5 ms·
That reads like the successor to Prof. John McCarthy's "Epistemological Problems in Artificial Intelligence" class, which I once took, back in the days of logic
by Animats 4y ago
That reads like the successor to Prof. John McCarthy's "Epistemological Problems in Artificial Intelligence" class, which I once took, back in the days of logical inference and expert systems. AI people thought back then that if you thought about thought enough, you could figure out how to mechanize it. That turned out to be a dead end, and the "AI winter" (roughly 1985-2005) followed.
That class was known informally as "Dr. John's Mystery Hour".
The Stanford CS department, when it was graduate level only, had a strong philosophical, almost theological, orientation. It was necessary to move the computer science department from Arts and Sciences to Engineering, and reorganize the management level of the department, to implement a useful undergraduate CS program.
- asimpletune 4y ago“To implement a useful CS program” That’s too bad. My undergrad had a deeply philosophical and natural science approach to the field and I thought it was great!
- __MatrixMan__ 4y agoSounds great. My CS degree got me a string of software engineering jobs. Which is fine I suppose, but what I was after was CS.
- LeanderK 4y agoAlso fair but a bit heartbreaking for me. Is this the product of mass academization? The motto of stanford is "The wind of freedom blows", not "mass produce uncritical engineers". A freedom to learn, to develop freely, to learn obscure math and think about the philosophical limits of computer science. I study in Tübingen, Germany and I love it that the top machine learning faculty here is located at a holistic, full university. There's constant reflection of the work and the professors engage in a lot of dialog. Multidisciplinary seminars thinking about fairness and discrimination and a "broader" look found in the basic lectures. It is really an enrichment of your university education and develops you as a person. Better than my last university. In the end, one is studying computer science and the science should stand for something, it's not a training of web-dev.
- ibebrett86 4y agopeople can choose how the tone of their education. some people may want brass tacks engineering and to focus on getting a job.. some people may want a philosophical approach... its a good thing that there are lots of diverse mindsets out there.
- LeanderK 4y agoWhile this is true for the individual I was still thinking a bit in the stanford-context. It is a world-leading, exceptional university where academic ideals should be lived and passed on. It's fine if you just want to pass some courses to get a job but I don't think those universities are really made for this and should be used in this way. You will never use the proof for the non-computability of the halting problem in a usual job but it's elementary for CS.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- __MatrixMan__ 4y agoI'm glad you ended up somewhere you can respect. I won't say I'm stuck with the local university, not exactly, but let's just say that switching costs are high. And I'm mad as hell about the way the place has been gutted of any academic integrity and turned into a job training program. If the employers want particular skills, they should train people in those skills, not offload it onto the universities.
- f1shy 4y agoAFAIK the AI winter was more related to the Minsky paper, and the hype and no delivery of the over-promisses made by the industry.
- btilly 4y agoFirst of all "this, then that" does not imply causality. The way that I heard it, it was the fact that Lisp environments on Sun workstations were able to outperform Lisp machines at a much better price point. And just like that, a significant AI specific industry collapsed, and its other promises came into question. That said, all three versions are consistent. The fact that researchers thought that they were closer than they were caused them to overpromise and underdeliver. Then when the visible bleeding edge of their efforts publicly lost to a far cheaper architecture, their failure became very visible. Which we call cause versus effect almost doesn't matter. All of these things happened, and lead to an AI winter. And we continued to get incremental progress until the unexpected success of Google Translate. Whose success was not welcomed by people who had been trying to get rule-based AI systems to work.
- cjohansson 4y agoGoogle Translate got a lot worse after the AI version was introduced, maybe not for english-centric translations but all other. The previous deductive translator was be much better. Same with Siri and Google Assistant, they are really bad at other languages except English
- jonathankoren 4y ago> Google Translate got a lot worse after the AI version was introduced, Jesus. I remember when statistical translation was considered "AI". Fun fact: One time I put "trompe le monde" into Google Translate, and it came back with the inspired mistranslation, "doolittle"
- LudwigNagasena 4y agoartificial intelligence (countable and uncountable, plural artificial intelligences) (computer science) Anything that performs better than whatever we called “artificial intelligence” a few years ago.
- freejazz 4y agoAnd instead now, we don't think about thought at all, but call whatever outputs from the AI thought
- glass3 4y ago>It was necessary to move the computer science department from Arts and Sciences to Engineering, and reorganize the management level of the department, to implement a useful undergraduate CS program. Why was it necessary? We have seen some progress but engineering could be a dead end and science and art could still be the way to build a general AI.
- Animats 4y agoOrganization. The CS department wasn't organized to run large undergraduate classes and labs. They just had a rotating chair. Engineering had deans and structure.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- razor_router 4y agoI understand why the "AI winter" occurred, but I don't think the move of the computer science department to Engineering was necessary to create a useful undergraduate CS program. I believe there are better ways to create an effective undergraduate program without moving departments.
- gwright 4y agoConway's Law comes to mind. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conway%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conway%27s_law
- xpe 4y agoConway's Law is frequently referenced, but the claimed connection is rarely explained. From Wikipedia: > The law is, in a strict sense, only about correspondence; it does not state that communication structure is the cause of system structure, merely describes the connection. Different commentators have taken various positions on the direction of causality; that technical design causes the organization to restructure to fit, that the organizational structure dictates the technical design, or both. Conway's law was intended originally as a sociological observation[citation needed], but many other interpretations are possible. My take: Conway's Law is vague, squishy, non-causal, misunderstood, and can mean a great many things, some of which are mutually inconsistent.
- californical 4y agoYeah I think the main idea is that people who like clean organization, boundaries, tidiness, clear responsibilities, etc, will tend to congregate together. And their organizations will be that way, and so will the things they create together. People who like experimentation, chaos, prototyping, flat hierarchies, etc, will also tend to congregate together, and the systems that they build will also have those values. Same for lots of different qualities. It isn’t A->B or B->A, it’s more like A<->B<->C.
- xpe 4y ago
- mjamil 4y agoJohn, any other thoughts to share on changes in the department? I’m curious to hear your perspective.
- Animats 4y agoI'm too out of date. I haven't even been on the Stanford campus since the pandemic started.
- bawolff 4y ago> AI people thought back then that if you thought about thought enough, you could figure out how to mechanize it. That turned out to be a dead end, and the "AI winter" (roughly 1985-2005) followed. To be fair, maybe we just haven't thought about it enough.
- Animats 4y agoIt may merely be beyond the power of the human mind. That's becoming less of a limitation.
- the_generalist 4y agoAny cool sources on the AI Winter?