10 ms·
Apple's Popularity with Gen Z Poses Challenges for Android
- brucethemoose2 4y agoI am sick of Android OEM shenanigans. While dont want an Apple monopoly, I dont feel much sympathy for the competition either.
- timbit42 4y agoThen get a Pixel.
- trinix912 4y agoEspecially the "fancy" OEM themes which are often attempts to copy iOS design trends - Gen Z aren't buying fake Nike's either.
- oneplane 4y agoOr the never ending annoying 'upsells' or 'USPs' where they do things slightly different from vendor to vendor so you can't really rely on android just being android, you have to play a game of ((hardware * android version)/telco)+(features*lifetime) every time because you have a good chance of ending up with a piece of crap that either won't fully work out of the box, or gets less useful after only a year of usage if you don't play that game.
- xzel 4y agoAnecdotal evidence, I'm just about Gen Z and I know a lot of people in that generation who buy rep sneakers and designer clothes via reddit from China. Reps have gotten very, very good if you're willing to pay a little more than fast fashion prices. Grain of salt / YMMV but that's what I've seen in my circles.
- datadeft 4y agoI was there was an alternative to iPhone that just works, the UI is consistent and "shallow" and the defaults are sane. I keep an Android phone around for the lolz. Sometimes I can do what I would like when there is no interruption from random weird software components and the weather app does not want to have access to the microphone.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoI have a Pixel phone and I love it. I honestly get super frustrated when I use an iPhone. There are so many hidden gestures and swipes that you just have to know, and if you're not a frequent user it's a painful experience. Of course, I totally understand that it's just a matter of what you're used to, but Pixels have some fantastic features like their handling of spam calls and on-hold features, not to mention that Google Assistant is leaps and bounds better than Siri.
- datadeft 4y agoI have a iPhone SE II and a Huawei P30 and I refuse to buy newer / more expensive phones. All of needs were met when iPhone 5s came out and 99% of new features are just pointless. Unfortunately we live in a world partially thanks to Google where version 1.0 is grossly underrated. Btw. what are those gestures you are talking about? I am pretty much a boomer when it comes to using software and my 2 year old son could show me new features of Youtube for example but I was not aware of any hidden gestures...
- awad 4y agoThe growth and size of the AirPods business alone is staggering.
- RobotToaster 4y agoA lot of that is probably people losing them all the time.
- Eumenes 4y agoI've found at least 7 individual airpods on hiking trails
- asdff 4y agoIf only there was some sort of wire to attach them together, maybe one that ran down to attach to the phone as well for more security.
- lotsofpulp 4y agohttps://www.amazon.com/airpods-straps/s?k=airpods+straps https://www.amazon.com/airpods-straps/s?k=airpods+straps
- rootusrootus 4y agoI don't miss cord noise at all. Not even a little, tiny bit. Or having it catch on things, or pull the earphone out of my ear. I'll take the miniscule risk of losing an wireless earphone (haven't yet...).
- HKH2 4y agoI have never had Bluetooth earbuds fall out of my ears. Maybe it's an Airpod problem. I don't know; I've never used them. I certainly don't miss having a wire catch on something and yanking my ear.
- Animats 4y ago"... younger consumers are concerned about being socially ostracized for not having an iPhone"
- iammiles 4y agoDifferentiating messages between iPhone and non-iPhone (i.e. blue text vs green text) has to be one of the greatest ploys in business history.
- RobotToaster 4y agoA good case could be made that apple are deliberately encouraging cyberbulling with it.
- rootusrootus 4y agoThat's a stretch. To begin with, you can't even see the blue/green difference until you actually send a message to someone. All received messages are gray. And even without the color, you instantly know the difference between the two -- one tells you it was delivered, the other one is a shot into the void.
- Jcowell 4y agoNo you can detect if a number is iMessage by putting it in the sender tab of a message. If it’s iMessage-able then it will turn blue.
- kaba0 4y agoDifferentiating between e2e encrypted, internet-sent messages vs SMSs are important, though. And it is not an issue anywhere else on Earth besides the US, people just use third-party messenger apps and that’s it.
- warning26 4y agoI'd argue that iMessage is one of the most monopolistic elements of the iPhone. With their market share as large as it is, and with only one remotely viable competitor, they should be forced to open up an API allowing other people to create clients. (Anyone remember the glory days of GAIM/Pidgin and multi-account messengers?)
- robotnikman 4y agoIt makes me wonder, what happens if Apple becomes a monopoly when it comes to smartphones?
- Jtsummers 4y agoNothing unless they abuse that position in some way that crosses certain legal limits. Same thing with MS. Their monopoly with Windows was not, strictly, the problem. The problem was their behavior with respect to obtaining, maintaining, and then abusing their monopoly position.
- ideamotor 4y ago0% chance in most of the world.
- MangoCoffee 4y agonah, that's not going to happen. > Android has an incredible 97 percent market share in India https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2023/02/androids-new-oem-rules-in-india-swap-requirements-with-revenue-sharing/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2023/02/androids-new-oem-rul... Not everyone can afford Apple's premium.
- Hellion 4y agoFeature by feature, and doing a cost comparison, shows that iPhones are very good value. But they don’t have a phone under $400. And even in the developed world that’s a lot of money.
- bilal4hmed 4y agowith apple now opening factories in India I wonder if that starts to shift, since they dont have to pay import tariffs
- rootusrootus 4y agoAnd every time one of our coworkers from India comes to visit the US, they return home with two or three iPhones. I'm guessing there's a big demographic correlation with phone OS choice in India.
- crazygringo 4y agoSay what you want, iPhones and Apple have been "fashionable" in a way that Android has not been. Which is due in no small part to branding, all the way back to the iconic iPod dancing silhouette commercials. Apple portrays a brand image of authenticity, fashion, and self-expression. (Whether or not you think that's deserved, it's definitely the vibe.) While Android branding is... well it barely exists. It's just kind of generic. It used to be a bunch of funny-looking cylindrical figurines juxtaposed with the names of candies... now I'm not sure it's anything at all? I will never understand why Google has never come up with a viable marketing strategy for Android, to be fashionable in its own different way.
- rcme 4y agoBranding definitely plays a big role. But I think it’s one part of many that makes Apple popular. Overall, Apple has great attention to detail. This shows up in the marketing, which you mentioned. But it also shows up other places. The iPod felt amazing. I used other MP3 players before and after the iPod, and nothing came close to how good it felt. The weight in your hand. The shape. The satisfying clicking sounds. And the same thing applies to three iPhone. Apple’s features have a level of polish not found on Android.
- exar0815 4y agoThat's why the only Tech-Co. in the US for which I always thought it's possible to build a car would be Apple. They give me the same vibes as all the German luxury OEMs I worked with - the 3 sound engineers per car just to dial in the sound of closing doors and stuff like that. Attention to detail - with better software in Apples case.
- theshrike79 4y agoI don't want Apple to make a car. But I do want them to make the software in my car. Preferably so that the car is just a wireless dock for my iPhone. So every time I upgrade my phone, my car gets a hardware update too.
- 4y ago
- newaccount2021 4y ago[dead]
- eppp 4y agoI have been on android since very early on. I am pretty much fed up with it at this point. The majority of the phones are just junk. I have paid more at each new iteration of the OS and gotten worse performance.
- JTyQZSnP3cQGa8B 4y agoI'm way too old to answer but anyway... I regularly come back to Android to see how it evolves, it's some kind of masochistic behavior that I have, or maybe because I'm a developer and I like comparison. My last Android (2 years ago, a Pixel phone, the real deal) was full of annoyances, the official "apps" were incoherent (every app has its own hidden settings' page with a different look, and there a hundred of those pages), and the worst was that I found DEBUG_STRINGS_WITH_UNDERSCORES in one page. iOS is a walled garden, but at least it doesn't entice me to throw my phone outside the window. Edit: last but not least, since I had to buy a brand new Google phone (to get an up to date OS), I remember that it was twice as expensive as my current iPhone...
- yamtaddle 4y agoMy conclusion after being an Android user for quite a while, then switching to iOS but continuing to be an Android developer for years after that, is that Google is simply a terrible steward of important software. It was beyond obvious that important things were being neglected or fucked-around with for purely portfolio-building reasons (and often badly half-assed—OMG, the Material UI stuff was shit at the programming level despite the huge marketing campaign for it, looked like the designers just spitballed some stuff then dumped it on the summer interns to handle the details), despite Android being their premier platform and probably in their top-5 most-prominent consumer software products (ChromeOS is important in some niches, but not much outside those).
- duffyjp 4y agoI got an android when it was on version 2.3. It was a Huawei P1 and blew everyone's mind. 1080p video recording, OLED display etc. I had various other androids that beat Apple on some feature; wireless charging, 4K video whatever. But the problem was they never lasted more than 2 years tops. My last android was an LG G7 and it got 18 months of OS updates from release. I didn't buy it immediately so I got even less. Enough of that. I bought an iPhone 12 Pro and it's as good today as it was out of the box if not better. The one single gripe I have is that the apple keyboard is utter trash. It's so bad I'll reconsider android when it's time to replace even if it costs me more over time.
- bioemerl 4y agoAndroid used to have a niche. It did stuff that Apple didn't. Now all that stuff, minus only sideloading, has been eroded to nothing. You get subpar software. Subpar apps. Subpar privacy. Subpar hardware. For what? For nothing. Unless you're a software or control nerd (see: me) there is zero reason to even think about Android.
- paulryanrogers 4y agoCost?
- Hellion 4y agoYeah, you can get an android phone that will take pictures, send messages, play, music, run Uber/maps, and take calls for under $50. Those phones aren’t great, but they are usable. They can do everything that you “need” a smart phone to do.
- eldaisfish 4y agoThose phones are not “usable” in any sense except the bare minimum. How many of these sub USD 200 phones have you used and for how long?
- paulryanrogers 4y agoAn older, once premium model can be a good middle ground. I usually buy used and had a Note4 for several years, then my SO used it, then I used it again, then we resold it in working condition. It also had a swappable battery and card slot. Both likely helped extend its life.
- RobotToaster 4y agoMy over two year old Xiaomi (mi max 3) cost just under that, it still works fine ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- abenga 4y agoHow are they not usable? I use a Nokia 7.2 and I think it's a perfect phone. Good screen. Pure Android. Fast. Nice camera (though I really don't care about this). It has 64GB of internal storage, but adding an SD card was straightforward.
- kepler1 4y agoAs tempting as it is to criticize Apple for being some evil empire, another highly plausible explanation is simply that their products are quite good, and people are willing to join the ecosystem for some inconveniences / loss of freedom. And the side point that not everyone (though it might seem here) is a 20 year old hacker demanding that they be allowed to jailbreak their phone, or insisting that all WhatsApp chats be able to integrate with iMessage as a matter of moral principle.
- pelagicAustral 4y agoI would argue that most people don't actually give a shit about 'better hardware', 'software ecosystem' or any other technicality beyond 'pictures look good'. I have friends that buy the latest maxed out iPhone version by version and they truly don't do a single more expensive action than take photos of their food and upload it to Instagram.
- eldaisfish 4y agoNote that this is US-only. That said, it is easy to extend to other developed market. Even in developing markets like India and China, apple products are positioned as status symbols. Even if you disagree with that, it is difficult to argue against apple’s vertical integration of software, hardware and supply chains. the android market has no equivalent and there is no “android” brand. for a good source of anecdotal data, look to the used device market. apple products retain value well.
- fidgewidge 4y agoOutside the US everyone uses WhatsApp which doesn't discriminate in the same way. I've never felt any social pressure to use an iPhone and have no idea what phones my friends use. It's weird seeing this be such a big factor in the US.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hn_throwaway_99 4y ago> As a result, Apple's ecosystem is shaping social decision-making, with particular emphasis on the importance of iMessage as a social signal, necessitated by inferior experiences messaging and using group chats via SMS. This really hits the nail on the head and is the absolute key factor in the US. And it's not because of the "blue/green" bubble that the media often likes to play up. It's because if you're in a group chat, everything works great for everyone if all the participants are on iOS in iMessage. The minute you get an Android user (and I'm speaking as the Android user in this situation), it sucks for everyone, NOT just the Android user: photos and videos get degraded, messages randomly get dropped, emoji reactions don't work as well, etc. I'm well into middle age and have been told by friends "Just get an iPhone" when I join group chats on vacation. iMessage really is the moat that is impossible to breach without government regulation. Folks in other countries don't notice it as much because they tend to use other platforms like WhatsApp or something else for group chats.
- colpabar 4y agocolpabar liked a message.
- asdff 4y agoHonestly complaining about groupchats is such a nitpick. I'd rather get this message in the chat log like that, versus what happens on the iphone where your phone buzzes all day from people liking some message way up in the chatlog, that you'd have no sense of that activity until you scrolled back and counted up the hearts.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoLol, took me a minute, bravo!
- drewbeck 4y agoI hate this part of cross platform messaging sooo much. Apple has “improved” it somewhat by making it so iOS users now don’t see the “[x] had liked a message” text, but of course this doesn’t happen on the android side, making iOS users equally annoying participants in the chat without visibility into how annoying it is!! They’ve made iOS users worse citizens. And I say this as an iOS user! I want it to be very clear when reacting to a text is going to pollute the chat. Grr.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- m3kw9 4y agoEven the word Android itself has an uncool feel to it. It has no identity, 1000 different phones can be an Android and with 500 different flavours
- dogleash 4y agoApple vs Android is Coke vs Pepsi for Zoomers. Having hard numbers in a report makes sense to nail it home, but it's instantly obvious if you interact with people that age. (And I say that as a millennial that's used to a lighter version of the same shit from my peers.)
- satvikpendem 4y agoIt's sad to see the growing monopoly of iOS in the US. I use an Android because it simply does what iOS doesn't, such as sideloading very important apps for me. I will literally not use a phone without an adblocker on the browser, on YouTube, on Twitter, on Instagram, for example. Android has the ability to load these (modded or otherwise) apps, iOS simply doesn't. Maybe the DMA in Europe will but I doubt it will be at the same level of functionality.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoWhile I am sure ublock origin or whatever is more powerful, I see no ads while browsing Safari in iOS or macOS using a content blocker like Wipr. Youtube ads sometime get through though as of late last year. Of course, I do not use websites like Instagram or Twitter, so maybe I am not affected by the less comprehensive ad blocking.
- kaba0 4y agoI don’t care for instagram and twitter, but the rest can have adblockers. Especially the web, you can choose from a litany of options without any hacking.
- russellbeattie 4y agoMy son and I prefer Android, but he switched to iPhone so he could better communicate with his gf and peers and eventually I switched to better communicate with him. It's like a social virus. iMessage is a real barrier to Android adoption.
- welfare 4y agoIf iMessage is such a killer feature, why hasn't Google developed their own alternative?
- russellbeattie 4y agoYou tell me.
- dutchCourage 4y agoIt's funny to see. The same thing that's happening with iMessage happened with Blackberry messenger over a decade ago. The major difference is that we now have huge data plans and a handful of great messaging apps to choose from. I don't understand why this hasn't reached the US market. I can't imagine communicating on an app that's not compatible with my friends' devices when there are so many alternatives out there.
- sharadov 4y agoApple is an entire ecosystem of devices that work very well and look really cool - phone,airpods,watch,macbook, ipad.
- Ancapistani 4y ago> As Gen Z gets older, this trend is likely to grow and further entrench Apple's market share, making it increasingly difficult for rival companies to capture new customers and make inroads. This is the closing statement in the article, but doesn't seem to be supported by the data and arguments provided. Why would a generation entering the workforce and establishing their careers necessarily cause entrenchment of an existing trend? If anything, as the biggest reasons for Apple's popularity in that generation seems to be driven by social factors, their advantage could very well fade as they leave behind their childhood social circles and build new ones.
- sebazzz 4y agoI don't care for AirPods, HomePod or all the other accessoires. However I do want a smooth and consistent OS. Windows Phone and Windows 10 Mobile after that was that for me. Usually very smooth, clear design language, very consistent. Until Microsoft killed it. Then you have Android which isn't Android. Samsung desperately trying to establish its own identity, by including own versions of apps on their devices - so you have Android Browser/Google Chrome and Samsung Internet. Gmail and Samsung Mail and Android mail. The list goes on. Then let's talk about security patches and updates. Improvements have been made over time, but it is still nowhere near Apple. Partially this is due to the way Linux kernel and build process works, but as a user I don't care about that. Even on flagship devices Android is not truly smooth. Sure, some animations are added here and there, but it is not truly smooth - and often there is some stuttering here and there. That completely ruins it for me. Let's not talk about how lower-end devices work. Apple asks too much for their devices, the apps can be incredibly expensive, and I don't like how they've handled repairability until now. Accessories are too expensive. AirPods shouldn't even exist. But what they offer does work and it works mostly well.
- gerash 4y agoI've used both and responsiveness to touch at all times is very important to me which iphone does a better job at. I hate how they abuse this iMessage situation though.
- thiht 4y ago> AirPods shouldn't even exist Why is that? I recently switched to AirPods Pro because I wanted to see what the fuss was about and I don't regret it one bit. - Pairing works seamlessly, including switching device, including non Apple devices - The controls on the buds are amazing and well thought of (I had Jabra before and the controls were different on the left and right earbud, so if I wanted to wear only the right one I couldn't skip a song because the control was on the left one) - Active noise control works great - The microphone is good enough that I can actually use them for calls, even in the street near cars - Integration with FindMy, not only for the case but also for each earbud individually is soooo useful. - Even the feeling of closing the case is amazing. They're easily the best earbuds (and headphones too) I've ever had.
- alkonaut 4y agoI imagine kids these days don’t “choose” between Apple and Android. By the time my kids buy their first smartphone with their own money, they will have use my old ones handed down over a decade. At that point, it’s too late to Switch. New Apple users are born every day by old Apple users.
- akmarinov 4y agoAs a mobile developer, the US being the big tech influence it is and the iPhone commanding 50-ish% of all phones there, when working with clients, we always end up designing for iPhone first. Then when we move on to testing, the clients have a hard time finding someone to test on Android on their end. That leads to a lot more polish on the iOS side and Android being treated as an afterthought.
- Slava_Propanei 4y ago[dead]