8 ms·
Documentary spurs a new look at the case of the first gene-edited babies
- ur-whale 4y agohttps://archive.is/Z8bsj https://archive.is/Z8bsj
- zug_zug 4y agoSounds like pearl-clutching to me. The outrage is not over the ethics of what he did, which is a scant drop in the bucket compared to real-world concerns (e.g. Ughyrs). To claim the parental waiver being insufficient was the heart of the issue is disingenuous. Still, nice to remind us the technology is here, would love to hear how the kid is doing.
- whatshisface 4y agoThe technology is definitely not here. Most attempts will result in the introduction of unpredictable mutations.
- altruios 4y ago...Mutations? You mean advantages, surly? /s
- RobotToaster 4y agoThere's no guarantee those mutations will be pathogenic though, most aren't.
- whatshisface 4y agoThe probability of a mutation being deleterious is so much higher than that of it being helpful that mutations are bad.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- j16sdiz 4y agoCRISPR CAS9 is not precise and bring lots of unexpected mutations. That’s why currently it is only used for disease that have no other cure.
- PragmaticPulp 4y ago> To claim the parental waiver being insufficient was the heart of the issue is disingenuous. The article doesn’t claim that was the heart of the issue. It lists that as one of a multitude of issues.
- JackFr 4y ago> The outrage is not over the ethics of what he did, which is a scant drop in the bucket compared to real-world concerns (e.g. Ughyrs) Because someone is not outraged by what you are is not evidence of disingenuousness.
- lo_zamoyski 4y ago> a scant drop in the bucket compared to real-world concerns Objectifying human beings in such a radical way and arrogantly putting the human germline at risk isn't a real-world concern? You have a very strange grasp of real-world concerns.
- SoftAnnaLee 4y agoThe ethical concerns were not just the parental waiver; but rather a number of issues. Such as implicit coercion (i.e. forcing subjects to pay exorbitant fines for backing out of the research; seeking out patients who may have no other options for IVF than this trial), inadequate communication of the risks that Gene Editing may have, and improper communication of the actual predicted effect of the trial (i.e. "your baby will be immune to HIV", rather than having a potential increased resistance to HIV). As for the ethics of gene editing itself, the risks of gene editing are poorly understood. Not in that we are ignorant of the risks, but rather that science does not have an understanding of what techniques of gene editing are effective. What therapies are effective. What therapies have side-effects, the intensity and fatalities of these side-effects. It would be one thing if the dimensions to these risks could be ballparked (e.g. with how HRT for gender affirmation, the risks of therapy vs abstinence are decently understood and communicated to a patient before starting due to the current understanding of the human endocrine system, and the track record of patients in the past). But since the current answers to these questions range from theoretical to mostly unknown, it is difficult to properly convey the risk. And caveat emptor is an irresponsible perspective to have of the risk, as one can not truly consent to a complete unknown; especially on the fetus and future person who has not yet been conceived. That said, I am in the opinion that in the case a person who understands the risk of no therapy is severe (i.e. a patient with a severely debilitating or fatal disorder or disease) or has a proper understanding of the lack of knowledge and risk of therapy (e.g. a geneticist who reads journals about these particular issues) then one can adequately consent. But the parents in this experiment were neither.
- RobotToaster 4y agoWhy should we allow self appointed "biomedical ethicists" to dictate what interventions we can use? If someone says they should have the right to refuse a intervention, even if those "ethicists" otherwise approve of it, those ethicists give a smug nod of approval. But if someone says they should have the right to use an intervention that those self appointed "ethicists" don't approve of, they will stamp their feet like toddlers and use every force of the state available to try and stop you. If we allow parents to destroy embryos, why is it so controversial to allow them to modify them?
- Analemma_ 4y agoI dislike biomedical ethicists as much as most people here, but the anger here seems way out of proportion to their actual influence. They don't "dictate" anything; for the most part they're a bunch of noisy busybodies who make statements which get quoted by journalists but otherwise influence nothing. For the most part, market demand dictates interventions and bioethicists are essentially an irrelevant speed bump in this process. If you don't like them, you can just ignore them.
- dekhn 4y agoAt least one point of those ethicists is to stop people who are naive from doing things with permanent consequences without first checking to see what those consequences would be. I would say that in the area of reproductive science, you need to be exceptionally cautious about what's permitted as you are permanently modifying the germline, and society has very strong opinions about that. At this stage of the science you're more likely to cause harm than cure disease (except in a limited number of Mendelian diseases) while also baking that harm into a person's genome so that if they do survive, their children may also inherit that. (I worked towards germline modification for several decades and concluded, well before He Jianku shat the bed, that we're not ready to do it, and there do need to be some guardrails preventing rogue scientists finding naive parents and getting them to sign inadequate consent forms).
- telotortium 4y agoWhat do you think about embryo selection?
- Animats 4y agoWe let people with known genetic defects breed. This is unlikely to be worse than that.
- tabtab 4y agoAnd idiots.
- kevviiinn 4y agoLike people who don't understand that creating new genetic diseases might be worse than the ones that we already have? That they might cause even more complex issues that we can't foresee?
- roywiggins 4y agoThis article really brought out the Buck v Bell supporters. https://education.blogs.archives.gov/2017/05/02/buck-v-bell/ https://education.blogs.archives.gov/2017/05/02/buck-v-bell/
- bglazer 4y agoI don’t think this is an area in which pure first principles reasoning leads to good outcomes. People are resistant to any sort of genetic restrictions on procreation for a couple reasons. First, the historical precedent of eugenics is so monstrously abusive that any step in that direction is viewed as dangerous. Second, how would you enforce a ban on procreation of people with genetic defects? Put the parents in jail? Forcefully abort the fetus? What if they don’t know about their genetic condition? With genetic engineering, it’s a bit more clear. It’s much easier to just not start doing germline editing than to roll back the (unknown) consequences. The harm in not doing that is of course that some people get sick and die, but we can mitigate that with normal medicine. Also the particularities of the case matter here. The scientist chose a questionably effective approach to preventing HIV, a disease that has good treatments. Also he did a shit job informing the parents about the risks. Just bad choices all around. Doing secret, shady genetic engineering on children is not the same thing as letting people with genetic conditions have children.
- dqpb 4y agoIf it's possible to greatly improve our species via gene editing, then it's grossly unethical to stand in the way if that progress. Convince me I'm wrong.
- giraffe_lady 4y ago"Progress" is something that emerges only in hindsight, and is a value judgement that embeds a perspective from which it is made. What we have in the present are choices, and possibilities, and estimations of their outcomes. You could oppose this because you think it's unlikely to work at all, and so is a dead end and wasted effort. You could oppose it because you think it will work, but that the changes are not likely to be improvements. Is a procedure that creates a new form of smarter, healthier, longer lived human progress? For them it certainly is. If they deny me that technology for my descendants, is it progress for them? It is simply not going to break down so easily into "this is progress and progress is good." It will have consequences, some of them negative, many of them unexpected. It will be better for some people some of the time and worse for some people some of the time, like almost all changes are. Resisting change simply to slow it down and better understand and predict the effects is a valid stance as well. None of these things are inherently unethical.
- roywiggins 4y agoWould you volunteer your child for experimental gene therapy to make them HIV resistant, a therapy that has never been proven to work and has an unknown risk of permanent side effects?
- Auracle 4y agoNo, because the chance of my child getting HIV is ridiculously low. If you shift it to make my child really smart or really pretty, the answer might be different - especially if the parents aren’t especially smart or good looking themselves.
- userulluipeste 4y agoImagine laws that sanction mandatory "improvements" on the future subjects. To me, in that context, this "it's grossly unethical to stand in the way if that progress" is where the true (as in hardcore) politics begins. (Compare to that, the current politics, which deals in easy amendable decisions, feels like child play.) Then there is this dynamic we can all see in software development, with haste of feature addition and not much regard for other lesser aspects (in the marketable sense), that may cross into gene development. There are many more interesting angles that will pop up if you give it a thought...
- tabtab 4y agoRich people will find a way to use and experiment with this. They'll do it on a private island if they have to. Then dictators will be tempted to "build" better workers and soldiers to get an edge on "those pesky democracies". If they succeed and become a threat to other nations, those nations will feel obligated to follow suit. The cat's out of the bag. (I'll pre-order a second wanker.) If nukes don't get you, AI will. If AI doesn't get you, genetically modified monsters will. If genetically modified monsters[1] don't get you, then rioters paranoid over the first 3 will get you. Enjoy every day like it's your last. [1] Could be altered humans, altered viruses, altered bears, altered mash-ups of all 3, etc.
- goethes_kind 4y agoRich people (and not only them) already do much more than this. We all select the best mates we can get our hands on. The gain from this kind of gene editing is likely much smaller than simply having a bunch of kids with a very genetically fit individual, and that is exactly what rich people do. I also recall reading that some countries had strategies to foster interaction between very genetically fit individuals, beyond what would naturally happen by the general tendency of people to be attracted to others like them.
- atleastoptimal 4y agoThe funny thing is is that the AI singularity will likely come before the gene editing singularity, nullifying the advantage of being able to genetically engineer super smart babies on account of the de-facto dominant species on the planet becoming the collective cloud hyperintelligence
- orbz 4y agoUnless we genetically engineer babies to interface with the collective cloud hyper intelligence better. In all seriousness, all advancements in AI have been around benefiting the individuals utilizing it to better perform. Raising the baseline of what an individual can accomplish by themselves will likely increase what they can do with AI help too.
- manv1 4y agoEthics is a funny thing. Why do the ethical concerns of gene editing matter, ethically, when there are billions of people starving? Instead of spending time and money on ethics of a few, why not spend that time and money on helping others who actually would love to have the opportunity to make an ethical choice by surviving? I mean seriously, bioethics is just a way for the upper-middle classes to feel better about their choices. But in real life the rich don't really care about that sort of shit; ethics really is a way for the rich to deny the almost rich the same privileges and opportunities.
- stuckinhell 4y agoThis is inevitable, ethics won't stop most of the world from this research. The advantages are too great for a nation state as well, from recent polls India is extremely pro designer babies. Once one country opens this pandora's box, they all will.