3 ms·
The solution to obesity is a lifestyle change, or dealing with the underlying (psychological) problems. I'm all for aiding people in their lifestyle changes, th
by jeroenhd 4y ago
The solution to obesity is a lifestyle change, or dealing with the underlying (psychological) problems. I'm all for aiding people in their lifestyle changes, through medicine or other means, but there is no drug that can fix obesity. Medicating obesity is like taking pills to make smoking healthy.
This is just the next step in the ultimate dream, losing weight without putting in effort necessary. If you need to keep taking pills to keep your healthy weight, you're just suppressing symptoms of something bigger.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoThis is about as helpful as saying the solution is to pray more. You're not wrong, but very few obese people are willing/able to do it. > Medicating obesity is like taking pills to make smoking healthy. This is wrong though. Eating is not unhealthy. Overeating is. These drugs stop people from overeating.
- jeroenhd 4y agoI've never met anyone who just managed to lose lots of weight and maintain their healthy weight all by themselves. Combating obesity requires huge changes to one's lifestyle, with months or even years of feeling (slightly) hungry as a side effect. Very few people have such discipline. It's not a measure of willing, it's about access to treatment that isn't a nice, quick, profitable pill that you end up hooked on.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoBut that's the point... These drugs simply make you less hungry. They take what was the herculean task of eating less than your body urges you to and turns it into feeling totally stuffed after 1000 calories a day. It's no longer a question of willpower or suffering all day feeling hungry.
- azan_ 4y agoOh yes, weight loss has to have this moral purity where it is achieved through pure willpower, otherwise it does not count.
- jeroenhd 4y agoThis isn't about morality. Quitting any addiction is objectively difficult and most people need several attempts before it sticks. I have no illusion that you can "just" lose weight. Making people chemically dependent on a drug to keep themselves healthy is optimising for the wrong solution. It's quick and easy but it mostly serves to keep insurance and drug company profits up. I certainly believe that these drugs can be useful as a means of gaining an intermediate result (which can significantly reduce the immediate risk of many diseases) during treatment, but that's not how people treat them; people treat them as a magical fix for obesity and that's simply not healthy.