3 ms·
I don't quite understand. Are people suggesting that congress considers legislation primarily based on campaign contributions and that this is the same for bot
by jiggy2011 15y ago
I don't quite understand.
Are people suggesting that congress considers legislation primarily based on campaign contributions and that this is the same for both main parties?
So they will only go against legislation proposed by lobbyists if they feel the votes they would lose would outweigh the benefit of those contributions to their next campaign?
If that is the case then I'm sorry to say but your entire government system is not fit for purpose.
If that is not the case then you should be able to beat these bills with good reasoning and debate alone.
- api 15y agoIt is the case. The U.S. congress basically runs on payola. You can buy any bill you want.
- jiggy2011 15y agoIf that is true then I'm amazed that a credible 3rd party has not yet surfaced that vowed to reform politics. Assuming even a half competent set of politicians they would be able to do an objectively better job since they would consider things on merits rather than contributions. Why do you need so much money to run a campaign anyway? Surely you could get the word out online and take donations from the public. Of course you would really need 2 parties so people could express their left or right wing beliefs.
- TheSOB88 15y agoI don't understand your points at all - and your last sentence sounds ironic. Should I be taking you at face value? Anyways, your 3rd party situation has one pitfall: how would it get into power? The 2 party system's devisors have us beat; nobody believes an independent can even get elected. There's an enormous barrier to entry.
- jiggy2011 15y agoNo not intended to be ironic, just badly worded. What I meant was that I am surprised how important campaign contributions are in an age where it is fairly cheap to get your message across online and get people talking. After all the London riots were an example (albeit not a pleasant one) of how social networking etc can very quickly get people to take action. Hopefully you could get enough contributions from private citizens and small business to run an effective campaign. Regards the 2 parties point. It would be difficult to create a third party that would appeal to both liberals and conservatives so in reality you might need a 4th party also. I assume your suggesting that people wouldn't vote for a 3rd party because the media would tell everyone that they were unelectable and a wasted vote? Unfortunately I don't really have an answer for that question, the only way around it would be to hammer home just how bad the current system really is.
- TheSOB88 15y agoIt's not that the media "tells" you that; though they do. But that's just a reflection of the current state of mind of the populace. People "know" this "fact", that a 3rd partier basically has no chance. I mean, look at Ron Paul. He's completely different from the normal Republican; by all rights he should have been in a separate party. But he wouldn't have gone very far with that. He had to stick with the big party to see it through. The problem is that Republicans and Democrats just have too much power. They have critical mass, and nobody else does.
- sophacles 15y agoIt is exactly what they are suggesting, because that is how it works in the Land of the Free[1]. Bills are usually written by lobbiests, paid large sums by the entrenched industries, and sponsored by congressmen who received large donations from the industry. Unless there is a real threat to votes (aka job security) these are passed. The only things that get serious attention and debate are the ones where 2 industries are fighting via congress proxies. Sad, but true. [1] Free is not an absolute scale, but proportional to the amount of money you can spend - e.g. lots of money means more freedom to pass laws, to get out of trouble, to buy licenses to do restricted things, etc.
- nextparadigms 15y agoI think "approval voting" would help weaken the 2 party system, and eliminate the need to vote for the "lesser evil" in elections: http://www.electology.org/approval-voting http://www.electology.org/approval-voting
- scott_s 15y agoAs I've said elsewhere in the thread, I think many people get the motivations confused. We don't have to assume that the politicians are voting on bills based on how they think the lobbyists will contribute to their next campaign. Rather, you only get to talk to people in Congress if you make campaign contributions. Those contributions get you into parties where you have a chance to talk to the person in Congress. The tech industry does a poor job of lobbying. For that reason, only MPAA and RIAA lobbyists have been talking to people in Congress. Imagine a random person who did not understand the internet and technology in general. Now imagine that they had, over the course of many months, only ever heard the RIAA and MPAA explain their side of the issue, and had never heard tech people explain the other side. How do you think they would vote? We don't need to assume a calculation of "If I don't vote yes on this bill, lobbyist Joe will not give me any more money." It's sufficient for them to think "Lobbyist Joe made a lot of sense when he explained this issue to me. I'm going to vote yes." Lobbyist Jane, who would explain why this issue is a terrible idea, does not exist.