8 ms·
Why the feds smashed Megaupload
- sabret00the 15y agoI really didn't know that ARS partook in smear campaigns like this. This is so utterly one sided that it's disappointing. Simple fact of the matter is, copyright holders could use an abuse tool to remove content and had said content removed. I mean, they arrested the graphic designer!...
- GigabyteCoin 15y agoI still don't get it. Why couldn't the same be done to thepiratebay? Because the FBI can't access their internal emails? That's it? If I recall, the pirate bay "thumb their noses at international laws, all while pocketing significant advertising revenues from trafficking in free, unlicensed copyrighted materials." as well.
- rimantas 15y agoI don't think that FBI acting in Sweden would be perceived in any positive light…
- mahyarm 15y agoAnd new zealand is much different?
- GigabyteCoin 15y agoOh ok then, so the ONLY thing that Megaupload did wrong was having file servers inside the United States?
- BiosElement 15y agoAnd were clearly not as well prepared as the TPB crew.
- furyg3 15y agoThe pirate bay doesn't host content. Megaupload did.
- guard-of-terra 15y ago"They had not one but three Samsung 83" TVs, and two Sharp 108" TVs. Someone owned a "Predator statue." Motor bikes, jet skis, artwork" The list is awesome. They probably compiled very similar lists in 1917 in Russia about the possessions of capitalist pigs: the lists justified expropriating the listed grossly excessive goods into hands of workers and peasants. That's what the article implies: they were too thick and therefore got expropriated. Raskulachili!
- Kadin 15y agoThat's pretty much the situation. But I think the lesson is the other way around: if you make $150M and don't share it with the fatcats in Washington through some strategic campaign contributions to protect your business model, prepare to have some Federal Acronym Agency come busting down your door. If Megaupload had played ball and used some of that cash to buy a few Representatives and maybe a Senator or two, they'd probably be fine. That's how business works today.
- albb0920 15y agoI'm confused, if "knowledge of infringing material and do nothing about it" cause you have no safe harbor. Any big content site like YouTube must know some of it's users are abusing the service, but they're more likely to handle it after there's complain. Or how can you tell whether a file is copyright infringement or not? censoring all uploads, non sense.
- sbov 15y agoHuge difference between knowing there's some infringing content somewhere versus reviewing, rewarding, and noting an uploader because of "10+ Full popular DVD rips (split files), a few small porn movies, some software with keygenerators (warez)." Censoring all uploads is hyperbole.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- tzs 15y ago"Actual knowledge" without doing anything about it. YouTube does something about it when they acquire actual knowledge of infringement.
- flomo 15y agoYouTube is probably not the best example, because they built their userbase on allowing copyright-infringement until they were big enough to negotiate directly with the content owners. If Megaupload had sold out to Google or some other legit business with deep pockets, they would not have been busted.
- lani 15y agoThe first paragraph makes it very clear. The case is against people who have expensive cars and big television sets.
- nekojima 15y agoFinally the DOJ is launching a case against someone in the top 1%!! Perhaps they didn't buy (aka donate to) enough Congressmen & Senators to protect themselves... :-)
- nextparadigms 15y agoWhat's really surprising about all this, besides the very strange and bogus charges, is how they are handling this. They are going after "copyright infringers" like they are some kind of drug cartel leaders. It's really amazing how things have changed at the top regarding copyright infringement, that they treat copyright infringers as some of the most wanted criminals. What's next? Sending the drones after them? Giving the chair to the Megaupload or ThePirateBay's founders? It's becoming really ridiculous.
- drivebyacct2 15y ago>They are going after "copyright infringers" like they are some kind of drug cartel leaders. And thus far they're about as effective at impeding my access to copyrighted content as they are impeding my access to illegal drugs. Fortunately trying to limit access to copyrighted material doesn't drive people's money to possibly terrorist organizations, but that's another issue.
- smokinn 15y agoFortunately trying to limit access to copyrighted material doesn't drive people's money to possibly terrorist organizations, but that's another issue. Well, not yet at least. But if they continue making the penalties more and more draconian then only the hardened criminals will get into that lucrative space and the money will be going to violent groups.
- bermanoid 15y agoAnd thus far they're about as effective at impeding my access to copyrighted content as they are impeding my access to illegal drugs. Seriously: 1) Google "watch 30 rock online" 2) Click first link 3) Click "Search links" for newest episode of 30 rock 4) Go to second to last page of results (just because the first and last page of results are always fake, as a rule - you always shoot for the middle) 5) Click random link 6) Watch Dove Soap ad 7) Watch tonight's episode of 30 Rock Replace "30 rock" with pretty much any other TV show (at least one that's been over for more than 30 minutes) or movie, and the same approach will get you to a working video, though you may have to click a few fake links before finding a real one. Is there a solution to this? Idunno. I do know that the "overseas" thing is a total red herring - in this particular example, that "first link" that I clicked was sidereel.com, registered to the Rovi Corporation in Santa Clara, CA. Completely and utterly within the jurisdiction of the US government, and clearly linking to pirated versions of almost every TV show that's on the air right now, and pretty much nothing else. If linking to content was such a clear and easily prosecutable crime, I'd think they'd be taking down sites like that, too, rather than leaving them active. I can't help but wonder if perhaps there's not such a legal consensus on how criminal sites like Sidereel are, and that's why they're trying to go after the endpoints that sites like this point to instead, as well as passing laws that would specifically make linking to them illegal.
- paul9290 15y agoWhat confuses me even more is they applied US laws to those who live outside the US? So the law of America and desires of the copyright cartel trump every other country's laws? Overall this seems like a big orchestrated F U to the opponents of SOPA (the Internet). Really if they provided us, what we all are screaming for - better access and selection to their product on the Internet, MegaUpload and future services wouldn't be a concern. Ridiculous! Updated: Further some of those behind MegaUpload are artist's of the RIAA.....
- ordinary 15y agoThe Berne Convention, signed by pretty much the entire world, including all of the countries involved with this case, states that "the copyright law of the country where copyright is claimed shall be applied".[0] ___ [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berne_convention http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berne_convention
- wmf 15y agoMegaUpload had servers in the US and accepted money from people in the US. Extradition is hardly a new concept.
- pauldmartin 15y agoNot to mention megaupload has filed lawsuits in US courts...
- nitrogen 15y agoThat's because Universal is in the US. Should filing a lawsuit against a US company subject the plaintiff to US jurisdiction in unrelated matters?
- rmc 15y agoExtradition and co-operation between national police forces is not new. They probably broke laws in New Zealand aswell.
- guelo 15y agoIt has been apparent for a while now that Obama's DOJ takes orders from the MPAA.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- dazbradbury 15y agoI have posted the full Indictment as a news story here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3487808 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3487808 It's an interesting and sometimes amusing read. However, in case people are curious, but don't want to read the ENTIRE document here are my extended highlights: ---- KIM DOTCOM, MEGAUPLOAD LIMITED, VESTOR LIMITED, FINN BATATO, JULIUS BENCKO, SVEN ECHTERNACH, MATHIAS ORTMANN, ANDRUS NOMM, and BRAM VAN DER KOLK, the defendants, and others known and unknown to the Grand Jury, were members of the “Mega Conspiracy,” a worldwide criminal organization whose members engaged in criminal copyright infringement and money laundering on a massive scale with estimated harm to copyright holders well in excess of $500,000,000 and reported income in excess of $175,000,000. ----- Megaupload.com was at one point in its history estimated to be the 13th most frequently visited website on the entire Internet. The site claims to have had more than one billion visitors in its history, more than 180,000,000 registered users to date, an average of 3 50 million daily visits, and to account for approximately four percent of the total traffic on the Internet. ----- Subscription fees collected during the existence of the Mega Conspiracy from premium users are estimated to be more than $150 million. Online advertising on Megaupload.com and its associated websites, which is heavily dependent on the popularity of copyright infringing content to attract website visits, has further obtained more than $25 million for the Mega Conspiracy. ---- KIM DOTCOM, who has also been known as KIM SCHMITZ and KIM TIM JIM VESTOR, is a resident of both Hong Kong and New Zealand, and a dual citizen of Finland and Germany. DOTCOM is the founder of MEGAUPLOAD LIMITED (“MUL”) and Megamedia Limited (“MMG”). ... In calendar year 2010 alone, DOTCOM received more than $42 million from the Mega Conspiracy. --- VAN DER KOLK had stated, “we have a funny business . . . modern days pirates :)” ORTMANN responded, “we’re not pirates, we’re just providing shipping services to pirates :)”. --- On or about April 8, 2011, VESTOR LIMITED transferred approximately $616,000 to NBS for yacht rental; b. On or about April 18, 2011, VESTOR LIMITED transferred approximately $3,606,000 to ECL for yacht rental; c. On or about May 27, 2011, MEGAUPLOAD LIMITED transferred approximately $212,000 to ECL for yacht rental; d. On or about June 22, 2011, VESTOR LIMITED transferred approximately $1,127,000 to NBS for yacht rental; and e. On or about June 24, 2011, VESTOR LIMITED transferred approximately $2,394,000 to SYM for yacht rental. ---- The United States of America gives notice to all defendants, that upon conviction of any defendant, a money judgment may be imposed on that defendant equal to the total value of the property subject to forfeiture, which is at least $175,000,000. ----- The United States of America gives notice to all defendants, that the property to be forfeited includes, but is not limited to, the following: 1. $175,000,000 in United States dollars; 2. Bank of New Zealand, Account No. XX-XXXX-XXXX200-04, in the name of Cleaver Richards Trust Account for Megastuff Limited; 3. Kiwibank, Account No. XX-XXXX-XXXX922-00, in the name of Megastuff Limited Nominee Account No. 1; 4. Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited in Auckland, New Zealand, Account No. XXXXXXXXXXXX2088, in the name of BRAM VAN DER KOLK; 5. Citibank, Account No. XXXXXX3053, in the name of Megacard, Inc.; 6. Citibank, Account No. XXXXXX3066, in the name of Megasite, Inc.; 7. Stadtsparkasse München, Account No. XXXX4734, in the name of FINN BATATO; 8. Commerzbank, Account No. XXXXXXXX4800, in the name of SVEN ECHTERNACH; 9. Deutsche Bank AG, Account No. XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX6600, in the name of MATHIAS ORTMANN; .... Rabobank Nederland, Account No. NLXXXXXXXXXXXX7300, in the name of Bramos BV; 58. Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Australia, Account No. XXXXXXXX0087, in the name of MATHIAS ORTMANN; 59. Ceskoslovenska Obchodna Banka Slovakia, Account No. XXXXXXXX9833, in the name of JULIUS BENCKO; 60. Paypal Inc., account paypal@megaupload.com; 61. Paypal Inc., account belonging to KIM DOTCOM (xxxxxx@ultimaterally.com); 62. Paypal Inc., accounts belonging to SVEN ECHTERNACH (xxxxxx@sectravel.com, xxxxxx@sectravel.com, and xxxxxx@sven.com); 63. Paypal Inc., account belonging to BRAM VAN DER KOLK (xxxxxx@bramos.nl); 64. Moneybookers Limited, account belonging to ccmerchant@megaupload.com; .... 66. 2010 Maserati GranCabrio, VIN ZAMKM45B000051328, License Plate No. “M-FB 212” or “DH-GC 470”, registered to FINN BATATO; 67. 2009 Mercedes-Benz E500 Coupe, VIN WDD20737225019582, License Plate No. “FEG690”; 68. 2005 Mercedes-Benz CLK DTM, VIN WDB2093422F165517, License Plate No. “GOOD”; 69. 2004 Mercedes-Benz CLK DTM AMG 5.5L Kompressor, VIN WDB2093422F166073, License Plate No. “EVIL”; 70. 2010 Mercedes-Benz S65 AMG L, VIN WDD2211792A324354, License Plate No. “CEO”; 70 71. 2008 Rolls-Royce Phantom Drop Head Coupe, VIN SCA2D68096UH07049; License Plate No. “GOD”; 72. 2010 Mercedes-Benz E63 AMG, VIN WDD2120772A103834, License Plate No. “STONED”; 73. 2010 Mini Cooper S Coupe, VIN WMWZG32000TZ03651, License Plate No. “V”; 74. 2010 Mercedes-Benz ML63 AMG, VIN WDC1641772A608055, License Plate No. “GUILTY”; 75. 2007 Mercedes-Benz CL65 AMG, VIN WDD2163792A025130, License Plate No. “KIMCOM”; 76. 2009 Mercedes-Benz ML63 AMG, VIN WDC1641772A542449, License Plate No. “MAFIA”; 77. 2010 Toyota Vellfire, VIN 7AT0H65MX11041670, License Plate Nos. “WOW” or “7”; 78. 2011 Mercedes-Benz G55 AMG, VIN WDB4632702X193395, License Plate Nos. “POLICE” or “GDS672”; 79. 2011 Toyota Hilux, VIN MR0FZ29G001599926, License Plate No. “FSN455”; 80. Harley Davidson Motorcycle, VIN 1HD1HPH3XBC803936, License Plate No. “36YED”; 81. 2010 Mercedes-Benz CL63 AMG, VIN WDD2163742A026653, License Plate No. “HACKER”; 82. 2005 Mercedes-Benz A170, VIN WDD1690322J184595, License Plate No. “FUR252”; 83. 2005 Mercedes-Benz ML500, VIN WDC1641752A026107, License Plate No. DFF816; 84. Fiberglass sculpture, imported from the United Kingdom with Entry No. 83023712; 85. 1957 Cadillac El Dorado, VIN 5770137596; 86. 2010 Sea-Doo GTX Jet Ski, VIN YDV03103E010; 87. 1959 Cadillac Series 62 Convertible, VIN 59F115669; 88. Von Dutch Kustom Motor Bike, VIN 1H9S14955BB451257; 89. 2006 Mercedes-Benz CLK DTM, VIN WDB2094421T067269; 90. 2010 Mini Cooper S Coupe, VIN WMWZG32000TZ03648 License Plate No. “T”; 71 91. 1989 Lamborghini LM002, VIN ZA9LU45AXKLA12158, License Plate No. “FRP358”; 92. 2011 Mercedes-Benz ML63, VIN 4JGBB7HB0BA666219; 93. Samsung 820DXN 82” LCD TV; 94. Samsung 820DXN 82” LCD TV; 95. Samsung 820DXN 82” LCD TV; ... 110. The following domain names: Megastuff.co; Megaworld.com; Megaclicks.co; Megastuff.info; Megaclicks.org; Megaworld.mobi; Megastuff.org; Megaclick.us; Mageclick.com; HDmegaporn.com; Megavkdeo.com; Megaupload.com; Megaupload.org; Megarotic.com; Megaclick.com; Megavideo.com; Megavideoclips.com; Megaporn.com. ---- Signed by: United States Attorney, Chief of Cybercrime Unit, and Assistant Attorney General.
- nostromo 15y agoWhat's clear now thanks to this whole affair is that PIPA and SOPA are completely unnecessary. Megaupload is the stated target of those bills. Here we are, with no new laws passed, seeing infringers charged and domains taken offline. Why isn't the media playing up this angle more? It writes itself.
- itsnotlupus 15y agoAnd it only took almost two years of investigations. Think of how many copyrights could have been saved if only some new draconian laws had allowed swifter actions.
- abraxasz 15y ago"And it only took almost two years of investigations." Yep well I consider it a small price to pay, if the alternative is handing some of my liberty along with internet security over to the government and/or the entertainment industry. Now obviously I'm not the one paying the price, so I do understand why "content owners" are not satisfied with the status-quo..
- firefoxman1 15y agoWow, I didn't even connect the two. That's a great point. Now that I think about it, I see it as proof of two things: 1. It just takes enforcement of current laws, not passing of new ones, to fight piracy. 2. This really proves that SOPA is the result of heavy lobbying by companies that think passing a bill fixes their problems, because if the US government saw piracy as such a problem, there would be way more takedowns of companies like Mega Conspiracy and way less censorship bill-passing.
- rickmb 15y agoIt's a classic move. Yes, people will start claiming PIPA and SOPA are unnecessary, and they may be taken of the table. Hurray! Of course, this now means that much of the evil stuff in PIPA and SOPA is already reality, but instead of being angry about it, we're now breathing a sigh of relief. In the mean time, the feds will start taking down sites left, right and center, and across the globe, without any form of due process. And we'll be cool with it, because things could have been so much worse with PIPA and SOPA... We're not seeing "infringers charged" here. Megaupload is gone. The entertainment industry has been playing judge and jury, with the feds as their executioners, and the justice department giving it a thin veneer of legal process. PIPA and SOPA are more of less a reality without the laws actually being passed. That in itself is way scarier than the actual content of those laws. And thanks to this wonderful sleight of hand, it will now be perceived as if it were a good thing. Maybe not yet checkmate, but definitely: check.
- jean_valjean 15y agoWhen I read the details of the story, I feel like this isn't meaningfully different from a few years back when there'd be warehouses of DVDs or VHS tapes,and hundreds of duplicators seized along with bags of cash. The medium change, but the crime appears to have remained essentially the same. There were two interesting things to me: 1) the email from Kimble to PayPal where he was clearly trying to cut off PayPal to his competitors whilst keeping it for himself; trying to convince PayPal that they shouldn't do business with those other guys. 2) the type of evidence they have makes me wonder if it was an inside job, or perhaps even a setup by a competitor who hacked into their systems. It doesn't feel like a case the FBI would pick up without a strong bootstrap.
- BiosElement 15y agoYou mean besides the MPAA/RIAA bribes?
- charliesome 15y ago> and they claim that Megaupload purposely offers no site-wide search engine as a way of concealing what people are storing and sharing through the site. So if my site doesn't have a search engine, I'm at risk of being seen as purposely concealing what my users are doing?
- oliciv 15y agoAnd if it does, you're making it easier for people to find copyrighted material
- nitrogen 15y agoSo I guess their indie music distribution site, MegaBox, isn't going to be released after all. And what does their choice of license plate have to do with their guilt or innocence, anyway?
- firefoxman1 15y agoIt doesn't; just makes for better journalism I guess.
- narkee 15y agoIn order for the MPAA/RIAA claim that copyright infringement causes large monetary damages to ring true, we must see profits increase in these industries. If profits do not increase, then Megaupload did not impact profits.
- mc32 15y agoNot necessarily. There are long term trends, cyclical trends, write-offs, etc. I don't see how one can look at a single indicator, profits, and then have insight into detail. It's a rather tenuous assertion.
- BiosElement 15y agoTell that to the MPAA then next time they claim piracy is hurting their business. :)
- thomasjoulin 15y agoFor me, there is a big difference between what I considered a garbage site like Mega Upload, and a site like The Pirate Bay. The first paragraph of this article is appalling. While I won't be surprised that TPB owners make a lot of money, the description of the cars, the aliases, looks like mafia guys coming from movies. TPB stands for civil liberties, right of sharing stuff like Wikileaks files in addition to Hollywood movies... I don't know, I may be wrong, but I won't miss Megaupload.
- roel_v 15y ago"TPB stands for civil liberties" ...seriously? Because the Wikileaks files wouldn't have made it out into the world without the pirate bay? Please.
- thomasjoulin 15y agoI didn't say "Only TBP stands for civil liberties". But they do have a philosophy (and are willing to make a point more than make tons of cash and spend it in yachts and funny car plates), which is a big difference with what Kim "Dotcom" is showing... Which explains why I won't miss his site (or him)
- koevet 15y agoAnd how about filesonic.com, hotfile.com, fileserve.com, wupload.com and hundreds of other sites that follows the same megaupload model?
- JumpCrisscross 15y agoI think the salience of the article is in how Megaupload became conspicuous after their ad campaign. That made them a focal point of the entertainment industry's wrath.
- Mordor 15y ago'piracy' is about control and the failure of the media industry to manage their product. Megaupload's only crime is to be outside of that control. I just don't understand why the media industry makes a product it can't control - perhaps they should be making something else?
- jonhendry 15y agoAnd, what, stop making music or movies or TV shows? That's heartless. What about the millions of people who have decided they are entitled to free entertainment for life? What are they going to do with all that free time that they won't be spending in front of a TV stuffing their faces with cheetos? They'll be lost, adrift!
- Mordor 15y agoLol - maybe a different business model would result in a better product?
- JBiserkov 15y agoHow not to die if your business model is (borderline) illegal: -delete your chat logs and email -don't have sensitive(incriminating, personal) information in logs at all (see 37sig story) -don't use your own (illegal) product -"outsource" the code to a "separate" entity, obfuscate it, claim ignorance and trade secret -donate to senators, judges, prosecutors, presidents All pretty obvious, I'm sure you can think of more, if your Mazerati depends on it.
- o2sd 15y agoActually, this article reads like a play book for the next group who wants to create 'MegaUpload2'. 1) Secure your servers 2) Encrypt your email 3) Keep a low profile 4) Hide your identity 5) etc
- GBKS 15y agoWouldn't this action only be valid if MegaUpload was only used for illegal activity? Obviously, there were copyrighted files, but I am pretty sure (and as somebody else mentioned) there was also plenty of legal activity. This legal side of the business was also destroyed, which does or seem legal.
- JulianMiller520 15y ago"Even the graphic designer, 35-year-old Slovakian resident Julius Bencko, made more than $1 million in 2010 alone." ugh what a disgusting comment as though graphic designers shouldn't be paid for their work regardless of the status of the company.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- a9 15y agoMegaupload had servers in the USA with Carpathia Hosting. That makes them subject to US law. SOPA/PIPA are aimed at situations where the servers are all offshore and the business has no connection to the US.