6 ms·
Office Landlord Defaults Are Escalating as Lenders Brace for More Distress
- Ancalagon 4y agoDefinitely gonna be a commercial real estate recession at the least.
- cld8483 4y agoLet the office real estate industry crash and burn, so that developers lobby for the zoning to build more housing instead of more offices. The worst thing we can do right now is bail out commercial real estate investors who bet on the construction of cities with 10x more cubicles than apartments. Markets as optimization tools only work if people are made to suffer their losses when they occur; bailouts subvert the process and pervert the outcomes.
- dingusdew 4y ago[dead]
- davidw 4y agoWhat'd be really fantastic is to just have "zoning" that keeps truly noxious uses (slaughterhouses, say) separated. Offices, housing, light commercial operating during daytime hours... it's not really that big a deal if it's mixed up a lot more than it is now. In many ways, it'd be preferable, so that people didn't need to go so far to do things.
- lallysingh 4y agoI don't know, how would that play out with school districts?
- davidw 4y agoWhere there's demand: build more schools. Where demand falls: decommission or repurpose the schools.
- ryukafalz 4y agoAren't school districts mostly funded by local tax revenue and by states proportionally to the number of students? More residents (and thus more students) means more funding to work with. They probably would need to expand, though.
- ghaff 4y ago> More residents (and thus more students) means more funding to work with. Except in my town, as is fairly common, an incremental student costs more than the contribution from local property taxes and the state. So the fairly rural town of about 7,000 generally resists any plans that would markedly increase the number of students in the town.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoHow are you sure they're trying to keep out students and not keep out something else, or trying to pump up something (their home prices on leverage)?
- ghaff 4y agoBecause I've heard the discussions at town hall and seen the actual figures. In fact that was just a very contentious vote to rezone some residential land for light industry (like distribution centers) primarily for the financial reasons.
- ryukafalz 4y agoIs the difference made up by federal funding now then? (I don't know as much about federal school funding but it doesn't seem to scale by the number of students.)
- ghaff 4y agoNo. They have to balance the budget which may mean taking money from other things like public services. (Although something like 60% of property taxes already goes to schools.) And, if they can't make that work, there will need to be a vote to raise property taxes.
- DelaneyM 4y agoGenerally I agree, but unfortunately many newer, denser, cities can't be easily rezoned/rebuilt into residential/mixed use because the city infrastructure (usually plumbing) can't handle it. So major conversion projects need not only zoning approval but also major municipal investments. It turns out zoning is not just an arbitrary categorization, but also a guidance for public works. This is a tough trap, because it's hard to convince a local gov to put up much more capacity than required for office use when an office building goes in (that would be a waste of taxpayer funds). (I've tried to do this, even put up capital and hired an architect, but it hit this wall.)
- davidw 4y agoZoning is extremely arbitrary, especially at a neighborhood scale. You could easily get rid of it and just let the technical limitations fall where they may. They'll differ a lot between different places. Also newer cities in the US tend to not be denser. Because of zoning. I've read that converting actual office buildings is tricky and often not worth it outside of all but the most expensive housing markets, but that's different from liberalizing the zoning regime.
- Animats 4y ago> converting actual office buildings is tricky In large commercial buildings, too much of the floor space is too far from a window. This is why dead malls are so useless.
- ghaff 4y agoDead malls have all sorts of problems. The buildings are usually often old and cheaply constructed and would probably largely need to be gutted which is probably not worth it. But even if you contemplate just building from scratch, if a mall is dead it's probably because it's located somewhere there isn't a ton of demand. That's certainly the case with the one near me.
- ericmay 4y agoThere are a few problems, Zoning is probably the least of the problems in the sense that we could effectively waive a magic wand and solve it, but it is a political problem which makes it more difficult than it needs to be. One reservation I have is what zoning we get rid of and where. Many cities such as Columbus where I live have fantastic, medium-density neighborhoods that we really shouldn't touch. On the other hand the downtown area is full of surface parking lots that are not only empty most of the time in the evenings but post-COVID empty most of the time all of the time. Something I'd advocate for in a 1-2 punch would be to remove parking minimums city-wide but also to remove zoning restrictions in the downtown core first to create density there where we lack it before we try and remove it in our neighborhoods that we know are good and appropriately dense to start with. Most of the density/zoning problems as they relate to neighborhoods exist in the suburbs, not cities. You're right about the office renovation though too. That's an issue. Thankfully those buildings are owned by someone who, frankly, has to spend the money to do something useful with them. We should make/let them solve their own problem there because whatever they solve for will be good for downtown cores. Unfortunately zoning is going to become a political nightmare. Already state governments in locations such as Ohio where I live are now working to block cities from slowing down traffic or providing alternate means of transportation options instead of the car-only (the government says you aren't allowed to do anything but drive a car) infrastructure we pay for now.
- spywaregorilla 4y agotraffic, plumbing, electric substations, schools, noise, animals, safety, affordability, walkability, public transit, etc.
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoZoning already separates commercial and industrial uses. Slaughterhouses, refineries, and the like are industrial.
- davidw 4y agoIt also does things like separate single family homes from, say, 3-plexes, or from corner stores, which is very arbitrary, and terrible in a number of ways, like increasing economic segregation and preventing people from being able to walk to every day amenities. Good book for the curious: https://islandpress.org/books/arbitrary-lines https://islandpress.org/books/arbitrary-lines
- bombcar 4y agoZoning has a lot of "good ideas" if you will, but arbitrarily implemented by limiting the types of building. So instead of specifically limiting heavy truck access on a given street, it tries to limit the type of buildings. Much of zoning could be fixed by directly aiming at the problems instead of just saying "only single family homes are permitted here".
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- brk 4y agoI think there is a harsh reality that the buyers that want nicer single family homes WANT economic segregation. There is generally no benefit for those buyers to live next to or near "affordable housing". This creates a disincentive to create this kind of housing layout.
- davidw 4y agoIt wasn't that long ago that buyers wanted racial segregation too: https://www.epi.org/publication/the-color-of-law-a-forgotten-history-of-how-our-government-segregated-america/ https://www.epi.org/publication/the-color-of-law-a-forgotten... That's one of many reasons that a lot of the better reforms we're seeing are at the state level, where it's easier to do the right thing and where politicians are less beholden to a few local loudmouths.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoWe already have this in the form of environmental regulations. They do a pretty good job preventing all but the most moneyed interests from doing stuff that will have effects off their and only their property.
- soperj 4y agoDon't know if you've ever been to a city with a slaughterhouse, but you can't exactly zone the smell away. Normally you can smell the city before you can see it.
- davidw 4y agoFair enough, it's just an example of something that I think most people really would consider a truly noxious land use, rather than, say, a corner store, or a 3-plex, which are things that current zoning has a big say about in a lot of places.
- readthenotes1 4y agoor papermill
- mikem170 4y agoI know that Japan has a separate industrial zoning category for things like that. In most of the developed world stuff like this often ends up the east side of town, because in the northern hemisphere prevailing winds usually come from the west. Poor people often end up on the east side of towns for the same reason.
- passwordoops 4y ago"The worst thing we can do right now is bail out commercial real estate investors" Which is why you know they're gonna do it. Can't let market forces get in the way of a good "campaign contribution", right ? :/
- jjoonathan 4y agoThey're gonna try to do it. The battle is not yet lost.
- ghaff 4y agoIt remains to be seen where city populations end up if convenient commute to an office and hangout with workmates in the city are no longer factors that play into living in a city for many.
- Someone1234 4y agoPresumably with more walkable suburban neighborhoods where you can hang out with your neighbors during your lunch breaks or after work. With the unfortunate side-effects of fewer vehicles, lower emissions, better traffic for those who do have to travel, and more economic efficiencies.
- RestlessMind 4y agoWhy would existing neighborhoods become suddenly walkable? Will there be a change in zoning? Will some single family houses be replaced by retail stores? Will there be sidewalks constructed everywhere (a prerequisite for walkability)? Would be great to see examples of suburban walkable neighborhoods. I might even consider moving there.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoCloser to family and a school if they need one for kids. No kids and no need to be near family? Closer to whatever makes your quality of life better in some way.
- ghaff 4y agoThink that's about right. Sure, some--especially younger--people will want to live in the city anyway. But remove avoiding a 2 hour unpleasant roundtrip commute every day as an incentive for urban living and the equation probably changes for a lot of people--even if they still end up going in once a week or so.
- short_sells_poo 4y ago> Markets as optimization tools only work if people are made to suffer their losses when they occur; bailouts subvert the process and pervert the outcomes. This is such an important aspect of optimization that is often forgotten. Small crashes have to happen and as much pain as they cause, they are nothing compared to what will get heaved if they turn systemic. They have an important function of keeping the players honest and up to date about their risk models. In a world where nobody is allowed to fail, risk taking will balloon monotonically until the entire system fails. This is basically axiomatic. Real estate investments are again seen as a risk free asset class, where the only way is up. You know things are bad when we have landlords clutching their pearls about having a negative year of returns. This is nuts. The pain is important. It reminds everyone about the left tails and that they should de-lever carefully now, before things get amplified into a systemic crash where controlled de-levering becomes impossible.
- lamontcg 4y ago> Small crashes have to happen and as much pain as they cause, they are nothing compared to what will get heaved if they turn systemic. The CMBS crash is very likely to be systemic.
- RichEO 4y agoIn the event of a systemic crash, human beings should be bailed out by government support. Corporations should be allowed to fail. Corporations already exist to shield their owners from consequences of their decisions.
- lamontcg 4y agoWhich causes rippling credit defaults and money market failures and now every corporation can't get short-term financing for payroll and ATMs stop working. And really that last sentence is the problem. Even if the companies fail it lands on the stockholders, who often had no idea what was going on, a good chunk of them having bought the company through 401(k) funds. The executives go on to other businesses and there's no real consequences for the humans that actually made the decision. We need to really end the fiction that its the legal entity of corporations that make decisions and should be punished. In reality its the humans behind the curtains doing the deciding, that curtain needs to get stripped away if there is to be real consequences.
- AlbertCory 4y agoBig non-residential buildings are hard to just convert to residential. They tend to stay as commercial. At least that's my observation in my 'hood. The Lucky supermarket is becoming a Whole Foods. The Orchard Supply Hardware was a Goodwill for a while, and now it's going to be a Costco. The Rite Aid became a dim sum palace. A Chinese restaurant became a Sprouts grocery store. None of them became homes. Why not? I can only guess, not being in that business.
- robertlagrant 4y agoThey're zoned as commercial, no doubt.
- bell-cot 4y agoArticle is "Office Landlord...", your examples seem all to be "large retail". Though obviously a stand-alone grocery store or such would be easier to knock down and replace with residential, vs. a (say) 5+ story office. (And the article clearly focuses on much taller office towers.)
- AlbertCory 4y agoYou're right, but there aren't any tall office towers near me. The office buildings that I'm aware of have not been converted to anything. Do you know of some?
- nradov 4y agoMost commercial buildings just aren't suitable for residential use. The plumbing, electrical, and interior walls are all wrong for code compliance and to make separate units where people actually want to live. Exterior windows and doors might also be missing. So developers have to completely gut the structure and rebuild. In high cost areas, most of the cost comes from land acquisition, permitting, and various impact fees or mandates (like requirements for BMR units). The construction cost is a relatively small fraction. Might as well demolish the existing structure and rebuild from scratch.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y ago
- 300bps 4y agobailouts subvert the process and pervert the outcomes Moral Hazard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_hazard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_hazard
- thwayunion 4y agoGood luck. The dominant economic ideology in the USA is capitalism, not marketism.
- jschveibinz 4y agoI’m not a commercial real estate guy, but…please be careful about wishing a “crash” on any sector of the economy. Whether you live in the US or not, commercial real estate investments are widely held—not just “those stinkin’ bilyunares.” A commercial real estate default would kill many urban centers and that only makes things worse for urban residents-rich or poor. Here is a relevant stat: 150 million Americans own some type of investment in REIT’s. Even if you don’t believe the number, I betting that the order of magnitude is correct. https://www.reit.com/data-research/research/nareit-research/150-million-americans-own-reit-stocks https://www.reit.com/data-research/research/nareit-research/...
- olddustytrail 4y agoSure, but how many of those are in funds of some sort where 1% is in REITs? They might not care that much.
- lamontcg 4y ago> Markets as optimization tools only work if people are made to suffer their losses when they occur; bailouts subvert the process and pervert the outcomes. Their losses become our losses when the failures create systemic risk of a banking and financial collapse. A total lockup of the US financial system would mean that companies with a yearly business cycle wouldn't be able to make monthly payroll and ATMs would stop working. You can't isolate the pain down only to the bad actors, everyone suffers. If wall street builds a shitty nuclear reactor and it melts down in the middle of Manhattan, there really is no option for "well just let it fail" because the fallout will cover the area. It works the same way with finance. Once the whole system is at risk then the government has to act in order to save it. What needs to happen is regulation up front. Once the financial system is melting down then the system has to be rescued. What we could alternatively do is at least jail the executives and remove the liability protections of working from within a corporate structure. But the idea to just let everything fail is how you destroy the US financial system. And we actually tried that back in 2008 when the Bush Administration let Lehman fail. That was bad enough that it would up with Paulson down on one knee begging Nancy Pelosi to not play politics and to rescue the financial system.
- rentpeek 4y agoIn NYC, occupancy of office buildings seems to be stabilizing at 30-40% below pre-COVID levels. However, many of the buildings refinanced during the zero rates period from ~'18-'22. Going to be interesting to see what happens when that debt rolls off and needs to be refinanced.
- kubota 4y agoDo you mean pre-COVID levels?
- rentpeek 4y agoyes - thanks for the catch
- somberi 4y agoSome note-worthy points from Crain's coverage (1). - Compared to 2019, the average New York office worker is spending $4,661 less on meals, shopping and entertainment near their workplace, the researchers found. That dropoff is the highest of any city included in the study, outpacing Los Angeles ($4,200), Washington, D.C. ($4,051), and Atlanta ($3,938), among others. - New York workers are spending about 33% fewer days in the office now than in 2019, according to the study. That ranks fifth among the studied cities, with Washington seeing the highest in-office decline, at 37%. - ....Only 9% of employees in their offices five days a week—unchanged from September 2022. - That amounts to at least $12.4 billion a year in losses for the city - estimated 2.7 million people who worked in Manhattan in 2019. (1)https://archive.is/YNjys https://archive.is/YNjys
- ghaff 4y agoI was just talking to someone last night. Their company has apparently figured that they're basically in a post-COVID steady state at this point modulo any incremental hiring they do. So they're basically doing a full worldwide real estate audit to figure out where they need to get to.
- xyzelement 4y ago
- LatteLazy 4y agoBetter hurry up and convert them to (desperately needed) housing...
- theptip 4y agoThis is harder than it sounds, impossible in some cases (commercial floorplates don’t really work for residential units in many cases). But a fine idea where it can work. Note that commercial rents at something like 10x the cost of residential per square foot, so this represents a huge loss for developers, and therefore there is a big incentive to hold on and bet that the market will pick up again.
- xnx 4y ago> commercial floorplates don’t really work for residential units in many cases Certainly not for the traditional concept of residential, but there are a lot of ways to reimagine residential that could be compatible (all electric, shared bathrooms, etc.)
- HALtheWise 4y agoIs it possible to solve the plumbing problem by just installing pumps under each unit's bathroom? Pumped sewage systems are common in some places where soil conditions and environmental concerns make it difficult to install underground sewage infrastructure.
- theptip 4y agoI think a big intractable part of the problem is the location of the windows (i.e. exclusively on the outside of the building). Big floorplates just don't have enough windows to utilize the space well for residential, since building codes require all bedrooms to have windows, so your living area would be interior and have none. Like if you take a 1-2k sqft pie slice of the center-to-window of a floorplate it ends up being extremely awkward to lay out a desirable apartment on that. I'm here for the general idea of rethinking residential though; personally I think we do more harm than good by requiring all bedrooms to have windows. Cheap pod apartments could be strongly preferable for many working-class folks that presently commute 1.5+ hours into metropolitan areas. But making that work would require a deep rethinking of permitting and zoning.
- bearjaws 4y agoTurns out plundering significant amounts of revenue from patrons to only offer the most bare minimum, lowest effort infrastructure has left everyone jaded and having no qualms leaving their leases... My last job had a terrible office, $30k a month in rent. The building required we use all their contractors and designers for everything, no surprise it was the brother and sister of the building owner. Any change in layout had to be run past an approval process that was slow. Even the services were overall disgusting, damaged ceiling tiles, AC didn't operate properly (e.g. rooms that only had intakes thus you couldn't close the door without hurting airflow). Landlords have been a menace for most businesses over the last 30 years as the expectation has become 'easy money'. Gordon Ramsey highlighted it best, the busier your restaurant gets the higher the rent keeps going. They scout your business and charge you just enough for you not to move...
- pasquinelli 4y agoi often wonder how much rent people indirectly pay anytime they buy anything.
- bearjaws 4y agoAt my last job we had ~$10,000,000 in ARR, so $360k a year works out to 3% of our gross revenue went to rent. I bet that is a lower number than many businesses given we were in a 'cheaper' office park. This does exclude the expense of expanding / renovating the office, which you typically do every 5-10 years, and costs more because you have to go with their contractors. However the delta is hard to calculate on this specific item.
- reducesuffering 4y agoIt bleeds into absolutely everything. You pay a huge amount to a hospital, requiring rent, paying doctors requiring rent and a huge education cost, which is inflated because of paying employees' rent and inflated healthcare costs because of... The land speculation, education, healthcare trifecta cost spiral in the US has to be like half of peoples' wages.
- 4y ago
- foota 4y agoBanker 1: Ok, over leveraging on real estate was a bad idea, clearly they can go belly up. Banker 2: Well, let's not get ahead of ourselves. Home mortgages, yes, but a business would never default on their real estate, where would people work from? Banker 1: That's genius, here's 100 billion dollars, go buy some swaps. Bankers 1 and 2: pikachu face Scene closes, title opens, "The Bigger Short"
- theptip 4y agoIs there any evidence that banks are now over-levered on swaps? I thought the general consensus was Dodd-Frank made collateral requirements higher, and banking “boring” again. If a developer goes under you don’t have the same systemic risk of deposits/ consumers losing their shirts as you do when a bank goes under.
- foota 4y agoSeems like this covers it: https://www.trepp.com/TreppTalk/bid/333936/What-Qualifies-Risk-Retention-in-CMBS https://www.trepp.com/TreppTalk/bid/333936/What-Qualifies-Ri... Some commercial loans are considered qualifying, and don't have retention requirements. The skin in the game requirement, notably, only acts as an incentive for issuers to write good loans. If they think the loans are good, but it turns out they weren't, I believe we're in the same situation. Especially with how money was essentially free, it seems like it would have been quite easy for issues to cover their retention requirements and still cover lots of real estate. The impact on banks if the loans go bad should be the same though, I believe.
- quarterdime 4y agoThere has been some reporting about commercial morgage backed securities (CMBS): https://www.propublica.org/article/whistleblower-wall-street-has-engaged-in-widespread-manipulation-of-mortgage-funds https://www.propublica.org/article/whistleblower-wall-street...
- EarthIsHome 4y agohttps://archive.is/c5q13 https://archive.is/c5q13
- moneywoes 4y agoWith huge companies calling us back in the offices, is this really a big concern?
- ElfinTrousers 4y agoI imagine that huge companies still make up only a small fraction of total tenants. And that's also assuming that huge companies will (a) continue to call people back to the office and (b) succeed in making people do so.
- phpisthebest 4y agoLarge and Small business are returning to in office work just a anecdote but my LinkedIn Jobs feed for sysadmins went from 80-90% full remote, to 80-90% hybrid, and now it is about 50-60% in office only, less than 5% full remote, and the rest hybrid for open positions, that is a national feed I have
- lamontcg 4y agoA recession would likely revert that as businesses go back to wanting to shed costs. I don't think the race back to "normality" is going to be won before the downturn starts.
- ElfinTrousers 4y ago> Large and Small business are returning to in office work I mean, if your LinkedIn feed of sysadmin jobs indicates that, who am I to argue.
- jeffbee 4y agoDefaults are good. Let them take a bath. Writing down the loss is the only practical way to get the asking rents down. Asking rents in SF are up 55% in real dollars over the past 20 years, but vacancy stands at an all-time high as well. It doesn't make any sense and some process is needed to destabilize this equilibrium.
- mint2 4y agoIndeed, sf has so many vacant and closing stores but the landlords are still raising rents. It’s strangling the city.
- criddell 4y ago> get the asking rents down I know it eventually happens, but it seems like a lot of commercial landlords would rather have excessive vacancies than lower the rent to attract new tenants or keep existing tenants. Is there some kind of tax reason for it?
- jeffbee 4y agoIt's not tax reasons. It is because they can pretend the building is worth X as long as they have tenants paying that rate and regardless of the vacancies, but as soon as they lease out at X`<<X they have to mark the value of the building down which upsets all of their financing. They are, in a loose sense, Wile E. Coyote just before he looks down.
- scott00 4y agoOften they are highly leveraged and funded with no recourse debt. If they can't pay the mortgage without low vacancy at high rents, there's no point to lowering rents. Low vacancy and low rents still ends up with the landlord losing their entire investment and the bank owning the building.
- ElfinTrousers 4y agoAs the late Joe Armstrong said, "let it crash". Of course, unlike large commercial landlords, neither Joe Armstrong or I have the ear of the people in charge of making that decision. Look for the bailout to come out of your tax payments sometime this year.
- mint2 4y agoReal estate in the Bay Area is so off kilter. Businesses and restaurants keep closing because corporate landlords keep raising rent by huge amounts. In this climate they keep raising rent. It’s absurd and a lot of the corporations have zero community ties to the area other than collecting rent from afar.
- nimbius 4y agoThis is already happening near the shop I work at. Four office buildings and a giant courtyard are basically completely empty and abandoned. The adjacent parking structure is as well and has been for a long time but the old corporate logos from companies that pulled out three years ago are still hanging in some places. the conglomerate landlord has doubled down on some sort of bizarre Potemkin village strategy to ensure investors dont pull out. muzak in the courtyard is turned up to blaring at all hours of the day, a cleaning staff roams around a few times a week as well but with no trash, they just sit at the tables and check their phones for a few hours. Security guards are staffing the buildings but the doors are always locked. The office for the parking garage is completely empty, no chairs at the desks or anything.
- nradov 4y agoThe music, cleaning, and security are to keep homeless people out. It has nothing to do with investors. The investors who care are well aware of occupancy rates and lease revenue.
- gauravphoenix 4y agoI am an investor via CrowdStreet in one of the office buildings in south-ish area (Campbell) of silicon valley. Here is a market update I got today- Silicon Valley’s office vacancy rate increased again in Q4 2022 to 19.0%, up from 18.6% in Q3. The end of 2022 marks the 12th consecutive quarter where the overall vacancy rate has risen. Campbell’s vacancy rate for in Q4 was 30.0% with negative 278,167 of overall absorption. Silicon Valley’s average asking rent increased slightly in Q4 2022, rising to $5.36 psf on a monthly full-service basis, a $0.02 increase from the previous quarter and a $0.04 increase year-over-year. Campbell’s average asking rent was $4.18. Given the current lack of demand for office space as well as upcoming economic uncertainty, there is little expectation that significant rent increases would occur in the near term. Transaction volume fell sharply in Q4 2022, posting just 778,712 sf of gross absorption, a 76% decrease compared to the previous quarter. Demand for new office space fell on the news of large-scale tech-sector layoffs this quarter that will likely persist through 2023. The Valley measured 2.6 msf of net occupancy losses in 2022, the largest amount since 2001 and marks the third year of negative net absorption
- jeffbee 4y agoI just moved my office from Campbell to DTSJ right near Diridon. Campbell might be the worst "city" I've ever encountered. Was only located there because I could not afford SJ rents but now I am like so many other fleeing to quality.
- nradov 4y agoIn what way is San Jose higher quality than Campbell? They are literally right next to each other, and indistinguishable in most ways.
- jeffbee 4y agoCentral SJ and central Campbell, to the extent that Campbell has a center that can be identified by a process other than the weighted centroid of its strip mall liquor stores, are five miles apart. That is a long way. SJ is sprawling and most undesirable, but DTSJ is well served by rail from SF and the East Bay so it's easier to ask people to come to the office, whereas asking them to come to the office in Campbell is the same as demanding that they buy a car.
- jeffwask 4y agoWith any luck, this is the start of winning back our city centers from megacorp logos.
- phendrenad2 4y agoBanks are going to take a massive hit as office landlords default. They'll have to sell the office buildings at a fraction of their previous value.