9 ms·
4-day workweek trial
- alldayeveryday 4y ago[dead]
- f1yght 4y agoI'd be interested in a study that looked at 5x6 or something similar. Sure there's 1 less day to the weekend but those shorter work days allow you to do more after work.
- ghaff 4y agoThat sounds like a recipe for working more hours and severely curtailing being able to do activities with other people. My main objection to the 4-day workweek is it optimizes for people who want a shorter workweek with a possible tradeoff of curtailing the ability to take big chunks of time.
- aetherson 4y agoWorking a 30 hour workweek constitutes "a recipe for working more hours and severely curtailing being able to do activities with other people"?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ghaff 4y agoYes. Because people end up working extra hours on the days they're working, especially if they have a commute, and they just have the overhead of getting settled in the now 6-day workday. Furthermore, weekends are the time a lot of people get together for activities.
- vineyardmike 4y ago> in the now 6-day workday I think its 6 hours for 5 days a day not 5 hours for 6 days a week. I agree with your point that when people do work on a day its easy coerces them work longer hours that day.
- ScoobleDoodle 4y agoI read it as 5 workdays for 6 hours each. I think this is what they meant. It appears you read it as 6 workdays for 5 hours each.
- ghaff 4y agoI think you are correct. I was thrown off by the one less weekend day but I think that was relative to a 4-day work week--not the status quo. I'd still rather than the 4-day week and/or just more vacation days in general.
- danaris 4y agoThat contradicts f1yght's note that "there's 1 day less to the weekend". It's possible they're misunderstanding how 5x6 is intended to work, but they are the ones who introduced it to the thread.
- f1yght 4y agoMy comment was relative to the 3 day weekend of the 4 day workweek
- aetherson 4y agoI think they were contrasting the number of days in the weekend to the other possible reduced hours proposal: 4 days, 8 hours (so 3 day weekends), and suggesting 5 days, 6 hours (2 day weekends, one less than the alternative).
- rootusrootus 4y agoThat sounds awful. I'd rather have 3x10.
- f1yght 4y agoDifferent priorities for different people, I don't mind doing a few hours but really value having time to exercise, cook, and have general free time. I don't think 10 hour days would leave me with much time to do the things I want every day.
- rootusrootus 4y agoI agree, everyone will have different priorities. A ten hour day still leaves me around six hours of awake time, so I could fit everything else I wanted into that time and then enjoy the heck out of the four completely open days I had left.
- benji-york 4y agoI don't have a study, but an anecdote: for the last 18 months or so, I've worked 32 hours a week. Originally, I thought I would work 4x8, but as time went on, I really enjoy working 5 or 6 or 7 hours a day, depending on my desire and the work needing to be done. It's really nice to be able to not set an alarm and just wake up and work whenever you're ready or be able to take an afternoon off and take the kids to the park if you feel like it.
- graeme 4y ago> That was all while companies reported revenue largely stayed the same during the trial period last year and even grew compared with the same six months a year earlier, according to findings released this week. It’s really too soon to tell the results. As long as you don’t shut down, most companies’ revenue is affected more by what they did in the medium term past than the recent past. Are there any metrics of productivity that companies could track which would be forward indicators rather than lagging indicators?
- debarshri 4y agoI know people who are happy working for 80h a week when work has purpose. I know people who work 4 days a week and they hate their job and are unhappy. I think hours don't matter, you should give freedom to your employees and make sure they enjoy and find purpose in work they do.
- yamtaddle 4y ago> I think hours don't matter So you think the article's mistaken that these workers are happier with reduced hours?
- PhasmaFelis 4y agoThat doesn't mean hours don't matter, it just means that hours aren't the only factor, which should be obvious. I don't doubt that there are people who are happy working 80h at something they love, but most people are not like that.
- hbrn 4y agoUnfortunately there's not enough work in the world that has purpose. Someone has to do the dishes.
- stinkytaco 4y agoDoing the dishes has a purpose, but I still don't want to spend 80 hours a week doing them, especially not at the rates it would pay. Lots of meaningful work is also quite hard work that has an upper limit even if it is purposeful.
- bradreaves2 4y agoI worry about publication bias with these studies. If a researcher finds the counter-intuitive results that working less leads to equivalent or better outcomes, it will be a headline. If a researcher finds that working less leads to getting less work done, who would publish it? It won't get media headlines, but even scientific journals will not accept the results.
- waboremo 4y agoYou would have to quantify why less work being done is an inherently bad thing to humanity.
- snapcaster 4y agoWhat? No you don't. Each individual firm uses their own metrics to decide these things. How would one even measure or quantify a "bad thing to humanity"?
- waboremo 4y agoContext is important. What's being discussed is general work week trials, and the idea that nobody would publish a paper that demonstrates working less = decline in work done. Individual firm metrics are useless to even bring up here.
- HEmanZ 4y ago(Almost) No one would argue that working less for the same exact output is worse than working more. That flies in the face of the most basic ideas in economics. The question is finding the balance, work that produces productive things people value. And it turns out, free market economic systems are pretty good at democratically converging on answer.
- corbulo 4y agoCan you define what that means without using socioeconomic-class terms?
- wahnfrieden 4y agoseems to somewhat validate graeber's bullshit jobs thesis
- hackernewds 4y agoUnfortunately the goal for most companies in a capitalist structure is not "employee happiness". It's "revenue growth" or "shareholder returns". It's romantic to think they coexist, but in a practical sense they don't intersect at the optimal solution
- whiplash451 4y agoTrue. But there are infinite ways of working out this tradeoff. Some companies are examples while some really aren’t. If you can’t be a good example, you’ll just have to be a terrible warning.
- vineyardmike 4y agoYea, thats why proving that a 4 day week doesn't impact "revenue growth" is important. It removes an argument companies can have against legislature to push it, or employee demands. Even something simple like google giving out free food increased employee happiness which translated to revenue growth from better workers. So it's not obvious that a 4 day week can't work, and at some companies a 4 day week could probably.
- ghaff 4y agoWhat I see from people I know at different companies is that Friday--and especially Friday afternoon--has sort of gotten normalized as a sort of wind down into the weekend day. Minimal number of meetings. People catch up on some reading. Stuff like that. People aren't fully off in general but they're cleaning up from the week, getting organized for the next week, and maybe closing their computer early. So, while most companies aren't on a 4-day workweek, a fair number have at least some percentage of employees who are on sort of an informal 4+ schedule.
- HEmanZ 4y agoEven 10 years ago, while working at an online marketing agency, we started “happy hour” every Friday around 1pm. Many people unofficially left the office at noon. This was just considered “casual fridays” which sort of translated to “work if you want”. Now I work for a company that doesn’t have official 4 day weeks but it’s well known you can tell your manager you won’t be working most fridays and so long as your productivity is reasonable, managers are happy to oblige. So it’s “4 day workweek if you want it” I think ya, a lot more people work 4 days per week than any data collection would suggest
- reidjs 4y agoI work at a full remote company in a similar situation. On the record, yes we work Friday, but it’s silently accepted you don’t make sweeeping changes to our products and organize intense meetings on Friday. And if you take a half day, nobody will judge you as long as you’re Not blocking anything important
- kiernanmcgowan 4y agoOne thing that I've experienced is making Friday a "non essential work" work day. Its a day to do small tasks that have piled up over the week, do some clean up, and otherwise try and figure out what the next week looks like. What made this really work IMO is that if someone needed to sync on something or get a context download Fridays became the day to do it because no one would have an excuse to not do some knowledge sharing. Toss in grabbing lunch and coffee with other coworkers and it ends up being a great way to build company cohesion and foster cross-team/org relationships. And, if you decide to leave after lunch to play tennis no one is going to give you the side eye.
- dalmo3 4y agoMy cynical view is that those people were happier because they were in a privileged position while the rest of society still functioned regular hours. Make 4dww universal then ask them again after every service they use start taking 20% longer, being 20% more expensive, their favourite restaurants closing down from the lack of staff, longer lines everywhere from the increased demand for leisure and reduced supply. It could work but it's far from obvious to me.
- baal80spam 4y agoIt's not a cynical view, it's a realistic one. People (obviously) don't want to see negatives of a shorter work week.
- tehf0x 4y agoDude if my restaurant choice being reduced is the cost of everyone having a nicer life I think we've already reached a pretty clear conclusion.
- dalmo3 4y ago> if my restaurant choice being reduced is the cost of everyone having a nicer life Your words, not mine.
- drewcoo 4y agoThe article said that productivity increased. How did this "20% tax" appear? Or are you saying that shorter work weeks will be an excuse to price gouge? That's valid. Any change seems to be an excuse to price gouge.
- dalmo3 4y ago> price gouge Price discovery. It's basic supply and demand. How can you cut short the supply and don't expect an increase in prices? Only if you assume a correspondent decrease in demand - again, as I said, not totally obvious to me. If anything, more free time would lead to more demand for services.
- atleastoptimal 4y agoAll this 4 day workweek hullabaloo really cements the entitlement of modern capitalist grievance discourse. Of course this won't affect restaurant workers, nurses, retail employees, deliverypeople, sanitation workers, migrant farmers, or any blue collar work that can just shut off 3 days a week and not cause any issues. Before you decide whether you deserve a 4 day work week, think about whether the people who wait on you daily deserve a 6 day work week.
- eat 4y agoIt seems silly to make this argument specifically regarding time when we've structured our society in such a way that certain people's time and labor is more valuable than other peoples'. Why not apply this logic to say restaurant workers, nurses, retail employees etc. deserve to make as much money as software engineers? Not that I'd disagree with that. Personally, I think it's absurd that someone writing JavaScript for an advertising company for a few hours a day should make more money than a nurse.
- pc86 4y agoNurses make a lot of money, especially the more specialized and senior ones. CRNAs make more than most software developers. Just about any NP will make over $100k/yr. It's kind of weird to group them together with the retail employee making $9/hr folding shirts or the server making $3.75/hr plus tips at some dive in the middle of nowhere. We do this weird thing in the US where you are tied so intrinsically to what you do for a living that it's become taboo to say the objectively true (and I would argue, very obvious) thing that some jobs are worth more than others. It's not a bad thing that one person gets paid $200k/yr to type JS into a computer and someone else gets paid $9/hr to fold clothes at Boscov's. It's because anyone can walk in off the street and start folding clothes with no training. That isn't making any comment on the people behind those jobs, just the jobs themselves.
- ScoobleDoodle 4y agoHow about they hire more people at the new “full time” and it applies to everyone. Happier employees and happier customers.
- jjice 4y agoI worked at a startup that did a four day work week. It was awesome for the most part. The problem is, they would rely heavily on the four day work week to be able to pay less in salary, which is completely fair and very worth it to a lot of people. The issue came in when they pretty much explicitly told people they were expected to work on Fridays anyway, defeating the benefit of the four day work week, but allowing them to keep salaries lower and put "four day work week" on job listings. They've threatened to get rid of it multiple times, claiming it's still a trial period (over a year of having it), which is fine, but they don't mention that it's a trial at all to new hires. I know a lot of the company that would leave in a heart beat if they got rid of it since it was a such a big part of why they chose the job. I left, got a more interesting job that paid a lot more and they kept trying to get my to stay by referencing the unlimited PTO they gave me but I didn't use (less than a week taken in two years) and the four day work week that I hadn't taken advantage of since I joined. Needless to say, I got a big raise and I work the same amount that I did before. An extra day off is absolutely additional compensation and is worth a significant amount. It's just that in my (small sample size and limited) experience, it's used as a crutch and there were pretty much expectations that you work on that extra day, negating the time off. I hope most other four day work week companies don't do this and I just had a bad draw, but that's my anecdotal experience.
- kadomony 4y agoSounds like Bolt.
- tehf0x 4y agoSounds like that was simply not actually a 4-day workweek company! My experience working 4-day workweeks (Thursday evening desktop goes off, corp phone gets left at desk) is brilliant, especially mixed with full remote, I would likely give up more than 20% of my salary to have this permanent 3-day weekend! (Shh, don't tell HR)
- jwestbury 4y agoI tried multiple times at multiple companies to negotiate an additional month off per year in exchange for a 15% decrease in compensation. I pointed out that giving me 8% of a year off for a 15% decrease in compensation was a pretty good deal. Nobody ever bit, unfortunately. Not even any counters.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoI would like it if media labelling of this sort of thing always talked about hours as well as days. A shift from a 40hr, 5 day workweek to a 32hr, 4 day workweek is utterly different than a 40/5 to 40/4 shift.
- ghaff 4y agoI'm not sure it is. For a lot of people here, an ostensible 8-hour workday and an ostensible-10 hour workday are probably not a lot different especially if they're working remote/hybrid.
- AndrewDucker 4y agoThey really are if you have kids. I basically wouldn't get to see them during those 4 days. Also, 10 hours really is more than I can consistently do. I'm tired by the end of an 8 hour day. I can do longer days when necessary, but my productivity is not going to be as high if it's every day.
- renjimen 4y agoIt's so strange to me how opposed to 4 day work week most of the comments here on HN are. It seems like the main grievance people have is how businesses will be affected (despite the study showing negligible or positive impact), while downplaying or ignoring the huge quality of life improvements reported. A business is just a lifeless entity with very little meaning, while your time is the single most meaningful thing to you. Why on earth wouldn't you be singing the positives of this study?
- corbulo 4y agoBecause you can find a study saying almost anything today. We live in an information rich world. It causes people to favor their anecdotes more. My question is, are a lot of the 'benefits' simply because people are contrasting it to a 5 day work week? Much of the logic i'm seeing about 4 day work weeks could be applied to a 3 day work week once people get used to 4 days. I'm not seeing anything unique about 4 days that makes it objectively superior. The main argument I see is less work=greater morale, so lets work less!
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 4y agoLess work leading to greater morale with negligible impact on productivity highly suggests that the extra workday is bullshit and should be done away with. Maybe that's also true of three days? I'm all for trying it. If it isn't, fine, that's a good argument not to do it.
- corbulo 4y agoOr maybe there are other relationships at play? Could it be not because its the 5th day, but because its the 'final stretch' to the weekend and would therefore apply to any final day of any workweek? In my experience, i've seen the same behavior before holiday weekends. Should workweeks be 3 days on this evidence? Should workweeks be dictated by productivity on the final day? Why? Is 50% productivity better than 0? Should the only important consideration about a company be morale? Should morale be directly tied to quarterly earnings? Why or why not?
- parpfish 4y agoI think that overall these are good numbers, but I have to push back on the claims about the 4-day workweek improving employee retention. I'd guess that the benefit is due to the fact that the competing offers would force you to go back to 5-day-weeks. i.e., in a world where everybody had 4-day work weeks, we wouldn't necessarily see less job-hopping.
- ljp_206 4y agoI'm curious if anybody knows of any 'practical guides' to the four day work week, or toolsets that can help traditional organizations make four day work week a reality. We hear about the 4DWW so often now, but I'd love to actually see how it's done - to be able to bring some suggestions to leadership at my company on how we could actually do that without doing a top-down audit of the company. Of course lots of things are going to be unique per org, but are there any "If you do this, do this instead" that can make the transition easier, or indeed even a feasible thing to broach with coworkers and executives?
- nunez 4y agoBetween this and the major push to work from home, it's almost as if people in tech and similar industries are willingly sprinting into replaceability and driving salaries down. While remote work and four-day work weeks are awesome, these will absolutely incentivize leaders of big companies to find cheaper labor in other countries that are plenty fine with working a full five-day work week. This is great for lifting a lot of people and countries out of poverty but doesn't help the family of four paying down a huge mortgage. Some leaders will (smartly) realize that it makes no sense to pay employees less just because they are available remotely for fewer hours of the week, but big companies run everything and crush views like this eventually. Interestingly, I think this will nullify the remote work movement while permanently decreasing average compensation.
- qup 4y agoIf a four day workweek is better and leads to better outcomes, I cannot help but wonder why there are virtually zero companies implementing it. This would seem particularly effective for hourly employees, where you could supposedly expect to get 90-100% of the same work output, only pay 80% for it, and not change the timeframe on which it's delivered. It would be a huge competitive advantage given how big of an expense payroll is.