4 ms·
> Apparently, it's not even something students feel they need to hide. Which is good! If a bit of work is trivially accomplished by a machine, we should take i
by paxys 4y ago
> Apparently, it's not even something students feel they need to hide.
Which is good! If a bit of work is trivially accomplished by a machine, we should take it for granted and move on to the next layer of complexity. I have always maintained that teachers complaining about students cheating at homework assignments with AI need to instead work on providing better homework.
- misnome 4y agoYou seem to have misunderstood the purpose of homework.
- jehb 4y agoTo be fair, I'm not sure there's consensus around the purpose of homework.
- thfuran 4y agoThe point of school work isn't to complete schoolwork, it's to learn.
- hutzlibu 4y agoIf the point of school work is to prepare for life - then you should mainly learn, how to get a job done. And if they want to teach special skills, like writing essays without computerhelp - then you can test that onsite.
- rpearl 4y agoThe point of writing an essay is not to learn how to produce an essay. It's to learn analytical thinking, research, and argument skills.
- humanizersequel 4y agoKnowing how to produce an essay is exactly the same as "analytical thinking, research, and argument skills" with the added challenge of making it legible to a reader — which is what makes those skills useful.
- Spivak 4y agoI suppose, but having written plenty of essays as an adult I can say with complete certainty that nothing I learned from my 5 paragraph days was of any use. No one, not you, not your teacher, not any real life audience for any topic you would be presenting on or publishing for, wants to read anything remotely close to what you're forced to write in school.
- dinkumthinkum 4y agoWhere did you learn to compose your thoughts and write them long form? If you were an autodidact then do you think that is a representative example?
- humanizersequel 4y ago>what you're forced to write in school What you were forced to write in school. I readily admit that I had an quality of education several SDs higher than usual, but the trite "5 paragraph" nonsense is neither universal or (more importantly) inevitable.
- hutzlibu 4y agoWell, as far as I know, that is an special case of an essay. And this you can test onsite. The kind of essays I had to write in schools were more about nice sounding words and less the content. CheatGPT can produce nice sounding words, so I am hoping that the focus will move towards rewarding content.
- criddell 4y agoIt isn’t clear to me if you disagree with the GP.
- jasmer 4y ago??? By this reasonning nobody should ever learn anything, because it's all 'trivially doable' by machine. Like 'addition' and 'subtraction'. So let's gaslight those dumb teachers by saying they should make up 'better' homework assignments?
- thfuran 4y agoIntractable and unsolved problems only!
- Spivak 4y agoOr just novel applications of the things you learn in class. "Congratulations! You leaned depth-first-search! ^award noises^ Below is the algorithm for reference because memorizing it just for this test is silly. You're working on a real time mapping application called Maply. Locations are represented as nodes and all direct routes between any two nodes are represented by directed weighted edges." a) Write a function that takes a start node, an end node, and a maximum distance to travel and return the shortest path between the two. b) Your boss said that users need to be able to add stops along their journey. Write a function that takes the final path you computed in part a and the new node for the added stop and compute the amended path changing as few of the original legs of the trip as possible (don't want to disorient your users). c) Now your boss is saying you need to handle the situation where users make mistakes. Use the function you wrote in part b to implement this feature.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dinkumthinkum 4y agoNovel applications? You mean incremental combinations. You realize finding and solving nontrivial problems is much more complicated task, right? This seems to imply that someone that cannot do simple things can do complicated things, where is the evidence of that? Why do the most complicated mathematics start with basic principles and work up to complex problems? Why don’t they just start with the Collatz Conjecture?
- yamtaddle 4y agoCreating the paper has never been the point of these things. The paper has no value at all, to anyone, as soon as the grade is issued.
- uneekname 4y agoThat may be the case for some students, but there are a number of papers I wrote in college that I am proud of and revisit regularly.
- SkyBelow 4y agoShould we? Basic arithmetic has long since been solved, but I've met plenty of people who struggle at higher level math because they haven't mastered enough basic arithmetic. Solving complex problems will often involve many much simpler problems that must be solved as well. The time to offload this to another system to solve it for you is immensely more expensive than being able to solve it mentally, meaning that to solve the complex problem ends up being far more expensive as well. Eventually students will reach problems whose price they can no longer afford. It is related to the reason we teach concepts starting with simple, small, easy to solve problems before building up. If I want to teach a student how to solve the limit of x*sin(1/x) as x approaches 0, I need them to understand quite a bit of math to even know what the problem is asking.
- dinkumthinkum 4y agoNo, we are supposed to believe you are not supposed to learn any of that because some technology exists and you will be better off with “higher level” tasks … that’s what they tell me, anyway.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dinkumthinkum 4y agoHow do you move on to other layers of complexity if you don’t know anything. History books have trivially had answers to questions about history for centuries, does that mean we should take it for “granted” and no one needs yo actually know anything about history? Where does this idea come from that you can be a Terence Tap of mathematics without even knowing basic algebra?