukraine isn’t going to take it from Moldova.
- bigdict 4y ago> Transnistria isn’t part of Russia It is controlled by Russia. > Ukraine isn’t going to take it from Moldova. What is that based on?
- dragonwriter 4y ago> It is controlled by Russia. And Ukraine obviously supports the Moldovan government’s opposition to that condition, but Ukraine isn’t going to unilaterally invade Moldova to fight Russians while its got plenty of Russians in Ukraine to deal with.
- bigdict 4y agoWhy are you so certain? Have you heard of the Cobasna ammo depot? It would be mutually beneficial to Ukraine and Moldova if Ukraine were to gain control of that depot and then cede back to Moldova.
- gerikson 4y agoIt would be like gaining control over an unstable nuclear reactor. https://www.arnika.org/en/hotspots/moldova/the-largest-illegal-arms-depot-in-eastern-europe https://www.arnika.org/en/hotspots/moldova/the-largest-illeg... Cobasna is a huge problem in waiting but it's not an urgent problem. The real solution is for Russia (as the Soviet Union's biggest successor state) to handle the cleanup and reparations when the region is handed back to Moldova.
- miguelazo 4y ago[flagged]
- luckylion 4y agoThe "just surrender and become one with Russia" diplomatic solutions? Are those solutions final?
- scohesc 4y agoIt really does seem that way... I think the west is using Ukraine as a way to whittle down Russian military forces at the expense of Ukrainians and "Allied" military equipment (instead of some theoretical war where the US send their soldiers _and_ equipment on the field, and the resulting PR nightmares, etc. that would cause) - essentially weakening Russia's military to a point so that Russia can't respond as aggressively to western expansionism or continue to meddle in western affairs as strongly as they have been. I wish the west would stay out of conflicts it doesn't have a stake in, and I wish Russia would stop attacking Ukraine. Unfortunately mentioning the former makes you a "putin-apologist" even though there's more than enough things to attend to in the west instead of sending trillions of dollars overseas and continuing to fund the industrial military complex - almost like it's a convenient excuse to help distract people how much they're getting screwed over at home - but that's getting into conspiracy theorist territory, which I'd rather not go down. The fastest way out of the war is negotiation unfortunately. It's only going to get bloodier as both sides get more desperate to win...
- fabian2k 4y agoThe Ukraine is in Europe, it is on the borders of the EU. And there are other former members of the Soviet Union that are now part of NATO and the EU. This is absolutely a conflict we have an enormous stake in. Do you think we should not help Ukraine, and not supply them with weapons and leave them to fend for themselves?
- JohnFen 4y ago> I wish the west would stay out of conflicts it doesn't have a stake in I think there's a solid human rights reason to be involved in the way we are. But even ignoring that, I also think we do have a stake in this. > The fastest way out of the war is negotiation unfortunately Russia wants no negotiation that doesn't result in them stealing territory from Ukraine. You can't negotiate with that.
- yucky 4y ago> An independence movement there could be well supported from Europe. Something to think about. The absolute irony of this line of thinking.
- andrey123 4y agoLast time I checked there was more than 1 million in internal forces (militia, rosgvardia, troops, probably some others). They are armed, trained specifically to suppress and loyal. I (looking from the inside) highly doubt that they will change sides unless they stop receiving paycheck. Of course, some regions are a bit special in this respect but they are not in the central Russia.
- RivieraKid 4y agoWhat is the mood regarding the war in your social circle? How often do they support it?
- andrey123 4y agoZero war support across friends/colleagues but maybe up to 30% support on the streets (taxi drivers, cashiers, mechanics, neighbors, ...). In small cities there shall be more supporters (less Internet, more TV).
- pshirshov 4y agoI really doubt it's "zero". I've quizzed many many people I had connections with and literally all of them support the war up to some extent. The most common opinion is "we shouldn't have started this but we should win this war and take over Ukraine and Poland". It would be really strange to count such opinions as "anti-war".
- andrey123 4y ago> I've quizzed many many people I had connections with and literally all of them support the war up to some extent. I would have reconsidered my approach to making connections if that happened to me :)
- miguelazo 4y agoIf you’re on HN in Russia, writing perfect English, you are no doubt part of a certain class.
- risyachka 4y agoRussia is a military state. They have about a million of police and other military forces inside the country. And internal separatist movements are so tiny you can handle them with 1/1000 of the force they have.
- TylerE 4y agoThey also thought they could take Ukraine in about the time it took Hitler to blitz into Poland.
- foverzar 4y agoThat is an assumption.
- andrewflnr 4y agoIt's the hypothesis that ascribes the least idiocy to Russian military command, compared to, say, deliberately wading into a multi-year attritional struggle. As much we may think they're fools, they're probably not that stupid.
- foverzar 4y ago> deliberately wading into a multi-year attritional struggle I don't understand how people expect anything different here. Even the US with all it's superpower fanciness spent years in Iraq and decades in Afghan. I am also skeptical over that whole "my opponent is more stupid than me" attitude. We can already see how people made fools of themselves spelling Russia's haste economic demise, while Russia is expecting an economic growth now according to the World Bank. Idiocy would be setting unrealistic expectations and treating this like a computer game, when a well-fortified Ukrainian army at the Donetsk border (that Zelensky was inspecting a few times in 2021) would somehow de-spawn or vanish in case Russia would hastily take Kyiv.
- andrewflnr 4y ago
- vondur 4y agoI would be more worried about the Caucasus's. Chechnya is run by a dictator with Putin's backing. I have a feeling that Ramzan Kadyrov will have the be very careful moving forward. I can't imagine he's well liked in Chechnya.
- pshirshov 4y ago> vulnerable to its own internal separatist movements Frankly, you have no idea about what's actually happening there. All these "movements" are nothing and the only potential sources of real separatism are the regional governments. Though there are multiple measurements in place to make that impossible.
- skissane 4y ago> Some of those movements are in areas landlocked or not economically viable, but the Free Ingria movement (Leningrad oblast, including St. Petersburg) has potential. That area is bordered by Finland, Estonia, and the Gulf of Finland. An independence movement there could be well supported from Europe. Most successful independence movements are based on some kind of distinct ethnic/national/cultural/religious/linguistic identity. “Ingria” is a historical term, coming from a time several hundred years ago when the area was ruled by Sweden and populated mainly by Finnic and Baltic peoples. However, the vast majority of its current population is ethnic Russian, and the Finns and Balts are now only small, highly assimilated minorities. The vast majority of its population don’t identify as “Ingrian”. That does not seem like a successful basis for an independence movement. I think the most likely place for renewed separatism is Chechnya. Not right now while Kadyrov and Putin are so close, but if something happened to one (or both) of them, or if they had a falling out, it could easily start again. And spread to Dagestan, Ingushetia too, maybe even the entirety of Russia’s North Caucus region-in most of which ethnic Russians are a minority. An Islamic separatist movement is likely to find international support and funding from the Islamic world.
- Gunnerhead 4y agoObviously you’re not a fortune teller, but I’m curious of where you think Tatarstan falls into this, given it’s a majority Muslim republic too.
- skissane 4y agoWell, it’s a lot more plausible than “Ingria”, given it has a distinctive language/culture/religion. On the other hand (1) it is some way from an international border, making successful separatism less plausible (unless, of course, the border were to somehow move closer); (2) ethnically, it is over 50% Tatar, with a Russian minority of about 40%. Assumably the Russian minority would oppose separatism, with great potential for inter-ethnic violence, genocide, partition, etc. By contrast, Chechnya is over 95% ethnic Chechen.