5 ms·
I've been that guy. It's hard to have fun in the modern "you will be FORCED to lose 50% of the time" matchmaking systems, compared to the small communities of t
by mrguyorama 4y ago
I've been that guy. It's hard to have fun in the modern "you will be FORCED to lose 50% of the time" matchmaking systems, compared to the small communities of the past. When I loved playing Halo 1 on the PC, you could actively chose how you were feeling that day, whether you wanted a very competitive match, or whether you just wanted infinite rockets with no shields so everyone's bodies are flying all over. You could have a relaxing game of chaotic fun, or you could load up a giant map sniper duel, or a very classic sidewinder CTF that requires teamwork and cunning and individual talent to make things happen.
Instead, every single game now is optimized for streamers, content creators, and a small "Professional" scene. So now, when a single popular youtuber wants a meme gun, the devs add a powerful slug to the double barrel shotgun and a red dot sight, so that youtuber can make a highlight reel of headshotting people across the map with a damn shotgun while throwing the entire tactical part of the gameplay out the window. The community spends 6 years complaining about a tactic that is basically just spawn camping, and the publisher gives radio silence, but there's a weird, niche tactic using your favorite character in the pro scene that is SLIGHTLY better than random in effectiveness, and you better believe that character is getting a hard nerf.
Now I boot up the game, and if I have a good match where I did better than expected, the system responds to that by putting me in a much harder game, where I'm expected to lose, because that 50% win rate must be ENFORCED. Even if you constantly improve at the game, you just get put in front of more and more talented people, wiping out any joy you might experience from your improvement. Meanwhile, you continually get destroyed by 12 year olds that don't have to cook dinner every night and have plenty of time to hone their skills. These systems are even implemented in """Casual""" game modes, which are then full of pro players on new accounts making youtube highlight reels.
So yeah, excuse my old man anger, I just literally lived through a better time. Right now it is impossible to sit down with my friends and enjoy a PVP game together, because casual multiplayer has been thrown to the wolves, often in service to memes.
- metalcrow 4y agoHow did the older games actually accomplish this? I would guess that if you just throw people into a match at random, on average half are going to be better then you, and half worse. So random matches will end up a 50% win-loss anyway unless you're especially good or bad at the game (compared to the rest of the population). So if most of the game's playerbase is kids who can afford to play 12 hours a day, normal people like us would likely get worse then a 50% loss rate with the random system!
- aidenn0 4y agoMany games didn't have a global list of servers, so you just connect to a server you know. Even games that did have a global list of servers, one wouldn't necessarily always play on random servers, but have some favorite servers (often ping-based, which means geographically local, to some degree) and play on those.
- scrlk 4y ago> How did the older games actually accomplish this? Using Counter-Strike as an example: no matchmaking system - relied upon community hosted servers offering a wide range of game modes (official and community created). More competitive matches (pick-up games) were often found via IRC.
- Tool_of_Society 4y agoYeah I had a whole slew of servers saved that I would regularly play on. If I was in a serious try hard mood I had a selection of servers I'd check. If I was in a half as I'm drunk and want to play I had a group of servers for that. If I wanted to play the warcraft 3 mod I had servers for that too. Even had servers for off the wall stuff talked about above. Now I dunno...
- usrusr 4y agoWith the consequence that games were suffering through a much harder sink or swim in terms of popularity: the matchmaking puts the threshold for "sufficiently popular" much lower. I'm not happy about the matchmaking, but there isn't really an alternative.
- hnick 4y agoYou would generally choose a server based on ping and population (many of which had custom maps or rule sets - like no sniper rifles in CS 1.6) then choose a team, but only if they had equal players otherwise you had to go to the one with fewer. In the servers I played at least, the better players were generally expected to swap teams if it got too one-sided. Otherwise people just get annoyed and go to another server. Admins would enforce rules around server culture just as readily as anything else. Persistent servers mean they can have distinct cultures and you get your favourite servers and start to notice the regular players. This doesn't happen with matchmaking so much. And I think the point about the 50% win rate is important - I am a person and my mood and skill varies day by day, but ranking stats are measuring the account not the player. Some days I wanted to stomp noobs, some days I wanted a challenge, and some days I wanted to turn my brain off and run fy_iceworld. You could also change your name at will if you were worried about your reputation due to any of the above.
- vel0city 4y agoIt kind of sounds like a good bit of the issue you see is that you end up with an about 50% win rate on large timescales. Isn't this kind of an ideal outcome though? Its not like its statistically possible for the majority of players to have a >50% win rate. Wouldn't you having a higher than 50% win rate essentially mean other players have a lower than 50% win rate?
- mrguyorama 4y agoNo, the ideal outcome is not a 50% winrate. The ideal outcome is to enjoy the time I spend playing. That is entirely disconnected from how good or bad I do on a given day. The way my friend plays Rainbow Six Siege gets him killed every single time without fail. But following "the meta" is really not fun for him. Instead of being able to find a community where we can play with people who might not be as bad at the game as us but are interested in everyone having fun, he gets thrown into the same generic "Casual" pool as everyone else, including kids who play 24/7 and streamers on smurf accounts building a highlight reel. There's no room for playing around, for trying different things, for just playing unoptimally. If you do anything not in "The meta", then you lose, repeatedly, and then the system forces you against literal children to ensure you win often enough to keep that 50% winrate. Like I said: In the past I could choose when I wanted to have fun, be lighthearted, and screw around by joining more casual servers. Then if I wanted to be competitive, I could join a more serious server, with more strict rules and systems, and play against both people much better than me, and much worse than me at the same time. Now you have no choice, because everyone is in the same pool, so if you don't play "the meta" or do something nonstandard to have fun, you will be crushed, and then placed against terrible kids, and then placed against really good kids, over and over again. There's no room for casual gameplay because the "casual" section of matchmaking isn't casual. The most fun we ever had playing Siege was getting a group of 8 people together to play "custom" games. The variability of skill was a huge and important part of the experience. We knew we had to carefully balance the teams for things to not be absurd, and we knew that playing "the meta" wasn't the best strategy in this case because you couldn't assume your teammates to play like perfect robots, giving you the freedom to try different strategies. This is also why people get so damn angry when you don't follow the meta and play like a perfect robot who has memorized all the strats, because if you don't, your team will most certainly lose. You could enjoy games you were bad at in 2001, because game design wasn't so aggressive about "perfect matchmaking" and "perfect competitiveness". I don't want my fun afternoon game to be a damn esport.
- Gordonjcp 4y ago> whether you just wanted infinite rockets with no shields so everyone's bodies are flying all over I did a Quake mod a bit like that, infinite rockets with massive explosive damage that did very little to your health but blew you right across the map. You could take about four or five direct hits from a rocket if you were pinned somewhere but mostly you'd take falling damage from bouncing the hell off the skybox. Yes, it was stupid. Yes, it was more-or-less unplayable. Yes, it was as fun as it sounds. I should resurrect that, if I can still find the code.
- mrguyorama 4y agoI forgot to mention in that example that it was infinite rockets, infinite grenades, no shields (so basically one hit), on beaver creek, Halo 1's smallest map, that was probably a couple thousand square feet total, with 32 players. Absolute, wonderful, fun for a while, chaos.
- pie_flavor 4y agoThis is, ironically, one of the best reasons to try a battle royale game like Apex Legends. Once winning at all is put far out of reach, the psychological aspect to losing vanishes and you can have fun purely with gameplay. The extent of SBMM in a chaotic anything-goes game like Apex is one lobby for KDRs below 2.0 and one lobby for those above, and despite firmly being in the 'below' range it's never gotten old.
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoBut winning 50% of the time on average in 1v1 is the absolute sweet spot of matchmaking. It means you are always facing a fair challenge. Winning easily is just boring. Plus if someone is winning in excess, someone has to be losing in excess too. I don’t understand the part about 12 years old. The game naturally shifts you towards players of your level. If you get destroyed, next game will be easier. Seems like you somehow feel entitled to winning. Sorry but I think you might indeed be that guy. You are basically complaining that you don’t want to compete. You can play a solo game if that’s the case. They are perfectly good fun.
- sdnas211 4y ago> It means you are always facing a fair challenge. You'd think that, but no. From my experience in overwatch, the system tends to favor win and loss streaks instead. You'll get 4-5 wins in a row, where the enemy team had no chance. Then 4-5 losses where your team was hopelessly outclassed. Maybe you'll get a couple of games that are close and feel fair. But not many.
- Aeolun 4y ago> Seems like you somehow feel entitled to winning. Well, yes. If you spend hours and hours playing the game, I can imagine that at some point you feel like you should be getting better than most people. This was definitely true for dedicated servers anyway.
- Rychard 4y ago> If you spend hours and hours playing the game, I can imagine that at some point you feel like you should be getting better than most people. I'm sure they feel the same way.
- runnerup 4y agoSo, with the old system. If you sucked you knew you sucked and it was okay. Now there’s no feedback. You can suck and convince yourself you’re awesome, and everyone who is awesome still thinks they suck, except the top 5-10 players in the world. I personally like matchmaking, but I get it. Sometimes I want to play people who are way, way better than me and “suck”. Like I used to.
- amanwithnoplan 4y ago> if I have a good match where I did better than expected, the system responds to that by putting me in a much harder game, where I'm expected to lose No, the system puts you in an easier/harder game, where you're expected to play _with and against_ people of your skill level (including if you want to play strictly meta or if you want to play with only one hand or whatever). I've been playing one of the most popular (for PC anyway) online game for 10+ years now and it only has skill-based matchmaking, in both ranked and casual mode. While plenty of people rail against the fairness of its matchmaking, I've rarely heard anything against the concept of skill-based matchmaking. It's the only kind of matchmaking that makes any sense to me. Why would I want to play against people that are way better/worse than me where I have no chance to have a good game either way? While my friends no longer play it regularly, when they used to play we'd just... play however we wanted in casual mode. Why does it matter if some people are better/worse or meta/casual? You can play the most random stuff you want and you eventually get matched against people of your skill level. Or if you don't enjoy the current match for whatever reason (winning/losing too much, or trying too much/little), just go next and let matchmaking do its thing until you get games at your level, wherever that level happens to be. If anything, your complaints sound to me like the developers care too little (rather than too much) about competitive balance/integrity across the entire playerbase.
- bobthepanda 4y agoThe way this used to get solved, was that people hosted servers, and there was always an empty one lying around for people who wanted to play with their own group, or you could just go figure out if you liked the particular server community or not. Then game companies took total control, made you play on their servers and introduced all these problems.
- vel0city 4y ago> when they used to play we'd just... play however we wanted in casual mode. Well, when you're on a 5-person team on Counterstrike and your fifth player doesn't want to buy guns and even try to complete the objective, they just want to run around and knife chickens and hide in corners the whole game, it can be a little frustrating to the other 4 players. Like, I get its casual, and you shouldn't necessarily expect everyone to always try as hard as they possibly can to win, but when one person not even trying to do the objective of the game it sours the experience for the other four. But this is kind of true of any team-based game. Imagine playing Spades or Rummy where your teammate is just always purposefully playing junk and never even trying to play their hand properly. Or a baseball game where whenever the second baseman gets the ball he just throws it up in the air to himself and never bothers to get the runner out. Or baseketball where one person on the team just wants to try and spin the ball on their finger instead of playing the game. If you're trying to actually play the game, its going to be frustrating having a player like that on your team. In causal its definitely forgivable to make mistakes and try something different, but if you're just in a casual match to sniff the proverbial flowers in the game you end up ruining the experience for your teammates. Ultimately in a team based match-made game all players really should at least try and observe the objectives of the match to some level, at least in my opinion.