5 ms·
> An egregious and nearly unbelievable oversight on Google's part. :-\ I agree it's egregious, but it's quite easy to believe. It's surely just using a stand
by crazygringo 4y ago
> An egregious and nearly unbelievable oversight on Google's part. :-\
I agree it's egregious, but it's quite easy to believe.
It's surely just using a standard modal and passing a string. The thing is, this is on a Mac that has scroll bars that are invisible until you scroll. It's easy to imagine testing was done other OS's where the scroll bars are obvious and the bottom line might be only partially hidden which makes it even clearer. And/or that testers never caught it on a Mac because they themselves never realized there were more.
I would hope somebody sees this now and prioritzes a Chromium bug for it. Because on a Mac at least, this is pretty serious.
(And I'm well aware this is a good example of a negative side effect of Apple's choice to make scroll bars visible by default only while scrolling.)
- Dalewyn 4y ago>this is on a Mac that has scroll bars that are invisible until you scroll. What modern UI even has visible scroll bars by default? And assuming it's even visible (either by default or user-configured after the fact if that's even possible), what modern UI even has scroll bars wider than 1px?
- nightpool 4y ago74% of all users? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usage_share_of_operating_systems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usage_share_of_operating_syste...
- Shared404 4y ago> What modern UI even has visible scroll bars by default? Pretty much all of them except Mac. Can speak personally for KDE, Sway, GNOME, and Windows 10. And when they are invisible, they usually show up on mouse motion/window interaction, so it's still not as egregious.
- djbusby 4y agoXfce4.18 (GTK) has them. Has for 15+ years. Shout out to Xfce for being so boring/consistent for more than a decade.
- teerak 4y agoI'm so grateful for Xfce, it's been my desktop for maybe 15 years. Such a godsend in a world where every other UI gets more bloated and less usable over time.
- lostlogin 4y ago> Pretty much all of them except Mac. iOS is way more prevalent and has hidden scroll bars unless scrolling. Thanks Apple.
- joombaga 4y agoI'm using Firefox 110, Gnome, Wayland, Pop!_OS 22.04. I only have a scrollbar when I scroll or mouse-over the scroll bar.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- thrdbndndn 4y ago> nearly unbelievable I don't get why people say something like this, especially on HN where lots of people are SDE themselves. Every single feature is hand-crafted by a/some real person(s), and is usually only reviewed by a handful people. It only makes sense sometimes it has serious oversight.
- djbusby 4y agoIt's true. However, the orgs in question have billions of money. They can afford more than a handful of people to address these things. Eight person startup? Sure. But not these folk who "only hire the best"
- yathern 4y agoBut the more people you hire, the more bugs there are to address!
- kccqzy 4y agoWhat you are proposing is adding bureaucracy and red tape. The government has billions of money and they can afford many people doing various checks and compliance work; do you want to work for the government?
- kibwen 4y ago> I would hope somebody sees this now and prioritzes a Chromium bug for it. Rather, one would hope that Apple sees it realizes that their short-sighted, bone-headed, pea-brained idea to eliminate scroll bars should be rolled back. Of course, I'm not holding my breath. Yet another example of their crusade to prioritize form over function, exemplifying why I find their products to be infuriating to deal with.
- dcow 4y ago[flagged]
- kanbara 4y ago> chrome extensions have horrible flaws and browsers are fundamentally broken > apple sucks and is the reason for all evil because scroll bars we dont have scroll bars on mobile as in days of yore. maybe browsers need to finish playing catchup to the threat and interaction models. having a vm on your machine with access to everything you do without sandbox is pretty bad
- kevingadd 4y agoHiding scrollbars has been obviously bad UX since day one and this has only become more obvious over time. It doesn't matter whether you're doing it in a web browser or not, whataboutism isn't an appropriate response
- elecush 4y agothe fact that the browser extension can have access to shared memory is the root problem though x)
- danuker 4y ago> Rather The air travel industry uses the Swiss cheese security model. EVERYONE does what they can to improve security. The equivalent would be both Google and Apple making improvements. Both of the problems might be leveraged in a future attack. Fix along the whole chain of events, not just break it - defense in depth.
- odysseus 4y agoFortunately, you can override Apple's choice: Settings > Appearance > Scroll bar behavior > Show scroll bars > Always If I were in charge of fixing this bug for Chromium, I might start by prioritizing which permissions are the most nefarious, list them first, perhaps in red. Then ensure the entire dialog expands vertically to fit as much content as possible.
- nneonneo 4y agoI wondered about this. I would sincerely hope that the permissions list is already priority-sorted somehow; otherwise, it’d be trivial to just list five innocuous permissions first and then put the dangerous ones later. Even with scrollbars, most users would just see the first few and likely not bother to scroll down at all. Note that in the author’s post, one of the dangerous permissions (read and modify data for all websites) is already listed in the box.
- froggit 4y agoHave users view and approve each permission individually. First permission is listed, buttons for "deny" and "approve", user clicks "approve", next permission is listed, etc. Clicking stuff is a lot of work for users and some of those permissions sound pretty intimidating, so I suspect either extensions would start getting by using fewer permissions or users would start getting by using fewer extensions.
- sanitycheck 4y agoEither of those outcomes would be a win for security and privacy. Users _should_ understand what an extension having access to this stuff implies, and if that means they only use "official" extensions or stop using them that's fine. Also "clicking stuff is a lot of work for users" made me laugh a little. How many damn cookie consent buttons do users have to click every day? An extension should be orders of magnitude more "work" to allow than that.
- 2h 4y ago> on a Mac that has scroll bars that are invisible until you scroll this has got to be one of the worst UX decisions of the past 10 years, come at me. You can just hear the meeting discussion: A: make the scrollbars invisible until you scroll, that nets us 4% more width! B: but it reduces discoverability by 50%, and its also an attack vector... C: ship it!
- eviks 4y agoI love this feature, scroll bars are mostly useless, the position indicator should be decoupled and doesn't need to have extra width (can be a mark on the window border), and the security issues are solved by a summary at the top of the list, not a generic scrollbar
- brookst 4y agoI dislike the invisible scroll bars, but I don’t think they’re about width, I think they’re about visual clutter. Apple likes simplicity (yes yes you can find examples where they failed) and this seems to be in keeping with simple design. Still a bad idea though.
- lostlogin 4y ago> The thing is, this is on a Mac that has scroll bars that are invisible until you scroll. I try to live with the defaults as it makes switching machines so much less painful, however turning scroll bars in is an absolute requirement for sane usage. At least you don’t have to do it in Terminal anymore. Edit: I can’t find any evidence that the preference could only be toggled via Terminal in some macOS versions. I’m thought that around version 10.6 this was the case, but maybe I’m wrong?
- concordDance 4y ago> The thing is, this is on a Mac that has scroll bars that are invisible until you scroll. Undoubtedly the stupidest UI decision made in the last 20 years.