12 ms·
US housing market posts $2.3T drop, biggest since 2008
- madboston 4y agohttps://archive.is/4ltaO https://archive.is/4ltaO
- nerddadnear40 4y agoOne little anecdote, many HUD loans are coming to the end of COVID government-sponsored CARES act forbearance periods and some of those may be eligible for 40 year refinance options, both extending the terms of mortgages and lowering monthly payment amounts. I have no idea the volume here, but I'd venture to guess it's substantial, partly why inflation has been so bad, and may lend it's hand to a soft landing and not a dive off a cliff. But just my humble two cents. https://www.hud.gov/press/press_releases_media_advisories/hud_no_22_070 https://www.hud.gov/press/press_releases_media_advisories/hu... https://www.hud.gov/sites/dfiles/SFH/documents/IACOVID19FB_FactSheetServicers.pdf https://www.hud.gov/sites/dfiles/SFH/documents/IACOVID19FB_F...
- Animats 4y agoThis is progress for affordable housing.
- piva00 4y agoIt never is, last time a lot of the housing supply ended up concentrated in Blackrock-esque kinds of companies, I don't expect anything different from a next crash.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoThe difference is, with the risk free rate so high, investors buying up housing might not be as attractive as when rates are 0. We’ll need to check back in after the next three hikes and Powell applies max pain by holding the rate up as long as possible (driving down asset prices).
- davidw 4y agoThis article does a pretty good job of addressing the big companies investing in housing. They're not helping, for sure, but not the root cause of the shortage, either. https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/01/housing-crisis-hedge-funds-private-equity-scapegoat/672839/ https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/01/housing-cr...
- andrepd 4y agoExactly. Crashes are just sale season for the very rich.
- umeshunni 4y agoNot really. Lower values, essentially reduce the incentive for builders for build new housing. This was a big reason why post 2008 building rates were so low.
- mywittyname 4y agoRight. Part of the inflation in housing is driven by core inflation in housing inputs: materials, labor, etc. In most of the US market (outside of Cali), housing costs roughly track building prices. Some of this has cooled, hence the market cooled off. But fundamentally, we are very far from a "housing crash" because the market is far from saturated with inventory like it was 2008. Oft forgotten fact of 2006 is that people were buying multiple new builds in their subdivision for speculative purposes. Because they thought they could flip them in six months for a 30-40% profit. To have a crash, someone needs to buy at inflated prices and lose their asses.
- ars 4y agoNot really, it's a drop after a large rise. There is still a net rise. For affordable housing people are moving out of cities, to me that's a bigger story.
- pixl97 4y ago7% interest rates and home prices still WAY above 2020 costs with much lower interest rates.... gonna need a lot more progress than this.
- SimonPStevens 4y agoExcept the higher interest rates actually makes the mortgage much less affordable. Monthly repayments over 25y: £300k mortgage at 2% = £1271 £250k mortgage at 5% = £1461 This loan would have to drop to £218k before the monthly payments became the same. That's a 27% drop before affordability even reaches the same level as before.
- qudat 4y agoThe notion that lower interests rates make it more affordable to own homes is a pernicious way to subsidize a specific class a people: those who can afford housing.
- JenrHywy 4y agoWhen rates are lower, more people can "afford" to buy a house because the repayments are lower. Lower rates also (all thing being equal) means lower rents.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoWhat does lower interest rates have to do with lower rents? Taxpayer subsidized interest rates simply transfer future taxpayer money to existing land owners, similar to how taxpayer subsidized educations loans transfer money from future taxpayers to educational institutions and their staff, via excessive tuition prices. If the government wanted to help someone buy a house, it could do one or more of the following: 1) build more houses 2) pay someone to build more houses 3) give people cash so that they can buy houses. Houses can be abodes of any kind, including apartment, condo, townhouse, detached house, etc.
- JenrHywy 4y ago> What does lower interest rates have to do with lower rents? Interest rates affect repayments. Higher repayments mean that the rent an owner is willing to accept will be higher (or, they won't enter the market). Your whole model seems a little strange to me. Keeping rates low/stable is not a housing subsidy; it's about keeping the entire economy growing at a sustainable rate.
- brailsafe 4y agoProgress toward affordable housing looks more like every boomer who did buy a house early dying and transferring their wealth to numerous gen x kids, and subsequently having marginally less political influence.
- hrunt 4y agoTo put this in context, the $2.3T drop is for the prior six months. In the prior 36 months (including the six months with this drop), the housing market posted a gain of $13T, a gain of approximately 40% (based on the peak valuation of $47.7T from the article). While it may signal some cooling, housing is still substantially less affordable than it was pre-pandemic. * edited to correct the time frame, 36 months not 24 months.
- colechristensen 4y ago[comment regarding error addressed]
- hrunt 4y agoI miscalculated the time frame. The time frame is 36 months, February 2020, which is before the pandemic started. I have since edited.
- epicureanideal 4y ago> While it may signal some cooling, housing is still substantially less affordable than it was pre-pandemic. Yes, and in addition, interest rates are higher, so the monthly payment is dramatically higher.
- beanjuiceII 4y agoyea I was looking to downsize and my payments are actually going to be higher
- darth_avocado 4y agoTo put this in context, the monthly payment for a million dollar loan (something that is almost a necessity in the big cities mentioned in the article), at 3% was 4200/month, but at the current rate of 6.75%, it is almost 6500/month, a more than 50% increase.
- tastysandwich 4y agoThis is pretty much the same in Australia. And if you're a buyer, it's even harder because nobody wants to sell right now, particularly established homes. It's mostly just new (and tiny) units/townhouses/apartments.
- paulpauper 4y agoUS housing market posts $2.3T drop, biggest since 2008 Yeah but the housing market has gained a lot too. Percentages are more important. Not nearly as bad as 2006-2009
- adam_arthur 4y agoFor now. Fundamental setup is worse than the 2000s bubble in many ways (for different reasons). But even a 30% drop would only take us back a few years this time, so there is a nice cushion, yes. Many still believe the various news pieces about a housing shortage, just as most people in 2005 were totally complacent. Only time will tell, but worth revisiting in 3-4 years
- jeffbee 4y ago> Many still believe the various news pieces about a housing shortage Have you got a solid argument against this? Just the demographics are pretty stark. Millenials are the largest generation ever and we simply did not build any houses for them.
- adam_arthur 4y agoHousing units per household is 1.1:1.0, same as it was in year 2000. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/TTLHH https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/TTLHH https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/ETOTALUSQ176N https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/ETOTALUSQ176N The millenial "hump" you're referencing just recently passed the average age for a first-time homebuyer. Demographics move strongly against housing demand going forward (without change in immigration policy). https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEj71OkndsZk6AEHrAxk4KablrkAXC0LGxcVUS_Jv2ghA25HIX1D9F67VI1JpCLKxCa1UtHB5v9qbbsVyYO1b7yEjLhEA3xTiz1cVujUSWTrr8nYLJazR84q3cS1N05lqwNoH1VIQNIDM347rA4PBzLPLhQmkh-StZC3rA9zfzYx0oGwGUSbZw/s1085/PopulationAge2021.PNG https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEj... We are at an all time high in units under construction: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/UNDCONTNSA https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/UNDCONTNSA The amount of overbuilding in 2000s compensates for underbuilding in 2010's. The housing shortage is a complete myth... the only thing there was a shortage of was active listings. There is no structural shortage that is provable by any hard number. There's a lot more to say regarding housing market fundamentals, but just answering your question directly
- 0max 4y agoMaybe fertility rates will bounce back once housing prices come back down to earth?
- dradtke 4y agoUnlikely, housing is only one factor, and I don't think it's the biggest one.
- echelon 4y agoI take Zeihan with a grain of salt, but his thesis that "children were free labor for farms, but are expensive poodles for yuppies in crowded houses" rings so true. Kids distract from the modern, busy, downsized life. They're a major time and financial burden, and they only add headache. You can't make them do meaningful work for you. They get in the way in ways that were impossible a century ago. You can't hop on a plane, take off after work, or shut them away and have them mind their own business. Not like on a farm, where kids could roam free, learn independently, and help with the mountain of chores. This is tongue in cheek, of course, but there's definitely some truth to the calculus of whether or not to have children. And it's on everybody's minds.
- outside1234 4y agoThis is not crazy - and it, along with better birth control worldwide, is why many researchers are predicting a population peak in a couple of decades.
- garduque 4y agoAs a parent, sure, seems about right. That said, these days I think it's more about having them around when you are old, rather then when you are young. Perhaps they seem like a burden now, but I sure will appreciate two doting daughters when I'm an old curmudgeon.
- echelon 4y ago> but I sure will appreciate two doting daughters when I'm an old curmudgeon. Fingers crossed. My worry(?) is that any children I potentially have would move across the country (or world) and be fully occupied / overwhelmed by their own lives.
- pessimizer 4y agoWhen will YIMBYs listen? We need to tear down more housing! It's a matter of simple supply and demand, not some complicated conspiracy theory about government economic policy choices, interest rates, and financial shenanigans.
- outside1234 4y agoSo crazy because Miami is going to be consistently underwater in as short as 20 years
- nocsi 4y agoWhat about Arizona?
- tcmart14 4y agoProbably out of water. Florida and Arizona may have problems that are the exact opposite of the other. Florida, too much water, Arizona too little water.
- lotsoweiners 4y agoYou’re right it has rained a lot here in the last 2 weeks but I don’t think we’ll be underwater just yet.
- nervlord 4y ago[dead]
- harambae 4y agoCME has a (thinly traded) futures market for Miami real estate predictions https://futures.tradingcharts.com/marketquotes/I5.html https://futures.tradingcharts.com/marketquotes/I5.html 5 years out it's expected to be 10% higher. If you know something they don't there's an opportunity for easy money.
- breakpointalpha 4y agoIn my opinion, there's too much real estate value locked up in Florida's coastline to allow rising sea levels. Flood control in the Netherlands goes back to at least 325 BCE. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flood_control_in_the_Netherlands https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flood_control_in_the_Netherlan... I'm not saying that Miami will last for thousands of years from now, but I would bet money that they have a few generations at least.
- darod 4y agoPrice of housing dropping but I'm sure rents are still high. Landlords trying to recoup all the cash they lost during the pandemic.
- blitz_skull 4y agoNot sure your part of the country, but I've never had a shortage of qualified tenants throughout the last 4 years. Why would "lost cash" be the driving factor of rent rates, rather than "local rental market rates"?
- madboston 4y agoMany corporate landlords will likely increase rents because they know people renting can't buy as well. So they sure are stuck with what they currently have.
- ProfessorLayton 4y agoI'm afraid the housing market might remain severely distorted for a long time, even after the rates continue to shoot up. As someone who bought a "starter home" years before the pandemic at rock bottom rates in the SFBAY, these new rates have made me reconsider my next steps. I originally planned to sell and upgrade at some point in the future, however, this is making less and less sense as rates continue to shoot up. It makes no sense to trade a mortgage well below inflation for a much higher one at an even more inflated price per square foot, with a higher tax bill to boot. My rate is locked down for the remainder of the loan, and I'm still well above water even as the market cools. I know I'm not the only one in this position, and it's definitely contributing to the lack of inventory, keeping prices higher than they should be. We need to build more housing!
- izzydata 4y agoI am also in this situation and it basically makes no sense to move. So I'm stuck here until something changes. I think 30 year mortgage rates need to be below 4% before anything makes sense for me.
- darth_avocado 4y agoWhich is going to fuel an even bigger housing crisis.
- lotsoweiners 4y agoWho knows. One thing is for certain though is that inventory is remaining low because people like myself can’t sell our homes due to interest rates.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoYou can sell it, you just do not yet have sufficient incentive to sell for a low enough price. If you have a job loss and cannot keep up with mortgage payments, then you would have to sell it, and the house would sell at some price (in most areas).
- jmyeet 4y agoA lot of young people (in particular) are understandably despondent at the state of the world. Saddled with student debt, fearing medical debt and having no hope of being able to afford housing in the current market. Some of these people understandably are hoping for some 2008-like crash as a kind of reset. It's their only hope other than winning the lottery. It isn't coming. There is now a confluence of interests to make sure that never happens. It's an alliance of homeowners and investment funds. Homeowners have a tendencey to become NIMBYs to protect their house values. For some this is now generational wealth they're creating. These presence of institutional investment funds are just adding to this to create a permanent renter class. Some markets are soft but we don't have a vast amount of unqualified buyers. Nor do we have massive unemployment. These are really the only things that could drive a sharp fall. This is the natural outcome of a capitalist organization of the economy. Every aspect of your life has become or is becoming financialized as the need for ever-increasing profits are going to extract every last dollar from you. Debt is quite literally built into your existence.
- bob1029 4y agoI'm on the fence with telling my realtor to hold off for a few months. I have been looking to do a bit of an upgrade. I thought I was in a hurry, but the economics are absolutely ridiculous right now. Some sellers are still clearly on drugs - 300+ days on market with zero price reductions in sight. Not sure if related, but I noticed a lot of the (empty) investor-owned homes in my area are falling behind in basic lawn care and other maintenance. One side of my street is going to be reclaimed by nature in a year or so if someone doesn't start living in these things properly.
- Beaver117 4y agoNot many people talk about Japan when it comes to housing. They seem to have evaded all the unaffordable housing problems that the rest of the world deals with. House prices are low, rents are low, population density is high. How do they do it? Can we do that in the US or the rest of the western world?
- acuozzo 4y agoFrequent Earthquakes make housing a rapidly depreciating asset in Japan. Homes are torn down and new ones are built all the time which is why they have such interesting architecture. There relatively few old homes in Japan.
- Beaver117 4y agoInstead of making eathquake proof houses they tear down and rebuild? Doesn't sound right. I thought the rapid depreciation is because of some government policy.
- xboxnolifes 4y ago> How do they do it? Maybe I'm naive, but it seems obvious: smaller plots, denser arrangements, and better zoning rules. Plus I'm pretty sure money isn't cheap in Japan and land is primarily bought in cash. Still, in the US land/housing is pretty cheap... outside of the popular areas. I'm not saying this to say everyone should just move out of cities, but to show that it's not an American issue, but an urban American issue. Our current rules do not scale into urbanism.