3 ms·
The Wired article’s title is frustrating. I’m pretty sure the Supreme Court does “understand the internet.” The judge I clerked for wrote the original decision
by rayiner 4y ago
The Wired article’s title is frustrating. I’m pretty sure the Supreme Court does “understand the internet.” The judge I clerked for wrote the original decision that struck down most of the CDA except Section 230, which the Supreme Court later affirmed. If you go read that decision, it’s got a pretty accurate description of the internet: https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/library/cyber/week/0612decision.html https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/library/cyber/we... (see Findings of Fact).
For example it talks about routing:
> “The Internet uses ‘packet switching’ communication protocols that allow individual messages to be subdivided into smaller ‘packets’ that are then sent independently to the destination, and are then automatically reassembled by the receiving computer. While all packets of a given message often travel along the same path to the destination, if computers along the route become overloaded, the packets can be re-routed to less loaded computers.”
And that was back in the 1990s. What people seem to really mean when they say “the Supreme Court doesn’t understand X” is that the Supreme Court doesn’t share the values they associate with X. That’s almost certainly the case. From the Supreme Court’s view, the internet is just another part of the national economy. They don’t understand or care about the distinct cultural values of people in that sector.
- glitchc 4y agoHear hear! Sounds like Wired is a mouthpiece for Big Tech.
- wil421 4y agoWired has been in the same camp as the Verge, IGN, Mac Rumors, and so on for a while now. They are closer to a tabloid than what Wired Magazine once was. Not sure who they are a mouthpiece for but they certainly don’t mind being one.
- corbulo 4y agoThey're owned by Conde Nast, who also owns Reddit.
- kridsdale1 4y agoI cancelled my WIRED subscription last week after their horribly insulting “review” of the Hogwarts game.
- fortenforge 4y agoI encourage anyone who thinks the Supreme Court is composed of 9 wordcel idiots who can't possibly understand anything about computers to read their opinion in Google v. Oracle [1]. It's very readable and well-argued. It's like a reverse Gell-Mann amnesia—clearly the author of the draft understands the issues at play quite well. [1] https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/20pdf/18-956_d18f.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/20pdf/18-956_d18f.pdf
- hnfong 4y agoGoogle v. Oracle is one of the most anticlimactic decisions I've read. The decision does show that the Supreme Court justices are savvy as to how the tech industry works, at least they know from a policy perspective they can't strike down the whole Android ecosystem without causing mayhem. And they know they can't affirm copyrights of APIs for similar reasons. But from a legal perspective the way they outright dodged the legal question they were supposed to answer (i.e. are APIs copyrightable?) and the way they just asserted the conclusion about fair use without pretending to apply legal reasoning (together with a disclaimer that they haven't tried to change the existing law even if it looks like they have), I wouldn't say it's one of their better decisions. As you say, in general people in tech have a tendency to assume judges are idiots. Most often they aren't, because judges sitting in the top courts are a handful of people at the pinnacle of their field, and they don't get there by being idiots. I agree with you that it's a good idea to sample some opinions from Supreme Courts or perhaps even others appeal courts to gain an appreciation of how judges tend to think. I just think Google v. Oracle is one of the worse ones to start with..
- freejazz 4y agoTo your point w/r/t Google v Oracle, the justices aren't being useful idiots, but instead, useless geniuses. Hopefully they do something of value with Warhol and the Alice cases coming up.
- telotortium 4y agoAlso, even if the Supreme Court judges are older, the decisions are written, to a very significant degree, by the Supreme Court clerks, who are generally the very best law school grads in the US a few years out from graduation (so generally around 30).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- corbulo 4y agoWired is owned by the same people who own Reddit. They're providing narrative in case 230 gets shit on.