6 ms·
How to Engineer Buildings That Withstand Earthquakes
- zepearl 4y ago> Many seismologists thought the East Anatolian Fault—the one involved in the Turkey-Syria quakes—was likely to produce a maximum magnitude of 7.4 or 7.5. But the February 6 earthquake was a 7.8—about four times bigger on the logarithmic scale of earthquake magnitudes. So it is possible that some structures built to code in Turkey may simply have experienced more force than they were built to withstand, Taciroglu says. There were probably some such cases, anyway this is as well interesting: From https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/erzin-turkey-earthquake-building-collapse-construction-codes-rcna70733 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/erzin-turkey-earthquake-b... : The city that didn't collapse: How Erzin became a haven from Turkey's earthquake - Residents and officials say Erzin suffered no deaths and saw no buildings collapse, and they credit a long-standing policy not to allow construction that violated the country’s codes. From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erzin,_Turkey https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erzin,_Turkey : Erzin was the sole district of Hatay Province to have none of its buildings collapse in the aftermath of the 2023 Turkey–Syria earthquake, despite being closer to the epicenter than other cities such as Iskenderun and Antakya which suffered greater damage. The mayor, Ökkeş Elmasoğlu claimed it was due to strict construction of housing; the district mostly consists of single houses, local authorities prohibited unsafe and substandard construction to a much greater degree than nearby areas, and apartment blocks do not have many floors. Even older structures such as houses from 60 years ago survived the earthquake.[4] Additionally, the city had fared relatively well during previous earthquakes. However, engineers and scientists (such as Omer Emre) attributed the town escaping unscathed to geological factors, such as Erzin's relatively higher sea level compared to surrounding towns, and it being built upon harder ground, consisting of bedrock and coarser grains than sand, compared to softer, water-laden sediments like that of cities to the south.
- mc32 4y agoFollowing strong building code certainly helps. However, I feel we'd be remiss to not investigate the geology of the different places. Are they similar, different, one alluvial one on bedrock? Seeing the iconic olive grove have a 30 meter collapse, I'm not sure what kind of building would survive that upheaval, unless the pilons went deeper than that into bedrock.
- mlinksva 4y agoI feel we'd be remiss not to read to the end of a paragraph: However, engineers and scientists (such as Omer Emre) attributed the town escaping unscathed to geological factors, such as Erzin's relatively higher sea level compared to surrounding towns, and it being built upon harder ground, consisting of bedrock and coarser grains than sand, compared to softer, water-laden sediments like that of cities to the south.
- nico 4y agoTalk to engineers and contractors in Japan and Chile. They have very good recent experience with their buildings withstanding some of the most massive earthquakes in recent history.
- LegitShady 4y agoThis article does a very poor job explaining what its headline claims its going to explain, and even a better article would benefit 1000x from pictures or illustrations.
- Aeolun 4y agoI don’t think it even attempted to explain anything… This is nice: https://youtu.be/7eO23oeXJlw https://youtu.be/7eO23oeXJlw
- LegitShady 4y agoThere are other ways engineers deal with the lateral forces from earthquakes - base isolation (as mentioned in your video), dampeners (as shown in your video), shear walls, braces, and engineered moment frame connections that stiffen the whole structure. shear walls, braces, and moment frame connections are a lot more common than base isolation and dampeners, especially for smaller buildings.
- Aeolun 4y ago> shear walls, braces, and moment frame connections are a lot more common than base isolation and dampeners More common, but much less interesting to look at :)
- rr888 4y agoThe main problem is the average wage in that part of Turkey is a few thousand dollars a year. In Syria of course is a fraction of that. You just aren't going to get Japanese/Chilean/Californian quality construction.
- ravel-bar-foo 4y agoThat also means engineering, management and labor for construction are much reduced in cost, provided you can find domestic engineers working at domestic salaries and management which isn't corrupt.
- dhikapow 4y agoIf labor is all that we have to worry then yes. But building materials prices are almost the same everywhere, so they still wouldn't be able to afford it
- franciscop 4y agoDefinitely not, a 2x1m plywood board in Tokyo cost ~$50, while the same one back in my hometown of Spain is $10 (despite the average wages being the same in both countries).
- prpl 4y agoI think you might be overestimating Chilean quality/economic circumstances. The big difference between Chile and Turkey is that larger earthquakes than that happen regularly all through the country (every two years at least) - and much larger ones one every decade.
- martynr 4y agoFrom experience of NZ quakes, wooden buildings seem to survive well. Aside from the flexibility of wooden vertical load bearing posts, the typical weather board / external wooden slat construction which is widely used in New Zealand allows for the narrow boards to slide independently under the lateral shaking forces. The external walls can deform into trapezoid shapes more effectively - hence a higher threshold for catastrophic damage and better future usability. Brickwork chimneys, internal plasterwork and the subsurface conditions are another story but a least the dwelling is still functional :/
- EdwardDiego 4y agoTe Papa is rocking some sweet tech. https://www.tepapa.govt.nz/quake-braker https://www.tepapa.govt.nz/quake-braker
- WalterBright 4y ago> the flexibility of wooden vertical load bearing posts I know you didn't write this, but lots of people think that the flexibility works because it "absorbs" the energy of the earthquake. It does not. What it does is spread a short sharp move into longer but lower amplitude move. The energy imparted is the same.
- wiredfool 4y agoUltimately, it's: Ma + cv + kx = 0, the differential equation for damped harmonic motion. M, C, and K are matricies/tensors that can change over time as damage occurs, x, dx/dt, and d2x/dt2 are time derivative vectors of your node DOF (xyz, + 3 rotations). Your boundary conditions are that the nodes connected to the ground have a forcing function xg = f(t). If everything is linear elastic, you can take the principle components/eigenvectors and get fundamental modes for a first approximation. Once you hit plastic deformation, things go non-linear and get more interesting. So, Wood: 1) Less stiff, so KX means less force due the ground motion. 2) Less mass, so the MA term is less. However, wood also tends to be used in smaller structures, so your on the left side of the resonance peak, were first mode structure motion is greater than the forcing function (but not into the resonance peak) Steel tends to be used for really tall buildings, where the earthquake doesn't excite the fundamental modes, so the ground basically wiggles the bottom of the skyscraper, but the top is nearly unaffected. (the right side of the resonance peak)
- ezconnect 4y agoIn South Korea even two story apartment stands on some sort of rubber footing for the foundation and first floor.
- tradertef 4y agoThe regulations and specs are all well and good but they are useless if there is no enforcement. If one can find their way out by bribing officials or by simply building first and getting "peace" or "amnesty" afterwards, regulations will not help much. Watch this with English subtitles (an ad by government): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LJGueK-Ocgg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LJGueK-Ocgg . State exists to solve the problems of its citizens :(
- wiredfool 4y agoRoughly, There are a few things that are generally applicable for earthquake performance. 1) The period fundamental period of a building is roughly .1 sec/floor. (+-, OOM) Earthquakes tend to have an energy peak in the 1 second range. Houses and skyscrapers have an advantage here, 5-10 story apartment buildings, no. (Houses move with the ground, it hits higher modes of skyscrapers, but apartment buildings resonate) 2) Unreinforced masonry or lightly reinforced concrete sucks in an earthquake. Very low tensile strength, which leads to crumbling under shear loads. Combine this with 5-10 story buildings and you have a death trap. Reinforced concrete helps, but it takes a _lot_ of steel, so much that you have difficulty placing the concrete. It's mostly for containment, so that you have this core of concrete wrapped in a steel jacket that can retain enough strength that the building doesn't collapse. It's still a write off after the quake, but hopefully you haven't killed anyone. 3) You want relatively consistent height vs stiffness and stiffness vs orientation profiles. One weak floor (e.g, double height ground floor with columns) concentrates the motion there, and with that the forces. One of the California quakes (Maybe Northridge) showed that the typical for the time arrangement of 3 walls + one open side for parking on the ground level, + 2 stories above was a really bad idea because that one weak wall doomed the buildings. You can't do that in California anymore. 4) Stiffness attracts load. This is a displacement driven regime, rather than a force driven one. If you make something stronger, it often becomes stiffer, and then attracts more load. This can go in a loop. The solution is to make things _really_ flexible, such as using base isolation. (source, Masters in Civil, working EIT for a couple years in an earthquake region before switching to internet stuff)
- xenadu02 4y ago3 is called "soft story" and is something San Francisco now requires be fixed or the building is red-tagged - no grandfathering of existing structures is allowed. Buildings like this are all over Turkey, parts of Central & South America, etc and just as you mentioned the soft story (usually the ground story) tends to collapse causing the building to pancake. It's still popular because it's easy to put parking or a commercial (large open space) on the ground floor for density.
- wahern 4y ago
- carlsborg 4y agoThis article is skims over the actual engineering details, which most readers might be looking for. These documents from IIT Kanpur in India are an excellent engineering perspective, diagrams included. https://www.nicee.org/EQTips.php https://www.nicee.org/EQTips.php For example "How do Earthquake Affect Reinforced Concrete Buildings? [1] describes the "strength hierarchy" for an RC frame building to remain safe during earthquake shaking, columns (which receive forces from beams) should be stronger than beams, and foundations stronger than columns. [1] https://www.iitk.ac.in/nicee/EQTips/EQTip17.pdf https://www.iitk.ac.in/nicee/EQTips/EQTip17.pdf